What If Windows 10 Fails?

Why do they need to "back down?" Windows 10 does a great job of making Metro/Modern apps usable on the desktop and eschews the Start Screen on devices where it doesn't make sense. I'd much rather have Modern apps be useful than to have them thrown by the wayside like Silverlight and XNA.

Why did they need to force us to switch at all? I HATE Metro and guarantee you that it won't change - I do use it at work and I can use it OK. But why is it that Microsoft always forces us to change? Vista did allow you to use XP-style start menu but that's the only time they gave us a choice. They switched Office to the still-crappy Ribbon, no choice to turn the menus back on. They switch to the even-crappier Metro, no choice to turn that off. The problem with Microsoft is that they think they know better than their users, rather than thinking they are there to enable their users. It's basically the same thing that Apple does, except that if I wanted to be constrained to what the author of my operating system wants me to do... Apple is actually better. (Overall, though, I don't like either MS OR Apple.
 
Why do they need to "back down?" Windows 10 does a great job of making Metro/Modern apps usable on the desktop and eschews the Start Screen on devices where it doesn't make sense. I'd much rather have Modern apps be useful than to have them thrown by the wayside like Silverlight and XNA.

Problem is that throwing Metro apps in peoples faces by making them default doesn't make them useful, or increase adoption. This was MS's big miscalculation in Windows 8. And feature-stripped web widgets - "phone app" quality - are going to continue to be shunned by desktop users where there are full fledged x86 desktop program counterparts. If I want to run laggy, buggy and sloppily coded phone apps, I'll do it on my phone.

We get it, Microsoft is desperate for an "app store" revolution in the mobile segment, but its not going to come from the desktop user side. Windows 8 proved it, and Windows 10 will continue to prove it.
 
Well to be fair, I was responding specifically about Metro. Do you do most of your day to day tasks on Metro itself? I wasn't trying to imply that the UI change was insurmountable, it's not, there have been an array of workarounds for it. My point why force something less functional on the majority of your userbase, and worse yet, confuse many people who aren't as technically savvy? There are many things you can do on the normal desktop interface that simply aren't possible on Metro. I'm not trying to damn Windows 8 in its entirety, mostly the wisdom of shoving Metro onto people for the Windows 8 launch.

Metro doesn't bring a lot to conventional desktops and laptops. Well there is one thing it can bring to laptops on battery. They can be a lot more battery friendly with viewing video content. Microsoft didn't do it right with 8 RTM setting the defaults for all devices to modern apps. They did change that in 8.1. Microsoft is constantly accused of not listening but many people are still complaining about stuff that Microsoft has not only acknowledged as a problem but have long ago addressed it.

Now on a tablet or hybrid that one uses as a tablet or hybrid, modern apps are critical. When the modern UI may not be the best for keyboards and mice the desktop is likewise the same for touch. The idea of a single device running applications designed for different input methods is problematic but also extremely flexible if you have need of that flexibility.

But in spite all of this, desktop apps still work just like they do on my Surface Pro 3 as they do on my Windows 7 work laptop. That's always the thing that get me. The vast majority of my time in Windows isn't in Windows, it's in apps, desktop or modern depending on the device I'm using. For me this is what I've always want Windows to do. Run whatever app I wanted. Need a tablet app, use it when on a tablet of if that app does something not available on the desktop or web. On desktop, do what I've always done, run a desktop app, Unless I'd rather use a tablet app.
 
Are you seriously running windows 8.1 on less than 512MB ram? because I've personally run 7 on 512 and I'd like to see 8.1 on less.

I've never run 7 nor 8 on anything less than 1 GB. That said on a resource constrained system running modern apps which are designed to run on resource constrained systems would have an advantage over desktop apps in general under those circumstances.

There are a number of low end windows 8.1 Bay Trail tablets with only 1 GB of RAM. I've long been interested in seeing how 7 would compare to 8 on these kinds of devices. I don't think there is any official driver support for 7 on Bay Trail and I've not come across anyone that's tried to install 7 on Bay Trail devices.
 
Now on a tablet or hybrid that one uses as a tablet or hybrid, modern apps are critical.

Critical for what? Nobody uses modern apps.

I have a 10" tablet that gets used for reading, controlling the HTPC, and web browsing. I never use the Start Screen or Modern apps. What do I need a whole separate UI for when 99% of the time I'm only using a web browser and media player?

When the modern UI may not be the best for keyboards and mice the desktop is likewise the same for touch. The idea of a single device running applications designed for different input methods is problematic but also extremely flexible if you have need of that flexibility.
Hardly anyone needs that sort of flexibility. That's part of why Windows 8 is a failure, touchscreens are a gimmick and completely unnecessary on a desktop or laptop. Touch-only devices are mostly used for media viewing and web browsing. Outside of specific niche applications there's little demand for hybrid devices. Microsoft ignored the clear market demand for low-cost media viewing/companion devices that started with netbooks and tried to push $1000 office tablets that nobody really wanted.
 
Microsoft ignored the clear market demand for low-cost media viewing/companion devices that started with netbooks and tried to push $1000 office tablets that nobody really wanted.

This isn't true anymore. Windows tablets and hybrids can be had for $100 to $200 dollars now. As these devices get better, Windows 10 gets out, there will be more and more people that will see a Windows tablet and hybrid and say "Hey for this one modest price I can have both a tablet and a full blown PC." As for those $1000 office tablets you mention, the Surface Pro 3 seems to be doing well in that category.
 
I say nothing will happen cause most people do not care. The cost to move to nix would be too much for most companies, not to mention training and I.T staff.....
 
I say nothing will happen cause most people do not care. The cost to move to nix would be too much for most companies, not to mention training and I.T staff.....

On the desktop? It's not going to happen. But on the back end, there's plenty of stuff that run on *nix. Where I'm at, almost all servers are *nix. Exchange is the biggest exception.
 
This isn't true anymore. Windows tablets and hybrids can be had for $100 to $200 dollars now. As these devices get better, Windows 10 gets out, there will be more and more people that will see a Windows tablet and hybrid and say "Hey for this one modest price I can have both a tablet and a full blown PC." As for those $1000 office tablets you mention, the Surface Pro 3 seems to be doing well in that category.

I think it'll be interesting if synching settings makes the mobile device experience better. I don't know if it will. I haven't even tried a Windows 8 tablet, but it could be interesting. I think what MS should try doing is offering a good high end phone that's unlocked. If necessary, finance it over 24 months. If they can support the same bands as the Sim Free Apple 6 (though even it's missing some), then it'd be interesting. They should probably do the same for a mid tier phone.

Of course I'm assuming WP10 is good.
 
I think it'll be interesting if synching settings makes the mobile device experience better. I don't know if it will. I haven't even tried a Windows 8 tablet, but it could be interesting.

Synching across multiple devices from phones to desktops certainly has advantages. Windows Phone is probably always going to have it tough. Windows tablets I think have a decent future. Windows tablets have made a lot of progress since Windows 8 launched in terms of price, performance and quality. Lack of tablet apps are the biggest issue for them. Windows 10 being free and possibly creating a huge Windows 10 user base quickly night help spur modern app development. It's going to be interesting.
 
Back
Top