FCC Votes to Require Closed Captioning for Web Clips

It was invented without government intervention, made popular by crowdfunded public broadcasting [...]

Are you talking about PBS, "a non-profit corporation created by an act of the United States Congress and funded by the United States federal government to promote public broadcasting"?
 
This implication that we wouldn't have CC without the FCC is a bit absurd.

This isn't at all what I said. But the government was pretty involved in CC. PBS pioneered it in the US and the FCC did set aside the bandwidth for CC based on PBS's tech I believe. If CC is great for TV and it's ok for the FCC to regulate it there, why wouldn't the same rules apply to the same content online?
 
CC is a very popular tool that we have come to rely upon. TV networks would lose all sorts of viewership if they decided to nix support.

It was invented without government intervention, made popular by crowdfunded public broadcasting and for profit network TV stations, became widespread on the most popular streaming websites before regulation and continues to show increased adoption every day.

This implication that we wouldn't have CC without the FCC is a bit absurd.

If what you are saying is true, then all countries should have naturally evolved to have CC on tv shows right? Last I checked this is not nearly the case.
 
I'M SO ANGRY DEAF PEOPLE WILL BE ABLE TO WATCH VIDEOS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
I think you need to reread the post. It was asked "If it's common sense, why is a law required to enforce it?" - the question is *explicitly* predicated on it being claimed as common sense.

Do you understand?

I understand fully, sans condescension. The context for Stiletto's question was that indeed he did not find it to fall under common sense at all. The question itself was rhetorical. If you'd like to ask Stiletto what he meant, I'm sure he would oblige.
 
Are you talking about PBS, "a non-profit corporation created by an act of the United States Congress and funded by the United States federal government to promote public broadcasting"?

A quote lifted from the CPB wiki. No, WGBH put together CC and broadcast in on PBS, much of the funds being privately donated. ABC had a hand in CC adoption as well.
 
I understand fully, sans condescension. The context for Stiletto's question was that indeed he did not find it to fall under common sense at all. The question itself was rhetorical. If you'd like to ask Stiletto what he meant, I'm sure he would oblige.

Qualified questioning (eg. if 'A' then why "B"?) is a pretty common pattern in argumentation. One of the key components to it is that it's irrelevant whether the interrogator believes 'A', only that the person being questioned believes it (or has proposed it as an uncertain possibility) - nonetheless the asker is predicating the question on 'A', and therefore it is not fallacious to provide counterexamples showing 'A' does not imply 'B'.
 
I understand fully, sans condescension. The context for Stiletto's question was that indeed he did not find it to fall under common sense at all. The question itself was rhetorical. If you'd like to ask Stiletto what he meant, I'm sure he would oblige.

Why should the FCC have the authority to require CC on content on TV but not have exactly the same authority to require CC on exactly the same content on the web? That would be considered common sense to many people unless one is arguing that the FCC shouldn't have the authority even on TV content.
 
If what you are saying is true, then all countries should have naturally evolved to have CC on tv shows right? Last I checked this is not nearly the case.

There are quite a few 3rd world nations that do not, this is true.
 
Why should the FCC have the authority to require CC on content on TV but not have exactly the same authority to require CC on exactly the same content on the web? That would be considered common sense to many people unless one is arguing that the FCC shouldn't have the authority even on TV content.

It's not so much the content, but the method of distribution.
 
I'M SO ANGRY DEAF PEOPLE WILL BE ABLE TO WATCH VIDEOS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

That's not the argument being presented by... anyone. The argument is should we allow the FCC, who currently has some shaky net neutrality views, further control over content being posted to the internet?
 
What significant negative effects do you think there will be due to enforcement on internet streaming vs traditional television?

Censorship and "decency" clauses making their way into the internet. The FCC already regularly fails upholding their core goals. Cronyism. Enforcing proprietary standards.
 
It's not so much the content, but the method of distribution.

Finally, I was wondering when this was going to be bought up. Ok, so for the same content, on TV it goes by these rules but on the web it goes by these rules, which I would imagine for many people here means no rules at all on the web. That is a bit counterintuitive in that if CC is good thing for TV and ok to regulate on TV, why wouldn't be on the web? Again, not anything that doesn't have to be done and isn't regulated today.

If the FCC can't even regulate the same players it has for decades now, I don't see how it could have any authority dealing with net neutrality which is a completely new and expansive authority with no real precedent in it's authority.
 
Finally, I was wondering when this was going to be bought up. Ok, so for the same content, on TV it goes by these rules but on the web it goes by these rules, which I would imagine for many people here means no rules at all on the web. That is a bit counterintuitive in that if CC is good thing for TV and ok to regulate on TV, why wouldn't be on the web? Again, not anything that doesn't have to be done and isn't regulated today.

If the FCC can't even regulate the same players it has for decades now, I don't see how it could have any authority dealing with net neutrality which is a completely new and expansive authority with no real precedent in it's authority.

There were several reasons for regulating broadcast television and radio spectrum. With the internet, the reasons are far fewer. The scope of the FCC grows year after year, new laws are passed, yet the control of information is quickly slipping out of their grasp.
 
Censorship and "decency" clauses making their way into the internet. The FCC already regularly fails upholding their core goals. Cronyism. Enforcing proprietary standards.


That's a huge leap. Last time I checked, you don't need an FCC license to run a web site or create an app. There is a middle ground between some regulation and super dictatorial censorship state. If the FCC is going to catch heat for something like this, net neutrality, blocking the sale of Time Warner to Comcast, MUCH more controversial, at least with the powers that be.
 
That's a huge leap. Last time I checked, you don't need an FCC license to run a web site or create an app. There is a middle ground between some regulation and super dictatorial censorship state. If the FCC is going to catch heat for something like this, net neutrality, blocking the sale of Time Warner to Comcast, MUCH more controversial, at least with the powers that be.

Yet look at the state of broadcast and television.

I do agree that anti-competitive practices and net neutrality are larger issues, though.
 
There were several reasons for regulating broadcast television and radio spectrum. With the internet, the reasons are far fewer. The scope of the FCC grows year after year, new laws are passed, yet the control of information is quickly slipping out of their grasp.

Perhaps, but CC is a good reason especially if the content is already being captioned. There's no additional cost added and no censorship, indeed CC is like anti-censorship.
 
Yet look at the state of broadcast and television.

I do agree that anti-competitive practices and net neutrality are larger issues, though.

The bottom line is that virtually everyone wants at least SOME robust government regulation even of the Internet. Be it child pornography, scammers, malware distributors, drug , animal and human trafficking, net neutrality, anti-trust oversight, there's simply no way to make the argument with most people that Internet is self-regulating anymore than anything else known to man.
 
Censorship and "decency" clauses making their way into the internet. The FCC already regularly fails upholding their core goals. Cronyism. Enforcing proprietary standards.

OK so nothing to do with closed captioning.
 
The bottom line is that virtually everyone wants at least SOME robust government regulation even of the Internet. Be it child pornography, scammers, malware distributors, drug , animal and human trafficking, net neutrality, anti-trust oversight, there's simply no way to make the argument with most people that Internet is self-regulating anymore than anything else known to man.

Pretty much all are legal issues, not mandated compliance in a commercial setting where no laws are being broken.
 
No. CC is excellent. I use it myself.

Just to be clear:

You object to the FCC selectively requiring the availability of closed captioning on internet videos which already have the captions prepared, because you think it will lead to 'Censorship and "decency" clauses making their way into the internet.'?
 
Pretty much all are legal issues, not mandated compliance in a commercial setting where no laws are being broken.

The point being even the Internet isn't a blank slate with no laws or desire from average people to want to regulate and litigate. And net neutrality and the pending Comcast/Time Warner merger are potentially HUGE expansions of government power into at least the business of the Internet.

The average American isn't a true conservative nor liberal nor socialist nor laissez-faire capitalist but a pragmatist. Unfortunately pragmatism isn't sexy and rhymes with compromise.
 
For example, a restaurant that is "whites only" totally fine with me, i would never eat there, nor would i associate with anyone who did. How many people do you think would actually eat there? i mean, seriously what would be their reasoning? Good food, great prices? Anyone who ate there would be racist, and they would be ridiculed and shunned by society, the business would fail miserably no government needed. We are far better as a society because of freedom and information, than we are from the government enforcing regulations for people to act or speak a certain way, let alone how to run their business.

I already responded to you on this, but a few points that I don't think get stressed enough when people say this kind of stuff. First of all, how could it be totally fine with you but simultaneously you wouldn't eat there nor associate with anyone who did? And what benefit is would there be in relitigating this issue?

If there is some injustice or undue force that government is enforcing the edict that "All men are created equal" I would love to know that that is. If employment quotas are bad and have no rule of law I agree. Telling people that they can't eat or piss at a public establishment with no rule of law to say otherwise is far, far worse. We've been there, done that, it was a fucking disaster all ways from Sunday. Why in the hell would anyone want to go there again to me is treason.
 
I'M SO ANGRY DEAF PEOPLE WILL BE ABLE TO WATCH VIDEOS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This is a shining example of the ignorance that makes civilized discussion impossible in today's society. Thanks for being the perfect stereotype.
 
Cowardly deflection. Such a lack of surprise that I'm not even going to make a joke about it.

Why should the FCC have the authority to regulate one method of distribution and not another over the same content? If you can't address this issue without personal insult, then obviously you have no reasonable argument.
 
Why should the FCC have the authority to regulate one method of distribution and not another over the same content? If you can't address this issue without personal insult, then obviously you have no reasonable argument.

Still waiting for a reason why the government should pass a law to require captions when all the major content distributors have already made them available. One good reason. Not a "okay, then tell me this...". Just give me a reason. If you're not going to give a reason for something that you and so many others are getting so indignant in favoring, then expect little to no respect.
 
Yeah, just too hard for some people to understand that one can be against the legislation of something without being against the free practice of that something by individuals. Government must tell us to do everything. When the government one day mandates that everyone take a shit at specific scheduled times in order to save water, anyone who questions that will be scoffed at as a rabble-rouser who wants to see the world awashed in torrents of shit spewing from every pipe.

This looks very shortsighted to me. Mandating closed captions on any electronic media presents next to no financial burden on anyone, yet it provides great benefits for small kids (oh yes, yes it does), and people with damaged hearing.
 
This looks very shortsighted to me. Mandating closed captions on any electronic media presents next to no financial burden on anyone, yet it provides great benefits for small kids (oh yes, yes it does), and people with damaged hearing.

What benefits does the mandate provide when all major content providers have already provided captions? Nobody seems to be able to answer this. As Hillary said about something far more important, what difference does it make? Or have laws simply become nothing more than mental masturbation for many people?
 
What benefits does the mandate provide when all major content providers have already provided captions?

Is your premise "all major content providers have already provided captions" true? Do you have any actual data?
 
I just went to abcnews, cnn, nbcnews, foxnews and played the first video that i could click on. All four offered a closed caption button in their video player, but only two actually showed captions when I enabled them; so from my very limited experience, it doesn't seem like your premise is true.
 
Is your premise "all major content providers have already provided captions" true? Do you have any actual data?

Have you used YouTube/Netflix/Hulu/Amazon Instant Video/etc? If not, why are you even discussing the matter? If so, you should know already.
 
I just went to abcnews, cnn, nbcnews, foxnews and played the first video that i could click on. All four offered a closed caption button in their video player, but only two actually showed captions when I enabled them; so from my very limited experience, it doesn't seem like your premise is true.

So from your extremely limited experience in online video captions, upon which you chose to embark expeditiously in the month of July of the year of our Lord Two Thousand and Fourteen, you went to four sites and all of them had caption options, two of which didn't work on your device for reasons you evidently didn't have the fortitude to unlock?

Tell me more.
 
Have you used YouTube/Netflix/Hulu/Amazon Instant Video/etc? If not, why are you even discussing the matter? If so, you should know already.

You said "all major content providers"; that would include the networks I mentioned. Contrary to what you stated, it appears not "all major content providers" are in compliance.

We are discussing it because you premised your argument on something which doesn't appear to be true.
 
So from your extremely limited experience in online video captions,[...]

I am simply asking you to defend *your* statement about "all major content providers", because to be honest it doesn't appear to be true.
 
Back
Top