FCC Votes to Require Closed Captioning for Web Clips

Because there are only pro-equality and anti-equality people, just like every other issue, and you happen to be on the side that isn't evil, right? :rolleyes:

I think you need to go back to school & read up on equality, especially for people with disabilities. As someone with a disability I look forward to full equality.

TLDR: Yep!
 
Wow, there are people AGAINST this? For what exactly? FFS people...
 
In addition to today's vote, the FCC also opened up a second notice of proposed rulemaking that asks for comment on what else the agency can due to help those with disabilities access the Web.
This is how it starts....

Im not a big fan of the government forcing people to do anything, however that does not mean I suport anarchy either.
The problem is enforcement of these heartfelt regulations that supposedly enriches our lives. This is how they overstep, they start with something like this, I mean who is going to be against something the helps the deaf? Seriously, anyone against this will be labeled a hater, but through this they will broaden their authority to control things. That’s how it works.
I say, let the people decide, if a site offers content that caters to the handicapped, then im sure they will receive more traffic from that demographic and probably from others as well, and sites that want more traffic will offer the same. Its like costco, Costco Pulls Dinesh D’Souza’s Book “America” did the government step in and force costco to put the book back on the shelves in the name of the 1st amendment? Nope, but the people sure did. Let the People/Market decide private sector issues, not the government. Now when it comes to things paid by taxes, then yes, regulation is required.
 
What about the deaf AND blind? Are you claiming these people don't exist? Are you such a a-hole that you can't appreciate that we should require a law that puts scrolling braille devices on each and every computer screen? And what about non-English speakers, there are certainly far more of them than deaf people. If you don't agree, the only logical conclusion is that you're racist.

I'm sure that when the deaf and blind people read his smartass comments, they'll be deeply offended. :)
 
As someone with a disability I look forward to full equality.
Equality doesn't have to mean "everyone catering to my special needs" though. If I'm too fat to fit into a standard sized restroom or airplane or movie theater or amusement park or Lotus Elise seat, does everyone need to be forced to accomidate me by law? To me, equality means treating everyone equally, not special treatment for some. Not that I care about closed captioning per se, but just a general commentary.
 
Equality doesn't have to mean "everyone catering to my special needs" though. If I'm too fat to fit into a standard sized restroom or airplane or movie theater or amusement park or Lotus Elise seat, does everyone need to be forced to accomidate me by law? To me, equality means treating everyone equally, not special treatment for some. Not that I care about closed captioning per se, but just a general commentary.

here here..
Equality enforcement should only apply to things paid by taxes, not the private sector.
 
News flash: just because something is a good idea doesn't mean it's a good idea for the government to force people to do it.

But in some cases it is. As a society, shouldn't we want people with disabilities to be as independent and self-sufficient as possible? So that these people can do for themselves without government aid? Isn't this the core value of conservatism? Yes, regulating things like close captioning could be considered government aid. But it's a better trade to create law that helps people help themselves rather than direct financial assistance. Simply ignoring people with disabilities doesn't make them magically disappear nor reduce their needs for things like medical care, education, jobs, transportation, housing, etc.
 
here here..
Equality enforcement should only apply to things paid by taxes, not the private sector.

But when you're talking about those with disabilities, there's often a huge tax payer aspect of their care. I've had a couple of friends in the last few years become paraplegics from accidents. Millions of tax payer dollars are going to be involved in their care assuming that live normal lifespans, with both becoming paralyzed before the age of 40.
 
But in some cases it is. As a society, shouldn't we want people with disabilities to be as independent and self-sufficient as possible? So that these people can do for themselves without government aid? Isn't this the core value of conservatism? Yes, regulating things like close captioning could be considered government aid. But it's a better trade to create law that helps people help themselves rather than direct financial assistance. Simply ignoring people with disabilities doesn't make them magically disappear nor reduce their needs for things like medical care, education, jobs, transportation, housing, etc.

Huh? that has nothing to do with conservatism. The issue here is enforcement.,this enforcement should only apply to things that are tax payer funded, as a society our taxes come from all types of demographics and that is why equality is an issue, but the private sector should not be forced into equality issues.
 
But when you're talking about those with disabilities, there's often a huge tax payer aspect of their care. I've had a couple of friends in the last few years become paraplegics from accidents. Millions of tax payer dollars are going to be involved in their care assuming that live normal lifespans, with both becoming paralyzed before the age of 40.

and what does that have to do with the private sector?
 
The only thing the FCC should be working on right now is resolving Net Neutrality. That should be their sole function at this point. Once that is resolved, then move on to this superfluous bullshit.
 
Huh? that has nothing to do with conservatism. The issue here is enforcement.,this enforcement should only apply to things that are tax payer funded, as a society our taxes come from all types of demographics and that is why equality is an issue, but the private sector should not be forced into equality issues.

The cost of relitigating the Civil Rights Movement would far outweigh any benefits to the private sector. Indeed many conservatives that have made this point about public/private distinction of discrimination laws go out of their way saying that any private sector business that started hanging out "Whites only signs" would go out of business.
 
The only thing the FCC should be working on right now is resolving Net Neutrality. That should be their sole function at this point. Once that is resolved, then move on to this superfluous bullshit.

Net Neutrality is infinitely more complex, invasive and controversial. If everyone is going to balk over this common sense regulation, then there's no hope for net neutrality.
 
The cost of relitigating the Civil Rights Movement would far outweigh any benefits to the private sector. Indeed many conservatives that have made this point about public/private distinction of discrimination laws go out of their way saying that any private sector business that started hanging out "Whites only signs" would go out of business.

They would have, the government does not stop racism, it only silences it. People do not stop being racist because the government tells them its bad, they stop through education. True conservatives pushed for equality in the public sector, not the private. During the Civil rights movement, the main issue was government, not the private sector and it still is.
 
They would have, the government does not stop racism, it only silences it. People do not stop being racist because the government tells them its bad, they stop through education. True conservatives pushed for equality in the public sector, not the private. During the Civil rights movement, the main issue was government, not the private sector and it still is.

People who say this nonsense couldn't have ever grown up knowing people living under Jim Crow. How in the hell does one make any meaningful distinction between private and public sector discrimination? So if I go to the Post Office I can't be discriminated against, But go to a restaurant, gas station, movie theater, oh my private sector job, etc., pretty much where people spend most of their time in public, and that's going to work like a charm?

If "true" conservatives want to fight for this, then by all means go for it. I assure you that the resistance will be overwhelming. There's no way I'd ever deal with what my parents dealt with in shops and restaurants during Jim Crow. Never.
 
It's not always about Jim Crow or discrimination. It's more about the FCC and what jurisdiction they have/should have over the internet.
 
It's not always about Jim Crow or discrimination. It's more about the FCC and what jurisdiction they have/should have over the internet.

What was being discussed went beyond the FCC's regulatory authority. Often when government regulatory authority comes up around here, this idea that government has no authority enforce anti-discriminatory laws against private businesses also comes up. And this completely silly idea that the Civil Right Movement was only about government discrimination. As though blacks living under Jim Crow were only worried about that. Never mind all of the public shops, restaurants and hotels were blacks were treated differently or not allowed to enter. Or the utter hypocrisy that black entertainers in some places were allowed to perform in front of white audiences to make money for someone but may not have been allowed to use the same bathrooms as the white patrons. Just imagine telling someone like LeBron James that he can play basketball in front largely white audiences but wouldn't be welcome to an owners booth.

I've spoken to dozens of blacks that grew up under Jim Crow into their adulthood. Not one ever make the distinction between government and private discrimination. Indeed virtually all of the accounts I've heard were about discriminatory practices in private shops, restaurants, clubs, etc. I have no idea how in the world someone could come up with the notion that the Civil Rights Movement was only about ending discrimination in the public sector, it is a flat out lie. Anyone with two ounces of common sense and a little knowledge of the history can see through that nonsense.
 
People who say this nonsense couldn't have ever grown up knowing people living under Jim Crow. How in the hell does one make any meaningful distinction between private and public sector discrimination? So if I go to the Post Office I can't be discriminated against, But go to a restaurant, gas station, movie theater, oh my private sector job, etc., pretty much where people spend most of their time in public, and that's going to work like a charm?

If "true" conservatives want to fight for this, then by all means go for it. I assure you that the resistance will be overwhelming. There's no way I'd ever deal with what my parents dealt with in shops and restaurants during Jim Crow. Never.

You are missing my point: the private sector self regulates. The public sector needs to be regulated because it does not depend on profit and therefore is supported by tax payers.
Private sector depends solely on profit and that profit comes from a free market that can crush you faster than any law ever written.
As for your post office private business analogy. Private businesses that wish to serve only one race should be able to do so. For example, a restaurant that is "whites only" totally fine with me, i would never eat there, nor would i associate with anyone who did. How many people do you think would actually eat there? i mean, seriously what would be their reasoning? Good food, great prices? Anyone who ate there would be racist, and they would be ridiculed and shunned by society, the business would fail miserably no government needed. We are far better as a society because of freedom and information, than we are from the government enforcing regulations for people to act or speak a certain way, let alone how to run their business.
 
What was being discussed went beyond the FCC's regulatory authority. Often when government regulatory authority comes up around here, this idea that government has no authority enforce anti-discriminatory laws against private businesses also comes up. And this completely silly idea that the Civil Right Movement was only about government discrimination. As though blacks living under Jim Crow were only worried about that. Never mind all of the public shops, restaurants and hotels were blacks were treated differently or not allowed to enter. Or the utter hypocrisy that black entertainers in some places were allowed to perform in front of white audiences to make money for someone but may not have been allowed to use the same bathrooms as the white patrons. Just imagine telling someone like LeBron James that he can play basketball in front largely white audiences but wouldn't be welcome to an owners booth.

I've spoken to dozens of blacks that grew up under Jim Crow into their adulthood. Not one ever make the distinction between government and private discrimination. Indeed virtually all of the accounts I've heard were about discriminatory practices in private shops, restaurants, clubs, etc. I have no idea how in the world someone could come up with the notion that the Civil Rights Movement was only about ending discrimination in the public sector, it is a flat out lie. Anyone with two ounces of common sense and a little knowledge of the history can see through that nonsense.

All I'm saying is you're inflating the scale of the discussion to something no longer considered analogous. I don't see this being about discrimination. While sort of kinda similar in some respects, due to the discussion about regulation, Jim Crow issues were exactly about discrimination.
 
I have no idea how in the world someone could come up with the notion that the Civil Rights Movement was only about ending discrimination in the public sector, it is a flat out lie. Anyone with two ounces of common sense and a little knowledge of the history can see through that nonsense.

never said that. This is what is posted
During the Civil rights movement, the main issue was government, not the private sector and it still is.

Blacks were not equal under the law.
 
All I'm saying is you're inflating the scale of the discussion to something no longer considered analogous. I don't see this being about discrimination. While sort of kinda similar in some respects, due to the discussion about regulation, Jim Crow issues were exactly about discrimination.

Exactly, my whole argument started with regulation leading to an over reach in power by the government. They always start out with good intentions ie, "helping the handicapped", but then they go way overboard or use that as a stepping stone for further regulations.
The private sector is "self regulating" and does not need the government to force them to cater to any demographic, if the market exist, the private sector will accommodate that market. No bureaucracy to get in the way.
 
You are missing my point: the private sector self regulates. The public sector needs to be regulated because it does not depend on profit and therefore is supported by tax payers.
Private sector depends solely on profit and that profit comes from a free market that can crush you faster than any law ever written.
As for your post office private business analogy. Private businesses that wish to serve only one race should be able to do so. For example, a restaurant that is "whites only" totally fine with me, i would never eat there, nor would i associate with anyone who did. How many people do you think would actually eat there? i mean, seriously what would be their reasoning? Good food, great prices? Anyone who ate there would be racist, and they would be ridiculed and shunned by society, the business would fail miserably no government needed. We are far better as a society because of freedom and information, than we are from the government enforcing regulations for people to act or speak a certain way, let alone how to run their business.

The problem with this logic is that neither slavery nor Jim Crow and most overt racial discrimination ended due to the free market. If the free market is such a great corrector of wrongs, let's repeal the 13th Amendment. If no one is going to patronize a business that openly segregates then certainly no one would patronize a place that enslaves at least some of its workforce.
 
The private sector is "self regulating" and does not need the government to force them to cater to any demographic, if the market exist, the private sector will accommodate that market. No bureaucracy to get in the way.

If this were really true we wouldn't have a 13th Amendment or any other number of laws where clearly the private sector failed to regulate itself.
 
The problem with this logic is that neither slavery nor Jim Crow and most overt racial discrimination ended due to the free market. If the free market is such a great corrector of wrongs, let's repeal the 13th Amendment. If no one is going to patronize a business that openly segregates then certainly no one would patronize a place that enslaves at least some of its workforce.

heat: please understand, the free market/private sector has no agenda other than to make money. Its made up of you, me, and everyone else who buys and sells, and we all regulate that market together with our wallets.
Public sector, is run by taxes, but people cannot pick and chose how their tax dollars are spent, and that is why regulation is necessary.
When private sector and government collaborate "crony capitalism" the free market cannot self regulate.
 
Wow, there are people AGAINST this? For what exactly? FFS people...

Yeah, just too hard for some people to understand that one can be against the legislation of something without being against the free practice of that something by individuals. Government must tell us to do everything. When the government one day mandates that everyone take a shit at specific scheduled times in order to save water, anyone who questions that will be scoffed at as a rabble-rouser who wants to see the world awashed in torrents of shit spewing from every pipe.
 
heat: please understand, the free market/private sector has no agenda other than to make money.

For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil.
1 Timothy 6:10 NIV

This is simply the human condition, it care not about politics, religion, education, public or private sector.

Its made up of you, me, and everyone else who buys and sells, and we all regulate that market together with our wallets.

First and foremost, in an world economy that based 2/3rds on consumption, most of us are consumers in the free markets. Any regulatory impact we have on markets is generally driven by out own greed as consumers.

Public sector, is run by taxes, but people cannot pick and chose how their tax dollars are spent, and that is why regulation is necessary.
When private sector and government collaborate "crony capitalism" the free market cannot self regulate.

Just as individuals, most of buy a good number of goods and services from many different providers. Then think of all of the relationships these providers have with their counterparties and so on. It's not nearly as easy to pick and choose where one's money goes in the private sector as you might think.
 
We have laws against murder, theft, rape, etc. Common sense tells us that we shouldn't do these thing yet there are laws against them.

So; murder, theft and rape are analogous with some videos on the internet that may or may not have closed captioning support? If not, that would be a logical fallacy.
 
So; murder, theft and rape are analogous with some videos on the internet that may or may not have closed captioning support? If not, that would be a logical fallacy.

If this is such a problem for some then at least be consistent and just say that the FCC has no authority to regulate closed captioning on TV as well. If the content is already required to be closed captioned on TV, why shouldn't the same content that's already been captioned not be so on the web? Especially as more and more people, including the hearing impaired, are moving away from traditional broadcast and cable TV and getting more content online.
 
We have laws against murder, theft, rape, etc. Common sense tells us that we shouldn't do these thing yet there are laws against them.

Oh, okay. The FCC regulating captions on internet videos is comparable to laws against murder. How many lives have been shattered by the tragedy of captionless videos of cats?
 
If the content is already required to be closed captioned on TV, why shouldn't the same content that's already been captioned not be so on the web?

Youtube, Netflix, Amazon Video, Hulu, etc all already have captions and/or subtitles. If the content is already captioned, tell me why a law is needed to accomplish what has been done without it.
 
I'm just imagining some proud kid coming up to his parents, announcing that he cleaned his room without any prodding.

The parents respond with "Well then, you better clean that room every week from now on, or you'll be in trouble!"
 
Youtube, Netflix, Amazon Video, Hulu, etc all already have captions and/or subtitles. If the content is already captioned, tell me why a law is needed to accomplish what has been done without it.

Then drop the FCC regulations on captioning the same content on TV.
 
So; murder, theft and rape are analogous with some videos on the internet that may or may not have closed captioning support? If not, that would be a logical fallacy.

It's called an argument by counterexample. It was suggested that "common sense" rules do not require laws, but per the counterexamples that's clearly not always true. It's a very common and valid form of argument.

Let me know if that's not clear.
 
Then drop the FCC regulations on captioning the same content on TV.

CC is a very popular tool that we have come to rely upon. TV networks would lose all sorts of viewership if they decided to nix support.

It was invented without government intervention, made popular by crowdfunded public broadcasting and for profit network TV stations, became widespread on the most popular streaming websites before regulation and continues to show increased adoption every day.

This implication that we wouldn't have CC without the FCC is a bit absurd.
 
It's called an argument by counterexample. It was suggested that "common sense" rules do not require laws, but per the counterexamples that's clearly not always true. It's a very common and valid form of argument.

Let me know if that's not clear.

No, it was suggested that it was not common sense at all.
 
No, it was suggested that it was not common sense at all.

I think you need to reread the post. It was asked "If it's common sense, why is a law required to enforce it?" - the question is *explicitly* predicated on it being claimed as common sense.

Do you understand?
 
Back
Top