Another Kickstarter Game Bites The Dust?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
How is it that a studio can get almost five times the backing they originally asked for and still end up like this?

The Stomping Land is supposed to be a "dinosaur survival" game in which players are a human, hunting and scavenging the land. It originally sought $20,000 in funding, but ended up receiving $114,060. This isn't the first time the ambitious project has gone silent, frustrating its backers.
 
Humans were not around when dinosaurs dominated the earth.
If you want to make a successful video game, get your facts straight and do not contribute to the Creationism propaganda.
 
Molyneuxvellian funding practices. They probably knew they needed more money, but didn't ask for it because they didn't think they could get it.
 
Humans were not around when dinosaurs dominated the earth.
If you want to make a successful video game, get your facts straight and do not contribute to the Creationism propaganda.

I didn't know that was a proven fact
 
Humans were not around when dinosaurs dominated the earth.
If you want to make a successful video game, get your facts straight and do not contribute to the Creationism propaganda.

Clearly you never watched the historically accurate documentary called the Flintstones. :D:D
 
Well Kickstarter is not a pre-order system even if many treat it that way, so no surprise these occurrences happen.
 
I am no longer backing Kickstarter or Steam early-access games (except for maybe a few rare nuggets). My problem: I already have about 500 Steam games. I've maybe played about 100 (and barely at that). I don't have time for this and have plenty of other items to keep me occupied.
 
This is part of the problem with Kickstarter. You don't need to have a legitimate business plan with a realistic idea of how you're going to get to your goal with the money you're asking for. You just have to throw an idea out there that gets enough people excited to toss some money your way. Then when you blow through it like some idiot that wins the lottery and suddenly has all this money and and no restraint, well, too bad for the suckers that gave you money to begin with.
 
How is it that a studio can get almost five times the backing they originally asked for and still end up like this?

Just because you have a great concept for a game that attracts investors does not guarantee that you have the business acumen to successfully produce the game. I suspect the majority of these Kickstarter or other crowd-funded projects suffer the same mismanagement. Everyone seems to love the idea of jumping on the venture capital bandwagon, but then never seems willing to grasp the concept of risk of failure. There's probably a reason why most big-time venture capitalists aren't playing in this nickel-and-dime pool.
 
Game should have been called "Furry Balls Plopped Menacingly on the Table".
 
When I thought to myself "Whats worse for the gaming industry than the pre-order craze?", the only thing that comes to mind is Kick-Starter... people literally paying for the IDEA of a game, instead of good ideas being vetted by venture capitalists that actually investigate deeply and get a return on their risk. *facepalm*
 
Humans were not around when dinosaurs dominated the earth.
If you want to make a successful video game, get your facts straight and do not contribute to the Creationism propaganda.

Lol because games have to be historically accurate. Plus you were better off just not posting.
 
This is part of the problem with Kickstarter. You don't need to have a legitimate business plan with a realistic idea of how you're going to get to your goal with the money you're asking for. You just have to throw an idea out there that gets enough people excited to toss some money your way. Then when you blow through it like some idiot that wins the lottery and suddenly has all this money and and no restraint, well, too bad for the suckers that gave you money to begin with.
Or as South Park pointed out, all you really need is a good unique Kickstarter name, and the rest solves itself, while Kickstarter takes a 15% cut for doing absolutely nothing.
 
Humans were not around when dinosaurs dominated the earth.
If you want to make a successful video game, get your facts straight and do not contribute to the Creationism propaganda.

Umm...Jurrasic Park. I mean cmon!

Anyway...where is this kickstarter website. I have some ideas about a game where Aliens and Humans coexist because I am wanting to state some truthiness from life experiences...:D
 
By the way, why not a Flinstones RPG game?
Could be fun (as long as the idiotic Gazoo character is omitted)...
 
I really think people fail to plan. A lot of studios fail for the same reasons, you can say you can build a game for 20K, but if you look at what it costs to live for two to four years and cost of the game engine as it takes roughly six years to build one from scratch which is why major studios costs are upwards of millions of dollars. An indie studio likely can create a small game but costs are higher for them and the turn around slower. The trade off is that if they know what they are doing they don't have the overhead of mass audience and focus on a small subset creating assets and systems to only target those gamers... ie a pvp only game does not have thousands of hours of dialog usually is cheaper than say a bioware title while relaying on the players to create the fun. Trade offs.
 
How is it that a studio can get almost five times the backing they originally asked for and still end up like this?

"A studio", or just some guy who seems to have some vague experience in the gaming industry and clearly was in way over his head from the start?
 
This is part of the problem with Kickstarter. You don't need to have a legitimate business plan with a realistic idea of how you're going to get to your goal with the money you're asking for. You just have to throw an idea out there that gets enough people excited to toss some money your way. Then when you blow through it like some idiot that wins the lottery and suddenly has all this money and and no restraint, well, too bad for the suckers that gave you money to begin with.

1422986584009.gif


In all seriousness though, this really is the key problem with Kickstarter - accountability.
 
How did anyone see a silly and impossibly low 20k goal, think this thing was legit and donated money?

Wasteland 2 balances this turd out. Fucking loved that game. Shadowrunner and FTL deserve honorable mentions.
 
No accountability they don't have to answer to anyone.

I have always held the position that KickStarter is a con man's dream.
Promise the sky an moon, deliver nothing but videos of some work in progress; and disappear with everyones $$$. OH, we have gone bankrupt. :rolleyes:
 
I have always held the position that KickStarter is a con man's dream.
Promise the sky an moon, deliver nothing but videos of some work in progress; and disappear with everyones $$$. OH, we have gone bankrupt. :rolleyes:

Yep, while I'm glad it was able to provide the means for me to play the previous examples of great games I listed, I am never giving a penny to a Kickstarter. I'm still surprised it has taken off like it has.
 
$100,000 is not enough to make a game. I don't care who you are. It just will not turn out unless it is a super simple game. This was not. Indie devs think it is a lot of money, and then they try and run a business and they find out how little it is.
 
I am no longer backing Kickstarter or Steam early-access games (except for maybe a few rare nuggets). My problem: I already have about 500 Steam games. I've maybe played about 100 (and barely at that). I don't have time for this and have plenty of other items to keep me occupied.

There was only 1 I paid for early access and now years later; the game is still a buggy pile of crap. That is StarForge. :mad:

But really I can't point a finger at the developers. Nothing is hidden; they just are not very good or motivated to produce a title that is as promised.

In truth you get the same kind of BS from AAA developers.
Demo a cutting edge game that pushes the the game engine for all it has. Thousands oooh and Ahhh.
Delivered is a buggy game with all high end features stripped so they will run on a console.
Same kind of CRAP.
 
How did anyone see a silly and impossibly low 20k goal, think this thing was legit and donated money?

Exactly. Know who and what you're backing. Don't feel sorry for anyone who got f*cked over on this one.
 
Well they hire 1 or 2 people and 6 months in that 100k is gone. I can't even imagine where this ridiculous 20k number came from.
 
$20k was their original target? That's not just "failure to plan," that's living on another planet.

On planet earth, a 3D game costs at least a few hundred thousand, and that's if you use a free engine, manage to find some usable public domain artwork, and then spend every dollar on modeling and game code. If you do it all in-house, it's at-least a million, and then since you can't afford playtesters the game will be buggy and not have good flow.
 
This is why I only back games that have some experience behind them. Wasteland 2 for example. They laid out their business plan, time line, and the fact the leaders had decades of experience doing what they are doing. Most of the games going up on Kickstarter are "hey I have this idea and some concept art and a few lines of code" but now business plan. The money was spent, poorly. "OMG, we got lots of money, let's buy an airhockey table and carter in food every day!"

Most of the games that make it are not PC / App games, they are physical games - card, board, RPG, etc. The PC / App games that do make it tend to be pretty damn good.
 
I think the kickstarter backers are just as much to blame. You know there is a chance this could happen. Don't invest more than you care to lose. These people starting petitions for refunds are delusional.

I personally don't invest in games until they have a playable alpha / beta that I am happy with. I put money down on Towns and SpaceBase df 9. Both games stopped development before being finished but I still got a crap load of enjoyable game play out of them.
 
Humans were not around when dinosaurs dominated the earth.
If you want to make a successful video game, get your facts straight and do not contribute to the Creationism propaganda.

Clearly you never play Primal Rage you young pup.
 
One of the few things more idiotic than Kickstarter is any online petition.
 
What I find more offensive than kickstarter is steam still selling games like star forge that development has halted on and is nearly unplayable. Rather than dropping the game they allowed the dev to slap a finished sticker on it and continue selling it as a pile of crap.
 
When I thought to myself "Whats worse for the gaming industry than the pre-order craze?", the only thing that comes to mind is Kick-Starter... people literally paying for the IDEA of a game, instead of good ideas being vetted by venture capitalists that actually investigate deeply and get a return on their risk. *facepalm*
It's a spectrum. On one side, you have clown shows like this where this people should have never been funded. On the other side, you have venture capitalists suffocating the project or ruining it with their own ideas of what the game should be (which could be awful), kicking it out the door before it's ready, refusing to touch awesome-yet-niche ideas, etc.

Crowdfunding has really lead to some amazing games that would NEVER have seen the light of day in the modern venture capital environment that have gone on to be wild successes. The thing is venture capitalists don't like risk. That means they're less likely to fund something that isn't likely to be a home run in terms of sales, so it can lead to a stagnation of content. Crowdfunding isn't concerned with how the sales of the game do, just that it gets made. Honestly, it's kind of a democratization of game development, rather than it being in the hands of those with lots of money.

That said, I agree, it would be nice having SOME accountability to prevent fly-by-night or in-over-your-head operations.
 
Small businesses in general fail more than succeed, which is exactly what these projects are. Honestly, the headlines should be saved when one does succeed.

Unfortunately, the success of Kickstarter is built on the ignorance of the majority of their users of the above fact.
 
Humans were not around when dinosaurs dominated the earth.
If you want to make a successful video game, get your facts straight and do not contribute to the Creationism propaganda.

This, and...

How is it that a studio can get almost five times the backing they originally asked for and still end up like this?

Underestimating what it will take to get the job done, poor management, startup biting off more than they can chew, etc. etc...

All of this, and the fact that they got 5 times the budget may have pressed them into scope creep as they felt the need to provide 5x the product.

No project can survive a lot of scope creep.

If a large scale development like the Olympics in London can wind up costing 3x more than expected, it shouldn't be a surprise that a game startup has similar problems.

That and most startups fail. Plain and simple fact.
 
Humans were not around when dinosaurs dominated the earth.
If you want to make a successful video game, get your facts straight and do not contribute to the Creationism propaganda.

Wait, games need to be historically or physically possible? Damnit...guess I'll go play "Cubicle Farm Simulator 2015"...hopefully their "Unemployment Line DLC" comes out soon, though doubt I can afford it.
 
Back
Top