$10,000 Ethernet Cable

how about that amazon essentials hdmi cable for less than 10 bucks that even saves driving anywhere? the amazon essentials line of stuff is great value.


Actually I have found AmazonBasics' HDMI cable to be worse than the much thinner Mediabridge cable. As I noted in my review for the latter, the Mediabridge cable had no connection issues or cable movement issues when connecting to my PS3, and was 10 feet longer (35 feet vs 25 feet), and was about half as thick (so in reality considering how the area of a circle works, and material density, less than half the weight too).

The AmazonBasics cable had issues with how the cable was positioned and all this other crap when hooking up to my projector. Mediabridge makes the best HDMI cables I guess.

go to randi.org and prove that you can hear a difference in a scientific setting (that is a double blind test with a statistically significant success rate or in other words "significantly higher than guessing randomly"). you will get a million dollars for that. actually, it used to be an award for demonstrations of supernatural abilities, but a couple of years ago james randi extended it to audiophile cables because it's equally esoteric crap. one million dollars, dude. everyone knows at least ten people that know someone who knows someone with a supernatural ability, but that jackpot is still unclaimed. i wonder why... and while you're at it, google "confirmation bias".

I actually disagree with double blind listening tests. I feel like the way they are set up is essentially biased towards "no audible difference" rather than neutral. I have a lot of reasons for that, but going into them here is a bit off topic.

I can't think of a test setup that's really perfect for utterly objectively measuring perceived audio, while involving a live human being. Rather, one would have to set up a computer listener that perfectly emulates hearing and does DSP to break the audible audio into various frequencies and then compares it against the ideal and also previous tests. It would also have to take into account the inherent sound signature of the speakers/earphones. That could probably be done with a simple frequency sweep... but this stuff gets complicated, and the tests would have to be performed meticulously.

Also for analog cables, I can see there being some minute differences in how the signal travels depending on cable quality. Digital? No, not really... well not usually... But I mean cables do make a difference. Go to the Qnix thread on OCN or here and then note how people have difference success rates with overclocking their monitors depending on the cable they are using. It's no fluff. Cable quality does make some difference... and that's on DVI.
 
What a crock of shit. An insult to the engineers that established the Ethernet standard decades ago.
 
I'm in the mid 30s and able to hear frequencies that normally go away in the early 20's, I catch differences in blind audio tests with cables (with my own ears in person that is). It's absolutely a thing with analogue signals - but not something that can reasonably cost over $10 foot of raw cable in the most heaviest duty circumstances of all time when you need cable able to take so much beating it could be used as ringside rope.

I would however pick the $25 cat6 over the $10 one, unless the more expensive packaging made it clear it was marked up hyped up big-brand brainwashing cheap shit like beats headphones. You want cables to not fail after a few plugs and replugs over a few years, like a 15 meter cheap piece of crap one I ran along the livingroom wall that can only stay plugged in due to gravity and blu-tac :(
 
The level of stupid that you would have to be to buy this is simply astounding. As astounding as that $9,990 markup on this cable.

These cables are 2 years or so on the market.

And actually is not that stupid, i have a friend that is a head accountant and audiofiel, and the shop ware he gets his stuff told him that he really needed it, and he believed them on there word, if you are not technical educated or smart, its not that hard to sell snake oil if you can talk and sell a good BS story.

After i explained how network cables work, he went back to the store and demanded a refund, that they only gave after he put a lawyer on the case.

As selling something like this is seen a fraud in the eyes of the law here in Norway, advertizing and selling something that has no real world benefits is illegal.
 
It's absolutely a thing with analogue signals
Even with analog signals, it takes extreme use cases for anyone to be able notice a difference. Period. End of story.

The extreme case would be if you're using unusually old oxidized cable, cable with say grease on the end connectors, crazy small cable with little to no insulation and a nearby noise source usually bundled with it, or very long distances.

The average Joe was buying monster analog cables to go from say a tape deck to the amplifier on a old school stereo unit which is downright retarded, as its a foot of cable with no need to bundle it close to other cables.

They also sold $200 power strips... craziness.
 
I can't think of a test setup that's really perfect for utterly objectively measuring perceived audio, while involving a live human being. Rather, one would have to set up a computer listener that perfectly emulates hearing and does DSP to break the audible audio into various frequencies and then compares it against the ideal and also previous tests. It would also have to take into account the inherent sound signature of the speakers/earphones. That could probably be done with a simple frequency sweep... but this stuff gets complicated, and the tests would have to be performed meticulously.

Please take just a wee step back and think about the absurdity of what you're saying.

Computers and test equipment have 0 fucks to give about music. If even the most discerning and superhuman of human beings can't tell the difference in a double blind test, there is effectively no difference.
 
Even with analog signals, it takes extreme use cases for anyone to be able notice a difference. Period. End of story.
I have a $8000 Dolby Atmos 11.2 surround set, and i agree expensive Monster cable is just bs, but i still payed 2x $25 for my two RCA cables, and i know i still got ripped off, but i wanted at least a minimum level of quality.

And even tho i properly would not hear a difference, i just did not wane use cables like these in my set.

The extreme case would be if you're using unusually old oxidized cable, cable with say grease on the end connectors, crazy small cable with little to no insulation and a nearby noise source usually bundled with it, or very long distances.
Agree, i used $2 per meter/yard 4mm2 cheap bulk speaker cable, and bet anyone that they cant hear the difference, between that and the Monster cable version.

If you payed more then me you really got ripped of, as i all ready feel i got ripped off a bit.
 
Please take just a wee step back and think about the absurdity of what you're saying.

Computers and test equipment have 0 fucks to give about music. If even the most discerning and superhuman of human beings can't tell the difference in a double blind test, there is effectively no difference.

I simply believe that double blind listening tests are biased towards "no difference". I have reasons for that, but that would turn this thread into a debate and frankly I think most of the crowd in here is against expensive cables and other such things considering the topic title.

Frankly it would just be a pain in the butt, far beyond where this thread is at.

As for computer listeners, the point is to see if there is an objective difference in signal delivery when switching cords and such. Supposing the difference or non-difference could be established objectively, subjective evaluations would at least either have possible basis or impossible basis.

Even with analog signals, it takes extreme use cases for anyone to be able notice a difference. Period. End of story.

You forgot your sources. Supposing you have some. Not only are all people different, ears can be a lot more sensitive than expected...
 
go to randi.org and prove that you can hear a difference in a scientific setting (that is a double blind test with a statistically significant success rate or in other words "significantly higher than guessing randomly"). you will get a million dollars for that. actually, it used to be an award for demonstrations of supernatural abilities, but a couple of years ago james randi extended it to audiophile cables because it's equally esoteric crap. one million dollars, dude. everyone knows at least ten people that know someone who knows someone with a supernatural ability, but that jackpot is still unclaimed. i wonder why... and while you're at it, google "confirmation bias".

Cause most people never even herd of this BS site before might help explain it. I mean take anyone who might really have a "gift", the odds are small, a rarity indeed. Then add some crap website most people never heard of and where do you think your odds lay in finding your rare gifted person? Just because something is on the internet and mostly everyone can get to it doesn't mean everyone is aware of it. Your presumption is based on false conclusions even if your statement proves accurate.
 
I simply believe that double blind listening tests are biased towards "no difference". I have reasons for that, but that would turn this thread into a debate and frankly I think most of the crowd in here is against expensive cables and other such things considering the topic title.

Frankly it would just be a pain in the butt, far beyond where this thread is at.

As for computer listeners, the point is to see if there is an objective difference in signal delivery when switching cords and such. Supposing the difference or non-difference could be established objectively, subjective evaluations would at least either have possible basis or impossible basis.



You forgot your sources. Supposing you have some. Not only are all people different, ears can be a lot more sensitive than expected...

Actually I would place far less emphasis on signal delivery and far more on signal interference, shielding is the greater issue. A cable is an antenna modified to NOT receive outside transmissions.
 
Cause most people never even herd of this BS site before might help explain it. I mean take anyone who might really have a "gift", the odds are small, a rarity indeed. Then add some crap website most people never heard of and where do you think your odds lay in finding your rare gifted person? Just because something is on the internet and mostly everyone can get to it doesn't mean everyone is aware of it. Your presumption is based on false conclusions even if your statement proves accurate.

Actually it is VERY well known in the DIY and car audio communities.
 
RIP Colbert Report. This would have been right at home in a "Colbert Platinum" segment.
 
You admit that it's difficult to tell equipment apart in controlled testing but think you can do it without controlled testing?

Controlled testing just implies that there is a control group. A standard to compare to. That doesn't mean the experiment is automatically definitive or objectively true...
 
Controlled testing just implies that there is a control group. A standard to compare to. That doesn't mean the experiment is automatically definitive or objectively true...

Stop trying to confuse the issue and please tell us how you think you can tell a difference without a reference point and why the world has come up with the scientific method and controlled testing if you don't think it's necessary.
 
Actually it is VERY well known in the DIY and car audio communities.

And they make up what percentage of the population? Is their site multilingual? What makes you think a savant possessed of incredible hearing doesn't prefer quiet environments to noisy ones?

If everything sound sounds great to people who can't hear well, does everything sound like crap to people who hear better then the best? If so would they bother to listen?
 
And they make up what percentage of the population? Is their site multilingual? What makes you think a savant possessed of incredible hearing doesn't prefer quiet environments to noisy ones?

And Golden Ears that think their hearing is SO PERFECT make up what percentage of the population?
 
Some more information to consider.

Do a search for Audio over Ethernet cables and you will find this being widely discussed. A lot of solid information about cables is being offered in many of these discussions. It's worth it to spend some time reading these.

Can the "digital" ethernet cable make a difference? Yes, if there is excessive bit errors. For real time data the errors just get passed on rather than corrected or retried. QOS for AoE can be different so I can't be 100% sure.

Are you likely to here the difference? Yes and No. Generally if things are bad enough you could here it the link would go down frequently. You would notice that. Per spec, the allowable BER is 10E-12. Even at 10Gbps that is only 1 bit every 100 seconds. You should do better than that with affordable cables.
 
Some more information to consider.

Do a search for Audio over Ethernet cables and you will find this being widely discussed. A lot of solid information about cables is being offered in many of these discussions. It's worth it to spend some time reading these.

Can the "digital" ethernet cable make a difference? Yes, if there is excessive bit errors. For real time data the errors just get passed on rather than corrected or retried. QOS for AoE can be different so I can't be 100% sure.

Are you likely to here the difference? Yes and No. Generally if things are bad enough you could here it the link would go down frequently. You would notice that. Per spec, the allowable BER is 10E-12. Even at 10Gbps that is only 1 bit every 100 seconds. You should do better than that with affordable cables.


I don't think you understand ethernet. You're right that cables aren't 100% perfect at transmitting even digital signals, but error correction and packet retransmission mean that no, you will not hear ANY difference unless you're comparing to a cable that is simply bad.

As for audio cables, did anyone link the Monster Cable vs coat hanger thing yet? http://gizmodo.com/363154/audiophile-deathmatch-monster-cables-vs-a-coat-hanger
 
I don't think you understand ethernet. You're right that cables aren't 100% perfect at transmitting even digital signals, but error correction and packet retransmission mean that ......

error correction and packet transmission work fine for TCP, but does it work the same for UDP or other protocols? :cool:

Some protocols do not resend dropped packets and if one of those protocols is used for transmitting music data then a dropped packet means a "skip" in the transmission right?
 
I don't think you understand ethernet. You're right that cables aren't 100% perfect at transmitting even digital signals, but error correction and packet retransmission mean that no, you will not hear ANY difference unless you're comparing to a cable that is simply bad.

As for audio cables, did anyone link the Monster Cable vs coat hanger thing yet? http://gizmodo.com/363154/audiophile-deathmatch-monster-cables-vs-a-coat-hanger

I understand AoE can be different and there is more than one protocol. I understand Quality of Service can mean errors do not get corrected.
 
error correction and packet transmission work fine for TCP, but does it work the same for UDP or other protocols? :cool:

Some protocols do not resend dropped packets and if one of those protocols is used for transmitting music data then a dropped packet means a "skip" in the transmission right?

Thank you
 
Not too familiar with Ethernet standards, but doesn't the error correction happen on the sender/receiver machines to begin with (ie the cable is completely passive)?

Who the fuck buys this shit?
 
error correction and packet transmission work fine for TCP, but does it work the same for UDP or other protocols? :cool:

UDP, improperly implemented, can be problematic, but you're generally going to know it if a bad cable is causing these problems. Nobody's arguing that cables can't go bad as I'm sure we've all had that happen. The $10k cable can go bad as well.
 
Even with analog signals, it takes extreme use cases for anyone to be able notice a difference. Period. End of story.

The extreme case would be if you're using unusually old oxidized cable, cable with say grease on the end connectors, crazy small cable with little to no insulation and a nearby noise source usually bundled with it, or very long distances.

The average Joe was buying monster analog cables to go from say a tape deck to the amplifier on a old school stereo unit which is downright retarded, as its a foot of cable with no need to bundle it close to other cables.

They also sold $200 power strips... craziness.

That's not entirely true. Back in the day, you could easily notice the difference in cable quality by running video signals from your video card's rca video output to your tv. Different quality cables had noticably different amounts of distortion or noise with coaxial cables with rca adapters on the ends as the best. Monster audio cables for a 3 foot run may be a bit overkill, but at least they are quality cables - unlike many of the cheap ones I've come across.
 
That's not entirely true. Back in the day, you could easily notice the difference in cable quality by running video signals from your video card's rca video output to your tv. Different quality cables had noticably different amounts of distortion or noise with coaxial cables with rca adapters on the ends as the best. Monster audio cables for a 3 foot run may be a bit overkill, but at least they are quality cables - unlike many of the cheap ones I've come across.

Video is a MUCH different story than audio. Transmission lines work MUCH differently at 20kHz than they do when you get up into the megahertz range. Also there is a lot more EM/RFI noise in the video range and not a whole lot in the audio range.
 
What I find highly dubious about the cable is the 72 volt dialectric bias system that runs off batteries that are supposed to last for several years. The thing is so small that it can't have more than a couple of watch batteries, and there is no way they are stepping up a couple of 3v batteries to 72v and having it last even a couple months. This is all assuming the device even does anything other than have a battery tester light it can light up.
 
Such a device would, at a minimum, require a base plate of pre-famulated amulite surmounted by a malleable logarithmic casing in order to have the necessary magneto-reluctance and capacitive diractance to accurately test this cable.

Lol
 
This is from the same company that makes $2+k HDMI cables that have some epic reviews on BestBuy's site. :D

I remember one of the reviewers saying that it made his VHS player look like Betamax quality. :D

So .... this Ethernet cable will make DSL speeds look like cable modem speeds. Right? Can't say fiber optic since it's copper Ethernet. Or maybe I still can. :D
 
What I find highly dubious about the cable is the 72 volt dialectric bias system that runs off batteries that are supposed to last for several years. The thing is so small that it can't have more than a couple of watch batteries, and there is no way they are stepping up a couple of 3v batteries to 72v and having it last even a couple months. This is all assuming the device even does anything other than have a battery tester light it can light up.

I don't know how they do it but you only need 40 or 50 coin cells in series. Since they don't actually connect to anything they last as long as the self discharge rate. Remember, money is no object here. After reading their paper (yes, they actually attempted a technical paper on it) it sounds like they are claiming wavelength dispersion is a problem, it's caused by unbiased insulation deformation, and applying 72VDC between the insulation and a wire or shield running the length of the cable will prevent this. Even if you accept this I couldn't see how their construction would achieve the the goal. I do enjoy this stuff as it gives me a reason to review fundamental science/engineering concepts.
 
One more thing. Since it doesn't look like they are doing power over ethernet the 72 volt bias is way off considering the relatively low voltage of ethernet signalling.
 
One more thing. Since it doesn't look like they are doing power over ethernet the 72 volt bias is way off considering the relatively low voltage of ethernet signalling.

Wish I could delete this one. I think their claims had nothing to do with signal levels.
 
Back
Top