Richard Stallman Says Windows Is Malware

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
In an op-ed piece written for The Guardian, Richard Stallman said that he believes operating systems like Windows are essentially just malware.

What kinds of programs constitute malware? Operating systems, first of all. Windows snoops on users, shackles users and, on mobiles, censors apps; it also has a universal back door that allows Microsoft to remotely impose software changes. Apple systems are malware too: MacOS snoops and shackles; iOS snoops, shackles, censors apps and has a back door. Even Android contains malware in a nonfree component: a back door for remote forcible installation or deinstallation of any app.
 
Somebody shut these die hard Linux Kool-Aid drinking neck beards up. My god. I have had to listen to this for 20 years, about how Linux will save us all from IBM/Microsoft/Apple or whatever. Fucking true believers. Run across them all the time. Went to a Server 2012 clustering workshop (awesome) across town and got to hear some 2 ton neck beard interrupt the class every 5 minutes to wax on about how to do that in Linux and how editing 4000 lines of a conf file was far superior to 45 mouse clicks and a few powershell commands.

/rantoff
 
Somebody shut these die hard Linux Kool-Aid drinking neck beards up. My god. I have had to listen to this for 20 years, about how Linux will save us all from IBM/Microsoft/Apple or whatever. Fucking true believers. Run across them all the time. Went to a Server 2012 clustering workshop (awesome) across town and got to hear some 2 ton neck beard interrupt the class every 5 minutes to wax on about how to do that in Linux and how editing 4000 lines of a conf file was far superior to 45 mouse clicks and a few powershell commands.

/rantoff

I f*ckin hate those people.

Anyway back to the article, that picture of the author though feels like he's missing a tinfoil hat, just saying.. /malware
 
Guy is 20 years too late to the party. Plus looking like that who takes him and his followers seriously.

He might do well at a D&D convention or tournament but no one in the IT industry, corporate or otherwise will listen.

Some folks just do not help themselves.
 
Lol at people calling Stallman a tinfoil hate. You guys are delusional. Everything of importance he has said so far turned out to be true.
 
Lol at people calling Stallman a tinfoil hate. You guys are delusional. Everything of importance he has said so far turned out to be true.

He and FSF have long made comments about Windows just before a Windows new release. FSF called Windows 7 "treacherous computing". So the tin foil observation isn't without some merit.
 
All of you will have to turn in your Richard Snowden fan club cards.
 
you guys are all aholes. This post was penned on paper and sent to kyle and steve to post on my behalf by drone.
 
Lol this 2 ton neck beard has some awesome software concepts but then he ruins it all by being a rambling idiot.
 
Somebody shut these die hard Linux Kool-Aid drinking neck beards up. My god. I have had to listen to this for 20 years, about how Linux will save us all from IBM/Microsoft/Apple or whatever. Fucking true believers. Run across them all the time. Went to a Server 2012 clustering workshop (awesome) across town and got to hear some 2 ton neck beard interrupt the class every 5 minutes to wax on about how to do that in Linux and how editing 4000 lines of a conf file was far superior to 45 mouse clicks and a few powershell commands.

/rantoff

Well, there is some truth to that (albeit it's largely due to preference). I work in a primarily windows environment and love the shit out of Server 2012 R2. But I also work with Linux on a nearly daily basis and have so for over a decade. And I find it infinitely easier to install and configure software in linux. Things like nginx and apache are stupid easy while IIS is a mess. Not the best example granted since nginx and apache are available in Windows, but I love configuring via conf files vs windows all day every day. Just so much easier to see everything all at once.
 
I get what he is saying.. don't understand the hate.
His way is one way of putting it.. another is, that computers are MS and Google's world and you are just living in it.
The truth is that now more than ever before, you only rent the software, and pretty much give up either implicitly (via 'covert' spying) or explicitly (via EULAs and other 'services') all your "rights" to privacy.
Of course if you don't connect to the internet its different, but that is changing also by programs requiring ever more connected computers... and yes windows will be one of those, its a matter of time, and I am not thinking decades.
 
Somebody shut these die hard Linux Kool-Aid drinking neck beards up. My god. I have had to listen to this for 20 years, about how Linux will save us all from IBM/Microsoft/Apple or whatever. Fucking true believers. Run across them all the time. Went to a Server 2012 clustering workshop (awesome) across town and got to hear some 2 ton neck beard interrupt the class every 5 minutes to wax on about how to do that in Linux and how editing 4000 lines of a conf file was far superior to 45 mouse clicks and a few powershell commands.

/rantoff


Don't get me wrong, the anti-closed source software zealots are very annoying. Sure it's not the ideal, but sometimes you just need something that gets the job done (like a closed source driver) and contorting oneself backwards to avoid anything losed source is nothing but annoying.

That being said, editing a text config file IS much easier to manage than digging through a GUI. Don't know where something is? Search it and find it instantly. Edit then save.

And if you like that config file, take a copy of it, and save it for later. Copy it to all your systems and easily deploy multiple systems.

Whenever I am forced to use a mouse to configure a server it makes me roll my eyes and impatient. it takes something on the order of 10-20 times as much effort to figure out where everything is and set it up, unless you are the type who does that stuff every day, and have the process and locations of everything memorized.

The open source zealots do have a point, though.

We are currently living in the dark future they predicted back in the 80's and early 90's, with data mining and ulterior motives of software developers.

On the other hand - when done right - data mining can pay for services that are free to the end users without risking their privacy. The trouble is, it is impossible - especially for the average user, but even for an expert - to determine which free software/service data miners can be trusted, and which can't, and whenever there is a profit incentive involved, those highly held ideals of privacy can go out the window in a real hurry.
 
Well, there is some truth to that (albeit it's largely due to preference). I work in a primarily windows environment and love the shit out of Server 2012 R2. But I also work with Linux on a nearly daily basis and have so for over a decade. And I find it infinitely easier to install and configure software in linux. Things like nginx and apache are stupid easy while IIS is a mess. Not the best example granted since nginx and apache are available in Windows, but I love configuring via conf files vs windows all day every day. Just so much easier to see everything all at once.

Yep!

This is news to some people, but use whatever does the job the best for a given task. Sometimes that's Windows, sometimes that's Linux, sometimes others.

I quote/paraphrase this line all the time, but I'll do it again.

"Oh, you know, it’s a tool box. I don’t care. You put the tools in for the job. That’s all." (Ronin)
 
I get what he is saying.. don't understand the hate.
His way is one way of putting it.. another is, that computers are MS and Google's world and you are just living in it.
The truth is that now more than ever before, you only rent the software, and pretty much give up either implicitly (via 'covert' spying) or explicitly (via EULAs and other 'services') all your "rights" to privacy.
Of course if you don't connect to the internet its different, but that is changing also by programs requiring ever more connected computers... and yes windows will be one of those, its a matter of time, and I am not thinking decades.

You have never really owned the software, just like you have never really owned the music on that CD or the movie on that DVD.

You own the right to use it, and the means to do so, but the software/music/video itself has always been the intellectual property of its creator.

I think you are blissfully nostalgic for a time and a concept that never existed in the first place :p
 
Of course if you don't connect to the internet its different, but that is changing also by programs requiring ever more connected computers... and yes windows will be one of those, its a matter of time, and I am not thinking decades.

In a Stallman vision world of computing, what exactly would computing be like? So reject anything that snoops or tracks? So then fine, give me the equivalent of the same thing at the same or lower cost that doesn't and we're good.
 
Give me an easily editable/searchable/backupable/copyable text config file any day over a complex GUI mess of menus, as long as the default config file is well commented and documented so that it is easy to understand what to do to set it up.

I can see how it can be frustrating to have to figure out config file syntax on your own without that well commented default config file, but its usually google-able, which is still easier than digging through a mess of a GUI.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041626342 said:
I think you are blissfully nostalgic for a time and a concept that never existed in the first place :p

If you can't steal digital stuff then how can it be owned?
 
Zarathustra[H];1041626342 said:
You have never really owned the software, just like you have never really owned the music on that CD or the movie on that DVD.

You own the right to use it, and the means to do so, but the software/music/video itself has always been the intellectual property of its creator.

I think you are blissfully nostalgic for a time and a concept that never existed in the first place :p

I actually do understand that, but as long as I had a the CD and the player and I am good (not much unlike a book I suppose), now and more so as time passes, that is not even true, if the software does not connect to the server its as good as useless, you already can see that, most extreme examples are those online games of course, i have seen them stop working within a second or so after losing the connection.
Other games I had for the PC would not activate anymore, even though I had the original game and the proper codes, just never played it... Point is, it will be more and more of that, software 'service' I guess.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041626356 said:
Give me an easily editable/searchable/backupable/copyable text config file any day over a complex GUI mess of menus, as long as the default config file is well commented and documented so that it is easy to understand what to do to set it up.

I can see how it can be frustrating to have to figure out config file syntax on your own without that well commented default config file, but its usually google-able, which is still easier than digging through a mess of a GUI.

I agree with this. Occasionally a GUI is nice, but there are tons of advantages to config files. Same with command lines. Sometimes it's just easier to tab-complete a command than to hunt through deep/cascading dialog boxes and menus. Other times, it's nice to have a visual on something though.
 
If you can't steal digital stuff then how can it be owned?

Well, I always struggled with the concept of "theft" when it comes to things that cna be duplicated.

Part of the crime of stealing traditionally was that you were depriving the rightful owner of something.

You steal a car, the owner no longer has a car. Pretty bad.

You duplicate a CD, or copy an mp3, no one has lost anything.

You can make the argument of lost revenue for the rights holder, but that is only true IF the person duplicating the content would have bought it, if duplicating it weren't an option.

With some of these 120GB iPods full of music at a claimed capacity of 30,000 songs that would have cost $0.99 each on iTunes, I very much doubt that your average teenager would even have had the means ($29,700) to buy all of them had they wanted to.

It would seem like a lower standard of "unauthorized use" would be more appropriate.
 
In an op-ed piece written for The Guardian, Richard Stallman said that he believes operating systems like Windows are essentially just malware.

Okay, hyperbole aside, Stallman has good points.

The problem is, his rambling and ranting about it has gotten to the point where people are simply inured to it.

It's like bitching about a politician being dishonest.

After a while, it becomes an old saw.

And people's reactions become "So what?"

There are good and valid reasons for people to use Open Source software.

Unfortunately, most "end users" aren't intelligent enough to make a meaningful decision about what they're going to use.

And of those that are, a majority are, in some way, constrained to using "non-free" software by other considerations (work requires a certain platform, they have apps that only run on Windows, gaming (see apps that only run on Windows), etc).
 
Ah, classic Stallman. Maybe he can regale us with stories of eating his own foot cheese.
 
I get what he is saying.. don't understand the hate.
His way is one way of putting it.. another is, that computers are MS and Google's world and you are just living in it.
The truth is that now more than ever before, you only rent the software, and pretty much give up either implicitly (via 'covert' spying) or explicitly (via EULAs and other 'services') all your "rights" to privacy.
Of course if you don't connect to the internet its different, but that is changing also by programs requiring ever more connected computers... and yes windows will be one of those, its a matter of time, and I am not thinking decades.

Hate? Hardly. Disgust? Amazement? Pity? Much more likely...;) The guy is a buffoon's buffoon...Anyone who uses an OS for its own sake, and doesn't care about the amount of hardware and software it supports, is surely a buffoon of gigantasaurus dimension...:) The better an OS is, the more hardware it supports ROOB--as that is Job #1 for any commercial computer OS, imo.
 
*Even Android* LOL
So he trusts the software from an advertising and private data collecting company more than software from a software company? Interesting.
 
Ah, classic Stallman. Maybe he can regale us with stories of eating his own foot cheese.

Tin foil has no nutritional value, unfortunately... otherwise he'd be set for life.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041626356 said:
Give me an easily editable/searchable/backupable/copyable text config file any day over a complex GUI mess of menus, as long as the default config file is well commented and documented so that it is easy to understand what to do to set it up.

I can see how it can be frustrating to have to figure out config file syntax on your own without that well commented default config file, but its usually google-able, which is still easier than digging through a mess of a GUI.

So you are comparing something "well commented and documented" to something that is "complex gui mess"...

Something about that statement seems off...

I get what you mean but its not a fair comparison selectively choosing the best of one class and the worst of another. And your google argument works exactly the same way for menu options... If you can't find menu item hits in google you will not find text file parameters as well. This assumption is solely based on how many people use and document anything on the web.

As far as windows goes for a long time most vendors used similar menu placement and wording for options. I look through app menus everyday and most of not a "hot mess" but maybe a "mild" mess... certainly not much worse then config files.

Text file configuration is nice and easy for global/overwrite all deployments but there are some issues as well. Selective editing is much more cumbersome then with windows registry based system.

No matter what you do you still have to learn what ever system you use, whether that is GUI or Text... Sure search-ability might help some but again depends on the vendor to use common standards... which they would do or not do whether gui or text.
 
tNaTbdU.png
 
I guess that if you get to use your own definition for malware, the potential candidates can be as many or few as you'd like.
 
Okay, hyperbole aside, Stallman has good points.

The problem is, his rambling and ranting about it has gotten to the point where people are simply inured to it.

It's like bitching about a politician being dishonest.

After a while, it becomes an old saw.

And people's reactions become "So what?"

There are good and valid reasons for people to use Open Source software.

Unfortunately, most "end users" aren't intelligent enough to make a meaningful decision about what they're going to use.

And of those that are, a majority are, in some way, constrained to using "non-free" software by other considerations (work requires a certain platform, they have apps that only run on Windows, gaming (see apps that only run on Windows), etc).

You summed it up well with some good points. Personally I don't care for the guy, but I see him more as an extreme counter-balance so the rest of us don't have to fight so hard.

As for the 'end users aren't intelligent' enough... No. Linux is unpopular and unusable by design. It could very easily accommodate most average user's needs. The community doesn't want normal people using it. They prefer to keep anyone even close to normal away from their empire so they can wallow in their own crapulence. Linux forums are full of cheeto-munching basement-dwelling assholes that proudly show off their introverted ways as a badge of honor. The minute you ask a help question that identifies yourself as "not one of them" it becomes a race to see what one of them can look more pathetic than the Comic-book Guy from the Simpsons.
 
Back
Top