Can You Get PTSD From A Virtual Experience?

but you can have triggers compounded by the original disease. It only complicates the matters especially when trying to medicate pts who are all over the place mentally and physically and the fine line between reality and what's not is blurred. Talk about a double whammy.

Really, you see these kids with loss of several limbs and on top of that, they're dealing with mental horrors, not just nightmares, severe night terrors. These things to add up, in memory and practice. They lend themselves to inadequate functions as simple as ADLs. We got so much work to do.

Good discussion.
 
You're right, it's what people are thinking happens right now and we all know things change, a lot. Still, I disagree with the ridiculousness that the brain can't distinguish real from not real at the chemical level. Your current research won't change that. You might know about PTSD but I know enough about my mind. Anyone that "there is no way for brain to differentiate from real or non-real at the chemical level" has issues, at the chemical level, IMO.
You keep talking about psychological differences and I'm explaining to you physiological differences.

I don't understand why you wouldn't want to learn about a complex topic rather than dig your heels in deeper. I gave you the name of a world renown researcher on memory, two links about her and other experts' research on the topic, some of it relating to PTS, and I even explained that PTS is my area expertise and gave you a lay-person nuts and bolts explanation about the problems with our brain's ability to differentiate real from imaginary, true vs. false memory and in response you personally attacked me?
 
You keep talking about psychological differences and I'm explaining to you physiological differences.

I don't understand why you wouldn't want to learn about a complex topic rather than dig your heels in deeper. I gave you the name of a world renown researcher on memory, two links about her and other experts' research on the topic, some of it relating to PTS, and I even explained that PTS is my area expertise and gave you a lay-person nuts and bolts explanation about the problems with our brain's ability to differentiate real from imaginary, true vs. false memory and in response you personally attacked me?

I will stop talking out of my butt and look into it. :)
 
Drone pilots maybe, still would seem fishy.

Video games? hahaha. I worked Guidance and Control for B-52s, I know planes I worked on killed people. Lots of people. I have more right to PTSD than someone getting it from Video Games. That said, if I tried to claim it (and I never would, as I don't have it) I'd expect everyone i served with to give me a bloody nose. This is reserved for guys who've seen some shit.
 
Mope,
part of the problem is that neuro science is still in its infancy. You might see the "same" results in a test between reality and simulation, but the reality is that the test isn't looking at every aspect of the reaction going on in the brain. There are so many co-interactions that the conclusions they are making (and the news is printing) are dishonest at best.
That and psychology is more wild theories by an extremely agenda biased community than actual science. (imo)
 
Yes, it is possible. However I seriously doubt it happens with traditional video games. What I am referring to is the immersive simulations they test when doing psychological experiments. I read about one somewhere. It uses a full room projection and isn't really much of a video game but more of an interactive story. Supposedly it is absolutely terrifying.

If you claim to have PTSD from call of duty you deserved to be kicked in the nuts.
 
Drone pilots maybe, still would seem fishy.

Video games? hahaha. I worked Guidance and Control for B-52s, I know planes I worked on killed people. Lots of people. I have more right to PTSD than someone getting it from Video Games. That said, if I tried to claim it (and I never would, as I don't have it) I'd expect everyone i served with to give me a bloody nose. This is reserved for guys who've seen some shit.

Not true, PTSD is not limited to people who have served in the front lines in war. Granted that is the most common way to get PTSD but people who has survived tramatic experiences such as rape, being trapped in a burning building, a major storm at sea, and things similar to this have developed PTSD.
 
at the chemical level, the brain isn't going to distinguish between virtual or real, tangible and live or on a screen (tv, movie, or view cam)..

Actually the brain does make these distinctions, unless a person has some kind of brain malformation that affects it. If we couldn't do that, we wouldn't be capable of learning through play and simulation.

I've gotta say, as somebody with PTSD already, I've played many games, even scary games, and never felt a real life threat from them.


Now, this all depends on the person, though. If somebody has a brain dysfunction where they have an issue between telling reality from fantasy, they very well might be affected greatly by games.. But that would be a mentally ill person, which means they most likely have many other concerns and issues.. Ones that would probably make getting PTSD from a video game the least of their problems. We're talking the schizophrenia family of disorders here.
 
Drone pilots maybe, still would seem fishy.

Video games? hahaha. I worked Guidance and Control for B-52s, I know planes I worked on killed people. Lots of people. I have more right to PTSD than someone getting it from Video Games. That said, if I tried to claim it (and I never would, as I don't have it) I'd expect everyone i served with to give me a bloody nose. This is reserved for guys who've seen some shit.[/Q]

I'm just going to chalk that comment up to ignorance.
 
Drone pilots maybe, still would seem fishy.

Video games? hahaha. I worked Guidance and Control for B-52s, I know planes I worked on killed people. Lots of people. I have more right to PTSD than someone getting it from Video Games. That said, if I tried to claim it (and I never would, as I don't have it) I'd expect everyone i served with to give me a bloody nose. This is reserved for guys who've seen some shit.

I'm just going to chalk that comment up to ignorance.
 
One of the issues with PTSD that stops so many from seeking the help they need is the feeling that what they experienced isn't as bad as what others have experienced, to the extent that they feel guilty, embarrassed, or unworthy when it comes to the idea of seeking help. No one other than a trained doctor is qualified to diagnose if someone has PTSD. It is a real shame when someone doesn't get the help they need due to stigma perpetuated by people who aren't medically qualified, trying to set limits on who can or can't suffer PTSD.
 
PTSD from video games... this sounds like one of those ridiculous state disability claims you see people making when they want to stay home and screw around all day while the middle class pays their way.

Get a job couch hippies.
 
I've not been in a war but the worst experience I had in my life was when I got burning oil over my hand and had to transplant new skin to it because it was completely burned off. I am now scared of any warm oil. I can tell you that no Call of Duty game could ever come even close to that experience. Video gamed don't give you PTS.
 
Makes me think of the episode of American Dad where Steve flips out from the war reenactment.
 
Yeah dude, I totally have PTSD, cause like I had a bad dream the other night and it really made me sleepy the next morning and I didn't even feel like stopping at Starbucks on the way home cause I was so depressed I bet I need medication.
 
I've not been in a war but the worst experience I had in my life was when I got burning oil over my hand and had to transplant new skin to it because it was completely burned off. I am now scared of any warm oil. I can tell you that no Call of Duty game could ever come even close to that experience. Video gamed don't give you PTS.


I don't think this is quite the approach you should take. While, like before, I said, I hardly think it's probable. There can always be an autistic kid or something that gets truly attached to a game. (It might be possible for a non autistic kid too, but I don't think it's nearly as probable because if they're not autistic or mentally challenged, they probably have other things to do, even if they don't find it as fun)

But, is it likely, I wouldn't think so.
 
Back
Top