Ghost In The Shell Official Trailer

It was almost as good as Charlize Therons Aeon Flux.

Ow.. That's harsh.

Probably true, but harsh. I'll find out when it hits blue ray.
(I suspect this is part of the box office problem. A lot of the fan base is of that age where getting out to the movies doesn't happen that much, me included).
 
"Everything they told you about your past was a lie". LOFL! Can a Hollywood script be any more by-the-fucking-numbers!? Hollywood is pushing hard to do Akira. Can you imagine the fucking mess they would make of that? Dragon Ball. The Last Air Bender. Keep them away from the beloved anime and let them do something like Powerpuff Girls. That has potential to be a good live action movie. Mojo Jojo would steal the movie imho. Who could play Miss Sara Bellum?
 
Last edited:
So I just saw this movie last night and I have to say ... it's not bad. If I measured this movie as a standalone without comparison to the original anime, I'd go so far as saying it's a good movie. Outside of the fact that Scarjo can't really act, at least she's pretty to look at.

I feel bad for the movie makers who have gotten all the flak from the butthurt anime fanboys / SJWs. I'm Asian and I don't even care about the casting. If this was made in Asia and they put a white chick in it, I'd be more upset, but a movie made in the USA starring a white chick ... is better than no movie at all. Production quality was good, special effects were good / cool. Dialog was ... OK, but this isn't Driving Miss Daisy ... it's a popcorn action / sci-fi flick ... so I can give that a pass. Heck, I even pre-ordered the blu-ray so I can watch it / and the extras on my home setup when it comes out.
 
A counter argument to "why is she Caucasian?" is simply, "why shouldn't she be Caucasian?". I don't feel like I should have to dig up references to show that many foreign cultures also adopt and appreciate aspects of American culture. To think that if someone manufactured a body, and had the option to make it look how they desired, it could look like a person from anywhere. As the body was a military weapon, though, It would make sense to design one that would appeal to the country with the largest military budget. Merica.
That being said, of course Holywood is going to pick a major Holywood actress to star in a financially significant film. As thematically, the body doesn't matter, I would have been satisfied with any person, as long as they could act the role, tbh.

I saw the movie with cautious optimism, and I was not disappointed. Sure it wasn't entirely faithful to any one source material, but I never assumed it would. If anything I felt a few of the characters and sections of dialog were maybe too authentic to the original materials, as there were too out-dated for modern culture and cinema. I'm just thankful they didn't include lines like the original movie's closing, "The net is vast and infinite."
The implication was that Dr. Ouelet created Major in her image as the daughter she always wanted. So it goes straight back to the plot they created and explains Dr. Ouelet's motivations.
If only because it would have been more true to the source material. I don't even care about real nudity, implied would have been fine and certainly enough, but the violence didn't come close and that is one of the series' hallmarks.
More graphic violence would have been welcome, but you don't think that this is implied nudity?

upload_2017-4-19_10-10-58.png


I think half of Major's screen time is showing her in the camo suit. The first scene in the movie is literally showing her cyborg body being built and molded.
 
I watched it again last week in 3d, and boy does it make a HUGE difference. I hadn't seen a 3d movie since Avengers IIRC and I gotta say I was quite pleased.
 
So I just saw this movie last night and I have to say ... it's not bad. If I measured this movie as a standalone without comparison to the original anime, I'd go so far as saying it's a good movie. Outside of the fact that Scarjo can't really act, at least she's pretty to look at.

I feel bad for the movie makers who have gotten all the flak from the butthurt anime fanboys / SJWs. I'm Asian and I don't even care about the casting. If this was made in Asia and they put a white chick in it, I'd be more upset, but a movie made in the USA starring a white chick ... is better than no movie at all. Production quality was good, special effects were good / cool. Dialog was ... OK, but this isn't Driving Miss Daisy ... it's a popcorn action / sci-fi flick ... so I can give that a pass. Heck, I even pre-ordered the blu-ray so I can watch it / and the extras on my home setup when it comes out.

Yeah I watched it few days ago and I felt it was ok. Definitely not total trash tier as majority of opinions suggest as I have seen much worse stuff.
 
Yeah I watched it few days ago and I felt it was ok. Definitely not total trash tier as majority of opinions suggest as I have seen much worse stuff.

That is the thing...people are treating it as "trash tier" because it didn't hit the mark 100% from their viewpoint. It is the whole logic of there are enough religions on this planet such that everyone is going to hell. It is becoming more of a binary world out there...and that is boring.
 
OK so I ended up seeing this early because a friend drug me there. I planned to watch it once it hit Redbox.

So let's get this out if the way, I didn't care about the cast. Who played what role wasn't important. It wasn't bad, it wasn't good it was just meh. Honestly if you watched GITS, this film really serves no purpose. If you haven't, then it isn't the worst representation of it. So it want trash like some are trying to say, I just don't feel like there was any real reason to make it. So it wasn't walk out bad, but I certainly wouldn't spend any money to watch it either.
 
I don't see how that question relates to what you quoted from me.
Your only example of her being japanese is her name. Despite the fact she looks overwhelmingly Caucasian.

You realize that Japanese characters portrayed in America cinema are often given American names just to make it easier to pronounce and remember. Thats the only reason Motoko is named Motoko. She's white but they gave her a jap name to make her more relatable.
 
Truthfully, this is a red herring. GitS is an American-produced film. So we should be talking about America, not China, and Asian Americans are 5.6% of America. So why shouldn't Asian American actors and actresses star in American films?
You're asking a negative. The proper question is "why should they star in American films?"

Movies arent meant to be some sort of handout to aspiring actors to launch their careers. When you have a hundred mill on the line your goal is to get that back and then some. Nobody is going to give some random no-name asian actress her big shot in a movie just because the story originated in a Manga. Truthfully there are just no proven female Asian actresses for a role like this.
 
Your only example of her being japanese is her name. Despite the fact she looks overwhelmingly Caucasian.

I wasn't aware that purple hair was a naturally occurring hair color among Caucasians. Because it's not.

And yes, let's forget that once again, the very first page of the comic states that the setting is Japan, it is the fictional future, but "the nation-state and ethnic groups still survive."

You realize that Japanese characters portrayed in America cinema are often given American names just to make it easier to pronounce and remember. Thats the only reason Motoko is named Motoko. She's white but they gave her a jap name to make her more relatable.

OK, where to begin here. So according to you, Japanese characters portrayed in American cinema are often given American names to make it easier to pronounce and remember. (Examples?) Therefore, give a white character portrayed in American cinema a Japanese name to make her more relatable. There is literally no logical connection between your premise and your conclusion.

You also don't seem to be aware that Ghost in the Shell, the 2017 film, is an adaptation of a franchise that began as a comic published from 1989 to 1990 whose first page, once again, clearly states that the setting is Japan, it is the fictional future, but "the nation-state and ethnic groups still survive."
 
You're asking a negative. The proper question is "why should they star in American films?"

OK, that pretty much reveals you to be a racist. You can play the SJW card if you want. I voted for Gary Johnson the last two elections. Doesn't work on me.

Asian Americans are a part of America. That is why they should star in American films. Simple as that.

Movies arent meant to be some sort of handout to aspiring actors to launch their careers. When you have a hundred mill on the line your goal is to get that back and then some. Nobody is going to give some random no-name asian actress her big shot in a movie just because the story originated in a Manga. Truthfully there are just no proven female Asian actresses for a role like this.

Yeah, that's exactly why The Last Airbender had a $150 million budget. Because they knew that Noah Ringer and Jackson Rathbone had proven track records of getting hundreds of millions in box office receipts.

Oh wait, The Last Airbender was Noah Ringer's first role, and Jackson Rathbone played a background supporting character in the Twilight films. I never saw any of them, but I assume that fangirls were paying to see Robert Pattinson, not Jackson Rathbone.
 
I'm waiting for one of you to produce a link to the universal law that says anything creative must be represented by the original intent of the author of the material specifically in regards to the race of the characters being portrayed. He/She who spends the 150 million to get the movie made can have Jake Gyllenhal play an Arabian prince all they want...
 
I'm waiting for one of you to produce a link to the universal law that says anything creative must be represented by the original intent of the author of the material specifically in regards to the race of the characters being portrayed. He/She who spends the 150 million to get the movie made can have Jake Gyllenhal play an Arabian prince all they want...

I've been arguing against bad reasons for whitewashing. You're going with the argument that people who secure the rights to the adaptation can do whatever they want, as long as it's not illegal. I've never questioned that.

What I've disputed are bad arguments. Like the repeated claims that studios aren't going to spend money on Asian American nobodies. Yet, it's clear that they will spend money, lots of money, on white nobodies. See The Last Airbender. $150 million to cast a nobody as the lead actor. Not a star like Jake Gyllenhaal. A nobody.

So this is a bad argument, and the people making it know it's bad because they have nothing to say in response to the Airbender counterexample.
 
I am a movie buff Alex, probably like a lot of people who frequent this forum. I don't disagree with you, and the Airbender example is spot on, although I would have went with Kung Fu with David Carradine, but whatever. I was just stirring the pot for Scarletts' sake...
 
Racist card: check.

Have we seen the conclusion of Godwin's Law, yet?
 
"Why can't we eat babies?" does not mean I actually enjoy eating babies... (but sometimes I do have to consume their spinal fluids, tossing the rest of them aside in a pile)
 
what? you used it in response to something about Japanese people and as if Japanese people do have naturally purple hair.
youre not making much sense with any of your arguments and then start calling people racist...
 
is a racist question. You would never ask "why should white Americans star in American films?" Asian Americans are Americans. Period.

People that end their arguments with the word "Period" or "Full Stop" have no real leg to stand on. It's as bad as saying "just because, so there!"

Movies are first and foremost, business enterprises marketed for both domestic and international audiences. Wanting to ensure the biggest box office return by casting a A-List white actress instead of a B or C-List ethnically appropriate actress is not whitewashing in my book. (especially since we're dealing with fictional comic book characters- and not characters based on real people)

And even if it doesn't boil down to money, filmmakers want to cast the best actors they can get. Lawrence of Arabia, has no Arabs in the principal cast. A Mexican, and Egyptian and a guy from West Sussex- and it's still one of the greatest films ever made. Zoe Saldana is a smarter casting choice to carry a biopic than Mary J. Blige in Nina. Cloud Atlas has an ensemble cast that acts across both racial and gender types- and it's not a whitewashing crime for actors to play those roles.

That is the thing...people are treating it as "trash tier" because it didn't hit the mark 100% from their viewpoint

It's no different from the complainers about Ghostbusters last year, or the Turks that are down-voting that Armenian genocide movie The Promise this year. It's shrill complaining that they don't like it, without having even seen the film. It's no different from review-bombing, and it's just as useful.

I liked GitS. I felt ScarJo did an okay job and I don't believe any other actress (regardless of their skin color) could've done better with the material. I feel the filmmaker's only mistake in making it a generic origin story instead of the challenging the audience. But it's one I'll buy on disc.
 
People that end their arguments with the word "Period" or "Full Stop" have no real leg to stand on. It's as bad as saying "just because, so there!"

The argument is one sentence: Asian Americans are Americans. Nothing else needs to be said. Hence, the period.

Movies are first and foremost, business enterprises marketed for both domestic and international audiences. Wanting to ensure the biggest box office return by casting a A-List white actress instead of a B or C-List ethnically appropriate actress is not whitewashing in my book. (especially since we're dealing with fictional comic book characters- and not characters based on real people)

Is casting a C-list white actor instead of a C-list ethnically appropriate actor whitewashing?

And even if it doesn't boil down to money, filmmakers want to cast the best actors they can get. Lawrence of Arabia, has no Arabs in the principal cast. A Mexican, and Egyptian

Uh, Omar Sharif was an Arab man.
 
It was a decent movie. I saw the original a long time ago but didn't plan on comparing the two.
 
what? you used it in response to something about Japanese people and as if Japanese people do have naturally purple hair.

No, I did not use purple hair to imply that Japanese people naturally have purple hair. I used it to mock the claim that Motoko Kusanagi is drawn white, as if purple hair connotes whiteness.

youre not making much sense with any of your arguments and then start calling people racist...

Would you ever ask "why should white Americans star in American films?" Would you ever ask "why should black Americans star in American films?" If your answers are "that's a dumb question" and "no," then "why should Asian Americans star in American films?" is a racist question.

I get that I'm replying to some people who think that racism is an overplayed card, and that is something SJWs can legitimately be blamed for. But I didn't pull the "card" when people went on and on about the money argument. I didn't pull the "card" when people claimed that anime characters look white.

I "pulled" it when nysmo claimed that the proper question was "why should Asian Americans star in American films?" That is a racist question because you would never ask that about white or black Americans.
 
No, I did not use purple hair to imply that Japanese people naturally have purple hair. I used it to mock the claim that Motoko Kusanagi is drawn white, as if purple hair connotes whiteness.
then you need to add /s or :rolleyes: or something to indicate so.
your reasonings, to me, are pointless. a Caucasian looking ANIMATED character with a Japanese name doesn't require a Japanese actor. youre turning this thread into some sjw bullshit about a fucking FICTIONAL character. give it a rest already. I'm done arguing.


so anybody else want to chime in on how the movie was?
 
then you need to add /s or :rolleyes: or something to indicate so.
your reasonings, to me, are pointless. a Caucasian looking ANIMATED character with a Japanese name doesn't require a Japanese actor. youre turning this thread into some sjw bullshit about a fucking FICTIONAL character.

Why is she "Caucasian looking"? That's something you people always claim but never explain other than "it's obvious."

Also, like I said, I voted for Gary Johnson. In two Presidential elections. Implying that I'm an SJW doesn't work on me (unless in your world, SJWs vote for Libertarian Party candidates).

give it a rest already. I'm done arguing.

Yeah, you said that already. In case you forgot, you were the one who decided to reply to me after I replied to someone else, after you said that you were done.
 
I know how we can settle this debate; please find me a picture of a blue eyed Asian. Major's hair color in the movie is black, not purple jackass.
 
And no I'm not racist, I'm just saying that hollywood does not have a habit of using actors that do not reflect their intended audience. You reference one dogshit movie that came out years ago. If thats how youre going to play it then I can reference every single movie that came out since then that did not star an asian actor. I mean wtf are you even getting at? Again, movies are a business, executives typically arent going to dick around with unproven actors. Every now and then you might get one producer whos willing to go out on a limb because they think rolling the dice might work out in their favor. But GITS was never destined to be one of those films, cuz ya'know, major is clearly a caucasian woman so it was a moot point to begin with.

And I think they would have been willing to use an Asian star if there were any. Tell me who the hell you would nominate for this role? Because guess what, despite the fact Asian cinema is predominately filled with Asian actors, I guarantee you if Tom Cruise volunteered for the leading role of an obese geisha woman in Asia's next big movie they'd snap jump at that offer regardless of who he was playing.
 
I know how we can settle this debate; please find me a picture of a blue eyed Asian. Major's hair color in the movie is black, not purple jackass.

Do you not get that Ghost in the Shell started as a comic?

https://static.giantbomb.com/uploads/original/18/185797/2716557-6467060587-l.jpg.jpg

And no I'm not racist, I'm just saying that hollywood does not have a habit of using actors that do not reflect their intended audience. You reference one dogshit movie that came out years ago. If thats how youre going to play it then I can reference every single movie that came out since then that did not star an asian actor. I mean wtf are you even getting at? Again, movies are a business, executives typically arent going to dick around with unproven actors. Every now and then you might get one producer whos willing to go out on a limb because they think rolling the dice might work out in their favor. But GITS was never destined to be one of those films, cuz ya'know, major is clearly a caucasian woman so it was a moot point to begin with.

One dogshit movie that came out in 2010 is all I need. That's called a counterexample.

Why is Major "clearly" a Caucasian woman? What from the source material (the comic that was serialized between 1989 and 1990) says she is "clearly" a Caucasian woman?
 
Nobody gives a fuck about the source because this movie was essentially being re-invented for an audience that is unfamiliar with the source. There was a lot of good source material hence their decision to try and stay somewhat close as far as style, action sequences, scenery, etc. But honestly they could have changed 100% of the story or cloned it, either way it would not have mattered since if you ask any random person "do you know what GITS is?" they'd say no. They'd just see a trailer and say "hmm, that looks cool, hey honey wanna see this new sci-fi movie with scarlett johansson?"

This movie was not made to bring GITS to the masses. It was made because comic books have been doing well as film adaptations this decade and this was another chance to cash in.
 
One dogshit movie that came out in 2010 is all I need. That's called a counterexample.
What exactly is this an example of? I said hollywood isnt going to gamble on unproven asian actors and then you mention a movie that utterly failed as an example that they did? Did you ever understand my point? In case you missed it, the question is ultimately "SHOULD hollywood risk hundreds of millions of dollars on actors that may or may not be able to execute their role?" Using your example the answer is a resounding NO. But hey, since thats how youre going to play it, you cant really claim any attempt at whitewashing because lookie here, hollywood DID give some unproven asians a shot at a big movie, case closed, that one movie is all we need to prove hollywood does not white wash.

I ask again who would you like to have seen in GITS?
 
Doesnt prove anything wrong. You're obviously some anime geek that is outraged they didnt give some asian actress blue contacts and an eye lift to make her actually resemble her character (i know i know, Scar Jo looks NOTHING like major right?). What else, should this movie have been given subtitles too? I mean it's Japanese right? How dare they provide english dialogue.
 

Lumping these two different peoples in the same basket is reductive. They may both speak Arabic and worship Allah, but it doesn't make them the same or fold into each other. But if all you know is what you've gleamed from R-to-L Manga and fansubbed Anime, I can understand your confusion, but not excuse it.

But the fact that you're still plenty outraged about The Last Airbender is pretty hilarious.
 
Lumping these two different peoples in the same basket is reductive. They may both speak Arabic and worship Allah, but it doesn't make them the same or fold into each other.

Translation: I got owned and am still trying to pretend that Egypt isn't an Arab country.

BTW, not only is Egypt a member of the Arab League, it was a founding member, and the League was founded in Cairo, Egypt.

http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/arab-league-formed
 
What exactly is this an example of?

I didn't say it was an example. I said it was a counterexample to the money argument. Your words: "I said hollywood isnt going to gamble on unproven asian actors." Yet, Hollywood has shown time and time again that they are willing, more than willing, to gamble on unproven white actors. This shows that it's not the "unproven" that matters; it's the "asian/white" that matters.

I ask again who would you like to have seen in GITS?

I don't know. That's kind of the point. It could have been an unproven nobody.
 
Doesnt prove anything wrong. You're obviously some anime geek that is outraged they didnt give some asian actress blue contacts and an eye lift to make her actually resemble her character (i know i know, Scar Jo looks NOTHING like major right?). What else, should this movie have been given subtitles too? I mean it's Japanese right? How dare they provide english dialogue.

xD

First you people claimed that the anti-whitewashing crowd are just SJWs who want something to complain about and never read or watched Ghost in the Shell. Now I'm some anime geek.

You have given no argument to support your claim that Motoko Kusanagi is white. In fact, you all admitted that you didn't have an argument since you said the source material should be ignored. You are as misinformed and ignorant as the SJWs you despise. The only difference between you is that they think almost everything is racist; you think almost every accusation of racism is a sign of being an SJW.
 
Back
Top