Engineers Develop Floating Solar Powered Seawater Electrolysis Rigs

DooKey

[H]F Junkie
2FA
Joined
Apr 25, 2001
Messages
16,309
Engineers at Columbia Engineering have developed a new technology that allows floating solar powered rigs to produce hydrogen gas for fuel. This new technology has a unique electrolysis method that doesn't require a membrane to keep the oxygen and hydrogen seperated. Also, it allows the rig to use seawater instead of highly filitered/purified water that current methods require. If this method can be scaled up then hydrogen fueled cars may be the wave of the future. Check out the video below to see how their electrolysis works compared to older methods. The left side requires no membrane, but the right side does.

Watch the video here.
 
Neat!
Although they forgot the plastic extraction chamber.
 
Solar power that's used to generate hydrogen is less efficient than using that power to recharge a battery.
 
Solar power that's used to generate hydrogen is less efficient than using that power to recharge a battery.
Good luck removing your car battery then shipping it to the ocean and back after waiting for it to charge.
And using your car while it has no battery.
 
Solar power that's used to generate hydrogen is less efficient than using that power to recharge a battery.

And doesn't Hydrogen generation like this essentially use up water? And what happens to the Oxygen in this process and will the hydrogen consumed by these engines ever find a way to become part of water again or are those hydrogen molecules destroyed/consumed by the process?

I'm just wondering if this won't create a much bigger problem than it's supposed to avoid.
 
Mini-Hindenburgs driving all over town. And people though the Ford Pinto was an issue back in the day!
 
And doesn't Hydrogen generation like this essentially use up water? And what happens to the Oxygen in this process and will the hydrogen consumed by these engines ever find a way to become part of water again or are those hydrogen molecules destroyed/consumed by the process?

I'm just wondering if this won't create a much bigger problem than it's supposed to avoid.

These are excellent questions to ask. I often wonder if we aren't so consumed with the idea of getting away from fossil fuels that aren't just introducing a more damaging replacement. I would love to get away from fossil fuels, but it has to be better, not just different.
 
And doesn't Hydrogen generation like this essentially use up water? And what happens to the Oxygen in this process and will the hydrogen consumed by these engines ever find a way to become part of water again or are those hydrogen molecules destroyed/consumed by the process?

I'm just wondering if this won't create a much bigger problem than it's supposed to avoid.

It would just be part of the water cycle. When used in your engine you would exhaust water vapor back into the environment.
 
And doesn't Hydrogen generation like this essentially use up water? And what happens to the Oxygen in this process and will the hydrogen consumed by these engines ever find a way to become part of water again or are those hydrogen molecules destroyed/consumed by the process?

I'm just wondering if this won't create a much bigger problem than it's supposed to avoid.
Nothing is lost, unless you count the "solars" that will be used in the process.;) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_fuel
 
Production is only one problem. Storage and transportation is another. And then there's hydrogen embrittlement. It's not really an easy element to work with. I don't expect hydrogen fuel to come into wide spread use in my lifetime.
 
Production is only one problem. Storage and transportation is another. And then there's hydrogen embrittlement. It's not really an easy element to work with. I don't expect hydrogen fuel to come into wide spread use in my lifetime.
We might not have another option.
The electric grid doesnt have anywhere near the capacity to cope with all battery electric vehicles.
Long charge times put a great limit on use.
Batteries degrade so arent as good as when new. They are useful for less than a decade and are expensive to replace.
Manufacturing elements and recycling of this number of batteries could be a problem too.

On the other side of the equation it will require mass use of hydrogen power cells.
These also use elements that are not in abundance.
However only filling stations are needed to replace petrol stations, no home grown storage.

We're gonna need to break apart some asteroids to nab elements by the looks of it.
 
Good luck removing your car battery then shipping it to the ocean and back after waiting for it to charge.
And using your car while it has no battery.
Why would I ship a battery to the ocean? We could use wind to power a grid and just plug the car into the wall.
 
Why would I ship a battery to the ocean? We could use wind to power a grid and just plug the car into the wall.
You didnt address the subject matter you created.
Your post commented on how batteries should be charged directly with sea water due to higher efficiency.
This is impractical for most applications, I gave one example.

We are looking to alternative ways to power vehicles because the grid infrastructure cannot cope if we all start using electric vehicles.
Adding more wind power to the grid will not suffice.
The use of Hydrogen directly in vehicles solves a lot of problems and will be extremely similar in function to the use of petrol stations.
 
It would just be part of the water cycle. When used in your engine you would exhaust water vapor back into the environment.


Oh, so save the exhaust and recyle it back through your car and it's on-board electrolysis system ?

A guy here at work was Navy, the Sub he was on had it's own electrolysis system used for water recycling while the sub is submerged. The difference is that in their case, they keep the oxygen and dump the hydrogen. He says they were sitting on a nuclear power plant and he was far more worried about what a fire in the water recycling system would do than the reactors. And he says this is the same problem with hydrogen power cars, your driving around a fucking bomb waiting to go boom, Hindenburg anyone?

Gas powered cars can burn up pretty fiercely, the same with electric cars, I suppose hydrogen might be more dynamic.
 
Oh, so save the exhaust and recyle it back through your car and it's on-board electrolysis system ?

A guy here at work was Navy, the Sub he was on had it's own electrolysis system used for water recycling while the sub is submerged. The difference is that in their case, they keep the oxygen and dump the hydrogen. He says they were sitting on a nuclear power plant and he was far more worried about what a fire in the water recycling system would do than the reactors. And he says this is the same problem with hydrogen power cars, your driving around a fucking bomb waiting to go boom, Hindenburg anyone?

Yep, it could be tricky to handle.
There may have to be a concession because of this, having local electricity generation stations that use hydrogen and keep the batteries in the cars.
Its not going to be pretty whichever method.
 
Converting water to Hydrogen may not be as efficient as storing the energy directly in a battery but for large parts of the world it is a strong option. Hydrogen is easier to transport than large quantities of batteries, it can be used for more purposes than said batteries and storage tanks have a longer lifespan than batteries. The reaction for burning Hydrogen is also very clean 2H2(g) + O2(g) → 2H2O(g) + energy so all you get back out of the reaction is water and energy so the result is a net balance and when done to scale it is a much cheaper alternative than just about any existing battery tech. Additionally mining for the resources to mass produce batteries to the scale needed for the electric car revolution is not feasible unless we collectively end a lot of environmental regulations which just wont happen, opening new mines is expensive and time consuming and the public outcry against them is too large. I do personally think the future will be in some sort of electric/hydrogen hybrid unless some of these "breakthroughs" that have been announced in both the Hydrogen and Battery tech fields start making their way to real world applications far sooner than expected.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nenu
like this
Yep, it could be tricky to handle.
There may have to be a concession because of this, having local electricity generation stations that use hydrogen and keep the batteries in the cars.
Its not going to be pretty whichever method.
In the case of a submarine those tanks would be huge, but for a compact car that tank may only need to be in the 20 gallon range which would make it 1/3'rd the size of a standard BBQ tank which would be far more manageable.
 
In the case of a submarine those tanks would be huge, but for a compact car that tank may only need to be in the 20 gallon range which would make it 1/3'rd the size of a standard BBQ tank which would be far more manageable.
There could be a feasible way of handling Hydrogen but it has to be weighed against how much destruction would occur if just one tank could blow. And then a cascade of tanks blowing.
As long as the container itself cant rupture once a burn has started there is hope. Downside here is weight.
If the valve gets knocked out/damaged and the gas exits through that only, the potential damage will be far less but even that needs assessing if the Hydrogen is lit some time after breakage.
It is a very light gas so may disperse rapidly.
A smaller neck might be the only solution needed.
 
There could be a feasible way of handling Hydrogen but it has to be weighed against how much destruction would occur if just one tank could blow. And then a cascade of tanks blowing.
As long as the container itself cant rupture once a burn has started there is hope. Downside here is weight.
If the valve gets knocked out/damaged and the gas exits through that only, the potential damage will be far less but even that needs assessing if the Hydrogen is lit some time after breakage.
It is a very light gas so may disperse rapidly.
A smaller neck might be the only solution needed.
I am saying the car could feasibly be run by a single small tank not much larger than the "green cans" used for portal BBQ's. As far as explosions go this is an old video but still sorta relevent.

Newer video with different info, sponsored by Toyota though so grain of salt


*Edited for video links
 
Last edited:
And doesn't Hydrogen generation like this essentially use up water? And what happens to the Oxygen in this process and will the hydrogen consumed by these engines ever find a way to become part of water again or are those hydrogen molecules destroyed/consumed by the process?

I'm just wondering if this won't create a much bigger problem than it's supposed to avoid.

In nature not much is destroyed or consumed, specially in chemical reactions at sub plasma temps. the hydrogen will just be burned by a combustion engine or a fuel cell. in both causes, it will use oxygen from air to become, once again, water.
 
You didnt address the subject matter you created.
Your post commented on how batteries should be charged directly with sea water due to higher efficiency.
No, my point is why waste solar power on generating hydrogen when you could use solar power to charge a battery. You seem to be stuck at the ocean. Solar can be used anywhere where there's sunlight. Also, you could just use a grid to transport that power directly to your home, even from the ocean. That's what China is doing.
We are looking to alternative ways to power vehicles because the grid infrastructure cannot cope if we all start using electric vehicles.
Who said? Also, there's homes with Tesla power walls and solar that can recharge cars right now.
Adding more wind power to the grid will not suffice.
Again, where you getting this from?
The use of Hydrogen directly in vehicles solves a lot of problems and will be extremely similar in function to the use of petrol stations.
With the added benefit of exploding vehicles, cause hydrogen isn't volatile or anything right? People have to admit that selling fuel for vehicles or even electricity for homes is soon to be over.
 
No, my point is why waste solar power on generating hydrogen when you could use solar power to charge a battery.

Fuel cells are a mature technology. Batteries have limited range and substantial charge times. With a hydrogen economy you can use solar/wind/whatever to maintain a hydrogen reserve and quickly refuel vehicles.

What's held fuel cells back is the lack of a hydrogen distribution system, while EVs can be plugged in anywhere. Demand for hydrogen is so low right now that most of it is sourced from fossil fuel operations rather than electrolysys of water via renewable energy.

With the added benefit of exploding vehicles, cause hydrogen isn't volatile or anything right

No. We're talking about hydrogen fuel cells, not the Hindenberg. They have a very good safety record. I'm not one to fear monger about batteries but lithium batteries aren't the safest thing to be on top of during a crash, either.
 
Last edited:
Who said? Also, there's homes with Tesla power walls and solar that can recharge cars right now.

Real life numbers do not add. At present day efficiency , the surface of a solar panel necessary to charge a car is much bigger than most homes, and available sun energy is even worst on higher latitudes. I would add that photovoltaic panels are one of the most toxic tech garbage ever created.

I am all in favor of increasing solar and wind power generation, but i am not a fan of the idea of covering our houses in toxic glass that will give us a lot of headaches trying to get rid of it in 20 years.
 
In nature not much is destroyed or consumed, specially in chemical reactions at sub plasma temps. the hydrogen will just be burned by a combustion engine or a fuel cell. in both causes, it will use oxygen from air to become, once again, water.

Thank You, always good to learn a little more about the things I know less about.
 
The Toyota Mirai debuted in 2015 and more than 3000 were sold globally. Safety has not been an issue with the hydrogen tanks.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Toyota_Mirai#Safety
The tank's valves can be shut off, just like with diesel/gasoline, but escaped hydrogen can dissipate, unlike fossil fuel.

Hydrogen fuel cells look the cleanest and most practical in the long run. If you only take into account the solutions which are working/feasible that is.
 
Back
Top