$2,000 Bounty Put on Open-Source Kinect Drivers

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
A New York company is offering a bounty to the first reverse engineer to deliver open source drivers from Kinect to GitHub, a coding website. The drivers have to be documented and a working application written to claim the $2000 prize. That sum should be sufficient to cover bail since Microsoft is definitely not amused with the offer. :p

CNET spoke to Microsoft about the project and found the company less than impressed by Adafruit’s intentions. “Microsoft does not condone the modification of its products,” a rep told the news website. “With Kinect, Microsoft built in numerous hardware and software safeguards designed to reduce the chances of product tampering. Microsoft will … work closely with law enforcement … to keep Kinect tamper-resistant.”
 
Obviously, this rep doesn't know what the fuck they're talking about because they seem to be confusing writing drivers for modding/hacking the Kinect. :rolleyes:
 
“With Kinect, Microsoft built in numerous hardware and software safeguards designed to reduce the chances of product tampering.

Just by saying that will just tempt that many more hackers to see what they can do to it and stick it to MS. Best of them to just said nothing at all.
 
Obviously, this rep doesn't know what the fuck they're talking about because they seem to be confusing writing drivers for modding/hacking the Kinect. :rolleyes:

Right. Reverse engineering is legal.

Don't you guys know the story about the first Compaq computer? This is basically what this company is asking for. It can be perfectly legal if done right and the legal precedents have been in the law and the computer industry for decades. For it to be legal, you have to reverse engineer it in a very careful way to ensure you never copy any portion of the existing code because that would be infringement.

When Compaq made their first IBM compatible, they had one team of engineers reverse engineer the IBM system and BIOS and write out the output of every single input they fed into it. Taking that information, another team of engineers who were quarantined and never got close to an IBM were told to take those outputs and create their own system that would replicate the results. They worked blind and created the first ever unlicensed and fully IBM compatible PC clone. IBM took them to court and Compaq won and that's why most of us are here today on our non-IBM PCs.

Then
 
Don't you guys know the story about the first Compaq computer? This is basically what this company is asking for. It can be perfectly legal if done right and the legal precedents have been in the law and the computer industry for decades. For it to be legal, you have to reverse engineer it in a very careful way to ensure you never copy any portion of the existing code because that would be infringement.

When Compaq made their first IBM compatible, they had one team of engineers reverse engineer the IBM system and BIOS and write out the output of every single input they fed into it. Taking that information, another team of engineers who were quarantined and never got close to an IBM were told to take those outputs and create their own system that would replicate the results. They worked blind and created the first ever unlicensed and fully IBM compatible PC clone. IBM took them to court and Compaq won and that's why most of us are here today on our non-IBM PCs.

Then

drives should be available for DL sometime this coming week
 
There you go, Microsoft trying to stick it to the PC customer one more time. You would think MS would want this to be adopted using their Windows 7 platform as well so they could sell more units.

Keep it up MS and everyone will be using someone elses platform.

Microsoft, the number one problem with PC gaming
 
There you go, Microsoft trying to stick it to the PC customer one more time. You would think MS would want this to be adopted using their Windows 7 platform as well so they could sell more units.

Keep it up MS and everyone will be using someone elses platform.

Microsoft, the number one problem with PC gaming

That would take common sense. Something sorely lacking today.
 
There you go, Microsoft trying to stick it to the PC customer one more time. You would think MS would want this to be adopted using their Windows 7 platform as well so they could sell more units.

Keep it up MS and everyone will be using someone elses platform.

Microsoft, the number one problem with PC gaming

Why would MS want this to be adopted by Windows 7? With an Xbox 360, they control the software, hardware, and network. With Windows 7, they just control their software. They wanted to tie PC gamers to Games for Windows Live, but that failed.

If MS could wave a magical wand to completely demolish PC gaming, I bet they'd do it.
 
bount's too cheap imho.

i bet playboy can offer 10 times as much.
 
I would love a kinect like device for my pc. So many cool possibilities. I'd love to browses XBMC from the couch minority report style and issue vocal play/pause commands. Would be neat to have it lock my screens down when my computer can't see me :D

As for getting one for my 360...I'll pass thanks.
 
Considering that the Image Recognition (skeletal kinetic interpretation) algorithms are all done in software now, drivers alone for this thing won't be too useful. That will get you the images, but the meat happens with what you do with them (the image processing), that is able to glean body positioning and motion information.

They took the hardware/chip(s) out of the unit to make it more affordable.

To make it really work, you'd need the appropriate image processing logic, which is probably worth way more then $2000 to develop.

Hell, that's probably why we won't even see this thing for the PC, due to the comparably easier ability to reverse engineer the software. (The hardware itself is just 2 cameras, 1 infrared?) hardly interesting at all.

That being said, "never say never" right? But I'd personally be very surprised as my understanding leads me to believe that it would be no trivial task.
 
Think about how MS got their start, then we can all laugh about who reverse engineered what from who and drink a beer about it. Really now.
 
These assholes can't seem to comprehend that it will only lead to increased sales of the device. Hell, if it worked for the PC, I'd buy one as well. I certainly don't plan to buy a Shitbox360 in time in the future.
 
Back
Top