DAN A4-SFX: The smallest gaming case in the world

FYI, I looked everywhere for a low profile cooler for ones that weren't mentioned in this thread, and I found this one which might be pretty interesting.

http://www.idcooling.com/Product/detail/id/49/name/IS-40PRO

20150628165508_66876.jpg


I think this one might be promising because it has 4 direct heat pipes, wide spaced fins (better at low RPMs), is 44mm tall which is low enough to not cause turbulence on the side panel, and is pretty cheap but still comes with a decent hydrobearing fan. The only problem is it's hard to find in Europe and the United States, mostly you have to find it on Ebay or Alibaba direct from China.

Another thing people might be overlooking with the C7 is that the heatpipes on the C7 are curved, so when you install it, make sure the heatpipes are facing sideways and not up (because heatpipes work terribly against gravity).

I have both the C7, the A9-14 Noctua Fan, and the ID-40Pro cooler on the way, so as soon as I get my A4 case I'll try to provide some updates. I have a 7600k ready to delid to test with.
 
Hey, I just wanted to say thank you. This was the post that got me thinking.

There are a LOT of us who are looking for a cooling solution that's 48mm or so, between the Sentry and the A4. Enough that, as you said, this quest has the momentum to annoy even Noctua. It also has enough interest to get Dan thinking about designing his own heatsink.

Well... Why not combine those thoughts? I just wrote to Noctua (you can see what I wrote in the Sentry thread), asking them what it would take for them to consider building us a cooler, and laid out my case for how many of us want something like this.

I figure if any company is going to take us on, it'll be the relatively small, exceptionally customer-servicing one that specializes in high performance, low noise cooling.

So... I need your help, guys. What exactly are we looking for? Here's what I've got so far:

  • Low profile - 48mm
  • Low noise - that means a slim fan on the bottom of the heatsink fins. (See the Nexus or Noctua's own, slightly too large, NH-L12.
  • High performance - I want a huge cooler that basically overhangs whatever it can on the motherboard. I don't think there's any problem with using VLP RAM, and I'd be happy if it went from the PCIe slot to the top of a mini-ITX motherboard.
  • (Input: how many of us are interested in Asus Maximus Impact motherboards with all those daughterboards? How would that impact cooling design?)
  • Ease of retention - I would really like it if the cooler screwed in from the bottom of the motherboard instead of fishing a screwdriver in through gaps in the fins.
  • Ideally it would be copper? I don't know how much Noctua uses copper outside of heatpipes, so... We'll see.
  • How many heatpipes are we looking at? We want to cool a 91W chip, ideally with a bit of room to overclock, so... Four? Would it be possible to fit six?

For me im after 4-6 heatpipes Tdp 130 W+.

Fan under THE heatsink to avoid air turbulens.

Fan efficient and silent with high air pressure. Optimal 120 mm fan.

I Will avoid minitx board as Maximus impact
 
Hmm... So it appears a standard stick of DDR4 is about 31mm tall, which means that above it we'd only have ~15mm of space; not enough.

The question now, I think, becomes two parts:

1) in a cooler with no ram overhang, is it possible to fit a 120mm fan? If not, does that change if it can overhang the ram with a restriction to half-height ram?

2) If it doesn't overhang the ram at all, how much thicker could the heatsink be? Could it make up for the loss in surface area by increased depth?


Also, just a side note on the fan, I'm using a Noctua NH-L12, with a 120mm fan underneath. Basically exactly same setup as we need, but just a little bit too large. I can assure you that you can't see the noctua colors through the heatsink. :)
Can you please tell me what board and ram are you using? Maybe even post a picture?
I am thinking of doing the same for the time being.
 
Can you please tell me what board and ram are you using? Maybe even post a picture?
I am thinking of doing the same for the time being.

Oh dear lord. I'm using an... Asrock z77E-ITX, and I can't remember if I'm using samsung miracle ram, or if I switched to standard height sticks with a low profile heatsink.

I'll see if I can dig around in my old build logs for a picture, but I'm loathe to take a new one. I'm using a Raven RVZ01, which is... not the friendliest to build in. A picture wouldn't be worth much without taking the entire motherboard out.

EDIT: I got nothing. I'll take a couple photos for you tomorrow. :)
 
FYI, I looked everywhere for a low profile cooler for ones that weren't mentioned in this thread, and I found this one which might be pretty interesting.

http://www.idcooling.com/Product/detail/id/49/name/IS-40PRO



I think this one might be promising because it has 4 direct heat pipes, wide spaced fins (better at low RPMs), is 44mm tall which is low enough to not cause turbulence on the side panel, and is pretty cheap but still comes with a decent hydrobearing fan. The only problem is it's hard to find in Europe and the United States, mostly you have to find it on Ebay or Alibaba direct from China.

Another thing people might be overlooking with the C7 is that the heatpipes on the C7 are curved, so when you install it, make sure the heatpipes are facing sideways and not up (because heatpipes work terribly against gravity).

I have both the C7, the A9-14 Noctua Fan, and the ID-40Pro cooler on the way, so as soon as I get my A4 case I'll try to provide some updates. I have a 7600k ready to delid to test with.

ID Cooling also makes the IS-50, which has one more heatpipe, should be able to fit a thin 92mm or 120mm fan under the fins, and will comfortably be <48mm high with an underslung fan. The bad news is that availability is similar to the IS-40 (eBay or Aliexpress) and I can't find any reviews.
 
Ip I
My two Nexus coolers just got cancelled a week after I ordered them.. Anybody knows if there are some available still? Doesn't matter where or how long shipping takes. If anybody on hardforum are willing to part with one I'd pay a fair price.
Same thing happened to me. They said it was shipped the next day so I thought I got lucky but apparently not. :-(
 
Thanks to absolut_zero I have ordered a Cooljag New Falcon II and got it today from Schneider Consulting (Germany). I was a bit worried about its height but it is very good, around 46 mm. Interesting to see the shop recommend to also buy a slim 100 mm fan for it, seems I wasn`t the first DAN A4 owner there :)

20170218_160016a.jpg 20170218_160114a.jpg 20170218_160553.jpg
 
Last edited:
ID Cooling also makes the IS-50, which has one more heatpipe, should be able to fit a thin 92mm or 120mm fan under the fins, and will comfortably be <48mm high with an underslung fan. The bad news is that availability is similar to the IS-40 (eBay or Aliexpress) and I can't find any reviews.

Thanks for this. I'm ordering the IS-50 now. It is available on both newegg and Amazon, shipped direct from ID-Cooling.

Also, the ID-40 looks to small to fit a fan between the fins and CPU plate.
 
Thanks for posting this, I'm particularly interested..Is your CPU delidded? Also just to confirm, when you say its quieter..do you mean completely quiet enough for most users to consider as tolerable, even at 100% fan speed

Running at 2000 rpm the fan is much quieter audible but only slightly. When I have it around 1200-1300 rpm I can't hear it at all. The problem is I need to under clock it so much to keep temps manageable. I did not delid it yet, but am thinking about it. Probably will try one of the bigger heat sinks first before I delid the processor. If I can run at stock clocks and keep it in the low 70's I'll be happy.
 
ID Cooling also makes the IS-50, which has one more heatpipe, should be able to fit a thin 92mm or 120mm fan under the fins, and will comfortably be <48mm high with an underslung fan. The bad news is that availability is similar to the IS-40 (eBay or Aliexpress) and I can't find any reviews.
Don't. I've read a review from a Danish site (tweak.dk) and this is the conclusion:
"I have never seen such bad cooler like this one. I even think a standard cooler from Intel will do better, and even allow the small overclocking to 4.0 GHz. It did look promising. I think during the unpacking that it was a really nice cooler. But that it hardly can handle standard turbo frequency of my CPU is bad. The cooler is rated for a TDP of 130W, and my CPU has an TDP of 84 W. I have no idea how they got the TDP. One would almost think that there was a manufacturing defect in the surface that presses against the processor. That's the only reason I could say that would justify the poor performance."
Roughly translated :)
 
Don't. I've read a review from a Danish site (tweak.dk) and this is the conclusion:
"I have never seen such bad cooler like this one. I even think a standard cooler from Intel will do better, and even allow the small overclocking to 4.0 GHz. It did look promising. I think during the unpacking that it was a really nice cooler. But that it hardly can handle standard turbo frequency of my CPU is bad. The cooler is rated for a TDP of 130W, and my CPU has an TDP of 84 W. I have no idea how they got the TDP. One would almost think that there was a manufacturing defect in the surface that presses against the processor. That's the only reason I could say that would justify the poor performance."
Roughly translated :)

Sigh, seems like ID Cooling's products are really hit or miss. Thanks for the translation.
 
My two Nexus coolers just got cancelled a week after I ordered them.. Anybody knows if there are some available still? Doesn't matter where or how long shipping takes. If anybody on hardforum are willing to part with one I'd pay a fair price.

Ip I

Same thing happened to me. They said it was shipped the next day so I thought I got lucky but apparently not. :-(

from which store it was canceled ?
 
Thanks to absolut_zero I have ordered a Cooljag New Falcon II and got it today from Schneider Consulting (Germany). I was a bit worried about its height but it is very good, around 46 mm. Interesting to see the shop recommend to also buy a slim 100 mm fan for it, seems I wasn`t the first DAN A4 owner there :)

View attachment 17253 View attachment 17254 View attachment 17256
Did you buy it from their webstore? When I googled it, it found a link but when I go to the webstore it doesn't find it there.
 
Running at 2000 rpm the fan is much quieter audible but only slightly. When I have it around 1200-1300 rpm I can't hear it at all. The problem is I need to under clock it so much to keep temps manageable. I did not delid it yet, but am thinking about it. Probably will try one of the bigger heat sinks first before I delid the processor. If I can run at stock clocks and keep it in the low 70's I'll be happy.

Thank you!! I think delidding the 7700K really is the way to go. Will get your temps nicely into your target range.

All these other coolers are too hit or miss. Many of them either dont perform or are impossible to find. I'll personally stick to the c7 heatsink along with the noctua fan and hope delidding does the job sufficiently
 
Did you buy it from their webstore? When I googled it, it found a link but when I go to the webstore it doesn't find it there.

They have it on Ebay and Webstore, but after it come up in this thread they sell out on this coolers and they will not restock it.
 
Thanks to absolut_zero I have ordered a Cooljag New Falcon II and got it today from Schneider Consulting (Germany). I was a bit worried about its height but it is very good, around 46 mm. Interesting to see the shop recommend to also buy a slim 100 mm fan for it, seems I wasn`t the first DAN A4 owner there :)
You're welcome. (y)

Did you buy it from their webstore? When I googled it, it found a link but when I go to the webstore it doesn't find it there.

When I found the product page on their webstore and posted the link here, I believe they only have about 2 or 3 stocks left at that time. Sorry to hear that they ran out of stock.
 
So does ~31mm-32mm tall RAM fit under the Falcon 2? I may have missed that. From this pic it looks like it does not? Also I wonder if the Asus 270i might not work with it due to the heatsinks everywhere, particularly the tall one next to the IO ports. I think you'd have to remove it.

31-TLYuG3GL.jpg
 
Last edited:
The PSU bracket is a separate removable piece, right? So I wouldn't even have to do it this way:
Yeah, I guessed it was for vertical stability. If it doesn't have any other purpose could it instead go down, along the side of the PSU?

Reason I'm asking is, I looked at the free space (at least 3cm since a SFX-L fits there) there is when using a SFX PSU and thought how to take advantage of that. One of the biggest drawbacks for this case is that there is no active exhaust which makes the case and components pretty hot - seen by the temp difference when not using the I/O panel.
I figured that there is enough room for a 92mm top fan if you lower the PSU with spacers/extending bracket, that attaches to the stock bracket, to make room for the powercable and airflow. It would also pull air from the GPU side. Below is a quick sketch of it:
View attachment 17081

Something for A4-SFX v2?

More great pictures by loafidelity.
I could just lower the whole bracket by drilling new screw holes 3cm lower on the front side and putting spacers to the mb side screws. Or would there be something blocking moving it down 3cm? Is there someone who could test out the temp difference? even just adding a fan outside the case on the top and temporarily lowering the PSU for better airflow?
Dan, could these extra holes be added to v2 and the top of the inner frame made 92mm fan friendly? I wager a lot of people would be interested in adding an active exhaust to the case.

Unfortunately, just measuring based on this pic http://i.imgur.com/9qw1acX.jpg a 92mm fan wouldn't be completely flat against the top panel since the bottom right corner would be against the inner frame.
 
Last edited:
I'm happy with these temperatures and even more with the sound the GPU fans and the Noctua NH-L9i makes - yes, hearable but no jet-engine - after playing Doom for several hours.

i7 7700K at default clock with a Noctua NH-L9i and a Asus GeForce GTX 1080 8GB ROG STRIX on a Asus MAXIMUS VIII IMPACT...

DHtloGVl.png
 
So does ~31mm-32mm tall RAM fit under the Falcon 2? I may have missed that. From this pic it looks like it does not? Also I wonder if the Asus 270i might not work with it due to the heatsinks everywhere, particularly the tall one next to the IO ports. I think you'd have to remove it.

31-TLYuG3GL.jpg

35.95 mm from bottom to tower, So no problem there.

31.24 mm for Ram on normal low profile DDR4.

So its 4.85 mm clearence there.
 
35.95 mm from bottom to tower, So no problem there.

31.24 mm for Ram on normal low profile DDR4.

So its 4.85 mm clearence there.

I may be intepreting it wrong, I thought the 35.95mm reading is from the bottom of the bolts, which would be on the back of the mobo, and the 29mm is from the where the cooler meets the actual top of the motherboard.
 
I may be intepreting it wrong, I thought the 35.95mm reading is from the bottom of the bolts, which would be on the back of the mobo, and the 29mm is from the where the cooler meets the actual top of the motherboard.

CPU are a bit higher than the motherboard always thats why the Bolts are there to get it upp from the motherboard and in the hight of the Cpu.

So the hight are 35.95 mm from the motherboard , check installation guide.

http://www.cooljagusa.com/uploadfiles/cc201102222058135626.pdf
 
You are correct, thanks! Should have thought to look at the manual, duh.
 
Jeeez christ please resize the pictures. Even on a 4K monitor it is a pita when users upload pictures that big. Resize them to 1280x, so that they work for pretty much everybody.
 
I'm happy with these temperatures and even more with the sound the GPU fans and the Noctua NH-L9i makes - yes, hearable but no jet-engine - after playing Doom for several hours.

i7 7700K at default clock with a Noctua NH-L9i and a Asus GeForce GTX 1080 8GB ROG STRIX on a Asus MAXIMUS VIII IMPACT...

DHtloGVl.png

Isn't 86 C a bit hot though? I'm hitting 81C while playing DOOM on a C7 with a delid 7700k. I would expect more from the delid :(. Maybe I need to reapply thermal paste on the CPU cooler side.
 
1. Can I install this fan if on my jag if I take the heat sinks off of my tridentz? (Asus Strix Z270i mobo)

2. Is there a consensus on the best 120mm for this use case for silence/efficient cooling?

Sorry if this was already mentioned, this thread is getting super active.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
1. Can I install this fan if on my jag if I take the heat sinks off of my tridentz? (Asus Strix Z270i mobo)

2. Is there a consensus on the best 120mm for this use case for silence/efficient cooling?

Sorry if this was already mentioned, this thread is getting super active.

I got this fan on the way and the nexus cooler (almost Same as yours) and the same mobo. i'll tell you when I receive the fan, but i'm thinking that you can't unless you bend and grind and unscrew. we'll see lol
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Just got my CooJag Falcon II. The copper base is attached to the heatpipes somehow (soldered?), I can't see any solder but it seems to be attached well.

The aluminum heatspreader fins are part of the aluminum base that screws to the copper. I don't have a pic but they were easy to bend back and forth and remove.

I'm planning to put this on my Asus Strix Z270i later tonight. I have a Noctua A9x14 fan ready too.


Vf8THeS.png


MlTATTf.png


CDNHFw1.png
 
Do you think there would be an issue running the bare heatpipes withiout the top aluminium section?

Maybe poor heat dissipation accross the pipes?
 
Jeeez christ please resize the pictures. Even on a 4K monitor it is a pita when users upload pictures that big. Resize them to 1280x, so that they work for pretty much everybody.

This request seems better suited for the [H] mods to adjust/modify the forum software to resize on upload (or display) than to try and control every user on here.. It's only going to make you upset to expect humans to reliably do what computers are really &#*$&#* good at :)
 
Do you think there would be an issue running the bare heatpipes withiout the top aluminium section?

Maybe poor heat dissipation accross the pipes?

I wondered about that as well. I would think you'd get slightly less cooling without the aluminum piece. Whether it would be measurable or not? Not sure.

The mounting brackets for the cooler sandwich between the aluminum and copper base though so you'd need to attach some sort of bolt to hold the cooler.
 
Back
Top