Windows 9 Will Offer Desktop Or Start Screen

Real question:

Could you tell me what is it about Windows 8.1 with Startisback, or a start menu replacement of your choice installed (I use ClassicShell because its free and feature filled), that you do not like?

tia

I hate its UI, start menu or not, and I hate it shoving cloud/online integration down my throat.
 
What a bunch of retardation...

If you think Windows 8 or 8.1 beat 7 for getting work done, you're incredibly dense.

If you gave me the opportunity to do a task in less clicks then someone using Windows 7 I would win 100% of the time. This is a load of bull manure.
 
I have an idea.

What if Windows 9 gave users the option of having only Modern UI, only desktop, or both.

::twiddles thumbs::

What do you guys think.
 
Gee, thanks a lot M$

This means next year I won't be able to get a cheap W9 Atom tablet that also includes the desktop.
 
Spotlite (a ModernUI Spotify app), Slacker Radio, and WeatherBug are a few very good ModernUI apps that I use that are windowed using ModernMIX and they act and feel just like regular Win32 programs. I haven't taken the time to really explore the Windows App Store but I'm sure there are more where those few apps I mentioned came from.

WeatherBug, the program with the worst reputation, which everyone hates and is infamously known for being spyware/adware. Nice, I can't wait to install that App. :rolleyes:
 
Fucking idiots.

Let there be both so people can choose which one they want.

I could do a better job running MS at this rate.
 
Well, I won't be upgrading anything to Windows 9 if that is the case. My gaming computer is hooked up to my TV and in that scenario it is far better and easier for me to work with the tiles for running programs than smaller icons. Plus, I like being able to quickly see if I have any new email from the live tile or new subscribed YouTube videos from that live tile. It gives me the best of both worlds and if they force me to choose between the two I'll be sticking with 8.1.

I simply fail to see why they're forcing you to choose. Why the bloody hell don't they give you three options .... Live Tiles, Live Tiles + Desktop, Desktop. Then people can pick what they want on installation and go into control panel to change it later if they want. This whole concept of forcing you to walk down a certain path with a certain type of computer is utterly ridiculous.

Heck, I have a Win8 tablet that I use in Live Tile mode about 95% of the time but then dock it and use it in desktop mode when I want to sit at my desk and do my taxes or pay some bills.
 
MS can do no wrong according to haters. Damned if they do, damned if they don't.

Meanwhile OSX releases 'new' versions with barely any features, and the OS is a pale joke compared to Windows, I used to think it was a decent alternative but after owning my MBP for 3 months I realize how deficient it is.

Windows 8.1 is a great OS and it takes literally 1min to install a start menu replacement if you wish, everything else about the OS is a big upgrade. But the small but vocal haters, including bloggers who are paid by Apple, have poisoned the minds of casual users who are turned away by the constant negativity and never get to use it.

If by deficient you mean lack of variety in viruses and malware then I agree. Other points I have a hard time agreeing to. Care to clarify?
 
A person comfortable with the 8.1 UI using the same desktops as one using Windows 7 will be just a productive.

If they manage to get it working. I've heard reports of Win8 users losing their profiles and settings without explanation for example.

Been hearing many many curses from many new Win8 owners lately :)
 
Well, I won't be upgrading anything to Windows 9 if that is the case. My gaming computer is hooked up to my TV and in that scenario it is far better and easier for me to work with the tiles for running programs than smaller icons. Plus, I like being able to quickly see if I have any new email from the live tile or new subscribed YouTube videos from that live tile. It gives me the best of both worlds and if they force me to choose between the two I'll be sticking with 8.1.

The article says that the new Start menu can be made full screen for users who want the Metro experience on the desktop. Having the Start Screen would be redundant.
 
You're missing out. Windows 8.1 plus Start-Is-Back is way better than W7 for desktop use.

Why? It isn't measurably faster other than boot times (and you could always just sleep/hibernate 7), the 'flat' GUI is ugly compared to Aero glass, and you lose features that are present in 7. Having to pay extra for things like Media Center and a Start Menu is frustrating and dumb. Other than the OS reset/refresh options and Hyper-V on 64-bit 8 Pro I'm hard pressed to find anything that makes 8 a worthwhile upgrade for desktop users.
 
Microsoft is damned if they do and damned if they don't. The tech community has turned into a bunch of crybaby little girls.

This is rubbish. You're not seeing the forest for the trees. Every single person that refutes another person's dislike for things done in Win 8.. are simply being closed minded jerks.

The one thing it boils down to is this: CHOICE!

or to be more specific.... the fact that MS are.... wait for it..... *removing choice*.

With Windows.... its always been a great system because of its ability to let the user chose what they want to do. Want a different Desktop Picture? have at it. Want a radical differnt thign to a desktop picture.. like just a solid color? HAVE AT IT! Want to change how large your menu text is? HAVE AT IT! Want to change the Window Boarder Padding size? HAVE A.... errr well ok you can't do that now in 2014 with Windows 8.1. And nor do you get the choice to NOT use this Touch interface on a none touch environment (one that is the majority of Windows' user base!).

CHOICE PEOPLE!

Also.. just a little addition. Everyone keeps arguing that you can't notice a difference with Win8 once you install an addin to bring back a Start menu. Well thats great. But look at it in a more objective manner. Go back and use Windows 7.. or use it concurrently with Windows 8 and see if its as GOOD AS YOU THINK IT IS. No one is arguing its not a nice little "Side-grade". Who doesn't want faster start-up times and more tweaks to copy-file-dialog? (although nice.. this was a little jab in the ribs at how small of an addition this is.. and how pathetic that it is only getting this kind of tweak now when it should have been standard 8 yrs ago or more).


NB: Don't assume. I have been a Windows 8 user since RP and CP and into 8RTM to 8.1.
 
Universal apps do exist today, how compatible the code is between the Windows Phone and RT largely depends on how the UI needs to be implemented which is something that isn't even 100% with iOS and Android if the developer wants more than a blown up phone app on a tablet. 9 is supposed to further unify Windows RT/Phone into a single whole, so most modern apps should be able to run as-is across tablets, desktops and phones.

Call the Modern UI version Windows RT2 and the desktop version Windows 9 and I would be cool with all of this. If they call the Modern UI version Windows 9 RT I'm going to kill myself. I'm sick as a technician dealing with people who buy things because of piss poor marketing then come to you and ask why their Windows 8 (RT) doesn't run Windows software. I tell them that they should have bought Windows 8, and they get nasty with me. I tell them to buy an Apple and never see me again.
 
Windows 8 is a failure on desktop and a failure on tablets. There is no need to argue about how crappy or not it is. The market has spoken.
 
My 2 points of contention with Windows 8 was the lack of a Start Menu (fix via StartIsBack) and the removal of the configurability that was present in Win7 desktop graphics. I like the 3d effects on windows, buttons and such. I can live with the crappy desktop graphics but if a Start Menu replacement hadn't been available I would have restored my Windows 7 backup to my machine.
 
But...

What does this mean for tablet users (for whom "Modern UI" actually is a better UI) who want to run apps that are desktop-only? (You know, like MS Office.) (snip)

Office 365 will be your poison. It will be the only option for tablets.
 
Why? It isn't measurably faster other than boot times (and you could always just sleep/hibernate 7)
Depends on what you're doing. Many Battlefield 4 players will attest to the game running faster on Windows 8.1 than it does on Windows 7.

the 'flat' GUI is ugly compared to Aero glass
That's a matter of opinion. I personally find the fake-glass effects to be incredibly gaudy and dated-looking.

and you lose features that are present in 7. Having to pay extra for things like Media Center and a Start Menu is frustrating and dumb. Other than the OS reset/refresh options and Hyper-V on 64-bit 8 Pro I'm hard pressed to find anything that makes 8 a worthwhile upgrade for desktop users.
Dunno about you, but Hyper-V is a HELL of a lot more useful than Media Center at this juncture. That seems like an amazingly good trade-off.

Maybe if Media Center were actually kept up to date, but as it stands... it's the same version that shipped with Windows 7. If you're joined at the hip to Windows Media Center for appliance-like Media Center PC purposes, then you're probably not going to bother upgrading anyway.
 
There you have the crux of what is wrong with "Modern UI". It takes the most basic defining concept of the Windows user experience (the ability to run multiple applications, each in their own WINDOW), and throws it out the, er, window.

This.
 
I have noticed something. So far, almost every person defending Windows 8/8.1 has 3rd party software installed to get the most out of it...

Why is it you HAVE to install 3rd Party Software to get Windows 8/8.1 to be livable?

Instead of picking Desktop or Metro, why hasn't Microsoft looked at the 3rd Party software, and copied it? I mean they copied Windows off of Mac OS, IE off of Netscape, Bing off of Google. So, why not copy and paste again?

Here is a thought Microsoft: Have this option in the Control Panel: Select Interface. Then Have it where the USER CHOOSES. The choices would be 1) Desktop Only 2) Mix - like 8 is now 3) Metro Only. Have it available and switchable at any time for the User. I would understand a reboot would be required going from one choice to the other, but it would enable Microsoft to make the majority of its customers happy.
 
I have noticed something. So far, almost every person defending Windows 8/8.1 has 3rd party software installed to get the most out of it...

Why is it you HAVE to install 3rd Party Software to get Windows 8/8.1 to be livable?

Instead of picking Desktop or Metro, why hasn't Microsoft looked at the 3rd Party software, and copied it? I mean they copied Windows off of Mac OS, IE off of Netscape, Bing off of Google. So, why not copy and paste again?

Here is a thought Microsoft: Have this option in the Control Panel: Select Interface. Then Have it where the USER CHOOSES. The choices would be 1) Desktop Only 2) Mix - like 8 is now 3) Metro Only. Have it available and switchable at any time for the User. I would understand a reboot would be required going from one choice to the other, but it would enable Microsoft to make the majority of its customers happy.
Both Microsoft and Apple stole the idea from Xerox PARC, Netscape copied Mosaic, and Google copied Lycos.

;)
 
I have noticed something. So far, almost every person defending Windows 8/8.1 has 3rd party software installed to get the most out of it...

Why is it you HAVE to install 3rd Party Software to get Windows 8/8.1 to be livable?

A lot of people that installed these utilities never bothered to actually learn the default UI in first place. They wanted to technical advantages of Windows 8.x but wanted the same old UI. At this point with 8.1, if you know how to use the UI, a Start Menu doesn't really bring much to the table, it's mostly for the sake of familiarity.

Instead of picking Desktop or Metro, why hasn't Microsoft looked at the 3rd Party software, and copied it? I mean they copied Windows off of Mac OS, IE off of Netscape, Bing off of Google. So, why not copy and paste again?

What's the point of copying 3rd party software that already exists?

Here is a thought Microsoft: Have this option in the Control Panel: Select Interface. Then Have it where the USER CHOOSES. The choices would be 1) Desktop Only 2) Mix - like 8 is now 3) Metro Only. Have it available and switchable at any time for the User. I would understand a reboot would be required going from one choice to the other, but it would enable Microsoft to make the majority of its customers happy.

I think this is where it's going generally. There will more options and ability to configure the UI but I don't think there will be anything as explicit as a "metro off" switch. I don't see that as being necessary if the rumors coming out are true.
 
I have noticed something. So far, almost every person defending Windows 8/8.1 has 3rd party software installed to get the most out of it...

Why is it you HAVE to install 3rd Party Software to get Windows 8/8.1 to be livable?
No 3rd party user-interface software installed here. Doesn't need any to be viable, as far as I'm concerned.

And I say this as someone who works in IT managing servers all day. Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days, as it's needed to run the Remote Server Administration Tools for Windows Server 2012 (R2).
 
And I say this as someone who works in IT managing servers all day. Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days, as it's needed to run the Remote Server Administration Tools for Windows Server 2012 (R2).

"COUGH***BULLSHIT***COUGH"!
 
I hate its UI, start menu or not, and I hate it shoving cloud/online integration down my throat.

The UI, fair enough. I suppose you cant please everyone with a UI since different items are designed and programmed to act in different manners. For me, ClassicShell at least changes the File explorer UI which makes it more than usable.

You can create a local account instead of being forced to use a Online/Cloud Microsoft Account. You can even convert a Microsoft Account to a local account after installation.




I guess I was more easily swayed toward 8 because I got it for free from my University, or more precisely, i paid for it in my tuition. After getting 8, I adapted to it very quickly, and now I enjoy 8 more than ever. I could not see myself going back to 7. I can see how someone would be hesitant to switch if it had a cost of $60-100.
 
Think that might be an additional rub, with 9, if you have to have an online/live/Microsoft account, over a local account. I have read the online account may be mandatory for 9, like it is for Office 2013. If so, that is a major turn off.

And as for the "what's the point of copying 3rd party software?" That is quite simple, this way Microsoft controls it, and can gain revenue from it, just like they have done with IE, Bing, etc. And they have actively copied in the past. It would be a quick (if dirty) way for Microsoft to fix the Metro UI issue, without having to reinvent the wheel...
 
What a mature response from Microsoft go those that demanded a desktop with Windows 8. "Take your stupid desktop, but no 'Metro', er, 'Modern UI' for you. Nyeah!"

You didn't notice that kind of attitude with the xbone release? It was all.. we'll rip out everything good by the roots because you want us to take out the bad stuff. We'll pretend it is impossible to do otherwise and won't you be sorry then.

AT least in this case, I won't be one of the affected, as I don't really like anything about the "modern UI" for desktop. I just want the improvements under the hood.
 
A lot of people that installed these utilities never bothered to actually learn the default UI in first place. They wanted to technical advantages of Windows 8.x but wanted the same old UI. At this point with 8.1, if you know how to use the UI, a Start Menu doesn't really bring much to the table, it's mostly for the sake of familiarity.

You, flat out, have no claim on this. You have no idea how much time people invested to learn the default UI. BTW familiarity is a very good thing in most circumstances. Try being unfamiliar with swimming, and see how unproductive it is when your drowning. I finally get most of your posts. Really, heatlesssun doesn't make sense! How can you have a sun that produces no heat! I ask you ladies and gentlemen, if the logic don't fit, you must acquit! Chewbacca defense. ;)
 
The unfamiliarity of Windows 8's UI to may desktop users is by far the biggest issue with the UI. However unfamiliar isn't the same as unproductive. And when looking at normal productive tasks on the desktop, very little of that time is normally spent in the Start Menu or Start Screen but in desktop apps which have the same UI between 7 and 8.x.

Is it an improvement? No, categorically, the modern UI is not an improvement for desktop productivity. When you fuck with something that's been more or less the same for the past two decades, it better damn well be an improvement. It better be a fucking major improvement, not just look pretty and work well on tablets.

I'm not talking about under the hood. I'm talking about how the user interacts with the OS. Windows 8 and 8.1 are not improvements in desktop productivity. There is no reason for someone to adapt to Microsoft's new version of what the Desktop experience "should be". Even their staunchest proponents (like yourself) use phrases like this:

A person comfortable with the 8.1 UI using the same desktops as one using Windows 7 will be just a productive.

Not only did you admit that productivity remains unchanged from 7. Not only did you have to omit Windows 8.0 as the failure that is. You had to qualify your statement by saying "a person comfortable with the 8.1 UI".
 
And I say this as someone who works in IT managing servers all day. Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days, as it's needed to run the Remote Server Administration Tools for Windows Server 2012 (R2).

Your credibility just keeps falling. This is so unbelievably false.
 
i absolutely HATE the metro interface on Server 2012.....completely not needed in a server environment.
 
Your credibility just keeps falling. This is so unbelievably false.
Your reading comprehension just keeps failing.

Again, what I said there was 100% true. The latest version of RSAT (required to fully manage Server 2012 R2 servers without remoting into them) only works on Windows 8.1.

Go ahead, try installing the latest version of RSAT on Windows 7. Doesn't work.
 
Again, what I said there was 100% true

Might want to rethink that:

Windows 8.1 is pretty much a requirement these days [for people managing servers all day]

Again, you are wrong. Nobody is picking up 8.1 because nobody wants to transition to a new OS and radically different user experience for marginal benefits. If you are in fact an IT manager (which I doubt), you need only to consult your peers at other companies to see how much of a "requirement" 8.1 is in any area of IT.
 
You, flat out, have no claim on this. You have no idea how much time people invested to learn the default UI.

When people go one about not being able to find the Control Panel or only one modern app per screen or still complaining about issues that were resolved from 8.0 to 8.1, it's hard to see where they invested a lot of time.

BTW familiarity is a very good thing in most circumstances. Try being unfamiliar with swimming, and see how unproductive it is when your drowning.

But you have to learn to swim first to become familiar with it.
 
Back
Top