No Warrant Needed For Cellphone Location Data

It's a database that each carrier must keep that that has years worth of phone calls and cell tower data which is searchable whenever we get a law enforcement request. I call it a data warehouse, because it's kinda like where they put the ark of the covenant at the end of Raiders....if that warehouse was searchable.

I should add we get tons of requests every day (hundreds) and we're a small carrier. I suspect Verizon get's tens of thousands/day.

IC, I thought you were talking about a government run data warehouse.
 
That's a huge load. I have hope that it will be overturned. As Assoc. Justice Sotomayor states, "...it may be necessary to reconsider the premise that an individual has no reasonable expectation of privacy in information voluntarily disclosed to third parties. This approach is ill suited to the digital age, in which people reveal a great deal of information about themselves to third parties in the course of carrying out mundane tasks."

On top of that when the government mandates you do something then it should automatically be protected. IE. the federal government now mandates that you have health insurance, if you don't then you pay a fine. Therefore you are essentially mandated to provide certain information to a medical insurance company. The argument that you "willfully" gave the information to that insurance company is bogus - since you are now fined if you do not get insurance, and part of getting insurance requires you to submit data.
 
Another reason for cell phone customers to demand the ability to disable ALL tracking on and of their phones if they so desire!

This de facto tracking has now put to the side our legal rights in actions taken by our government :rage:

No it hasn't.

There are legal searches, both with and without a warrant just as NExUSG1 so adequately explained above. And there are searches deemed illegal and in a court this information is suppressed by the court as it should be.
Our rights have not been put to the side. I will acknowledge that we are still defining the proper limits regarding this data. I'll acknowledge that some people have had to fight for their rights in court against the government but I think you would have to concede that this has always been the case.

Our legal system never guaranteed that we would never have to stand up for ourselves. It just tries to give us a chance to come out on top when we are right and the government is wrong.
 
wow, that judge is an idiot.... Yes I know I am being tracked by my cell company for the purposes of 911 emergency. I also have a very reasonable expectation that my data will not be handed over without the proper use of a warrant.
 
So, I was just reading a story in the local news about a Canadian women who was strip searched and cavity searched by three *male* USA customs officers and no female officer present. How can that be legal? Her only cause for being harassed by them was she was riding a Harley motorcycle. Thank fuck I live in Canada.
 
wow, that judge is an idiot.... Yes I know I am being tracked by my cell company for the purposes of 911 emergency. I also have a very reasonable expectation that my data will not be handed over without the proper use of a warrant.

You must have missed the John Oliver episode on 911. If you call from a cell they most likely have no idea where you are, that GPS data is not sent to them. So they may have mandated it using that as an excuse (like all the fun stuff we do to save us from terrorists), but that's not what it's being used for.
 
You must have missed the John Oliver episode on 911. If you call from a cell they most likely have no idea where you are, that GPS data is not sent to them. So they may have mandated it using that as an excuse (like all the fun stuff we do to save us from terrorists), but that's not what it's being used for.

I didn't miss anything, Agreeing to data being sent to 911 != to what this judge did. want the data, get a warrant like you are supposed to. Phones have been required to send your location to 911 for a decade already (A GPS for example) but you agreed to that aspect when you accepted service.
 
No warrant needed for cellphone location data = no active location tracking turned on, on my phone, period. I was already keeping it off anyway (to save battery life) and just turning it on when I needed it and turning it right back off until I needed it again before this anyway so it's routine. I can look around to guess the weather which is almost as accurate as the local weatherman's forecast anyway. I do like how everyone used to be able to just put in their zip code for the weather but now Android demands location data be turned on, fuckers, I know what you're up to.

And no I'm not doing anything illegal 99.1% of the time, just tired of being the enemy of my own state. Noam Chomsky has stated for decades now that the citizens are the biggest threat to any government and as I get older I'm believing it myself. I'm not feeling too free these days.
 
Last edited:
No warrant needed for cellphone location data = no active location tracking turned on, on my phone, period. I was already keeping it off anyway (to save battery life) and just turning it on when I needed it and turning it right back off until I needed it again before this anyway so it's routine. I can look around to guess the weather which is almost as accurate as the local weatherman's forecast anyway. I do like how everyone used to be able to just put in their zip code for the weather but now Android demands location data be turned on, fuckers, I know what you're up to.

And no I'm not doing anything illegal 99.1% of the time, just tired of being the enemy of my own state. Noam Chomsky has stated for decades now that the citizens are the biggest threat to any government and as I get older I'm believing it myself. I'm not feeling too free these days.
Unless you're in airplane mode, your location is tracked. It's not precise gps coordinates, but they know what cell tower you're on and that can narrow your location dramatically (especially since when you're moving, they'll have a record of the direction you came from and where you went after that). Trust me, this data is used for tracking people they think committed a crime (or just to track their wife/husband, if you can convince the phone company to provide that info).
 
Unless you're in airplane mode, your location is tracked. It's not precise gps coordinates, but they know what cell tower you're on
Knowing what cell tower I'm using is a lot better than it showing what room of my house I'm in and I've seen that first hand with the app 'Cerberus' and other apps (possibly Googles tracking app). I was moving around my house and watching it know (almost) exactly where in the room I was at. Scary stuff considering phones aren't that secure and warrants aren't even needed by authorities anymore. The thing is I'm not even doing anything wrong and yet what they're doing with all this tech now and other shady shit just feels wrong.

Question though, what's the range of cell towers?

 
Knowing what cell tower I'm using is a lot better than it showing what room of my house I'm in and I've seen that first hand with the app 'Cerberus' and other apps (possibly Googles tracking app). I was moving around my house and watching it know (almost) exactly where in the room I was at. Scary stuff considering phones aren't that secure and warrants aren't even needed by authorities anymore. The thing is I'm not even doing anything wrong and yet what they're doing with all this tech now and other shady shit just feels wrong.

Question though, what's the range of cell towers?
AFAIK, cell providers don't store GPS coordinates. I know I've never seen them. AFAIK, GPS is only sent to 911. It's not that they could find you with tower data, but it's a much wider area and if you're in bad shape, it could be the difference between life and death.
The range of towers depends on the population density. The more customers using your service, the more towers you need in a given area and that means you reduce the range of each tower. OTOH, if you live in BFE, then a tower could go maybe 20 or 30 miles (CDMA). You'd really have to be in the sticks for a tower to go that far.
 
NSA does.
I don't know how they do it, but it seems to me that if they're doing that, they'd exploit E911 code to get GPS coordinates, which would completely bypass your shutting off GPS (because that can't be shut off). If you don't want any GPS sent, you probably need a phone without a GPS. I suspect an old flip phone is your best bet.
 
I didn't miss anything, Agreeing to data being sent to 911 != to what this judge did. want the data, get a warrant like you are supposed to. Phones have been required to send your location to 911 for a decade already (A GPS for example) but you agreed to that aspect when you accepted service.


Except your GPS location is NOT used to send to 911 in most cases, that's what I'm saying. Call 911 on your cell phone and they will most likely have very little idea of where you actually are, and if they do have a location it could be WAY off. So we are agreeing to allow them to track us "for 911 calls" that don't actually get that data. Makes you wonder what they ARE using it for (Like the crap this thread is about)....
 
Knowing what cell tower I'm using is a lot better than it showing what room of my house I'm in and I've seen that first hand with the app 'Cerberus' and other apps (possibly Googles tracking app). I was moving around my house and watching it know (almost) exactly where in the room I was at. Scary stuff considering phones aren't that secure and warrants aren't even needed by authorities anymore. The thing is I'm not even doing anything wrong and yet what they're doing with all this tech now and other shady shit just feels wrong.

Question though, what's the range of cell towers?

It depends on many factors but since you are mostly talking about how far away can the cell "hear" your phone, it's not really up to the tower, it's up to how far your phone can broadcast a reliable signal.

Think of it this way, it's a handshake thing, both sides need to hear each other or there is no back and forth. If the tower doesn't hear your phone, then it doesn't talk to your phone, no bars.
 
No it hasn't.

There are legal searches, both with and without a warrant just as NExUSG1 so adequately explained above. And there are searches deemed illegal and in a court this information is suppressed by the court as it should be.
Our rights have not been put to the side. I will acknowledge that we are still defining the proper limits regarding this data. I'll acknowledge that some people have had to fight for their rights in court against the government but I think you would have to concede that this has always been the case.

Our legal system never guaranteed that we would never have to stand up for ourselves. It just tries to give us a chance to come out on top when we are right and the government is wrong.

What I was pointing to is the fact that most people would have an objection to having a tracking chip inserted in their bodies and it would be a Constitutionally supported objection on several levels.

Yet, because of the always-on E911 tracking and availability of retained cell tower ping data, cell phone companies use for advertising and infrastructure enhancements, law enforcement and the government in general has anyone with a cell phone (smart or otherwise) effectively "chipped".

We should be allowed to determine what level of nonessential activity (E911 location included) we want enabled or disabled on our devices and we should also be encouraging providers to aggregate ping data in real time rather than store the details.
 
Except your GPS location is NOT used to send to 911 in most cases, that's what I'm saying. Call 911 on your cell phone and they will most likely have very little idea of where you actually are, and if they do have a location it could be WAY off. So we are agreeing to allow them to track us "for 911 calls" that don't actually get that data. Makes you wonder what they ARE using it for (Like the crap this thread is about)....


Yes it is, it is required by law or did you miss that part? E911 which dates back to 2005. All of the major carriers use A-GPS to locate you in the event of an emergency. . Alltel, Verizon Wireless, T-Mobile 3G, and Sprint PCS use Assisted GPS. It will be required by 2019 and that is less than 3 years away... GPS was not included in phones because consumers wanted it, it was part of a Federal Mandate. It is a lot easier to have the phone provide the location than it is to try and triangulate off of several towers... especially in areas that are not heavily populated.
 
Another reason for cell phone customers to demand the ability to disable ALL tracking on and of their phones if they so desire!

This de facto tracking has now put to the side our legal rights in actions taken by our government :rage:

I am not sure how you are going to disable all tracking of your phone? Are you then not going to use cell service at all? Because that is basically what you are suggesting here.

EDIT: Now that doesn't mean the government should automatically get access to that information, however, if the government starts providing infrastructure like many people say they want, then the government would automatically have that information anyway. Also when the government subsidizes programs (such as providing money for new infrastructure), it puts in a bunch of language allowing them to control almost anything to do with that investiture.
 
Last edited:
You must have missed the John Oliver episode on 911. If you call from a cell they most likely have no idea where you are, that GPS data is not sent to them. So they may have mandated it using that as an excuse (like all the fun stuff we do to save us from terrorists), but that's not what it's being used for.

No warrant needed for cellphone location data = no active location tracking turned on, on my phone, period. I was already keeping it off anyway (to save battery life) and just turning it on when I needed it and turning it right back off until I needed it again before this anyway so it's routine. I can look around to guess the weather which is almost as accurate as the local weatherman's forecast anyway. I do like how everyone used to be able to just put in their zip code for the weather but now Android demands location data be turned on, fuckers, I know what you're up to.

And no I'm not doing anything illegal 99.1% of the time, just tired of being the enemy of my own state. Noam Chomsky has stated for decades now that the citizens are the biggest threat to any government and as I get older I'm believing it myself. I'm not feeling too free these days.

I am starting to get the feeling people don't really understand cell tower usage... The "location" tracker on your phone is GPS data, but that is different from Cell Tower data that the cell phone company keeps. They can still track your generally location and sometimes pretty accurate location from cell tower use no matter if you allow the tracking feature or not.
 
I gave up my cell phone about 7 years ago and do no regret it. Life is so much more peaceful without the electronic leash. :D

Which is smart if you do not specifically want or need one for anything. I have had cell phones for over 20 years now and with the exception of a few business related circumstances, I can't say as I have ever really 'needed' a cell phone myself. But then personally I have not cared as much about who knew where I was for the most part. Although I can certainly sympathize with people who feel their personal space or security is violated by that.
 
Yes it is, it is required by law or did you miss that part? E911 which dates back to 2005. All of the major carriers use A-GPS to locate you in the event of an emergency. . Alltel, Verizon Wireless, T-Mobile 3G, and Sprint PCS use Assisted GPS. It will be required by 2019 and that is less than 3 years away... GPS was not included in phones because consumers wanted it, it was part of a Federal Mandate. It is a lot easier to have the phone provide the location than it is to try and triangulate off of several towers... especially in areas that are not heavily populated.

Did you miss all the new recently where they pointed out most 911 call centers have not been updated in a long time and do not have the ability get get that GPS info? I never said it wasn't federally mandated that cell services collect that info for "911 purposes", I'm saying most of the call centers will not get that info.... They had a guy IN a 911 call center dial 911 and asked them what location they had for him as a test, and it showed him MILES away. Or the person who crashed her car into a lake, called 911 and since she couldn't tell them where she was she ended up dying before they found her.... They even joked about how something like a domino's app could get your exact location to deliver a pizza when 911 can't...

So of course they mandated it for '911 purposes' because it sounds reasonable, just like they passed the patriot act to protect us from "terrorists"
 
You're doing it wrong. You use "Airplane mode", which disables your cellular connectivity. This causes all calls to go to voicemail, just like when you are not home to an answering machine. Texts don't get delivered. Your phone won't even ring. You can even turn on WiFi so your browser etc works, but you won't get interrupted by people you don't want to talk to.

I gave up my cell phone about 7 years ago and do no regret it. Life is so much more peaceful without the electronic leash. :D
 
I am starting to get the feeling people don't really understand cell tower usage... The "location" tracker on your phone is GPS data, but that is different from Cell Tower data that the cell phone company keeps. They can still track your generally location and sometimes pretty accurate location from cell tower use no matter if you allow the tracking feature or not.

How big is the range of a cell tower, because that is the limit of accuracy . If you can connect to a cell tower 1/2 a mile away, you could be anywhere in a 1/2 mile radius of that tower, they can't narrow that down (Cell provider probably could with signal stregnth, but even that would vary based on model of phone). You don't connect to multiple towers, so they can't triangulate your signal, so using cell towers is barely more than a rough estimate of your location, if the 911 call center even gets that info.
 
How big is the range of a cell tower, because that is the limit of accuracy . If you can connect to a cell tower 1/2 a mile away, you could be anywhere in a 1/2 mile radius of that tower, they can't narrow that down (Cell provider probably could with signal stregnth, but even that would vary based on model of phone). You don't connect to multiple towers, so they can't triangulate your signal, so using cell towers is barely more than a rough estimate of your location, if the 911 call center even gets that info.

This is not an accurate depiction of how it works at all. First, you can connect to multiple cell towers. Second, cell towers can gauge your location from which antenna is receiving your signal, then it can find how far away you are from that tower by your signal strength. There are actually a number of programs you can get that can track you via cell tower information. Not sure where you are getting your information from, but most of the things you have been saying are wrong.

Now where you want to focus is not that you cannot get location or that the location is a 1/2 mile radius but that even with determining the signal strength and the specific angle of the antenna being used, you can still only narrow it down to certain specific areas. They are far more accurate than a 1/2 mile raidus, but still are not pinpoint accurate. What gives them more accuracy is how many towers get pinged (so yes they absolutely do use triangulation among other methods) and what their range and angle information is in relation to the same device. That is how they can narrow down your location more accurately. Obviously they tend to get far better accuracy in cities and far less accuracy out in rural areas.
 
Last edited:
This is not an accurate depiction of how it works at all. First, you can connect to multiple cell towers. Second, cell towers can gauge your location from which antenna is receiving your signal, then it can find how far away you are from that tower by your signal strength. There are actually a number of programs you can get that can track you via cell tower information. Not sure where you are getting your information from, but most of the things you have been saying are wrong.

Now where you want to focus is not that you cannot get location or that the location is a 1/2 mile radius but that even with determining the signal strength and the specific angle of the antenna being used, you can still only narrow it down to certain specific areas. They are far more accurate than a 1/2 mile raidus, but still are not pinpoint accurate. What gives them more accuracy is how many towers get pinged (so yes they absolutely do use triangulation among other methods) and what their range and angle information is in relation to the same device. That is how they can narrow down your location more accurately. Obviously they tend to get far better accuracy in cities and far less accuracy out in rural areas.


Who is 'they' that you keep referring to? If you mean by cell provider, sure they have a lot more access to information and can analyze the data to narrow down the location. I'm talking specifically about 911 call centers, who do not get that info. So the only thing I'm arguing is why the feds mandated collection of location info for a service that doesn't actually use it (but absolutely should), and wondering what they are really collecting that information for.
 
Who is 'they' that you keep referring to? If you mean by cell provider, sure they have a lot more access to information and can analyze the data to narrow down the location. I'm talking specifically about 911 call centers, who do not get that info. So the only thing I'm arguing is why the feds mandated collection of location info for a service that doesn't actually use it (but absolutely should), and wondering what they are really collecting that information for.

No you specifically listed a limit about what could be obtained from cell tower information. That is what I debunked in your statement. You said that cell tower information could not give location except in very broad terms, that cell phones do not connect to multiple towers, and that it was not possible to triangulate from that information. You were incorrect on all those counts.

The problem is you have been shown to be incorrect each time and you keep coming up with new excuses and shifting the goal posts.
 
How big is the range of a cell tower, because that is the limit of accuracy . If you can connect to a cell tower 1/2 a mile away, you could be anywhere in a 1/2 mile radius of that tower, they can't narrow that down (Cell provider probably could with signal stregnth, but even that would vary based on model of phone). You don't connect to multiple towers, so they can't triangulate your signal, so using cell towers is barely more than a rough estimate of your location, if the 911 call center even gets that info.

Well now you are talking about several things to answer that question.

First, range is a very subjective term when you are dealing with radios and that is what you are dealing with. Multiple radios and the tower end has to be able to communicate with the phone end. If either one isn't receiving the other then there isn't much communication going on.

So first we have the physical, issues of signal strength and the effects of weather and terrain.

Then you have to remember that there is 4G, 3G, and still 2G. Each operates in different frequency ranges. basic radio wave theory says the lower the frequency the farther the signal will travel. But since we are talking about data being sent over these signals, the higher the frequency of the signal means the more data you can send. That is the problem, to have a fast network you need higher frequencies which travel shorter distances so you need to spend more on towers. What that means is that your 3G may not reach the tower but your 2G is still talking fine but at a slower data rate. That means if you don't need to send much data, like location tracking probably doesn't take much, it could go over your 2G radio just fine and have a greater range.

Is this helping?
 
No you specifically listed a limit about what could be obtained from cell tower information. That is what I debunked in your statement. You said that cell tower information could not give location except in very broad terms, that cell phones do not connect to multiple towers, and that it was not possible to triangulate from that information. You were incorrect on all those counts.

The problem is you have been shown to be incorrect each time and you keep coming up with new excuses and shifting the goal posts.


I've shifted nothing, the point was always that this data does not go to 911, regardless of the reasons storing the data was mandated.
 
Back
Top