FCC Votes to Require Closed Captioning for Web Clips

You said "all major content providers"; that would include the networks I mentioned. Contrary to what you stated, it appears not "all major content providers" are in compliance.

I love your world where leftover news networks are major content providers. Being totally out-of-touch is adorable.
 
I am simply asking you to defend *your* statement about "all major content providers", because to be honest it doesn't appear to be true.

Netflix currently accounts for roughly 1/3 of internet traffic in North America. Your research into "major content providers" involved declining news outlets whose traffic constitutes a gnat fart in comparison. About what I expect considering, as usual, you appear only to be responding in order to start shit with the same people you always do.
 
I love your world where leftover news networks are major content providers. Being totally out-of-touch is adorable.
It's fine with me if you don't want to classify those networks as "major".

To answer your question:
"What benefits does the mandate provide when all major content providers have already provided captions?"

Since you're not including networks such as Foxnews or CNN in "major content providers", the benefit is that people would get closed captions while watching these networks online.
 
Since you're not including networks such as Foxnews or CNN in "major content providers", the benefit is that people would get closed captions while watching these networks online.

Okay, let's play jimmyb's kiddy game.

*goes to FoxNews.com, plays video*

Oh look, closed captioning.

*goes to CNN.com, plays video*

Oh look, closed captioning.

Now go ahead and tell me what this law is for, genius.
 
*goes to FoxNews.com, plays video*

Oh look, closed captioning.
The video I watched told me no captioning was available after I turned it on. I'm not claiming all videos are missing captions, but it was pretty easy to find them (50% failure rate for me).

*goes to CNN.com, plays video*

Oh look, closed captioning.
The video I watched did not have captioning.

Now go ahead and tell me what this law is for, genius.
To bring closed captioning to some online videos which don't have captioning.
 
The video I watched told me no captioning was available after I turned it on. I'm not claiming all videos are missing captions, but it was pretty easy to find them (50% failure rate for me).

The video I watched did not have captioning.

To bring closed captioning to some online videos which don't have captioning.

So I guess your individual problems with caption features on websites, either because the website is broken or poorly built, or because your browser is having trouble with the features, will be resolved by an FCC ruling?
 
Just to be clear:

You object to the FCC selectively requiring the availability of closed captioning on internet videos which already have the captions prepared, because you think it will lead to 'Censorship and "decency" clauses making their way into the internet.'?

I object to the FCC regulating the internet at all. They have a history of imposing exactly those types of regulations on every other form of communication they have jurisdiction over.

The companies that CC their TV content, but fail to do so on the internet, aren't likely doing it to be malicious or discriminatory. It's much more likely to be a case of ineptitude or laziness. The FCC should send them a formal letter asking them to include it, not pass a new law.
 
I object to the FCC regulating the internet at all. They have a history of imposing exactly those types of regulations on every other form of communication they have jurisdiction over.

The companies that CC their TV content, but fail to do so on the internet, aren't likely doing it to be malicious or discriminatory. It's much more likely to be a case of ineptitude or laziness. The FCC should send them a formal letter asking them to include it, not pass a new law.

But why bother being polite and asking for something when you can just MAKE them do it? Isn't it always a good thing to FORCE people to do what you want them to do? It's always best to give someone NO CHOICE in the matter.
 
But why bother being polite and asking for something when you can just MAKE them do it? Isn't it always a good thing to FORCE people to do what you want them to do? It's always best to give someone NO CHOICE in the matter.

You don't even have to be polite. You can go out publically and say, "HEY! These assholes don't provide closed captioning!" and the public will shame them into doing it.
 
Isn't it always a good thing to FORCE people to do what you want them to do? It's always best to give someone NO CHOICE in the matter.
When it comes to providing accessibility services at minimal cost I agree, it sometimes is better to force people.
 
When it comes to providing accessibility services at minimal cost I agree, it sometimes is better to force people.

Of course you do. Force is always the default option for the primitive mind.
 
FCC does not pass laws. Need a civics lessson?

lol you might want to double check the meaning of law; even legal positivists recognize law as coming from more than just legislative branches.
 
So there is no illegal content? Everything is now legal and no one can touch anything? Not even child pornography, drug trade or human trafficking?
I know it's been a long time, but I just got back to this. I'm not saying there isn't illegal content out there. I'm saying that the rules are implicitly allowing blocking of illegal traffic, and the only way for them to know that is by knowing what each packet holds. Those examples you gave are illegal, but your response ignores the main point I was trying to get across, which is who determines what else is deemed illegal? Do we want the FCC to determine what is legal traffic? With the laws regulating certain kinds of speech being proposed and passed, I worry about the continued ability to exercise free speech, especially on the internet.
 
I know it's not a popular stance on [H] because this is such a bastion of independent Libertarian thinkers, but I applaud this. Both my wife and daughter have moderate to severe hearing loss and Internet video is basically a non-starter for them due to the lack of closed captioning. Don't even get me started on the farce that is YouTube's automatic closed captioning -- or, rather, butchering thereof.

I think this could actually HELP people who use web video for advertising by opening them up to a a new market of consumers. There are approximately 30 million people with bilateral loss that can benefit from this (http://www.nidcd.nih.gov/health/statistics/pages/quick.aspx).
 
Back
Top