Intel Spills the Beans on Optane: Kaby Lake Processor Required

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
Intel has launched a microsite detailing their Optane technology, which clearly states that their new memory will require a 7th Gen Intel Core processor. Some will find it interesting that back in 2015, a Skylake system was used to show the technology off—but now, with 3D XPoint close to release, it seems that only the latest and greatest chips will be supported.

…Skylake support appears to have been dropped. According to a freshly launched microsite detailing the company's plans for the 3D XPoint technology, Optane will require a seventh-generation Kaby Lake processor at minimum. Additionally, anyone looking to add Optane into their system will need an Intel 200-series chipset motherboard with an M.2 type 2280-S1-B-M or 2242-S1-B-M storage connector linked to a PCH Remapped PCI-E controller with two or four lanes and B-M keys meeting Non Volatile Memory Express (NVMe) v1.1 standards. Said motherboard will also need to have a BIOS supporting Intel's Rapid Storage Technology (RST) driver version 15.5 or above.
 
I dunno, is there an actual reason not to support older processors with this Optane tech, or is it more of a 'Windows 10'-style feature lockdown to promote upgrading?

We will probably never know for sure. It could be a combination of technical and marketing direction.

What people fail to realize is that older processors may produce certain errata with the newer technology, even if it was at some point designed to use it. Necessary revisions to the technology may very well have locked out backwards compatibility late in the design stage. Having seen a test mule supporting the technology on an older CPU doesn't mean that the lock out is artificial in nature. That said, this could be an artificial way to promote sales of the new platform. It is very unlikely we will ever know for certain if Z170 and Skylake ever could support Optane properly. For all we know Optane was only stable or only worked 90% of the time on Skylake and Intel locked it out for quality / stability reasons. Without really digging into the white papers or getting a straight answer out of Intel, I can't say for sure but it's possible that Z170 was never a real option for Optane and that Skylake could have supported Optane on Z270. I don't know. In other words, the lockout of Optane from Skylake could be part technical and part artificial. It might have worked on Skylake with Z270, but wouldn't work on Kaby Lake with Z170.
 
We will probably never know for sure. It could be a combination of technical and marketing direction.

What people fail to realize is that older processors may produce certain errata with the newer technology, even if it was at some point designed to use it. Necessary revisions to the technology may very well have locked out backwards compatibility late in the design stage. Having seen a test mule supporting the technology on an older CPU doesn't mean that the lock out is artificial in nature. That said, this could be an artificial way to promote sales of the new platform. It is very unlikely we will ever know for certain if Z170 and Skylake ever could support Optane properly. For all we know Optane was only stable or only worked 90% of the time on Skylake and Intel locked it out for quality / stability reasons. Without really digging into the white papers or getting a straight answer out of Intel, I can't say for sure but it's possible that Z170 was never a real option for Optane and that Skylake could have supported Optane on Z270. I don't know. In other words, the lockout of Optane from Skylake could be part technical and part artificial. It might have worked on Skylake with Z270, but wouldn't work on Kaby Lake with Z170.
You stop making sense and stuff. People need to whine why their 2600k don't support it.
 
While I'm at it, I thought I'd point out some examples of what I mean. In the Northwood Pentium IV days, the Northwood core supported "Jackson Technology" which would later be known as Hyperthreading. Though it was only ever enabled on the Pentium IV 3.06 "B" CPU. The next revision of Northwood Pentium IV's known as "C" processors generally had Hyperthreading enabled. It was a technology that was built into all Northwood cores but not actually enabled. Similarly, Prescott Core "E" Pentium IV's had x86-64 / EM64T support which wasn't enabled until it made the transition from socket 478 to LGA775.

Sometimes support for better memory technologies, certain CPU instruction sets and features are built into the silicon for the purpose of bringing them out later. Sometimes Intel can enable these features via microcode updates and sometimes they can be enabled via BIOS updates. Other times these design elements simply aren't ready for prime time and can't be cut out of the design entirely and will remain unused until a new processor revision or stepping comes out. Sometimes the revision has to be a major one. If you read documentation concerning processor erratum, you'll find that processors can often behave in ways that are not intended under very specific circumstances. They are far more flawed than we generally realize. So, Intel may have wanted Skylake to support Optane technology but couldn't because it simply didn't behave as intended with the technology. This sort of thing often happens when a feature is designed to interface with something that's not released or available at the time the design was finished. In this case, Optane memory wasn't available for QVL testing during the earlier stages of Skylake's development.
 
sad really, microsoft sets every shiety precedent, and other firms follow the exemple, because...why not
taking hostage new tech to try and force you to upgrade to their new product, shows how much respect the company award you for supporting them by buying their previous product, this only happens because of monopoly, if they had competition they would be mindful of brand loyality.
come on AMD don't screw up Ryzen plz
 
Am I having Deja Vu?

Didn't Intel or Microsoft, push some kind of "storage boost" tech back when SSDs were too expensive, for most people to use as main drives.

This looks like that all over again. Using their new storage tech as some kind of storage cache, because it is too damn expensive to use as a main drive.

I really don't give a rats ass about having an Optane cache.

Intel can get back to me when they have affordable Optane drives, for main drive usage, which obviously shouldn't require a specific CPU to operate.
 
What about Skylake-X/EP? Does the high end have to choose between a boring 4 core with Optane or 6+ without?
 
sad really, microsoft sets every shiety precedent, and other firms follow the exemple, because...why not
taking hostage new tech to try and force you to upgrade to their new product, shows how much respect the company award you for supporting them by buying their previous product, this only happens because of monopoly, if they had competition they would be mindful of brand loyality.
come on AMD don't screw up Ryzen plz

This is without a doubt the biggest bullshit statement I've read today. It's still early though. :) Microsoft never set such a precedent. That's Apple you are thinking of. Optane support and Skylake almost certainly has little or even nothing to do with Microsoft. Even if it did, Microsoft is one of the many companies that holds onto legacy features and supports legacy hardware far longer than they probably should. The PC platform has been held back by legacy software and hardware compatibility since the very beginning. Microsoft and even Intel often provided alternatives to legacy platforms which were ignored by the public. The inability to support 32bit code through emulation is why IA64 never took off. Microsoft brought about a true 32bit only OS years before the public would accept it. Unfortunately, people wouldn't accept Windows NT for a long time because it had poor DOS program compatibility. Apple is the only company that gets away with telling it's users that you have no choice but to move on.
 
Am I having Deja Vu?

Didn't Intel or Microsoft, push some kind of "storage boost" tech back when SSDs were too expensive, for most people to use as main drives.

This looks like that all over again. Using their new storage tech as some kind of storage cache, because it is too damn expensive to use as a main drive.

I really don't give a rats ass about having an Optane cache.

Intel can get back to me when they have affordable Optane drives, for main drive usage, which obviously shouldn't require a specific CPU to operate.

You might be thinking of "Ready Boost" which wasn't for SSD's but any flash drive. The problem was that it wore out the flash memory too quickly by exceeding the finite reads and writes the flash memory could handle. This was in the infancy of the SSD and the earlier days of removable flash storage.
 
So first Kaby Lake and W10 is required for UHD Bluray playback, now this shit.

Guess they gotta get me to "upgrade" from my 5960X @ 4.6 running Server 2016 somehow :p
 
Regardless of whether there were technical reasons or if it was just a cashgrab, it looks bad.

That's not going to help adoption. Combine this bad optics with impending Ryzen price undercutting, relatively affordable SSDs, and disappointing levels of performance improvement and you have a stinker even if this was all totally justified from an engineering standpoint.
 
Even though it will have mainstream CPU support with Kabby Lake I don't believe Optane was ever meant to be a consumer oriented product. This is an enterprise product with enterprise prices for enterprise applications.
 
This is without a doubt the biggest bullshit statement I've read today. It's still early though. :) Microsoft never set such a precedent. That's Apple you are thinking of. Optane support and Skylake almost certainly has little or even nothing to do with Microsoft. Even if it did, Microsoft is one of the many companies that holds onto legacy features and supports legacy hardware far longer than they probably should. The PC platform has been held back by legacy software and hardware compatibility since the very beginning. Microsoft and even Intel often provided alternatives to legacy platforms which were ignored by the public. The inability to support 32bit code through emulation is why IA64 never took off. Microsoft brought about a true 32bit only OS years before the public would accept it. Unfortunately, people wouldn't accept Windows NT for a long time because it had poor DOS program compatibility. Apple is the only company that gets away with telling it's users that you have no choice but to move on.

i wasn't thinking of apple at all, to me apple made it clear from day one to everyone, that they have a nich, their macs are not PCs, that they have their own OS, apps, api even hardware, and charges ppl exactly for that, for the apple eco-system, nothing shady, everything is clear.
but microsoft is another story, they are the ones who try to force ppl to upgrade to the next OS by taking the only laverage hostage " directx ".
and their support for legacy is not because of the kidness of their hearts, it's simply the pro sector that forces them to keep old OS rolling.
 
i wasn't thinking of apple at all, to me apple made it clear from day one to everyone, that they have a nich, their macs are not PCs, that they have their own OS, apps, api even hardware, and charges ppl exactly for that, for the apple eco-system, nothing shady, everything is clear.
but microsoft is another story, they are the ones who try to force ppl to upgrade to the next OS by taking the only laverage hostage " directx ".
and their support for legacy is not because of the kidness of their hearts, it's simply the pro sector that forces them to keep old OS rolling.

Except that your statement about Microsoft isn't true. Microsoft has traditionally left support for hardware and OSes in place far longer than they probably should. Microsoft had a DOS core in it's Windows consumer products for many years after its planned replacement. Between legacy hardware and software compatibility, Windows has been held back. You can argue that the x86 CPU itself has been held back by this compatibility. If it weren't for that, we might be running IA64 CPUs on something from Microsoft that isn't even called Windows. In contrast Apple is the one that says "fuck you, time to upgrade." They did it when they decided to drop support for PowerPC processors and go Intel. They do it all the time where they drop certain systems from newer OSes that really aren't necessarily at the end of their life cycle. They are the ones who tell customers what they can and cannot do and they get away with it. People don't bitch "cash grab" when they force upgrades / obsolescence. When Microsoft even hints at moving people along they are vilified.

I simply want to keep things in perspective here. Optane has nothing to do with Microsoft choosing not to support it on Skylake. This is an Intel decision that's either based on sales / marketing directives or its based on technical necessities we aren't privy to.
 
Jeez. This generation of chips really does simply feel like a whole lot of nothing that simply enables you to use other tech.
 
I'm beginning to find it humorous that after first review, people complained that Kaby Lake wasn't a worthwhile upgrade, because it didn't bring anything new to the table. On the desktop, It wasn't significantly faster or cooler or more power efficient, and most people didn't care about integrated graphics. Now that we are discovering features the platform allows (DRM for 4K Netflix and UHD 4K Blu Ray, Optane support) people are complaining about that too.

tl;dr Kaby Lake is nothing new, Intel is bad! Oh wait, Kaby Lake has new stuff, Intel is bad!

The other thing I think is funny, is that these complaints are going to be very short lived, regardless of whether people buy into Kaby Lake or not. These features are probably going to be in all the next generations of products from here on out.

I feel like many members of the community have changed mindset over the last 10 years. When Crysis and Doom 3 first came out, there were no solutions that could play the games smoothly at highest settings, if at all. Now, many people expect AAA titles to play at 4k 60 fps ultra on launch day. We used to dream about what the future would bring, instead now we complain when what we already have isn't the best thing forever.
 
CrazyRob,

Some of those enhancements feel too artificial to people. Relatively few people watch Netflix at 4K; on this forum probably quite a few but out in the wild, 720/1080 TV still rules the lands.
I personally liked KL enough to finally get off the 2600K and I'm thoroughly enjoying it, I think it was a good upgrade.

As far as Optane goes, it's a different problem. The lack of backward compatibility does not seem justifiable. Whether it is, that's one thing but Intel hasn't quite bent over backwards explaining why. People are miffed that when something new comes along that promises good improvements, they're locked out on their Skylake machines that still have the 'new car' smell. They might well *want* the feature but can't *have* it even though they have M.2 slots and whatnot.

I do miss the days of home computing on platforms that would last 5-10 years and have huge followers trying to eek out whatever possible from the machines. It was great fun. The progression to today's short-lived components makes a lot of that fun much less so. But I do feel kind of good about the status of the PC world. We're getting pretty damn nice games these days that run smoothly when you don't demand the latest, highest resolution. The new DOOM, Civ 6, Fallout 4, Overwatch, Battlefield 1, Deus EX, a very much blooming indie market... we're living in good gaming days.
 
CrazyRob,

Some of those enhancements feel too artificial to people. Relatively few people watch Netflix at 4K; on this forum probably quite a few but out in the wild, 720/1080 TV still rules the lands.
I personally liked KL enough to finally get off the 2600K and I'm thoroughly enjoying it, I think it was a good upgrade.

As far as Optane goes, it's a different problem. The lack of backward compatibility does not seem justifiable. Whether it is, that's one thing but Intel hasn't quite bent over backwards explaining why. People are miffed that when something new comes along that promises good improvements, they're locked out on their Skylake machines that still have the 'new car' smell. They might well *want* the feature but can't *have* it even though they have M.2 slots and whatnot.

I do miss the days of home computing on platforms that would last 5-10 years and have huge followers trying to eek out whatever possible from the machines. It was great fun. The progression to today's short-lived components makes a lot of that fun much less so. But I do feel kind of good about the status of the PC world. We're getting pretty damn nice games these days that run smoothly when you don't demand the latest, highest resolution. The new DOOM, Civ 6, Fallout 4, Overwatch, Battlefield 1, Deus EX, a very much blooming indie market... we're living in good gaming days.

Gaming PC's never really lasted 10 years once the 3D accelerator came onto the scene. It's been an anomaly that Sandy Bridge systems are still relevant in the AAA titles 6 years after they were introduced. This is far from the norm that we've seen over the last two decades.
 
I'm beginning to find it humorous that after first review, people complained that Kaby Lake wasn't a worthwhile upgrade, because it didn't bring anything new to the table. On the desktop, It wasn't significantly faster or cooler or more power efficient, and most people didn't care about integrated graphics. Now that we are discovering features the platform allows (DRM for 4K Netflix and UHD 4K Blu Ray, Optane support) people are complaining about that too.

tl;dr Kaby Lake is nothing new, Intel is bad! Oh wait, Kaby Lake has new stuff, Intel is bad!

The other thing I think is funny, is that these complaints are going to be very short lived, regardless of whether people buy into Kaby Lake or not. These features are probably going to be in all the next generations of products from here on out.

I feel like many members of the community have changed mindset over the last 10 years. When Crysis and Doom 3 first came out, there were no solutions that could play the games smoothly at highest settings, if at all. Now, many people expect AAA titles to play at 4k 60 fps ultra on launch day. We used to dream about what the future would bring, instead now we complain when what we already have isn't the best thing forever.
I feel the same way, my friend...
 
New season of Grand Tour on Amazon...

Just need an i7 Kaby, Windows 10 Pro or better, and Optane memory.



/s
 
People bitching about 4k Netflix most likely are annoyed about the drm requirements connected that require new processors. I mean I can run 4k videos why the hell do I need new processors or tvs or boxes and shit.
 
I haven't really been keeping up on this.

This is essentially a dedicated RAM Cache for SSD's and hard drives, in M.2 format, yes?
 
I'm beginning to find it humorous that after first review, people complained that Kaby Lake wasn't a worthwhile upgrade, because it didn't bring anything new to the table. On the desktop, It wasn't significantly faster or cooler or more power efficient, and most people didn't care about integrated graphics. Now that we are discovering features the platform allows (DRM for 4K Netflix and UHD 4K Blu Ray, Optane support) people are complaining about that too.

tl;dr Kaby Lake is nothing new, Intel is bad! Oh wait, Kaby Lake has new stuff, Intel is bad!

The other thing I think is funny, is that these complaints are going to be very short lived, regardless of whether people buy into Kaby Lake or not. These features are probably going to be in all the next generations of products from here on out.

I feel like many members of the community have changed mindset over the last 10 years. When Crysis and Doom 3 first came out, there were no solutions that could play the games smoothly at highest settings, if at all. Now, many people expect AAA titles to play at 4k 60 fps ultra on launch day. We used to dream about what the future would bring, instead now we complain when what we already have isn't the best thing forever.

I don't recall ever dreaming about software being locked behind a hardware DRM ..
 
They wonder why people just pirate the stuff. drm has never stopped any thing form getting pirated but we have crappy hdmi on all tvs vs dp just for drm ect
 
They wonder why people just pirate the stuff. drm has never stopped any thing form getting pirated but we have crappy hdmi on all tvs vs dp just for drm ect

This +1

You have a problem when your copy protection causes legitimate customers so many problems, that it's easier for them to pirate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: M76
like this
Yeah but do we need it?

It will be fantastic for a non volatile cache (without the latency and write endurance problem of NAND) on server applications. I can see this is exactly what a lot of zfs users want. I am hoping the 32GB model will be less than $300.
 
It will be fantastic for a non volatile cache (without the latency and write endurance problem of NAND) on server applications. I can see this is exactly what a lot of zfs users want. I am hoping the 32GB model will be less than $300.
All important servers have battery backup anyway.
And do we need it?
 
All important servers have battery backup anyway.

This removes the need for a battery backed cache and allows a much larger cache.


And do we need it?

Depends on the required application performance.
 
Last edited:
Just upgraded to a SkyLake setup when things were on sale back in November. I'm all set for a while. I stopped being an early adopter after getting screwed a few times with the latest and greatest.
 
Dan_D makes some cogent points and I suppose its possible there COULD be some technical element, but honestly....unless they do what he suggests and make a transparent statement explaining the technical necessities for this change, based on Intel's past behavior I'm more inclined to think its more marketing/business practices than anything else. This kind of nonsense is pretty frustrating and seems especially grating to those like myself with HEDP. Especially with the long run-up to 3D XPoint and Optaine etc... they had ample time to make it work or explain things. It seems like from what they request there, many Skylake/Z170 boards could easily support it, not to mention the bevy of X99 boards out there which, if nobody else, should be supported in deference to their increased cost and advanced feature set that usually lead to long useful lifespans.

Oh and while I'm thinking on it from the blurb.... Why did Intel, who for the hell of it demanded an alternative to M.2 NVMe slots and created U.2, not support this technology on U.2? My Rampage V Edition 10 has a pair of the suckers that will probably be completely useless (unless I want to buy old, expensive SSDs. Latest gen Intel SSDs are all now M.2 it seemsl); this prompts me to look into U.2 > M.2 converters...

But yeah, either Intel should come forth with a good, honest report on why this is mandatory (which will expected to be tested by the community and hopefully will not be a smoke screen for business reasons) or they should tacitly change direction and say they're "testing" it on other supported hardware. Anything else, such as the revelation that a technical excuse is paper thin and has a reasonably easy workaround and/or any actual impediment seems to be purposely placed, and it will be revealed that it was not a technical but a slimy business decision.

Whatever the case, it seems Intel could have handled it better and I'll join the chorus chanting "Please don't let Ryzen Suck" to AMD; if nothing else, their strong showing in the market may encourage Intel to behave.
 
Back
Top