WB: Arkham Knight’s PC Version Is Unfixable

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
So is it safe to say this is one of the worst PC ports of all time? The good news is that WB is giving refunds until the end of the year.

Ever the bearer of bad news on Steam, WB community manager Yorick took to the community's news page on this Hallow's Eve with some spooky news. The issues that continue to plague Batman: Arkham Knight's PC port are unfixable. Even after last month's patch that fixed many issues and the update that was pushed when sales resumed Wednesday, many gamers are still experiencing a number of issues with Arkham Knight.
 
Nvidia should give another game to those who got it free from video card deal. lol
 
I got it from the Nvida deal when I got my 970, it was totally unplayable, even at the lowest settings. tried it again the other day and its much better, was able to move up to medium-ish settings and its very playable now.

Glad I'll be able to go through it, heard it was a good game from those that could play it.
 
Nvidia can probably sue WB over this, brand damages because of the cross-promotion and WB really not seeming to do the due diligence to make sure the product bearing their property was up-to-snuff.

However I'm also thinking WB may wisely avoid this by putting some cash in an envelope or conceding some future game pack-ins where the $$ deal greatly favors Nvidia.
 
I contacted Newegg a few months ago about the free batman game I got with my gtx 980 ti. They gave me Metal Gear Solid without arguing.
 
Nvidia should have offered another free game months ago following all of these issues. but again when it comes to sales ethics Nvidia doesn't stand behind customer service and fixing its mistakes
 
Unfixable? Bull.

More like "we don't want to spend any more time/money on this"
 
How can it be unfixable?
Some people have reported they can run it fine.

A serious cop out.
 
Terrible. One of the few games I was looking forward to, completely ruined by a botched porting.

Guess I'll wait for it to go on sale for 5 bucks and play when I upgrade my 780.
 
What are the issues people have been having?

I only recently got it (didn't know anyone was having issues) and so far for me it's been fine. gtx 980 ti in an old x58 system.
 
These are the issues WB confirmed still exist:

Warner Brothers said:
We are still working with our GPU partners to add full support for SLI and Crossfire. In addition, we are working with these partners to address stability issues on certain cards related to the latest drivers.

After extensive testing, a hard drive paging issue with some GPUs on Windows 7 may occur after extended gameplay sessions. If you encounter this, simply re-launching the game will resolve the issue.

For Windows 10 users, we’ve found that having at least 12GB of system RAM on a PC allows the game to operate without paging and provides a smoother gameplay experience.

Warner Brothers post on Steam, October 28 2015
 
What are the issues people have been having?

I only recently got it (didn't know anyone was having issues) and so far for me it's been fine. gtx 980 ti in an old x58 system.

x58 980x at 4 GHz, Windows 10 but with an ancient GTX 680. I have to use low textures as that's all that 2 GB of VRAM runs well with but everything else on high and I'm getting about 45 FPS and it's smooth at 1080p. No SLI support though.

It seems to be an optimization issue such that decent hardware will take care of it. I really hate this happened, I really have liked this franchise on the PC and it looks like it's in danger. It is coming out for OS X and Linux in the spring so maybe that's a good sign that PCs will still be supported in the future if there are other games in the franchise.
 
I contacted Newegg a few months ago about the free batman game I got with my gtx 980 ti. They gave me Metal Gear Solid without arguing.

After hearing about people getting a replacement game for Batman, I asked Amazon if they could give me MGS since Assassins Creed that came with my 980 in December had issues, they gave me $64 to buy MGS when it was released.
I ended up trading a copy of Zombie Army Trilogy for MGS with member here.
I used the Amazon credit to buy some LED strip lighting and other stuff for my cubicle.
 
All evidence points to this game simply requiring vram and system ram above recommended specs.
 
Honestly the game has ran fine for me Before and After the updates, I must just have gotten lucky.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041944215 said:
Unfixable? Bull.

More like "we don't want to spend any more time/money on this"

How can it be unfixable?
Some people have reported they can run it fine.

A serious cop out.

There are bugs but they don't believe they'll recoup enough profit to warrant fixing them. This, to the company, means it's unfixable. These companies aren't your friend - they're out to make a profit, plain and simple.
 
All evidence points to this game simply requiring vram and system ram above recommended specs.

Or people trying to play it above what their hardware will allow. I'm running Windows 10 with 12 GB and had to the game clearly points out in the textures option that Low requires 2 GB of VRAM. The game however didn't detect that right on my system and for some reason added up the VRAM of my 3x SLI GTX 680 2GB cards and thought I had 6GB and set the textures to high. Once reduced to low things were smooth as butter. And I think the game still looks very good even with the low textures.
 
I'd encourage any Green Man Gaming customers to demand refunds via that route if applicable. They are currently sending out denial e-mails, but that should change if they get enough outrage.
 
All evidence points to this game simply requiring vram and system ram above recommended specs.

There's (supposedly) a memory leak and the patch notes for the fix said "after playing for X Time, please close and reopen the game".

Lol, that's not a solution.
 
All evidence points to this game simply requiring vram and system ram above recommended specs.

I completely agree. It ran fin on my PC since it launched. The only real issue I had was when I had my 970, it really didn't run at 2560x1600 with med settings. It runs great on my current system with a 980Ti. Still though I have had 32GB of ram so I am sure that made all the difference. Personally I think they "can't" fix it because they don't want to spend the money to fix the memory usage properly to the min specs they originally published. It would probably require a rewrite of a good deal of that portion of the code + retesting QA.
 
All evidence points to this game simply requiring vram and system ram above recommended specs.

Ahh that's probably why it's not given me any issues.

980ti has 6gb vram. I also have 24gb system ram in this old x58, i7-920@3.6ghz, Windows 10.

If all the game is doing is incorrectly setting the games' video options, seems like that should be fixable.

I did go in and turn all the settings to high, but I am only playing in 1920x1200.
 
Of ours really unfixable they should pull it from sales permanently, refund everybody, and scrap it.

Otherwise it's fixable.
 
Or people trying to play it above what their hardware will allow. I'm running Windows 10 with 12 GB and had to the game clearly points out in the textures option that Low requires 2 GB of VRAM. The game however didn't detect that right on my system and for some reason added up the VRAM of my 3x SLI GTX 680 2GB cards and thought I had 6GB and set the textures to high. Once reduced to low things were smooth as butter. And I think the game still looks very good even with the low textures.

Thing is, it makes absolutely no sense for it to require way more ram than the consoles.

The consoles have 8 GB ram shared between graphics, OS and actual game that is allocated so that only 4.5 to 5 GB are usable for game loading+ graphics, and yet somehow on PC you require 12 GB system ram+ 2GB video or you get a stutter fest?... you know that Windows 7, 8 and 10 are actually light on ram use, so it doesn't make any sense. The performance is the same as the interim patch 2+ months ago, what were they doing during all this time, besides churning out the DLC?
 
Zarathustra[H];1041944215 said:
Unfixable? Bull.

More like "we don't want to spend any more time/money on this"

This!

So they tried to use cut-rate developers and it bit them in the rear.

I doubt they will learn though. They will probably do the same exact thing next time and expect different results.
 
Thing is, it makes absolutely no sense for it to require way more ram than the consoles.

The consoles have 8 GB ram shared between graphics, OS and actual game that is allocated so that only 4.5 to 5 GB are usable for game loading+ graphics, and yet somehow on PC you require 12 GB system ram+ 2GB video or you get a stutter fest?... you know that Windows 7, 8 and 10 are actually light on ram use, so it doesn't make any sense. The performance is the same as the interim patch 2+ months ago, what were they doing during all this time, besides churning out the DLC?

I'm not saying that it does make sense, indeed I believe there's some optimization issues going on with the PC version. But if you have the enough hardware and software the issues go away. 12 GB of RAM and a 2GB VRAM are a bit stiff for the PC but this game certainly doesn't need the latest and great hardware to run in my experience as well. It looks like I got lucky with a 12 GB Windows 10 system and a 2 GB GTX 680.
 
Strange, I am playing for the first time on my I7 6700K 32GB DDR4 Ram, R9 290 system. Plays quite well at 4k for me and will only get better with a more capable card next year. It uses all my VRam and as much desktop ram as it needs. Does it play better on AMD or something?
 
Strange, I am playing for the first time on my I7 6700K 32GB DDR4 Ram, R9 290 system. Plays quite well at 4k for me and will only get better with a more capable card next year. It uses all my VRam and as much desktop ram as it needs. Does it play better on AMD or something?

This is great hardware and I don't think people with great hardware are having many problems with this game.
 
Thing is, it makes absolutely no sense for it to require way more ram than the consoles.

The consoles have 8 GB ram shared between graphics, OS and actual game that is allocated so that only 4.5 to 5 GB are usable for game loading+ graphics, and yet somehow on PC you require 12 GB system ram+ 2GB video or you get a stutter fest?... you know that Windows 7, 8 and 10 are actually light on ram use, so it doesn't make any sense. The performance is the same as the interim patch 2+ months ago, what were they doing during all this time, besides churning out the DLC?

If you understood how consoles work that would make perfect sense. PC games will always require higher specs than a console. It is as simple as that. For a console you know exactly what hardware you have and can optimize the game perfectly for that hardware. When it comes to a PC, you know nothing about the end target other than it will need at the very least X hardware. But you don't know if it has 2GB of ram or 24GB. You don't know if it has 4cores or 16 cores... So all of your coding is generic so that it runs on all platforms and all hardware mixes. In doing so you lose some performance. So it is expected that a PC game will have at the very least slightly higher spec requirements than a console for the same graphical settings that you are playing at on a console.
 
How can it be unfixable?
Some people have reported they can run it fine.

A serious cop out.
I think it's probably more along the lines that it's not economical for them to fix. It'll cost thyem less money to offer refunds than it will to fix the issues.
 
I think it's probably more along the lines that it's not economical for them to fix. It'll cost thyem less money to offer refunds than it will to fix the issues.

No doubt but unfixable is a cop out and they should compensate all game owners, not just those who purchased.
They let down a hell of a lot of gamers.
 
This is great hardware and I don't think people with great hardware are having many problems with this game.

You are probably right. I do note that more vram is being requested that the 4GB I have available. However, I am not running a fps meter so I do not even notice anything other than the game play itself. Too much going on to stop and admire the view. :D
 
Welp thats is, I'm DONE with wb. They consistently make crap pc ports and this is the last straw.
 
No doubt but unfixable is a cop out and they should compensate all game owners, not just those who purchased.
They let down a hell of a lot of gamers.

Why would you compensate someone who did not purchase it?
 
Welp thats is, I'm DONE with wb. They consistently make crap pc ports and this is the last straw.
I dunno who to blame here. WB published Dying Light and Shadow of Mordor, which were good ports.

Did WB place too much pressure on Rocksteady to meet a sale date, forcing them to outsource to Iron Galaxy? Did WB not allocate enough money to PC development, requiring Rocksteady to pass the duties on to Iron Galaxy? Did Rocksteady just not give a fuck about the PC port?
 
Back
Top