4 Separate Arrays on Intel ICH10R?

ExplodingTaco

2[H]4U
2FA
Joined
Jul 5, 2005
Messages
2,571
Sata Port 4 just died on my MSI X58 Pro. This is my main rig so I cant wait for RMA so I will be buying a new board and selling the MSI when I get it back (which pisses me off cus I will loose my shirt on it). Either way, My current set up is :

2 x 6400AAKS in a matrix raid: 120 GB total in Raid 0 and the rest in a raid 1
2 x 6400AALS in raid 1
2 x 1.5 Seagate in raid 1
1 x sata DVDRW
1 x IDE DVDRW

I know there are more efficient means of storing data, but I do not trust an onboard card with raid 5 nor do I have the means to quickly rebuild a raid 5 or other raid should it fail so that is why the raid 1's.

The problem is the board has always been flaky, I do not know if it is the 4 arrays on the ICH10R or not. So my question is two fold, Am I pushing the controller too far? And which MB should I get now. Stability is my primary concern, but I would also like to not have to pay a few hundred more for a separate controler unless I have too.
​
 
Well I dont think you are pusing the conroller too hard. I think you just had a shitty board.
Just get a good board like an Asus, or Gigabyte.

If you want hardware independence for your Storaage arrays, you could use OS Raid since its only R1 it would be just as fast
Also if your gonna do a reinstall I would put the OS on the 6400AALS instead of the AAKS...they have slighty lower access times.
 
Asus, or Gigabyte.

Was thinking the GIGABYTE GA-EX58-UD5 for the 10 sata ports.

If you want hardware independence for your Storaage arrays, you could use OS Raid since its only R1 it would be just as fast
Also if your gonna do a reinstall I would put the OS on the 6400AALS instead of the AAKS...they have slighty lower access times.

Actually I have the Black AALS for the OS, I just confused the two. Also, since I have to use the hardware raid for the Matrix array, is there any advantage/disadvantage to hardware vs software for the Raid 1 arrays?
 
Was thinking the GIGABYTE GA-EX58-UD5 for the 10 sata ports.



Actually I have the Black AALS for the OS, I just confused the two. Also, since I have to use the hardware raid for the Matrix array, is there any advantage/disadvantage to hardware vs software for the Raid 1 arrays?

I have the UD5 and love it.
only 6 of the Sata ports are on the ICH10r, the other two are on a diff controller and only do R0/R1

Advantage of the ICH is you have that writeback cache you can use.
 
you will be happy with it.
that x4 slot does not have the back on it so it will accept an x8 or x16 card.
I run a 9800gt in mine for Folding.

Also that x1 slot is useless because of the heatsink.
 
Well its hard to say that one is better than the other.
I went with HW raid because I like the config options better, like volume size, stripe size, cache.

OS though is great for R1 arrays because it allows you to move your data to another system as long as its windows and just plug it in.
 
If a R1 over hardware fails, IE MB/card fails, can I just plug the drive into another box and grab the data. I know the Array will be lost but will the data be accessable? I have been working under the assumption that it will, but we both no where assumptions get us. ESPECIALLY with raid!
 
Thats a damn good question? I never really thougt about it like that.
 
I think the board would have to have the same chipset, etc for the raid to be seen
 
If a R1 over hardware fails, IE MB/card fails, can I just plug the drive into another box and grab the data

Ive been able to do this using drives from hardware cards and also motherboard chipset's with raid1 (mostly via). In my test lab, ive pulled drives out of a multitude of RAID1 systems and plugged them onto a USB device to read them in. Shouldnt see why it wouldnt work. of course best way to test is to power down the system unplug the drive and find out for yourself.

I think the board would have to have the same chipset, etc for the raid to be seen

For R1 it shouldnt really matter unless the controller does something specific........i know most motherboard chipset versions dont, and so you can just plug the drive in and take the data. Controllers could be different though, but as above ive had luck there as well.
 
General consensus (I have read nothing to the opposite) online is that a drive out of a R1 will plug in and be readable. I'm pretty sure I have done it in the past myself, just not for sure. I see no reason to use software as I have a tendency to reinstal OS's too ofter so this way I dont have to worry about reconfiguring the array.
 
Back
Top