2ms vs 5ms~! and other concerns

QPrime

n00b
Joined
Aug 20, 2004
Messages
6
I'm going to buy a new monitor tomorrow with my birthday money, and I'm stuck between two monitors.

http://www.futureshop.ca/catalog/proddetail.asp?logon=&langid=EN&sku_id=0665000FS10099163&catid=
-magic rotation for work documents and programming
-20" large enough for my needs and will look better compared to the following monitor at the same resolution
-high contrast for videos
-5ms response time (?? good)
-vesa mount
-cheaper than following monitor

http://www.futureshop.ca/catalog/proddetail.asp?logon=&langid=EN&sku_id=0665000FS10099507&catid=
-looks damn sexy
-missing some of the above features (rotation and vesa mount)
-2ms response time
-1.6" larger...


i think i like the first monitor better but I'm not sure about the response time will it be enough for gaming? currently my monitor has a 2ms response time so I'm not familiar with the quality of anything slightly slower.
 
Responstime is nothing to concern yourself about today, all under 6ms GTG is ok.

Input lag on the other hand, is a much bigger concern for the gamer.
 
Responstime is nothing to concern yourself about today, all under 6ms GTG is ok.

Input lag on the other hand, is a much bigger concern for the gamer.

having said that though, the 2043NW (5ms) is using a panel without Response Time Compensation, and so that figure you see there is the ISO quoted black > white > black response time. G2G transitions will be longer since there is no RTC being used. The 2253LW will be essentially the same panel, but this time with RTC applied. This reduces response time across G2G transitions (which are far more common in real use than a black > white transition) and so responsiveness in practice will improve across the range. This is why you see a 2ms G2G figure being quoted, since the ISO point is no longer the fastest

in pratice, overdriven panels are more responsive than non-overdriven, so the 2253LW should offer some improved performance. Input lag also needs to be considered as mentioned already
 
in pratice, overdriven panels are more responsive than non-overdriven, so the 2253LW should offer some improved performance. Input lag also needs to be considered as mentioned already

Yeah, and with artifacts and most likely more input lag to boot. There is no visual difference in moving images between 2ms GTG with RTC and 5ms BWB, IMO.

There will always be slight blur in moving images with LCD-technology, since LCD refresh every pixel individually and not the whole picture as with CRT screens.
 
Yeah, and with artifacts and most likely more input lag to boot. There is no visual difference in moving images between 2ms GTG with RTC and 5ms BWB, IMO.

There will always be slight blur in moving images with LCD-technology, since LCD refresh every pixel individually and not the whole picture as with CRT screens.

if RTC is poorly controlled, you can get some unfortunate artefacts, and some models have had issues with inverse ghosting (see Dell 2407WFP-HC) and white halo-ing (some of the LG 22" models for instance). Input lag does not necesarily go up with RTC though, thats a bit of a broad statement. Personally I think there is a pretty obvious difference between the fastest non overdriven panels (5ms TN Film) and monitors with RTC (whether that be 6ms G2G S-PVA, 5ms G2G IPS or 2ms G2G TN Film). All down to the individual though admitedly, but the technology does help on the most part
 
What Frameless is talking about is adding the input lag of the monitor to the lag of your current set up. Different monitors have different input lag.

You can have a 1ms monitor that takes 47 ms to react, so there is no motion blur, but your mouse feels like it's stuck in molasses or you can see a visible difference between your hand moving your mouse, and the cursor on the screen move.

I'd take the 21.6" Samsung if I were you.

oh alright well i have a g15 keyboard and a g5 mouse so i think i'm okay there.. then i guess my other concern is what about manufacturers.. lg vs samsung? i decided against the first one because it's analog but then i came across this one http://www.futureshop.ca/catalog/proddetail.asp?logon=&langid=EN&sku_id=0665000FS10089640&catid= which is nearly the same except lg, 10 dollars more expensive and has dvi.
 
Back
Top