Star Trek Beyond Trailer

Just ignore them, just old angry nerds with extremely misplaced nostalgia. I grew up with TNG and watched ToS extensively and have fond memories of them. That doesn't stop me from appreciating the fact that the new movies are frankly a breath of fresh air for the franchise. ST had been stale and quite frankly bad for a very very long time. Most of them are just angry because something that used to be watched by only the loyal dedicated few can now actually be enjoyed by anyone even if they haven't watched every previous movie and series.
You mean how Scotty is an incompetent boob at engineering. How the entire interior layout of the ship looks like a brew factory with no explanation or function or how the warp core looks like it was pit together by 4 year olds or Spock having a relationship when he is the most anti emotional of characters....or skirt is just power hungry or they turned a ship over to a fresh cadet graduate or that the federation made a marvelous technological leap in technology from a man that was frozen in time...yes Kahn. Oh and his acting sucked too
Other then that the acting was fucking horrible in a bad campy way. I mean what's not to love?

JJ assshit...gautentee to take a shit on any movie he touches with special effects bad acting clichés and no real character development.
 
Star Trek was bout exporation, science, and discovery.

The new movies throw all of that out the window in the name of "Action and special effects."

Gone is the deep rooted science (many things in thei original show were based on things that were theoretically possible and even came to fruition). The new ones have zero merit for using science in the least and just throw in whatever they wish without having any kind of explanation or logical scientific basis or theory for it.

All the new movies want to do is make big summer blockbuster movies where you don't need to think.
Yeah who wants action anyway????

Or for that matter, who wants special effects???

Bring back the boring next generation version!

The new star treks are badass... bunch of haters in here.
 
It was never rooted in science. It was always about magical technology. And exploration and discovery got really boring and stale even before TOS ended. There's only so many different ways the Good Ship Spaceshuttle Reference can run into an unexplored planet/species and have it end up differently. And TOS did all of them, then TNG did all of them yet again...and then Voyager did all of them a 3rd time....

They did plenty of things with science, it wasn't ALL science or real, but many things within the show were developed with some understanding of how things work, theories at the time, etc.

Far more then the new movies do with just throwing out everything with zero explanation or thought behind how it works or functions.


Yeah who wants action anyway????

Or for that matter, who wants special effects???

Bring back the boring next generation version!

The new star treks are badass... bunch of haters in here.

The old ones had action in it and special effects (even if that part didn't hold up well lol) but the focus wasn't on that.

It's like the Resident Evil games. You had the first few focused on having a tense survival horror game with limited tools to use in combat to the point that a single lone zombie or something could be a threat. After RE4 that become a moot point and the series swung into a full on action game fighting hordes of zombies and it's now largely lost the horror and survival elements in favor of action.

Some of us liked the old Star Trek and would just like to see new Star Trek things that go back toward a more intellectual/character focus/Exploration shift rather then focusing so much on action and being a popcorn movie.
 
They did plenty of things with science, it wasn't ALL science or real, but many things within the show were developed with some understanding of how things work, theories at the time, etc.

Far more then the new movies do with just throwing out everything with zero explanation or thought behind how it works or functions.

star-trek-motivational-poster-ingenuity.jpg
 
haters gonna hate. Yes, I will say it, trek was dead. JJ brought it back to mainstream. I want more trek, grew up on TNG/DS9 (voyager SUUUUUUUUUUUUUUCKS x1000000101101). I'll take an action trek just to have trek over having zero trek around. So yeah, i'd prefer a star trek 2/4/6 type flick, but I will eat up what they will give us. Because otherwise, there would be NONE. JJ's reimaginging of ST is the ONLY reason there is a new series in the works.
 
Looks cool to me and it may be a good story too. Definitely better than all the newest Star Trek book authors.


Sounds like you have no idea what you are talking about. But hey, I am not certain you have ever read any of the novels either? Have you?

I did like reading some of them: Star Trek Spectre, Star Trek Prime Directive. I also liked the Star Trek Motion Picture movie. Did not like the other ones as much as the first one.
 
Last edited:
Paramount would green light Axanar and drop court case (Seen you youtube) and quite a story with 4 year war with Klingons. Looks like a awesome idea for movie or even tv series. I grew up on star trek countless hours my father watching it. I am sci-fi nut.
 
The novels with the origin of the Borg were awesome. I loved how it spanned multiple trek timelines. And how they destroyed the borg.
 
So since Star Trek only really works if you're willing to completely turn off your brain and not think too much, I find it ironic that people say that the new Star Treks are too dumbed down and don't make sense. Star Trek never has.

LOL! This is hilarious given the number of people that for years have said that Star Trek inspired them in STEM fields. My interest in computers was a direct result of watching ST:TOS reruns.
 
You mean how Scotty is an incompetent boob at engineering. How the entire interior layout of the ship looks like a brew factory with no explanation or function or how the warp core looks like it was pit together by 4 year olds or Spock having a relationship when he is the most anti emotional of characters....or skirt is just power hungry or they turned a ship over to a fresh cadet graduate or that the federation made a marvelous technological leap in technology from a man that was frozen in time...yes Kahn. .
They tried a very lame version of a BSG reboot.
 
Not sure why such the hate for Star Trek movies. They brought up some very interesting points.

The Prime Directive is a legitimate scientific thought process. That an alien civilization might actively hide it's presence from us because we are not on the same level as them. We as humans have had similar feelings when we come across other "indigenous" human races. We also somewhat do it with preserve parks. We artificially limit contact for a certain species because we think it's better for that species. You can compare it to whatever political movement you hate, but the reason those political movements exists is because it is a normal human thought process.

In First Contact they explored the idea that we have no yet met the limit of "visibility". As humans we consider radio emissions to be the threshold of galactic visibility. But gee, wouldn't you know it, we just so happen to also be at that level. Why would we ever think it's something higher then what we currently are? In First Contact it puts forth the thesis that the first warp speed signature is what brings us to the attention of a passing alien species (Vulcan).

The Voyage Home, there is thesis that an alien race could have visited Earth before humans were the most intelligent race. Or that the alien race just happened to establish communication with an animal besides humans. This of course goes back to idea that humans believe they are the gate keepers for anything that happens on Earth.

The first Star Trek (The Motion Picture) put forth the idea that something found in space could be deeply misinterpreted. That was a Voyager satellite misinterpreted by aliens as being something more grand then it really was. One would have to imagine what would humans think if we found something similar floating through space. How would we interpret such a thing? The book/movie Contact by Carl Sagan also deals with this subject, as did author Isaac Asimov occasionally.

The Genesis Device (from Wrath of Khan) represents a desire that we have had for a long time. We have yet to find a planet that is habitable for humans and at this point even if we do it is so far away that it's impossible to get there in a reasonable amount of time. Instead we want a way to teraform quickly. Several movies have dealt with this desire. Total Recall and Titan AE are two that dealt with the fantasy of quick teraforming. The reality of 1000 year teraforming plan just doesn't appeal to us.

Regarding Generations (7th movie), fuck yall, it had Kirk, Picard and Malcom McDowell. I don't care who you are, that's good shit right there.
 
Not sure why such the hate for Star Trek movies. They brought up some very interesting points.

The Prime Directive is a legitimate scientific thought process. That an alien civilization might actively hide it's presence from us because we are not on the same level as them. We as humans have had similar feelings when we come across other "indigenous" human races. We also somewhat do it with preserve parks. We artificially limit contact for a certain species because we think it's better for that species. You can compare it to whatever political movement you hate, but the reason those political movements exists is because it is a normal human thought process.

In First Contact they explored the idea that we have no yet met the limit of "visibility". As humans we consider radio emissions to be the threshold of galactic visibility. But gee, wouldn't you know it, we just so happen to also be at that level. Why would we ever think it's something higher then what we currently are? In First Contact it puts forth the thesis that the first warp speed signature is what brings us to the attention of a passing alien species (Vulcan).

The Voyage Home, there is thesis that an alien race could have visited Earth before humans were the most intelligent race. Or that the alien race just happened to establish communication with an animal besides humans. This of course goes back to idea that humans believe they are the gate keepers for anything that happens on Earth.

The first Star Trek (The Motion Picture) put forth the idea that something found in space could be deeply misinterpreted. That was a Voyager satellite misinterpreted by aliens as being something more grand then it really was. One would have to imagine what would humans think if we found something similar floating through space. How would we interpret such a thing? The book/movie Contact by Carl Sagan also deals with this subject, as did author Isaac Asimov occasionally.

The Genesis Device (from Wrath of Khan) represents a desire that we have had for a long time. We have yet to find a planet that is habitable for humans and at this point even if we do it is so far away that it's impossible to get there in a reasonable amount of time. Instead we want a way to teraform quickly. Several movies have dealt with this desire. Total Recall and Titan AE are two that dealt with the fantasy of quick teraforming. The reality of 1000 year teraforming plan just doesn't appeal to us.

Regarding Generations (7th movie), fuck yall, it had Kirk, Picard and Malcom McDowell. I don't care who you are, that's good shit right there.

While the cast was rockin, the story wasn't. It was a slow story. Boring. I'm complaining, but there hasn't been a trek movie I didn't go see.
 
Oh c'mon, like Star Trek was ever more than fake-scientific socialist nonsense with virtually no creativity in the first place. All the aliens look like and act like humans, oh except one of the aliens has pointy ears, oh no sorry two of the aliens have pointy ears and look identical, but one of them acts like the aliens with ridges on their foreheads... oh and sorry, I forgot about the space jews that have big ears instead of noses.

Don't get me wrong, Star Trek was always very entertaining, but its as full of crap as Thundercats which I also thoroughly enjoyed. They act like resources are infinite, but then compete for them, and you have rich and poor, and they never explain why someone would choose to be a grunt swapping Riker's "love stains" off the holodeck for his entire life, when he could live a life of luxury inside his own personal holosuite back on Earth where he is a king and has sexy slave girls sucking his toes and bending to his every whim. It was a half-ass nonsensical way to promote marxism while marrying the old tales of ship captains on the open seas that have a strong network for support yet are out of communication and thus empowered out on the oceans exploring new lands.

People really give Star Trek too much credit, when oddly other amazing sci-fi series like Battlestar Galactica were so much more thought provoking and challenging. Or the Aliens franchise for that matter.

So since Star Trek only really works if you're willing to completely turn off your brain and not think too much, I find it ironic that people say that the new Star Treks are too dumbed down and don't make sense. Star Trek never has.
One thing is clear, you don't understand Star Trek and the world of Star Trek at all. Which is not surprising based on how superficial your knowledge of it is.

Here are just a few things so you can't accuse me of not giving any arguments.

Actually the science of star trek, at least the most popular next generation is much better than most scifis. Of course it's not always accurate but the nonsense fake science only started with Voyager, when they tried to appeal to a bigger audience.
If you ever watched Star Trek you'd now that there were numerous aliens that were nothing like humans. Of course the aliens serving on a human ship must be able to breath the atmosphere and must be able to function in that environment catered to monkeys walking on two legs. Otherwise they wouldn't be much use. These non-humanoid aliens were most often featured in TNG. Of course sometimes they were ridicilous but that's due to the budget of a TV show or the technology of 60s / 80s. And not a flaw with the philosophy of Star Trek.

You only have rich and poor in star trek in societies outside of the federation. People go to serve on a starship to explore, to see strange new worlds (to parrot the catchphrase) . But you don't choose to be a captain or a lowly deck hand. You finish starfleet academy then go through the ranks. Sorry but your notion that it would be a choice of someone to mop the floor his entire life is so absurd I got to laugh at it. People in a post scarcity society don't work for monetary gain, they work for their own betterment and to achieve their goal, whatever may that be. In starfleet that would mostly to be a captain on a capital ship. It is definitely not marxism. Sure you may find one or two things in common, but to equate the two based on that, is pure unscientific nonsense. It's like saying that Water is Sulphuric Acid because both have H2 in them.

The Aliens franchise is great in its own way. But the world it presents is a simplistic go to future for every 2nd bad scifi flick. It has nothing that would make it stand out in that regard. BSG is better, and presents a believable and interesting world, but this is not a race. There is no need to choose a "better" scifi show. Enjoy both or don't enjoy them, but going on to belittle another show and through that every person liking that show is very bigoted.
 
>posting in a legendary thread

star trek series are "real" star trek, TNG is best of course
old star trek movies are a balance of action/exploration (and slowly go to shit)
90-00's star trek movies are action shit
abrams remakes are brainless (but fun) trash
 
Granted those things mentioned we don't have today, but what about Cell Phones, Tricorders, ect. Those things we DO have today and were inspired by Star Trek. I don't see anything in the world today that was taken from Star Wars and implemented into reality, nothing that actually works or improves mankind that is, unless you count those toy lightsabers.
T.I.E. (Twin-Ion Engine) Fighters
How an Ion Drive Helped NASA's Dawn Probe Visit Dwarf Planet Ceres

Star Wars was more about the creatures and machines than technology, anyway. Much of the tech came from Star Trek anyway (cloaking, faster than light travel, lasers/phasers, androids/droids, etc.)
 
Last edited:
I like some of the fucked up logic here. The original is better because 40 years later we have some of the technology where as 5 years later we have nothing from the reboot yet so that shows the reboot is worse.... Of you know there is a difference in time.

this thread makes me glad I am into geek culture but am not a fucking nerd
 
You only have rich and poor in star trek in societies outside of the federation. People go to serve on a starship to explore, to see strange new worlds (to parrot the catchphrase) . But you don't choose to be a captain or a lowly deck hand. You finish starfleet academy then go through the ranks. Sorry but your notion that it would be a choice of someone to mop the floor his entire life is so absurd I got to laugh at it. People in a post scarcity society don't work for monetary gain, they work for their own betterment and to achieve their goal, whatever may that be. In starfleet that would mostly to be a captain on a capital ship. It is definitely not marxism.
You have poor people in the federation as well, like the miners busting their asses in dangerous environments... for what? And people go to serve on a starship to explore? Why? Why not "buy" their own ship? And they gave the Bajoran a few blankets... really? Give them a bigass replicator and a power station and they would supposedly have unlimited resources.

And while the exploration is exciting for the bridge crew that we see on the Enterprise, how is it exciting for guys that never get off the ship on away missions (only a handful of actors do and the rest usually die), that are always in their little departments, most possibly without a window (not that there would be much to see), and have mundane tedious jobs. Think about it, there are around a thousand people on those ships, and only a few get to really experience anything fulfilling, with lots of grunts doing dirty work behind the scenes to ensure that the few "elite" on their ship can do all the fun/exciting stuff. That makes sense when you have bills to pay, but is total nonsense in the real world when you can have anything you want and don't have to work (I can tell you right now, I would never ever go to work and would just have fun with my own hobbies and probably play games on my own holodeck all the time). And notice how everyone really busts their ass day and and day out... why? There are only so many ships, and they are generally only ever run by the command crew on starships that are already on the bridge. So out of the thousand on each ship, at least 900 will never see the bridge and most on the ship really just have orders barked at them and will never have any real control of their lives that they give up when there is no reason.

Its great for people that want to imagine some socialist utopia, but without addressing any inconsistencies or completely ignoring the human condition. No one will be a plumber if there's no economy, but someone still has to do the dirty jobs, which is something Star Trek generally ignores... just like toilets. No one ever poops in the Star Trek universe... its a ship of 1000 people, and I think there are two hidden toilets on the ship, lol! Can you imagine the lines after lunch?

And that's fine, you don't need realism to be entertaining, and there's nothing wrong with sci-fi fantasy which is what it is. That's why humans are always right on the show, and the main characters really don't have any vices or character flaws, or personal agendas, or really change much and grow. Its fun clean entertainment for all ages (a key factor), and that's great.
 
You have poor people in the federation as well, like the miners busting their asses in dangerous environments... for what? And people go to serve on a starship to explore? Why? Why not "buy" their own ship? And they gave the Bajoran a few blankets... really? Give them a bigass replicator and a power station and they would supposedly have unlimited resources.

And while the exploration is exciting for the bridge crew that we see on the Enterprise, how is it exciting for guys that never get off the ship on away missions (only a handful of actors do and the rest usually die), that are always in their little departments, most possibly without a window (not that there would be much to see), and have mundane tedious jobs. Think about it, there are around a thousand people on those ships, and only a few get to really experience anything fulfilling, with lots of grunts doing dirty work behind the scenes to ensure that the few "elite" on their ship can do all the fun/exciting stuff. That makes sense when you have bills to pay, but is total nonsense in the real world when you can have anything you want and don't have to work (I can tell you right now, I would never ever go to work and would just have fun with my own hobbies and probably play games on my own holodeck all the time). And notice how everyone really busts their ass day and and day out... why? There are only so many ships, and they are generally only ever run by the command crew on starships that are already on the bridge. So out of the thousand on each ship, at least 900 will never see the bridge and most on the ship really just have orders barked at them and will never have any real control of their lives that they give up when there is no reason.

Its great for people that want to imagine some socialist utopia, but without addressing any inconsistencies or completely ignoring the human condition. No one will be a plumber if there's no economy, but someone still has to do the dirty jobs, which is something Star Trek generally ignores... just like toilets. No one ever poops in the Star Trek universe... its a ship of 1000 people, and I think there are two hidden toilets on the ship, lol! Can you imagine the lines after lunch?

And that's fine, you don't need realism to be entertaining, and there's nothing wrong with sci-fi fantasy which is what it is. That's why humans are always right on the show, and the main characters really don't have any vices or character flaws, or personal agendas, or really change much and grow. Its fun clean entertainment for all ages (a key factor), and that's great.

Lol, all corruption, Earthly wars are vanished, no corporations or business since there is no money. I wonder if everyone's apartment or bed is the same or do some get special arrangements based on what? Anyways the society shown is about as workable as the science in Star Trek - it wouldn't. Some how the experience is suppose to be the Pay you get, no savings and I guess you can retire anytime you want and do what ever you want. Except you can't, someone will be ordering you to do what ever they think is needed, ones that are above you. Anyways it is interesting to explore different social systems - this one in Star Trek I doubt would work with real humans.

Now from that, I can't wait to see the next movie.
 
>posting in a legendary thread

star trek series are "real" star trek, TNG is best of course
old star trek movies are a balance of action/exploration (and slowly go to shit)
90-00's star trek movies are action shit
abrams remakes are brainless (but fun) trash

Hey! Nemesis was awesome!
 
Now this is Star Trek old school style....This was what the lawsuit was over....made by fans for a fraction of the budget.



They THINK they can't make money using the old school format with new characters. They were wrong. And the studio didn't like that something so great came out of fans, and threatened their stranglehold, their precious demographics, and holy grail JJ.
 
I look at the new movies as a separate, stand-alone series, and for that they are fine. I'm not about to compare them to the old 'Trek. However, the overreach in referencing the original series or movies is absurd for those of us who saw and enjoyed them. Like in "Into the Darkness" where Spock sreams "KAAAAHHHHN" when Kirk "dies." Direct reference to "Wrath of Kahn" but without the same buildup or situation. I mean, at the beginning of the movie, Spock and Kirk still basically hated each other, by the end of the movie, one of them dying has such a severe emotional reaction. It was such a forced issue simply to reference a previous movie.

Make them their own stories and movies, and forget about tying them in this sort of way to the originals, and I'll be happy.
 
This honestly looks like Michael Bay-level garbage to me. I'm sure it will do well at the box office (as Transformers always does for some reason) but this is not Star Trek.

I watched the previous two films and they were mediocre at best. Neither felt like Star Trek at all, really, other than fan service references.
 
Don't forget that if you want a slower paced Star Trek, the new TV series is coming out soon.

I just hope they don't go full SJW propaganda on it, and have a barely passable overweight Aboriginal male to female transsexual captain to teach us that xe's healthy at any size and fat shaming is wrong, and has a love interest with his bisexual albino Klingon engineer who struggles with Klingon society's gender role expectations for him when he just wants to tinker instead of fight and that discriminate against him because of his color, while even well intentioned shitlords fail to recognize their privilege and falsely expect him to act like a Klingon cuz day raciss!

Seriously, it really could happen. Think about how SJW Voyager was, and that was back in the day before the "safe space" full retard affair we have on college campuses all over America today.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zuul
like this
Lol, all corruption, Earthly wars are vanished, no corporations or business since there is no money. I wonder if everyone's apartment or bed is the same or do some get special arrangements based on what? Anyways the society shown is about as workable as the science in Star Trek - it wouldn't. Some how the experience is suppose to be the Pay you get, no savings and I guess you can retire anytime you want and do what ever you want. Except you can't, someone will be ordering you to do what ever they think is needed, ones that are above you. Anyways it is interesting to explore different social systems - this one in Star Trek I doubt would work with real humans.

Now from that, I can't wait to see the next movie.
A post scarcity economy doesn't mean everyone gets 8 ferraris and a mansion with 10 swimming pools and a minisub docked at the front porch. It means you have your needs met without work. That means you have basic housing, food, education, and utilities for free. If you want status you still have to do something productive. But it might be enough to just work 4 hours a week, instead of 40. Noone would be ordering you around, you'd volunteer. Becuase you'd go stir crazy doing nothing. Of course we coming from a work for a living society doing jobs we hate, or at least hate doing them around the clock we couldn't function in a society like that. We'd just lay back and do nothing for months or years if we happened to suddenly find ourselves in that world. But for someone who was brought up in a world like that it would be normal that work is voluntary and there is no pay. The common argument against this type of society is that noone would do anything, but even in our society there is evidence that people want to act. There are a lot of volunteering going on even now, and the rich could just sit back and do nothing, except most of them stay active. Especially those who already born into a rich environment where they had everything they still go to school and they still work, but not to get food on the table, but to achieve some kind of intellectual / societal status. That wouldn't change in a Star Trek like "utopia" except everyone would have the same opportunity as the 1% has now.
 
A post scarcity economy doesn't mean everyone gets 8 ferraris and a mansion with 10 swimming pools and a minisub docked at the front porch. It means you have your needs met without work. That means you have basic housing, food, education, and utilities for free. If you want status you still have to do something productive. But it might be enough to just work 4 hours a week, instead of 40. Noone would be ordering you around, you'd volunteer. Becuase you'd go stir crazy doing nothing. Of course we coming from a work for a living society doing jobs we hate, or at least hate doing them around the clock we couldn't function in a society like that. We'd just lay back and do nothing for months or years if we happened to suddenly find ourselves in that world. But for someone who was brought up in a world like that it would be normal that work is voluntary and there is no pay. The common argument against this type of society is that noone would do anything, but even in our society there is evidence that people want to act. There are a lot of volunteering going on even now, and the rich could just sit back and do nothing, except most of them stay active. Especially those who already born into a rich environment where they had everything they still go to school and they still work, but not to get food on the table, but to achieve some kind of intellectual / societal status. That wouldn't change in a Star Trek like "utopia" except everyone would have the same opportunity as the 1% has now.

You forget in many a star trek book there are special outpost for the loonies....AKA the street vegabonds of today. A number of them have psychiatric issues. So to say everyone is treated equal only is true if you "get inline with what society expects of you."

And I hate to sound like a Judas here, but Gene Rodenberry almost KILLED TNG. He was out of his mind on drugs and very hard to work with. Writers were constantly fired by him left and right, season after season. It's only when CBS stepped in and found ways to "sidetrack him" that TNG really took off. There's a documentary on this on Netflix. I was in shock. Look up "Chaos on the Bridge"
 
Back
Top