Microsoft Announcing New Surface 3

Zarathustra[H];1041522978 said:
Oh, I know, under normal circumstances I wouldn't have burned it. The windows 8 install overwrote my grub bootloader though, so getting back into linux to use the bootable USB from ISO creator wasn't an immediate option.

I also didn't feel like goggling around trying to find an other obscure piece of software just to write it to my usb stick. I mean the mediacreationtool.exe (or whatever it is called) was supposed to do it on it's own, but failed to write it to the stick for some reason, forcing me to do it again. I was at the point where I had wasted enough time trying new things, and decided to cut my losses and do what I knew worked.

I still need to boot from a Live Linux disk, so I can chroot into my main linux install, and re-run the grub install script.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041522981 said:
I still need to boot from a Live Linux disk, so I can chroot into my main linux install, and re-run the grub install script.

Yuck at losing the grub. :( I've only dual-booted once before and it was like a pretty controlled thing where Windows was installed first and then Linux afterwards to avoid that problem. I mean, it's not a big deal to fix it, but I do wish Microsoft would be a little less domineering over taking over the boot sector regardless of the presence of another OS.
 
Yuck at losing the grub. :( I've only dual-booted once before and it was like a pretty controlled thing where Windows was installed first and then Linux afterwards to avoid that problem. I mean, it's not a big deal to fix it, but I do wish Microsoft would be a little less domineering over taking over the boot sector regardless of the presence of another OS.

Agreed. Not a big deal, just annoying.

When I install from scratch, I always do Windows first for that reason, but as it stands, my windows needed a refresh, but the Linux partition is working just fine.

If the windows installer had an "advanced" menu, allowing you to choose where to install the boot loader (drive, or partition) this would go a long way.
 
FYI yellow text on the white mobile background is A+ killer awesome.
Yeah, that's always annoyed me when browsing on a mobile device.

Admins, if you're reading this, in the admin panel go to the replacement variable manager and create a new replacement variable for the mobile style. In the "Search for Text" field enter "LemonChiffon", then put "black" in the "Replace with Text" field. This will be a big improvement for mobile users which would take all of 20 seconds to implement.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041522951 said:
Conclusion:
I'm sorry, but I am going to have to disagree with your assertion.

Linux is WAY more efficient than windows.

It uses disk space more efficiently (by an order of magnitude!) it uses RAM more efficiently and it MOST CERTAINLY uses my time more efficiently.

It is by far a sleeker, easier to use system where I don't hae to hunt for drivers and software, as everything I need is right there. Stuff just works. And it just works quickly.

The entire time I was installing windows I was in disbelief how painful the process was compared to Linux.

So you're concluding all these things about Linux based on installing it versus Windows. A process that very few people do. A much better judge of efficiency would be how well something common in day to day use would perform.
 
As a Linux user, I totally agree with the fact that Windows feels faster on equal hardware. I've got two netbooks, one's an Asus 1005HAB with an Atom n270 running Mint 17.1 from a 32GB compact flash card on a 2.5 inch SATA adapter and the other is a Dell Latitude 2110 with an Atom n470 - it's like an school and institution-targeted netbook that's sorta heavier and more ruggedized. Both have 2GB of RAM (yay!). The Dell has Windows 7 Pro on it right now, but before settling into 7, I went through Mint 17.1, Ubuntu 14.04 LTS, and Lubuntu 14.04 LTS.

Netbooks being super slow to begin with really bring the differences in performance to light between operating systems. Ubuntu was basically unusable because of how slow it was to navigate the UI. Mint 17.1 was more tolerable, but there were some annoying latencies. There's a rotating background image on the login screen that's new to 17.1 that wasn't in 17.0 and the image resolutions are so high that the computer chugs really badly to load them which makes typing a password really bad. There's like a 2-3 second wait between typing something and keystrokes registering on screen. I fixed it on the Asus by shrinking the background images to 30-50% of their original size, but ugh...annoying! Opening Firefox results in an unresponsive browser for about 5 seconds before you can start typing in a URL. Once things are settled in, its' okay, but Adblock and Noscript set to be really aggressive, caching to RAM only, along with disabling most extensions like Flash (which I'd do to keep creeper Google out anyway) are necessary to make most ad-infested sites load quickly. Mint is otherwise mostly usable and since my Asus' storage solution is a tiny camera memory card, I'm sticking with Mint on it. Windows would be faster. I didn't wanna deal with it on the Dell soooo...

Lubuntu was pretty responsive from a UI perspective on the Latitude netbook, but it had the same problems with web browsing and program execution. Since the computer is licensed to Win 7 Pro and I still need MS Office for college papers, I just installed it and Office 2010. Even with an AV suite, it feels more responsive. Yup, its still not fast. Web browsing in IE11 demands patience sometimes (also not loading Flash and liberally dumping known advertiser URLs into your restricted sites list based on their cookies you find in your cache folder) but it is a smoother feeling experience on the same hardware.

I think the differences are a lot less significant on more modern, powerful hardware so a lot of Linux community sorts don't notice the performance hit even when they use Windows alongside Linux distros. There's also the argument that lightweight distros are more efficient than Windows (which is true and I think Lubuntu was at least competitive with 7 from my experiences with it recently) but the UI isn't as pretty and mainstream Linux distros aren't better out of the box. Yup, you can configure them, but there's the pain of doing dumb stuff like resizing login screen rotating background images that are kinda stupid to implement in the first place and the time it takes to investigate how to make those adjustments along with the potentially lost capabilities in the case of ultra-light distros like Puppy or TinyCore (*shudder*).

I can't help but wonder if the GPU's in those things are fully supported driver wise, based on your results. I have never had issues like that, even on low end hardware (though I don't own any Atoms, but I do have a Zacate, E350)

So you're concluding all these things about Linux based on installing it versus Windows. A process that very few people do. A much better judge of efficiency would be how well something common in day to day use would perform.

Well, I did compare storage space use, if you missed that.

The difference is rather staggering.

As is the time it takes to run and manage updates.

Linux appears to manage its RAM much better too. If I weren't into virtualizing and games, I feel like 2GB would be overkill on a linux box, where I wouldn't run a Windows box with less than 8Gb.

Linux - coming in as many flavors as it does - is going to differ in other regards. There are desktop environments that are surprisingly GPU hungry (Ubuntu's Unity is one of these), ones that are fairly Windows equivalent (Cinnamon is one of these) Mid to low (Mate is one of these) and a number of really low resource desktops if you want to be minimalistic (LXDE, XFCE, etc.)

That being said, unless you are on SERIOUSLY low end/old hardware, it isn't going to make much of a difference. My two HTPC's, AMD E350 (granted, with a Geforce 630GT) and AMD A107850K (IGP) both run Unity flawlessly.

(While I tend to hate Unity for desktop use, it's not a bad HTPC interface)

CPU wise I find Windows and Linux to be fairly equivalent. Things that take CPU cycles on one, tend to take them on the other as well.

From a power efficiency perspective, they are also pretty similar during operation, but Windows tends to have better support for the various ACPI suspend states.

In most cases Linux has no problem entering S3 or S5, but waking from USB can be very tricky to set up. Not a problem if you are sitting right by the power button, but if it's an HTPC across the room it can be annoying (I'm fighting with this right now)

The only exception to this is when I update kernels on the E350, and those kernels don't have matching pre-compiled Nvidia drivers, triggering the Nvidia drivers to compile their own driver module. This can take frustratingly long on the E350 (but still quicker than most Windows updates, I should add)

Honestly I'm not sure what Windows is doing during a large chunk of the update process.

Monitoring system resources there is very little activity on CPU, drive and network a lot of the time.


So, to summarize my efficiency conclusions:

1.) Power: (Slight advantage to Windows)
2.) CPU Use: (Tie)
3.) Desktop GPU use: (depends, advantage windows, tie or advantage linux, depending on hardware, drivers and choice of desktop)
4.) RAM use (large advantage, Linux)
5.) Disk use (large advantage, Linux)


One example:

On my ESXi server, I have many dedicated ubuntu 14.04 server installations. Two of them (one managing the UPS, ans SSH:ing in to shut down ESXi if power goes out, and one running as an SFTP server) are assigned one CPU core, and 128MB (yes MB) each, and they run perfectly, without even swapping.
 
And you could also say that Windows can work with as little as 25 MB of disk space and a working set of 40 MB memory and is fine without a GUI. http://www.istartedsomething.com/20071019/eric-talk-demo-windows-7-minwin/

that was back when Win 7 was new. it's smaller now. Of course you can do a small linux install and be smaller than windows. If you took a copy of Red Hat or any other version of Linux that's trying to be something for everyone it can also be just as big as a full Windows install too. The point still stands, the only people shocked that windows can fit on a phone are the people who keep going on about how they 'think' it's bloated.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041523151 said:
I can't help but wonder if the GPU's in those things are fully supported driver wise, based on your results. I have never had issues like that, even on low end hardware (though I don't own any Atoms, but I do have a Zacate, E350).

I'm reluctant to accuse the GPU of being the source of my problems. They're an Intel GMA 950 partnered with the Atom n270 and a GMA 3150 (derived from the GMA x3100 that shipped with the 965 chipset) working alongside the n470. The 950 is in the Asus netbook where I'm running Mint currently. It was super commonplace as an iGPU because it had a really long production lifespan starting around 2006 with the first Core-series processors and getting a second wind through around 2009 when a clock speed reduced version was paired with early Atom processors. Though they are ultra-suck when it comes to anything graphics related, lack hardware T&L support, (IIRC) didn't even completely implement contemporary Direct X hardware, and are OpenGL stupid, they were everywhere for a while. Besides that, the laggies I experience seem more CPU dependent whereas they involve crunching a few numbers and processing data rather than drawing it on the screen. We are talking about single core, in-order processors that are the rough equal to a Pentium M clocked at about half their speed (so a fictional Pentium M at 800 - 900 MHz). The E-350 has a very solid lead in processor power having two out-of-order processor cores, probably close to 3x the old Atoms.
 
And you could also say that Windows can work with as little as 25 MB of disk space and a working set of 40 MB memory and is fine without a GUI. http://www.istartedsomething.com/20071019/eric-talk-demo-windows-7-minwin/

that was back when Win 7 was new. it's smaller now. Of course you can do a small linux install and be smaller than windows. If you took a copy of Red Hat or any other version of Linux that's trying to be something for everyone it can also be just as big as a full Windows install too. The point still stands, the only people shocked that windows can fit on a phone are the people who keep going on about how they 'think' it's bloated.

There are larger and smaller versions of each, that's why we should compare apples to apples.

A complete modern desktop Linux install, with Office software, browser, graphics editing software, essentially all the (non-game) software you could want or need, can easily fit on a 16GB SSD. The base install (which includes libreoffice and a lot of other useful software) has a minimum install size of 5GB.

Office 2013 takes 3GB of drive space on its own... Windows 8.1, another 20GB.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041523151 said:
IWell, I did compare storage space use, if you missed that.

The difference is rather staggering.

Didn't miss that. However I have an HP Stream 7 that came with only 32 GB of storage and out of the box with initial updates before installing Office and there was only 4.5 GB of storage used. And it took about 20 minutes to fully update and setup initially. An $80 PC, so nothing fancy in the slightest. The Steam 7 has less hardware than a smartphone and while it's no where near a speed demon it get's constant praise for working much better than people would have thought in such a cheap device.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041523209 said:
There are larger and smaller versions of each, that's why we should compare apples to apples.

A complete modern desktop Linux install, with Office software, browser, graphics editing software, essentially all the (non-game) software you could want or need, can easily fit on a 16GB SSD. The base install (which includes libreoffice and a lot of other useful software) has a minimum install size of 5GB.

Office 2013 takes 3GB of drive space on its own... Windows 8.1, another 20GB.

As it was mentioned before, a wimboot image of 8 can match both of those. I have a Venue 8 Pro where I reinstalled windows using the wimboot method and the install was under 4GB. Office would probably make it around 6GB or so, I haven't checked. And the Office install isn't 3GB as reported by the installer. It rounds up to the nearest gigabyte for safety.
 
sounds interesting (full ver of windows, 10")

but the pricing isnt TOO different. this starts at $500 (with 2gb ram, $600 for 4).
---------------------------------------------pro 3 starts at $700 (with 4gb ram)
 
sounds interesting (full ver of windows, 10")

but the pricing isnt TOO different. this starts at $500 (with 2gb ram, $600 for 4).
---------------------------------------------pro 3 starts at $700 (with 4gb ram)

I think it's too expensive, particularly after adding a $130 keyboard. $499 with the keyboard would've been a good entry point. $630 is quality laptop territory, not entry-level tablet territory.
 
I think it's too expensive, particularly after adding a $130 keyboard. $499 with the keyboard would've been a good entry point. $630 is quality laptop territory, not entry-level tablet territory.

The Surface 3 is many things but it's not an entry-level tablet, even for Windows. The $80 HP Stream 7 is an entry-level tablet.
 
It's a bloody Atom.

For $500.

They were a shitty value proposition at $250.

In the eyes of the average consumer it's competing with an $80 device.

Fine for Office/Mail/Facebook ... but neither of them are doing anything useful in Illustrator or Photoshop.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041522951 said:
Lets see:

Linux:
...
This resulted in everything installed (including all software and drivers) updated with all the latest patches in less than 20 minutes using less than 5GB on the main partition, rebooting only once.



Windows 8:
...
In the end, I have a functioning system (drivers installed, but no software yet) after having worked on it for 7 hours, and god knows how many reboots that uses ~40GB on my main partition.

...
The entire time I was installing windows I was in disbelief how painful the process was compared to Linux.

I can install Ubuntu from USB -> SSD have all my main programs installed as well as the main system updated in about an hour or less. (add about 30 mins for Arch)

Install -> htop/mumble/steam/zsh/cifs+mounts etc.

I can install Windows 8.1 from USB -> have all my main programs installed as well as the main system drivers in about two hours or less.

Install -> winupdates -> mumble/steam/drivers -> reboot etc.

The process is much smoother on Linux, sure, but I can't possibly conceive how it can take you 5+ hours to install Windows. The simplest way of installing Windows 8.1 is to grab the ISO, make a bootable USB using the "Windows 7 USB Download Tool" enter a KMS key during install and once you're in switch and activate keys via slmgr.vbs.

The only thing that pisses me off is no matter what you do if you've got two SSD/HDD installed Windows installer with fuck with grub even if you instruct it not-to or completely leave it alone so I always un-plug the SSD with my *nix installs on it during a fresh install of Windows. Otherwise you have to reboot and dick with a Live session like you mentioned.

*Note: This is using a UEFI-based install for both solutions.
 
It's a bloody Atom.

For $500.

They were a shitty value proposition at $250.

In the eyes of the average consumer it's competing with an $80 device.

Fine for Office/Mail/Facebook ... but neither of them are doing anything useful in Illustrator or Photoshop.

Newer Atom platforms perform much better in both CPU/GPU performance compared to the Atom's of the netbook craze days.

I'm not 100% certain but I would gander that they outperform Core 2's in IPC, at least from a "user-experience" stand point they seem to.
 
It's a bloody Atom.

For $500.

They were a shitty value proposition at $250.

In the eyes of the average consumer it's competing with an $80 device.

Fine for Office/Mail/Facebook ... but neither of them are doing anything useful in Illustrator or Photoshop.

The price difference is stupid, but they're trying to position the Surface 3 as like a premium product. There's a big segment of untapped market potential because there are people who don't want to use an Apple device but want to present themselves as trendy, connected, and upscale in the same way. The Surface is sorta an attempt to fill that niche with an equally impractical, yet expensive device that attempts to look just as elegant and classy. It absolutely will have to compete with inexpensive offerings from other companies, but I think there will still be buyers among the Microsoft crowd that wants to emulate Apple owners.

Also, Atoms run Photoshop just fine and the current generation is pretty capable. Even a really old single core Atoms have no problems with image editing and some lightweight 3D rendering. I use Terragen on one of my netbooks from like the 2009-2011 cheap laptop craze era for scenery rendering and it's completely usable.
 
I like this device very much but, it is beyond my budget at this time. I will continue to use my Surface 2 with battery type cover for what I use it for. Also, I have picked up a used 8 inch Insignia tablet for $40 and a HP Stream 7 for $75 and they work great for what they are.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041522951 said:
Lets see:

Linux:
Last week I recently installed Ubuntu 14.04 on my HTPC for XBMC use.

Installing from my USB stick took maybe 5-10 minutes.

Updating to the latest versions of everything online, took maybe another 10 minutes.

This resulted in everything installed (including all software and drivers) updated with all the latest patches in less than 20 minutes using less than 5GB on the main partition, rebooting only once.



Windows 8:
Last night I decided to do a clean install of Windows 8 on the gaming partition of my Desktop (I dual boot, Linux for most things, Windows for games, and that games partition has been around, well, almost since the launch of Windows 7)

I started as soon as I got home from work (~5pm)

Installed windows 8 (reboot like 4 times)

Went to windows update, to download and install patches (reboot like 3 times) and waiting over an hour for almost 100 patches to install.

Troubleshooting to try to figure out why the hell the upgrade to 8.1 refuses to install.

Finally downloading a 4GB 8.1 recovery disk using "mediacreationtool.exe" in order to force it to upgrade, off of Microsoft's shitty servers at less than 10mbit per second.

Download completes, but for some reason fails to write the recovery files to my USB stick. That's OK, it cached the files it downloaded right? WRONG. Re-run "mediacreationtool.exe" and re-download the 4GB again (this time writing it to an iso, so at least I have the file if something goes wrong)

Wait for mediacreationtool.exe to convert the files into an ISO and burn to disk. (thinking to myself, wow, I haven't been forced to burn an ISO to install something in a very very long time)

Installing said 8.1 upgrade reboot 4 more times

Woot, another 60 or so patches. Way too much time and a few more reboots later, now I can finally get to hunting down, and individually downloading each driver package and installing it.

Giving up and going to bed because it is after midnight, and I have to be up for work in 6 hours.

In the end, I have a functioning system (drivers installed, but no software yet) after having worked on it for 7 hours, and god knows how many reboots that uses ~40GB on my main partition.


Conclusion:
I'm sorry, but I am going to have to disagree with your assertion.

Linux is WAY more efficient than windows.

It uses disk space more efficiently (by an order of magnitude!) it uses RAM more efficiently and it MOST CERTAINLY uses my time more efficiently.

It is by far a sleeker, easier to use system where I don't hae to hunt for drivers and software, as everything I need is right there. Stuff just works. And it just works quickly.

The entire time I was installing windows I was in disbelief how painful the process was compared to Linux.

PEBKAC error for sure. I have never had a Windows 8.1 install take anywhere near that long or take up that much space unless: The hard drive is very small and slow or, I was using the incorrect AC adapter on the laptop and it down clocked the processor.

Sorry but, Windows 8.1 does not take anywhere near 7 hours to install and is not painful in any way, shape or form. The internet amazes me that misinformation can be spread as fact and people believe it.
 
Yeah, that's always annoyed me when browsing on a mobile device.

Admins, if you're reading this, in the admin panel go to the replacement variable manager and create a new replacement variable for the mobile style. In the "Search for Text" field enter "LemonChiffon", then put "black" in the "Replace with Text" field. This will be a big improvement for mobile users which would take all of 20 seconds to implement.

This please, it's impossible to read the text.
 
Also yea installing windows 8.1 is extremely simple, and Linux installs are also very easy. The problem is when you want to do anything else in Linux like get Cisco Packet Tracer working on 14.04, get Dell laptop fans to stop spinning at 100%, install Plex, or any other number of things.

You will ALWAYS have to google the program's repository to get it installed outside of the barren distros storefront. I never could get over this. I use Linux on the side for educational purposes and goddamn can it be aggravating as hell. God forbid you need to make a USB not drive from Linux for Windows and any number of tools availible won't mount the drive having to rely again on the terminal to figure out which drives are what and going through a painful process.
 
Also, Atoms run Photoshop just fine and the current generation is pretty capable. Even a really old single core Atoms have no problems with image editing and some lightweight 3D rendering. I use Terragen on one of my netbooks from like the 2009-2011 cheap laptop craze era for scenery rendering and it's completely usable.

That's not been my experience even on current Atom devices, unless by "image editing" you're talking about poking pixels on a single layer.

A few, standard, non-destructive adjustment layers, an image bigger than that from a cellphone camera (and I'm not talking about the big files off my Leica or Nikon), and the experience becomes frustrating at best.

Though to be fair, RAM is a big factor here too, which is another bane of Atom devices ... they're always low-RAM solutions and even 4GB on a WIMBoot device doing anything that actually requires Photoshop has been a very poor experience.
 
No, an Atom isn't going to run Photoshop all that well, but not a lot of $500 machines are going to either. But they still should run better since a lot of the intentional memory and sata limitations have been removed.

When you consider that a Core M is benching similar to a 2011 1.8ghz i7, It's probably is reasonable to say that a new X7 Atom will probably be on par with the Celerons and I3's you see in the $400-500 price range.
 
An important aspect to the Surface 3 is it's weight and battery life. At about 1 pound 6 ounces it's about only 6 ounces heavier than the iPad Air 2 with battery life that on paper is roughly equivalent though in the real world I'm guessing the iPad Air 2 would probably be a bit better as intensive tasks that can't run on an iPad could drain an x86 faster than a typical battery bench mark. Add the Type Cover and you're looking at still a bit less than two pounds. Add a keyboard and cover stand to an iPad and you're looking at two devices very close in total bulk.

Yes a Surface 3 won't be a go to device for PS but it could easily be a go to device for PS on the go, especially with the pen support. As niche as pens are PS is one app where pens add an a lot for tablet use.

It took a while but I think Microsoft has found its stride and market for the Surface. A portable, lightweight and flexible hybrid that's not a laptop nor a mobile OS tablet. It's something that's both of these things yet really neither. It is it's own thing. Not that there aren't other Windows hybrids that are functionally the same, but the Surface has lots of marketing and is becoming something that identifiable on it's own.

I think that what Microsoft is doing is right on target. Sure cheaper would be better for consumers but for what this device is the pricing I think is pretty much in line with the market. I bought a Bay Trail based Toshiba Encore 2 Write back in January. That device is still around $400 for a 10.1" 1280x800 screen, 2 GB RAM/64 GB storage with the digital pen included. The equivalent Surface 3 would be $550 including the pen. The Encore 2 Write is nice, I like it a lot, but it's all plastic, no stand, no USB 3 and the Surface 3 is faster.
 
Are people really complaining about the performance of a $500 tablet that runs full windows, has pen support, and is fully capable of running basic editing tasks?

If they toss more Ram into the entry level Stream type devices I'll be stoked. I have a Stream 8 in front of me now and that's really the only thing it's missing is a little more ram
 
Are people really complaining about the performance of a $500 tablet that runs full windows, has pen support, and is fully capable of running basic editing tasks?

If they toss more Ram into the entry level Stream type devices I'll be stoked. I have a Stream 8 in front of me now and that's really the only thing it's missing is a little more ram

Not only that, they are complaining about how long it would take to install windows on said $500 tablet, even though its already installed :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top