The Tech Industry Thinks Journalists Are Too Mean

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
Companies are apparently astounded by the pessimistic and aggressive approach that the media has taken in regard to tech coverage. While technology may have been exclusively heralded as some sort of liberator in decades’ past, everything is now doom and gloom with security-vulnerability this and robots-taking-our-jobs that. The fact that there is still arguably plenty of good news along with the “bad news,” however, gives the impression that what the tech industry is really frustrated over is the decrease of marketing shills.

According to the ITIF, companies in the 1980s and 1990s enjoyed working with a media industry that celebrated the benefits of technology and promised it would bring more jobs and wealth. These days, however, they find that the media is more apt to focus on the negative implications new technologies could have, such as the loss of jobs or invasion of privacy. Rather than place the blame for this shift on privacy invasions, defective products, unsavory employment policies, or toxic corporate cultures, the report says the tech press is not adhering to the marketing directives of tech companies because it is more lucrative for publishers. The ITIF takes the bizarre stance that being adversarial is bad because it makes it easier for media outlets to turn a profit.
 
I don't see this as just a tech related problem.
Journalism, whether print or digital, has become very caustic and full of haters.

I guess sensational half wrong bullshit sells more newspapers?

Good, well written, well researched material is hard to find.
 
All this whining about the press, all those hurt feelings. I know what you can do to avoid bad press about privacy invasions and defective products and unsavory employment policies.. do a better job! There!

And perhaps not getting your news and journalism off facebook and obvious click-bait sites helps tremendously.
 
Given the growing list of tech fails or near fails, about time.

A few:
The earlier posting about DDOS. Some of those are due to crap security in IOT devices.
Poor UI in cars and use of smart phones while driving canceling out recent gains in auto safety.
"Smart" entertainment devices that seem more interested in spying on the users then being an actual benefit to them.
Exploding phones and other devices.
Legal positions by companies challenging full ownership of things traditionally assumed owned by the purchaser.
 
Safe spaces for tech companies! (Energy companies need not apply.)
 
What's funny is I work in finance and they rip my profession as a bunch of criminals when the vast majority of us try to do a good job for our clients, the vast majority of us are completely honest, and the vast majority of us aren't making anywhere near tech money. Someone like Jamie Dimon (who helped solve the financial crisis rather than create it) made $18m and he's vilified. Satya Nadella makes $84m nobody blinks an eye.
 
Show me a journalist who wants to report on both sides so that way you, the reader or consumer, can be better informed......and I'll show you a dodo bird. Today's journalists just seem to want to BE the story, they're just little actors...sharking their way up the popularity pole.....get their followers who treat them like genius celebrities, and watch it all go to their heads.

You get young journalists today who really aren't, they only want to cover ONE SIDE of the story...and 9 times out of 10 its the side they agree with......and so they build their little following of sycophants too.

Journalists are supposed to provide context, now they only provide opinions. Useless.
 
I nearly spit up my coffee.

This is pretty hilarious coming from an industry which by and large seems to want tech news sites and reviewers to just copy and paste their review kits and essentially serve the company as a free marketing and advertising resource.

By that yardstick, yes, any good tech site will seem "mean" and "hostile". They seem to forget - however - that the purpose of the media is not to be their puppets, but rather to serve their readership, by presenting the information they believe their readership needs to make a decision that is best for them, NOT the information the manufacturer wants to present. That information is inherently and openly biased.

If a product from company A does not perform as well as a product from company B, or is not priced competitively or has flaws, they are not doing their journalistic duty if they gloss over these issues, and only present the positive side to their readership.

The best way to get a poor name in tech is to try to muzzle, cajole or otherwise influence those trying to serve their readers.

The press should not be working for the manufacturers. The press SHOULD be working for their readership. Sadly, most of the time today, this is not the case. The internet is littered with "review" sites who stick to the press-kits when they review a product, because they are scared shitless to deviate even for a second, because it might mean they get cut off when it comes to review samples, and that might mean the financial end of their publication. Maybe it isn't apparent, but many of those goofy YouTube reviewers you see are carefully watching their words for fear of pissing off the hardware manufacturers. As a consumer of this information, you are thus clearly not getting the unbiased information you deserve.

I - for one - am proud to have been a 20 year part of a community for a site that has been cut off from both AMD and Intel in the past.
 
Every organisation who gets savaged for doing stupid shit over and over thinks that journalists are all a bunch of biased meanie-faces.
 
Come on guys, lets please try to not get this tread locked with off-topic political rants.
 
Seriously? Name a single news outlet that is bipartisan. This country's news couldn't be MORE partisan.

I think that he was trying to say that it was coming from both sides, not that a news outlet was literally taking both sides (although i wouldn't be surprised if eventually a huge mega corporation ends up owning outlets on each side of the fence... heck it is bound to happen).
 
Yesterday I learned that PinTerest is valued at 11 billion. With revenue of around $300 million or so (this is not directly reported). So.... yeah, tech can stfu.
 
I think the biggest problem is that the tech industry in general has gone from innovation to exploitation.

They're selling you the same stuff they did a decade ago, but now a lot of it is crippled or compromised in such a way that it's detrimental to use.

Case and point would be the trend towards IoT in the home. The liability far outways any potential benefit to the technology.

https://www.extremetech.com/g00/electronics/242169-internet-things-officially-hit-peak-stupid-courtesy-smart-toaster-griffin-technology?i10c.referrer=https://www.google.ca/

Moving beyond the pointlessness of it, imagine if this toaster were compromised. It could burn down your fucking house (maybe not but a stove certainly could).

Moving on, you have companies like Amazon, Samsung, Visio, pushing 'smart devices' whose primary function is collect as much data on the user as humanly possible.

https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/pre...illion-ftc-state-new-jersey-settle-charges-it

Then there's the stuff that's just plain anti-consumer.

https://arstechnica.com/information...ers-given-18-months-to-upgrade-to-windows-10/
 
Maybe if median income was actually rising, people felt that this technology was actually significantly improving their lives, etc.

In general, change is occurring and rising tides have lifted many fewer boats than they have in the past; sure you can play video games cheaper and learn online, etc. But that isn't as quantitative a gain as has occurred in the past.

Plus, half the shit that "tech" puts out nowadays is just rebranded fluff. As NeoNemesis states, "smart" toasters. My gym has a "smart" scale that literally takes 2 minutes just to tell you your weight, and gets it wrong half the time - costs 3x as much, likely, and is 3x as worthless.

Aside from tech, the "startup" world that seems to add tech to anything that's a new business nowadays that isn't tech related. Look at all the "revolutionary" consumer products I see advertised all the time. Amazing quality watches, shoes, clothes, mattresses, sheets, - all that's changed is the marketing, they're literally doing nothing more than buying the shit from the same factories, slapping some different coloring or styling on it, then telling you it's organic homemade from literally the best crafting families since the beginning of time, and only $5!
 
New flash for you the least corporate candidate won the election.

Lol. I'm just going to say this.

I find it amusing that anyone would consider the billionaire owner of multi-national brands who has spent a lifetime marketing himself as a business leader and filling his cabinet and administration with the swamp of business leaders and wall street bankers is the "least corporate" of anything.

He is the very definition of the corporate candidate, and now that he has won, he's doing exactly what you would expect of a corporate candidate, filling his administration with corporate cronies.

The only thing that is not corporate about him are his brash, offensive, uneducated and unsophisticated mannerisms.
 
Good, well written, well researched material is hard to find.

That stuff is somewhere in the void (2nd or even 3rd page of google search) where no one wants to look. If it isn't the first 3 items, it isn't reliable. Which, is sorted by popularity (or if paid enough) and is in no way a measure of accuracy, but it seems many people don't think that way.
 
Decline in journalism is kinda our fault too. No one wants to pay for a newspaper or subscription = not much money to pay for good journalists or in-depth research.

Also, giant companies buying up all the media learning that we love to hear what we expect to hear, and then giving it to us, makes them a bunch of money, so they do it.
 
Back
Top