The Drone That Hunts Other Drones

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
A drone that hunts other drones? Yikes! And, with a name like "Rapere," I don't even want to know what it does with the other drones once it catches them. :eek:

Fences used to be perfectly fine for keeping prying eyes out of our backyards -- but as drones become more accessible to the consumer, concerns about privacy are on the rise. One new startup wants to fight drone with drone.
 
A 12-gauge pump action is way more versatile. You can take out both the drone and the pilot with it. :D
 
A 12-gauge pump action is way more versatile. You can take out both the drone and the pilot with it. :D

Shotguns have lousy range and cause a lot of collateral damage. You're better off with a rifle.
 
Actually, I had a better idea, 5MW laser. It's not legally considered a weapon and it can melt those rotors from quite a distance.
 
HTML:
Actually, I had a better idea, 5MW laser. It's not legally considered a weapon and it can melt those rotors from quite a distance.

I would like to see a laser stay on target for the couple seconds needed without some uber expensive gyro stabilizers and shake reduction hardware.

Stability issues like a mofo.

Besides:

Utter and completely worthless.

1. If for military use, it's not fast enough, high enough, or dangerous enough to shoot down military drones which can be jet powered.

2. If for civilian use, I'm pretty sure sending down a drone in a public area will result in a lawsuit from where it crashes.

3. How do you determine optimum rope size with all the variants of prop driven drones out there?

This is just an attention grabber.
 
Shotguns have lousy range and cause a lot of collateral damage. You're better off with a rifle.

Size 6 or 8 and a full choke you'd still have 40-60 yard effective range. And if shooting up and out those pellets are basically harmless after 100 yards. Most bird hunters have been peppered before at distance. Shotguns lose power extremely quickly past a certain point unless you're using large shot and magnum rounds.
 
So they say it works but no pics or video just cartoons?

And it will take more than that to drop hex or oct multirotors. Not to mention, if that thing starts flying toward mine, it just is going to be messy and will end up with me getting a new multirotor to add to my collection.

It would look like that scene in chronicles of riddick when the ship hovered over top of his.
 
Actually, I had a better idea, 5MW laser. It's not legally considered a weapon and it can melt those rotors from quite a distance.

Presumably you mean 5mW laser not 5MW laser, because a 5MW laser would DEFINITELY be illegal to discharge in any public setting, that said a 5mW laser is the strength of a laser pointer, it isn't going to melt anything. And if you say up the power so it can... guess what you just delved into that illegal territory again, you're not supposed to use anything more than 5mW in public.


That said, who sees anything good coming out of this? Some angry homeowner who thinks that his fence should extend to infinity and that's good enough justification to destroy a thousand dollars of someone's equipment? Yeah I can see this going off real well.
 
Next up, the drones you see will have police markings. What then? Better nip the attitude, "I'm not doing anything wrong so I don't care if they surveill me", in the bud right now.
 
Funny, because technically this anti-drone drone is breaking the law, because somebody is using something to steal something of yours.

By law, you are not allowed to seize somebody's property via any means of force, be it via hand or via drone.

Legally all you can do if you see a drone violating your property is call the police. Literally, that is all you can do.

I await the lawsuits a plenty this anti-drone drone company will face
 
south-park-s18e05-the-magic-bush_4x3.jpg


Carry on with the serious discussion.
 
I want one, but forget arming it with a piece of rope, I want something that does more than just making it fall from the sky, I want carnage!
 
A foot long, micro-EMP missle will do the job. Doesn't have to score a direct hit, just go off when within radius.
 
The list legal of things I can take a drone out with of the size and type this thing can for far cheaper.

1) Paintball gun - I guarantee even my old 2003 spyder is more than capable of downing most if not all drones.

2) Decent water guns if you are talking about paprazi type drones that are going to be far too close.

3) Anything I can carry with my CCL.

4) Lasers - Lots of them actually. 1W lasers are legal and more than capable and really anything from 100mW on up are not only capable but pretty easily made as well.

This list could go on for a while.
 
The list legal of things I can take a drone out with of the size and type this thing can for far cheaper.

1) Paintball gun - I guarantee even my old 2003 spyder is more than capable of downing most if not all drones.

2) Decent water guns if you are talking about paprazi type drones that are going to be far too close.

3) Anything I can carry with my CCL.

4) Lasers - Lots of them actually. 1W lasers are legal and more than capable and really anything from 100mW on up are not only capable but pretty easily made as well.

This list could go on for a while.

The "things" may be legal, but taking out someone's drone with them may not be. The funny thing about owning property is that I don't think your property rights extend to the airspace above ground. Without proof of the drone doing something illegal, and I don't think a guess is going to fly, you are going to run into trouble fast no matter what you use.

I have an idea, what if you had some very sensitive electronics that could "tap" into what the drone was doing, ie. if the drone is recording video of your home you can see what it's seeing?

Wouldn't that be useful?
 
Presumably you mean 5mW laser not 5MW laser, because a 5MW laser would DEFINITELY be illegal to discharge in any public setting, that said a 5mW laser is the strength of a laser pointer, it isn't going to melt anything. And if you say up the power so it can... guess what you just delved into that illegal territory again, you're not supposed to use anything more than 5mW in public.

There are a lot of illegal lasers on eBay shipped from China.

The FDA's Centers for Devices and Radiological Health (CDRH) has regulatory powers, but they have been very poor at enforcing them. Occasionally they seize large shipments, but it is rare.

It is likely you could get a china laser and pull something like this off, without anyone ever knowing you did it.
 
The Second Variety by Philip K. Dick 1953, turned into the movie Screamers in 1995.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041361740 said:
There are a lot of illegal lasers on eBay shipped from China.

The FDA's Centers for Devices and Radiological Health (CDRH) has regulatory powers, but they have been very poor at enforcing them. Occasionally they seize large shipments, but it is rare.

It is likely you could get a china laser and pull something like this off, without anyone ever knowing you did it.

that is changing quickly

additionally you won't have to worry about the CDRH if you point a laser at a drone, now it's an FAA issue and they don't fuck around
 
So this is how it all begins, this is how skynet started. Terminator the movie is becoming a reality.
 
that is changing quickly

additionally you won't have to worry about the CDRH if you point a laser at a drone, now it's an FAA issue and they don't fuck around

I always wonder about this.

I've heard of idiots getting in trouble for pointing lasers at planes. I always wonder how on earth they found them afterwards. Lasers aren't easily traceable. Maybe someone spotted them doing it, or they were stupid and bragged about it?

Also, small drones for non-commercial use (like the one used by the caricature pimply teenager trying to get nude sunbathing pictures over the fence) aren't governed by the FAA, so would the FAA have jurisdiction in this case?
 
I want one, but forget arming it with a piece of rope, I want something that does more than just making it fall from the sky, I want carnage!

I can imagine the rope is done to not cause property damage. A lot of drones can lose a motor or two and still land safely (automatically when they detect the faults). Some even have parachutes.

You don't want to be buying someone a $50k Red Dragon camera and/or fixing someone's car (or worse) because you caused someone's drone to crash violently.
 
There are a lot of illegal lasers on eBay shipped from China.
Note, there's nothing "illegal" about owning a laser that is stronger than 5mW, hell any of those lasers that can pop balloons are more powerful than that, you just are not allowed to use them in a public setting or as demonstration devices (rock concerns, etc), and trying to "shoot" a drone down definitely qualifies as being used in public. The bit I was talking about 5MW being illegal is because a 5 MEGAwatt laser would be enormously overpowered for anything, it's a billion times more powerful than a 5mW laser, hell that laser they got on a navy destroyer they use to shoot down drones/missiles I think is only 30 kilowatts.


Zarathustra[H];1041361963 said:
I always wonder about this.

I've heard of idiots getting in trouble for pointing lasers at planes. I always wonder how on earth they found them afterwards. Lasers aren't easily traceable.
Depends upon the laser, lasers are not easy to point if you can't see the laser either, so people use the green lasers which allow you see a long light beam in the sky so real easy to aim... however it also trails right back to you as well ;)

I use green lasers for pointing out astronomical objects, it's very handy, I'm just real careful to keep it away from any aircraft. Because yeah I don't want to screw with the FAA.
 
Downing a drone - ON YOUR PROPERTY and below the non-FAA regulated airspace - with a firearm, might cause less trouble than this drone.
1st off, you cannot down it in the public space - much less with a firearm.
2nd even if you did, you might risk injuring somebody if that rogue spins out of control and falls onto someone.
 
Back
Top