No, the Linux Desktop Hasn’t Jumped in Popularity

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
There have been numerous stories that Linux has more than doubled from its usual 1.5 to 3 percent market share to 5 percent due to reports based on NetMarketShare's desktop operating system analysis, which showed Linux leaping from 2.5 percent in July to almost 5 percent in September. Unfortunately, it's not true: an executive has revealed that the share being reported is not correct. NetMarketShare is aware of the issue and currently looking into it.

If that sounds odd to you, that's because you probably think that NetMarketShare and StatCounter simply count user numbers. They don't. Instead, each uses its own secret sauce to come up with operating system numbers. NetMarketShare's methodology is to "collect data from the browsers of site visitors to our exclusive on-demand network of HitsLink Analytics and SharePost clients. The network includes over 40,000 websites and spans the globe. We 'count' unique visitors to our network sites, and only count one unique visit to each network site per day."
 
Thank god, for a minute there I thought the forums would be inundated with people saying that gaming on Linux was just as good as gaming on Windows.

All of the poker websites load just as well on Ubuntu or Windows, or even OSX. Just need to use the Firefox browser.
 
All of the poker websites load just as well on Ubuntu or Windows, or even OSX. Just need to use the Firefox browser.
Emulators fine for the most part. Those emulators that are ported. Games that only run on Windows are a problem. Valve needs to fix that.
 
The truth is, desktop Linux really doesn't offer anything compelling for the average end user over Windows or OSX, other than not being Windows or OSX. The "it's more secure" and "no telemetry" arguments fall on deaf ears, and the "it's more stable" argument became false after Windows XP. What does desktop Linux offer to the average end user that makes it easier, better, or what does it do differently that will significantly improve the computing experience? For the average user - nothing.

I'm sure we will see the usual Linux evangelists come in and provide a laundry list of features, but the reality is, none of those matter to the average user. Until there is a distribution overwhelmingly adopted by the Linux community that offers something that the average user will see as a vast improvement over Windows or OSX, Desktop Linux will remain as a tiny part of the Desktop computing experience.
 
The reality is, nobody really knows the correct number, since Linux installs dont have a way to report unique numbers to anyone/anywhere.

In part is good, but in situation like this, is bad.

Either way, use what works for you, but not because you have an obligation to blindly follow/worship a particular corporation.
 
There's good reason. Linux is a BIG P.I.T.A.! I hate it. Having to support Linux servers is bad enough. Having to deal with it on the desktop? Never!
 
linux_desktop_meme.png
 
The truth is, desktop Linux really doesn't offer anything compelling for the average end user over Windows or OSX, other than not being Windows or OSX. The "it's more secure" and "no telemetry" arguments fall on deaf ears, and the "it's more stable" argument became false after Windows XP. What does desktop Linux offer to the average end user that makes it easier, better, or what does it do differently that will significantly improve the computing experience? For the average user - nothing.
Considering the amount of Windows XP market share is miniscule and everyone has 7, 8 or 10. There is quite a bit to like over Windows. First stability, Linux as it stands now is a shit ton more stable. I'm typing this right now while I try to repair my Windows 10 machine. Updating the system: Do I need to even go there? Malware: While Linux has had some doozies as of late it's nothing compared to Windows. Using Windows and being on the Internet is like taking a helpless virgin and dropping them in a jail where no one has had sex in years. Could the virgin survive? Yes, but it won't be easy and at any moment a predator could strike leaving the virgin walking sideways and talking with a lisp that he/she didn't have before. Ads: Windows 10 is like Android without the polish, and phones home more than E.T except you are not riding a bike in the sky. Instead it's like being anal probed when you fall asleep. Performance: Linux can be tuned. Hell it can also be recompiled to offer the performance far greater than what you can do in Windows. Headless mode or not.

I'm sure we will see the usual Linux evangelists come in and provide a laundry list of features, but the reality is, none of those matter to the average user.
Except all of the things I listed matter quite a bit to the average user. The problem with Linux is that there isn't one experience. There are many. Depending on the distribution the end user experience could be rich and wonderful as anything Apple has released. But it can also be as remote as trying to be productive on BeOS. That and the ability to install it has become far more difficult with Secure Boot making everything extra difficult.

Just my two cents.
 
W3Schools actually shows a Linux market share of 6% and Mac at 9.9% : https://www.w3schools.com/browsers/browsers_os.asp

So... which of these stats is not only trustworthy, but actually useful?

I would argue none of it.

Consider the following:
  1. Should we be tracking per computer, per installed OS, or per public IP?
  2. What if you have a home with 4 Linux computers and 2 OSX computers, but 3 peoople. How should that be tracked?
  3. What if one person uses 1 Windows computer and 3 Linux computers in their daily computing usage. How should that be tracked?
  4. What about browsers that hide the OS and other info? Are we accounting for that?
The thing is, there's many different ways to look at the same data, and it doesn't necessarily do anything productive.

If we look at, for example, the STEAM stats, we get a few notable things:
  1. Kotaku reports, as of Feb 2015, that STEAM has 125 MILLION active users : https://kotaku.com/there-are-over-125-million-steam-accounts-1687820875 (this has probably increased since then)
  2. Linux on STEAM shows a 0.35% of usage
  3. This means that there COULD be upwards of 437,000 users on STEAM, or more, that are on Linux.
  4. These users still buy games.
  5. There are 2,519 games on STEAM that run natively on Linux, as of this writing : https://steamdb.info/linux/ (and this has been continually increasing for years)
So, at what point does market share percentage stop really mattering? When is it going to be enough?

Honestly, it's already enough. More and more games are coming to Linux, and that's clearly a sign that it's profitable. There are also countless stories of companies releasing games for Linux and saying that they're now making profits, they weren't making before.
 
Until I can install the vast majority of current popular video games easily and play them smoothly the linux desktop is dead to me. Games are the primary example but really its applications in general that I shouldnt have to worry about being compatible. With all the cloud based services this eliminates most applications for me but games are still a problem.

Servers on the other hand are the reverse. Unless its a SQL server or Domain Controller I try and push everything to linux as much as I can.
 
Considering the amount of Windows XP market share is miniscule and everyone has 7, 8 or 10. There is quite a bit to like over Windows. First stability, Linux as it stands now is a shit ton more stable. I'm typing this right now while I try to repair my Windows 10 machine. Updating the system: Do I need to even go there? Malware: While Linux has had some doozies as of late it's nothing compared to Windows. Using Windows and being on the Internet is like taking a helpless virgin and dropping them in a jail where no one has had sex in years. Could the virgin survive? Yes, but it won't be easy and at any moment a predator could strike leaving the virgin walking sideways and talking with a lisp that he/she didn't have before. Ads: Windows 10 is like Android without the polish, and phones home more than E.T except you are not riding a bike in the sky. Instead it's like being anal probed when you fall asleep. Performance: Linux can be tuned. Hell it can also be recompiled to offer the performance far greater than what you can do in Windows. Headless mode or not.

Except all of the things I listed matter quite a bit to the average user. The problem with Linux is that there isn't one experience. There are many. Depending on the distribution the end user experience could be rich and wonderful as anything Apple has released. But it can also be as remote as trying to be productive on BeOS. That and the ability to install it has become far more difficult with Secure Boot making everything extra difficult.

Just my two cents.
Well that took longer than I expected to come, but was exactly what I expected.

First - Stability - Windows 9x was unstable. XP and beyond was stable. Last time I had a system crash that wasn't hardware related? Let me get back to you, my extreme-long-term memory isn't what it used to be.
Second - security - do you really think that the average user really cares about security? If they did, THEY WOULD QUIT OPENING EMAILS FROM KATARIANA SAYING HI! Much easier to stop opening emails than to switch OS.
Ads - don't know what you're talking about. I turned it off with an easy to find switch on Windows 10. No ads for me.
Performance - again, we are talking about average user experience. Average users are not going to tweak their OS for performance, and certainly are not going to recompile their OS kernel. For power users, with the exception of source OS compilation (which goes way beyond power user) and kernel compilation, there are many advanced tweaks you can do in Windows, if you're willing to learn how.

Now, I certainly agree with you about the varied user experience with Desktop Linux. I see it as the prime hindrance to the development of Desktop Linux and thus its adoption.
 
W3Schools actually shows a Linux market share of 6% and Mac at 9.9% : https://www.w3schools.com/browsers/browsers_os.asp

So... which of these stats is not only trustworthy, but actually useful?

I would argue none of it.

Consider the following:
  1. Should we be tracking per computer, per installed OS, or per public IP?
  2. What if you have a home with 4 Linux computers and 2 OSX computers, but 3 peoople. How should that be tracked?
  3. What if one person uses 1 Windows computer and 3 Linux computers in their daily computing usage. How should that be tracked?
  4. What about browsers that hide the OS and other info? Are we accounting for that?
The thing is, there's many different ways to look at the same data, and it doesn't necessarily do anything productive.

If we look at, for example, the STEAM stats, we get a few notable things:
  1. Kotaku reports, as of Feb 2015, that STEAM has 125 MILLION active users : https://kotaku.com/there-are-over-125-million-steam-accounts-1687820875 (this has probably increased since then)
  2. Linux on STEAM shows a 0.35% of usage
  3. This means that there COULD be upwards of 437,000 users on STEAM, or more, that are on Linux.
  4. These users still buy games.
  5. There are 2,519 games on STEAM that run natively on Linux, as of this writing : https://steamdb.info/linux/ (and this has been continually increasing for years)
So, at what point does market share percentage stop really mattering? When is it going to be enough?

Honestly, it's already enough. More and more games are coming to Linux, and that's clearly a sign that it's profitable. There are also countless stories of companies releasing games for Linux and saying that they're now making profits, they weren't making before.

So among "web developers," the world's most flexible set of users, the Windows market share is still 85%?

That's still pretty damn depressing.

I'm sorry, but there's nothing special about Linux. The best open-source applications are already ported to your platform of choice.
 
Considering the amount of Windows XP market share is miniscule and everyone has 7, 8 or 10. There is quite a bit to like over Windows. First stability, Linux as it stands now is a shit ton more stable. I'm typing this right now while I try to repair my Windows 10 machine. Updating the system: Do I need to even go there? Malware: While Linux has had some doozies as of late it's nothing compared to Windows. Using Windows and being on the Internet is like taking a helpless virgin and dropping them in a jail where no one has had sex in years. Could the virgin survive? Yes, but it won't be easy and at any moment a predator could strike leaving the virgin walking sideways and talking with a lisp that he/she didn't have before. Ads: Windows 10 is like Android without the polish, and phones home more than E.T except you are not riding a bike in the sky. Instead it's like being anal probed when you fall asleep. Performance: Linux can be tuned. Hell it can also be recompiled to offer the performance far greater than what you can do in Windows. Headless mode or not.

Except all of the things I listed matter quite a bit to the average user. The problem with Linux is that there isn't one experience. There are many. Depending on the distribution the end user experience could be rich and wonderful as anything Apple has released. But it can also be as remote as trying to be productive on BeOS. That and the ability to install it has become far more difficult with Secure Boot making everything extra difficult.

Just my two cents.

First: No, it is not more stable, at least not when properly cared for. I have not rebooted my work computer in the last 4 months, according to my network stats, and that was when I enabled the Hyper-V role so I could make templates for another admin. Even my updates haven't required reboots lately. My home computer is in a similar situation, but I recently swapped my motherboard, CPU, and memory, without having to reinstall the OS or games. Now, my older sister's computer has been horrible, but she has a habit of powering down machines while they're updating, because she doesn't leave them on to update during off hours, and she has a habit of picking up malware, usually from links in Facebook. Her machine is horrible to support, but she has recently given up Facebook, so I anticipate things improving in the future.

Second: updates. When properly used, updates aren't a problem. Leave the machine on and it will update itself during off hours and if it needs to reboot, it can do so during off hours. Now, I have stalled the "creators'" update so far, but that's really not any different than stalling a Ubuntu update from 16.04 to 17.04. It is kind of annoying that I am going to have to let it happen soon, because Windows Update will force it, but it won't be a major upheaval any more than the stated Ubuntu update would be.

Third: Malware is easily avoidable with prudent web surfing and using the right browser. Yes, there are idiots that use IE to surf the web and click on all kinds of links, and yes, that is the typical public. However, that is not the OS's fault. If the general public were to start picking up Ubuntu, it would easuily face as many if not more problems than Windows faces today. Obscurity is NOT a proper security model. That being said, I do use a VM running Ubuntu for doing certain types of web surfing for security reasons, but that is more to isolate my personal info from anything I might snag, and to run it with Windows 10, I'd have to pay for an extra license. So, I went with a free OS. It's still a pain in the butt to do most things with. I'll get to that after addressing your points.

Fourth: Ads: Not a real thing. They come up a little bit at first, Microsoft trying to be "helpful", supposedly, but they disappear after a little while and simply don't come up. They're less bothersome than telemarketers, and FAR less bothersome than the Linux command line.

Fifth: Performance. Yeah, Linux can be tuned, to an extent, but only with major levels of expertise. 99.9% of users couldn't possibly do anything to tune Linux. I'm a systems admin, versed in all things hardware, Windows, FC storage, backups, VMWare, and some Linux and Unix, and I wouldn't know where to begin to tune my Ubuntu VM mentioned above. I know how to get some software, and I know how to use wget to pull a couple additional programs (graylog collector sidecar, salt master and minion, nxlog) and get them installed. (I am BY NO MEANS an expert on any of those. I was given instructions and I configure clients. Our systems engineer handles the configuration of the graylog and salt servers, and soon to come zabbix server. I deal with the AD, storage servers, and backups.) I know how to change the IP address, DNS, default gateway, passwords, and even iptables policies. However, performance tuning is WAY outside my experience. I don't even want to bother with that. I can tune a Windows machine in minutes: change virtual memory, temp folder location, map Onedrive to a different drive, get drivers updated, etc. I'd be willing to bet that it takes far less time to tune a Windows machine than a Linux machine.

Finally, my comment on why I hate Linux, and the likely reason why most people avoid it: it is a major pain in the butt to deal with. It is like having a car with a steering lever instead of a wheel and 17 levers to control the fuel mixture, transmission gearing, U joint gearing, tire pressure, windshield height, each door lock, seat cushion fluffiness, coefficient of tire friction, and floor solidity. Most people, including myself, don't want to have to deal with all that garbage. They want a known set of constants, and easy interface where they don't have to memorize a bunch of things, and will work around any deficiencies. If you want to control your floor solidity, then fine, but don't expect normal people to want to do that. 20 years in IT, 13 in desktop support and 7 in systems administration, has taught me that very well, and I'd rather not deal with more work than I have to do.

Linux will NEVER become mainstream for desktops. Perhaps servers. Linux is a pain in the butt, but it does do well for servers. However, it SUCKS for desktop work.
 
I like Linux. I wouldn't use it as my primary desktop, though. Even outside of Windows. At work, sure. If it had all the tools I need to do my job.

Linux works fine. It's not the best for gaming compatibility. It's a good OS that people can learn. A lot of the Linux folks are nice, but there are some that are complete dicks. Same with OSX, though. It's probably the same with Windows, but I haven't been in that "newbie learning stage" with Windows in decades.

It's not the year of the Linux desktop. If anything, I'd put it out about 10 years. Microsoft has a good hold on it, but some of their recent decisions have people wondering what the direction of the company is.
 
The year of the Linux desktop (Linux already owns every other computing category)... will come when MS releases their next version of windows. There is a very good chance the next version of windows (ya I doubt 10 is really the last) will in fact be a Linux distro.

Really I know I sound nuts but its the next logical step for MS... in 4-5 years from now. MS will opensource what they need to API wise and move to a Kernel based OS. It will save them a ton of development cash... and average users really won't see any difference. Heck its possible some of their core software like office still won't run on anyone elses "linux" distro as it will be locked to their own store.

Of course the same people that say Googles Chrome OS isn't really Linux will say the same about a non-GNU Windows running the Linux Kernel. :)
 
Linux usage is clearly going up whether they want to admit it or not. It's being driven by Google devices.

The main reason Windows dominates the PC market is that almost all PC's come with Windows. Now there's a Chromebook at the end of the laptop aisle in every Walmart and suddenly Linux is creeping up to 4, 5, 6%+ marketshare. Microsoft is in a very weak position right now with no viable successor to Windows 7 readily available. If Google comes in with some kind of Chrome Pro OS and more midrange products they could disrupt the whole PC market.
 
The year of the Linux desktop (Linux already owns every other computing category)... will come when MS releases their next version of windows. There is a very good chance the next version of windows (ya I doubt 10 is really the last) will in fact be a Linux distro.

Really I know I sound nuts but its the next logical step for MS... in 4-5 years from now. MS will opensource what they need to API wise and move to a Kernel based OS. It will save them a ton of development cash... and average users really won't see any difference. Heck its possible some of their core software like office still won't run on anyone elses "linux" distro as it will be locked to their own store.

Of course the same people that say Googles Chrome OS isn't really Linux will say the same about a non-GNU Windows running the Linux Kernel. :)
That might be the case, but Microsoft has a tendency to actually finish things before releasing them, at least far better than any and all Linux stuff. The biggest problem I have with Linux is that every time I have to deal with something new in Linux, commanded from on high, the product isn't half finished. Graylog, for example, will take in logs, but one has to be a programmer to actually see the logs. Salt is another one, where it is pretty easy to get the basics going, but it's not even half finished, and actually do anything with it requires programming experience in three different languages. It's asinine.

If Microsoft brings out a version of Windows based on Linux, it won't be Linux anymore. It will actually be finished.
 
The year of the Linux desktop (Linux already owns every other computing category)... will come when MS releases their next version of windows. There is a very good chance the next version of windows (ya I doubt 10 is really the last) will in fact be a Linux distro.

Really I know I sound nuts but its the next logical step for MS... in 4-5 years from now. MS will opensource what they need to API wise and move to a Kernel based OS. It will save them a ton of development cash... and average users really won't see any difference. Heck its possible some of their core software like office still won't run on anyone elses "linux" distro as it will be locked to their own store.

Of course the same people that say Googles Chrome OS isn't really Linux will say the same about a non-GNU Windows running the Linux Kernel. :)
I don't think this will happen, but if it does, my money would be on MS picking a non-GPL kernel, like a BSD or Open Solaris.

Linux usage is clearly going up whether they want to admit it or not. It's being driven by Google devices.

The main reason Windows dominates the PC market is that almost all PC's come with Windows. Now there's a Chromebook at the end of the laptop aisle in every Walmart and suddenly Linux is creeping up to 4, 5, 6%+ marketshare. Microsoft is in a very weak position right now with no viable successor to Windows 7 readily available. If Google comes in with some kind of Chrome Pro OS and more midrange products they could disrupt the whole PC market.
The problem with Android and Chrome OS is that they are still relatively closed systems, not the open system that is traditionally thought of as Linux. Just because they use the Linux kernel does not mean it is desktop Linux. It would be like me bragging about the huge adoption of FreeBSD, simply because Sony uses a FreeBSD kernel for the Playstation.
 
The problem with Android and Chrome OS is that they are still relatively closed systems, not the open system that is traditionally thought of as Linux. Just because they use the Linux kernel does not mean it is desktop Linux. It would be like me bragging about the huge adoption of FreeBSD, simply because Sony uses a FreeBSD kernel for the Playstation.

I don't think so, but it's entirely speculation so who knows.

All they really need at this point is a Debian clone with a really nice GUI. Take any cheap $400-700 Windows laptop in the store, dump windows and replace the spinner with a 250gb SSD and a Debian clone + Steam and you instantly have a faster, better product for the same price for the majority of users. Even if Google just pushes Chrome OS onto more devices it will further drive the trend towards Linux and away from Windows.
 
Until I can install the vast majority of current popular video games easily and play them smoothly the linux desktop is dead to me. Games are the primary example but really its applications in general that I shouldnt have to worry about being compatible. With all the cloud based services this eliminates most applications for me but games are still a problem.

Servers on the other hand are the reverse. Unless its a SQL server or Domain Controller I try and push everything to linux as much as I can.
I expand on that and say that the games have to work with no compromises. As an example, the Linux version of Metro: Last Light is inferior to the Windows version due to porting it to OpenGL. Granted, that may not be the case with Vulkan but the developers need to put in the effort to properly port the rendering engine from one API to another.
 
The truth is, desktop Linux really doesn't offer anything compelling for the average end user over Windows or OSX, other than not being Windows or OSX. The "it's more secure" and "no telemetry" arguments fall on deaf ears, and the "it's more stable" argument became false after Windows XP. What does desktop Linux offer to the average end user that makes it easier, better, or what does it do differently that will significantly improve the computing experience? For the average user - nothing.

I'm sure we will see the usual Linux evangelists come in and provide a laundry list of features, but the reality is, none of those matter to the average user. Until there is a distribution overwhelmingly adopted by the Linux community that offers something that the average user will see as a vast improvement over Windows or OSX, Desktop Linux will remain as a tiny part of the Desktop computing experience.

This is pretty spot on. Also I quit using Linux more than just enough to stay up to date years ago mostly because of the community not the OS. The OS itself is largely fine for most of my applications, the community however is largely insufferable.
 
Considering the amount of Windows XP market share is miniscule and everyone has 7, 8 or 10. There is quite a bit to like over Windows. First stability, Linux as it stands now is a shit ton more stable. I'm typing this right now while I try to repair my Windows 10 machine. Updating the system: Do I need to even go there? Malware: While Linux has had some doozies as of late it's nothing compared to Windows. Using Windows and being on the Internet is like taking a helpless virgin and dropping them in a jail where no one has had sex in years. Could the virgin survive? Yes, but it won't be easy and at any moment a predator could strike leaving the virgin walking sideways and talking with a lisp that he/she didn't have before. Ads: Windows 10 is like Android without the polish, and phones home more than E.T except you are not riding a bike in the sky. Instead it's like being anal probed when you fall asleep. Performance: Linux can be tuned. Hell it can also be recompiled to offer the performance far greater than what you can do in Windows. Headless mode or not.

Except all of the things I listed matter quite a bit to the average user. The problem with Linux is that there isn't one experience. There are many. Depending on the distribution the end user experience could be rich and wonderful as anything Apple has released. But it can also be as remote as trying to be productive on BeOS. That and the ability to install it has become far more difficult with Secure Boot making everything extra difficult.

Just my two cents.

Windows stability has been fine for a long time. Linux is great but I think another problem is the community can be hostile to newbies. Ubuntu, Mint, are pretty easy to setup but some of the other distros are more difficult to properly setup so your average Joe can get frustrated with that and some of the community.
 
the community however is largely insufferable.
You got that right. The phrase "RTFM" comes to mind. Great so I have a problem and I'm coming to the community for help and the first thing you tell me is "RTFM". If you tell me that I'm going to tell you where to go and how to get there.

If you say you have a problem in either the Windows or MacOS community they're going to be far more helpful than the "RTFM"ers in the Linux community.

For the uninitiated RTFM stands for... Read The Fucking Manual.
 
You got that right. The phrase "RTFM" comes to mind. Great so I have a problem and I'm coming to the community for help and the first thing you tell me is "RTFM". If you tell me that I'm going to tell you where to go and how to get there.

If you say you have a problem in either the Windows or MacOS community they're going to be far more helpful than the "RTFM"ers in the Linux community.

For the uninitiated RTFM stands for... Read The Fucking Manual.

Well sometimes people do need to read the manual. ;) --help :)

Really I have seen the same sort of responses on EVERY tech support forum that isn't moderated by a private company. I have also seen 1001 responses in every forum... but for sure a larger % of them from windows support sites that are just plain stupid. Some suggested fixes you see on windows support sites are just painful to read... never mind that in many cases they'll make someones issues worse, or send them on an hours long goose chase.

The support sites for the new linux user focused distros like Mint / Ubuntu are not full of RTFM people... anyone claiming they are is full of it. If we are talking about gentoo or arch or something which IS NOT AIMED at new users and they go out of there way to make that clear from day zero, well in those cases... ask a stupid question, get a stupid answer. :) Linux isn't one unified operating system... so people shouldn't paint the different types of support for different distros with the same brush is all I'm saying. Newbie focused Linux distros have very helpful patient communities and its a disservice to them to claim that "Linux" users are all assholes. Yes advanced linux distro users, are also very helpful but in general have no time for people that have never touched Linux trying to install an advanced NOT aimed at them distro, who are asking basic newbie questions about grub ect.
 
Desktop Linux use/desirability/interest is climbing which is a good sign, but nobody in the community seriously thought that one metric jumping so significantly was indicative of anything and/or not an error. Rather, many many metrics have been growing steadily over the past several years and that's the real strength. However, I would venture that a great number of metrics are actually under-reporting Linux adoption, especially when it comes to gaming. For instance, the way Steam "counts' a game being purchased and play metrics, Steam hardware survey, many vendors (including now Humble Bundle) who exclusively use browser User Agent to asssign platform sales, etc... all underreport significantly in the very likely scenario that the player ever uses something that doesn't "register" as Linux. This can be as simple as using WINE, or something like virtualization, dual booting, or using multiple PCs with different OSes. The user may be making their purchase decisions and play on Linux, but if they were on the WINE Steam version at the time of purchase, well that's a Windows platform sale unless very specific things happen in a specific time frame. Browsing on a Windows machine on Humble or GMG without manually hacking your UserAgent before purchase? Another Windows sale etc. This is to say nothing for things that are unlikely to be detected easily by automated metrics at all, such as the increasing interest in Linux ports on Steam Forum threads, or Linux nearly being a required feature/stretch goal for successful Kickstarter projects etc.. despite the importance of these changes showcasing a strong interest with money available for those who cater to it.

Some may say correctly "How can these metrics detect something that isn't being used at the time" and that's true - but we actually need new metrics that can better detect the "Influence" of Linux and its growing adoption on the desktop and for other circles such as gaming. For instance, Steam should give users the option to "flag" their account/purchases etc... manually with one (and maybe more, but certainly 1) preferred platform. No matter what person X is playing, if they flag their account as Linux-preferred, that will show up on the other end when metrics are taken, at least offering a bit more information. Likewise, changing how metrics on gameplay and what counts as a sale on Steam itself, not to mention 3rd party sites etc... could be done to make things clearer. Linux adoption and as driving force for game/software purchases is growing, but that doesn't mean the majority of users are full, time, exclusive to Linux for a wide variety of reasons. Its not realistic for either Linux advocates or developers/publishers appraising the platform to discount or ignore this, as there are far more users in the "Linux native is best, but I'll also use workarounds until we get closer to full parity" than the "Linux native only, anything else I'll just give up" category. Many of the ways sites, devs/publishers, and platforms gather information are flawed with respect to this most crucial demographic, which under-represents the adoption and more importantly the drive and desirability of Linux support.
 
The truth is, desktop Linux really doesn't offer anything compelling for the average end user over Windows or OSX, other than not being Windows or OSX. The "it's more secure" and "no telemetry" arguments fall on deaf ears, and the "it's more stable" argument became false after Windows XP. What does desktop Linux offer to the average end user that makes it easier, better, or what does it do differently that will significantly improve the computing experience? For the average user - nothing.

I'm sure we will see the usual Linux evangelists come in and provide a laundry list of features, but the reality is, none of those matter to the average user. Until there is a distribution overwhelmingly adopted by the Linux community that offers something that the average user will see as a vast improvement over Windows or OSX, Desktop Linux will remain as a tiny part of the Desktop computing experience.
It offers a lot more(or less if you like). It gets rid of windows viruses/malware/telemetry/metro/crap. If all my games played on Linux, I would switch no problem.
 
It offers a lot more(or less if you like). It gets rid of windows viruses/malware/telemetry/metro/crap. If all my games played on Linux, I would switch no problem.
Again, the same arguments that have been made for the past 20 years, which has been demonstrated to not be a concern to the average user.
 
Well that took longer than I expected to come, but was exactly what I expected.
Well I expected you to speak about it truthfully. I guess I overestimated.
First - Stability - Windows 9x was unstable. XP and beyond was stable. Last time I had a system crash that wasn't hardware related? Let me get back to you, my extreme-long-term memory isn't what it used to be.
Stability inherently includes hardware. If Linux can run forever without the video card driver crashing then Windows can as well. Furthermore stability also includes the software WORKING. You know like clicking on the menu in Windows 10 and having it populate correctly.
Second - security - do you really think that the average user really cares about security? If they did, THEY WOULD QUIT OPENING EMAILS FROM KATARIANA SAYING HI! Much easier to stop opening emails than to switch OS.
Of course they do. You think they like going to Geek Squad over and over. Funny that I could open that email in Linux and chances of it ruining my system is 0.005%.
Ads - don't know what you're talking about. I turned it off with an easy to find switch on Windows 10. No ads for me.
If you don't know what I'm talking about then why are you telling me you turned it off. Furthermore that doesn't address the ad revenue generated by mere use of the OS.
Performance - again, we are talking about average user experience. Average users are not going to tweak their OS for performance, and certainly are not going to recompile their OS kernel. For power users, with the exception of source OS compilation (which goes way beyond power user) and kernel compilation, there are many advanced tweaks you can do in Windows, if you're willing to learn how.
Putting in compilation flags is easy. But I agree, the kind of performance tweaks in Linux would never be performed by your average user.
 
Windows stability has been fine for a long time. Linux is great but I think another problem is the community can be hostile to newbies. Ubuntu, Mint, are pretty easy to setup but some of the other distros are more difficult to properly setup so your average Joe can get frustrated with that and some of the community.
I agree about the community.
 
Well I expected you to speak about it truthfully. I guess I overestimated.

Stability inherently includes hardware. If Linux can run forever without the video card driver crashing then Windows can as well. Furthermore stability also includes the software WORKING. You know like clicking on the menu in Windows 10 and having it populate correctly.

Of course they do. You think they like going to Geek Squad over and over. Funny that I could open that email in Linux and chances of it ruining my system is 0.005%.

If you don't know what I'm talking about then why are you telling me you turned it off. Furthermore that doesn't address the ad revenue generated by mere use of the OS.

Putting in compilation flags is easy. But I agree, the kind of performance tweaks in Linux would never be performed by your average user.

You're going back to technical details. I am talking about average user perception.

Amiga OS was technically superior to DOS/Windows in almost every way
OS/2 was technically superior to Windows 95 in almost every way
BeOS was Technically superior to Windows 95 in almost every way
Mac OS was technically superior to Windows 9x in almost every way
Some may argue that the latest version of each of these is still superior to any Windows OS in almost every way.

End user perception was that they could do better with a Windows computer than with Amiga, OS/2, BeOS, etc.
Yes, there were other "issues" that resulted in each of these OS's dying, or in the case of Mac OS, diminishing, but the fact remains that technical superiority does not sway the average end user. If that were the case today, everyone would be using FreeBSD ;)

The Technical superiority that Linux supposedly has on the desktop realistically is not great enough to persuade the average user. Until the Linux community realizes this, and is able to design the OS to improve the computer experience in a significant perceptible way, Linux on the Desktop is going to continue to be relegated to the extreme minority.
 
It offers a lot more(or less if you like). It gets rid of windows viruses/malware/telemetry/metro/crap. If all my games played on Linux, I would switch no problem.
Yeah, that's pretty much the short and long of it for me.

Again, the same arguments that have been made for the past 20 years, which has been demonstrated to not be a concern to the average user.
Maybe there's a good reason that same argument is still being made 20 years later, while simultaneously PC gaming has become bigger than ever, with a a market worth $35 billion, containing some of the most dedicated enthusiasts that have a history of driving hardware sales and development due to rampant consumer demand. Yeah, you totally don't need to cater to that crowd for Linux to catch on and average users to follow.
 
You're going back to technical details. I am talking about average user perception.

Amiga OS was technically superior to DOS/Windows in almost every way
OS/2 was technically superior to Windows 95 in almost every way
BeOS was Technically superior to Windows 95 in almost every way
Mac OS was technically superior to Windows 9x in almost every way
Some may argue that the latest version of each of these is still superior to any Windows OS in almost every way.

End user perception was that they could do better with a Windows computer than with Amiga, OS/2, BeOS, etc.
Yes, there were other "issues" that resulted in each of these OS's dying, or in the case of Mac OS, diminishing, but the fact remains that technical superiority does not sway the average end user. If that were the case today, everyone would be using FreeBSD ;)

The Technical superiority that Linux supposedly has on the desktop realistically is not great enough to persuade the average user. Until the Linux community realizes this, and is able to design the OS to improve the computer experience in a significant perceptible way, Linux on the Desktop is going to continue to be relegated to the extreme minority.


People use Windows because it's literally forced onto them, when you buy an OEM device there's a 99% chance it's going to have Windows 10 installed on it - It's the McDonalds of operating systems, most consumers aren't even aware of the fact that the operating system is installed and can be replaced!

Windows popularity has got nothing to do with some "end user perception rubbish". In fact, as far as end user perception goes Windows 10 adoption has stalled and they're giving it away! Desktop Linux awareness is growing, the CEO of MS can be quoted as stating that desktop Windows usage is declining, I see no evidence whatsoever that Linux usage is not increasing.

Windows is quickly becoming a cesspool of viruses, malware and PUP's and this situation is not improving. Linux is the more secure OS and a modern distro is easily as simple to use as macOS (yes, terminal is necessary in certain situations under macOS).

Even Adobe was recently spotted showing their software suite running under Ubuntu.

All your posts are unfounded rubbish based on 20 years ago.
 
Last edited:
All your posts are unfounded rubbish based on 20 years ago.

I could say the same for your post. Windows is not "quickly becoming" a "cesspool of viruses..." as it is much more secure than it was in the 9x - XP days. Your statement there is based solely on opinion without facts or reality to back it up.

And I will make another point again that the average user doesn't care about security. When Windows Vista was introduced, it was very secure due to the UAC, and the default user not being an admin account. Users cried loudly for this "inconvenience" and everyone was turning off UAC and setting their login accounts to Admin status. You think these same people will suddenly change their tune if switched to Linux, and not want their login account to be superuser/root just for convenience sake?

So Windows 10 adoption has stalled? How much of that is due to the stalling of the PC market in general? Most of that stall is people staying with Windows 7, not switching to SUbuntora Minnimon.

most consumers aren't even aware of the fact that the operating system is installed and can be replaced!
This proves my point. Average user perception. What will the Linux community be able to do to change this? The same tired arguments aren't working, no matter how much the Linux evangelists want to grasp onto any news that promises wide desktop linux adoption. For Linux to make appreciable gains in adoption, and even begin to challenge OS X in market share, there will need to be an OEM putting Linux Desktop computers in Best Buy, Wal-Mart, etc. Why do they not do it? That is the question and problem the Linux community needs to address and fix to see the New Linux World Order ushered in.
 
I could say the same for your post. Windows is not "quickly becoming" a "cesspool of viruses..." as it is much more secure than it was in the 9x - XP days. Your statement there is based solely on opinion without facts or reality to back it up.

And I will make another point again that the average user doesn't care about security. When Windows Vista was introduced, it was very secure due to the UAC, and the default user not being an admin account. Users cried loudly for this "inconvenience" and everyone was turning off UAC and setting their login accounts to Admin status. You think these same people will suddenly change their tune if switched to Linux, and not want their login account to be superuser/root just for convenience sake?

So Windows 10 adoption has stalled? How much of that is due to the stalling of the PC market in general? Most of that stall is people staying with Windows 7, not switching to SUbuntora Minnimon.


This proves my point. Average user perception. What will the Linux community be able to do to change this? The same tired arguments aren't working, no matter how much the Linux evangelists want to grasp onto any news that promises wide desktop linux adoption. For Linux to make appreciable gains in adoption, and even begin to challenge OS X in market share, there will need to be an OEM putting Linux Desktop computers in Best Buy, Wal-Mart, etc. Why do they not do it? That is the question and problem the Linux community needs to address and fix to see the New Linux World Order ushered in.
Secure from external virus's. It has so much crap in it now you could say it has internal virus's, malware, and spyware. But it is not the users software anymore and MS knows what you want. You get what you get and don't throw a fit!
 
Secure from external virus's. It has so much crap in it now you could say it has internal virus's, malware, and spyware. But it is not the users software anymore and MS knows what you want. You get what you get and don't throw a fit!
So why aren't people demanding OEM's provide computers with Puparchtoo Linux installed by default? If Linux is so superior in so many ways to Windows, why are the computer buying public not clamoring for these?

Again, remember my point. I am not arguing that Linux is not more secure than Windows. I am stating that this argument for people to ditch Windows for Linux is not convincing people, because it is not a significant enough issue (Windows is secure "enough") for the average user. Simply repeating the talking points of the last 20 years is not working, and will not work for the next 20 years.

The Linux community seems stuck on "it's more secure, it's more stable, and you can do essentially anything you can do on Windows." This isn't convincing the average computer buyer. What can the Linux community do to make Linux a more attractive alternative that the average user will prefer that over what they already know, and has gajillions more compatible programs?
 
So why aren't people demanding OEM's provide computers with Puparchtoo Linux installed by default? If Linux is so superior in so many ways to Windows, why are the computer buying public not clamoring for these?

Again, remember my point. I am not arguing that Linux is not more secure than Windows. I am stating that this argument for people to ditch Windows for Linux is not convincing people, because it is not a significant enough issue (Windows is secure "enough") for the average user. Simply repeating the talking points of the last 20 years is not working, and will not work for the next 20 years.

The Linux community seems stuck on "it's more secure, it's more stable, and you can do essentially anything you can do on Windows." This isn't convincing the average computer buyer. What can the Linux community do to make Linux a more attractive alternative that the average user will prefer that over what they already know, and has gajillions more compatible programs?
It all depends on the users. I switched a business center over to Linux and since it looks/feels like Windows, it was no problem. Only problem was after I left the company I got a call because the tech had NFI what to do with Linux.
If you have to have a program that only Windows can do, then it's an easy choice.
 
People use Windows because it's literally forced onto them, when you buy an OEM device there's a 99% chance it's going to have Windows 10 installed on it - It's the McDonalds of operating systems, most consumers aren't even aware of the fact that the operating system is installed and can be replaced!

Windows popularity has got nothing to do with some "end user perception rubbish". In fact, as far as end user perception goes Windows 10 adoption has stalled and they're giving it away! Desktop Linux awareness is growing, the CEO of MS can be quoted as stating that desktop Windows usage is declining, I see no evidence whatsoever that Linux usage is not increasing.

Windows is quickly becoming a cesspool of viruses, malware and PUP's and this situation is not improving. Linux is the more secure OS and a modern distro is easily as simple to use as macOS (yes, terminal is necessary in certain situations under macOS).

Even Adobe was recently spotted showing their software suite running under Ubuntu.

All your posts are unfounded rubbish based on 20 years ago.

If you honestly think that regular users would accept Linux as an OS, try giving one of your relatives a Linux machine, explain how much more stable and secure it is, and let them try it out without your help. They'll run back to their Windows machine inside two hours.

It's been tried. A town in Germany tried pushing Linux to their city workers for years. They had constant problems with users being unable to figure out how to do things on it, and had training nightmares on nearly every aspect of the OS. They also had all sorts of administration nightmares with it, such as pushing updates and permissions. The went to Windows 8 rather than stay on Linux. Windows 8. If that doesn't say it all, I don't know what does.
 
Back
Top