FCC Votes to Require Closed Captioning for Web Clips

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
The FCC is back at protecting the US populace by imposing additional rules. The federal agency has expanded its 2012 ruling of close captioning videos by requiring closed captions on some Internet video clips also.

It is essential that people with disabilities not only get the same access as the rest of us, but that the access that they get is as timely and therefore as relevant, as what the rest of us get. Access delayed is often the same as access denied.
 
So the FCC is claiming the ability to police an entire multi-national network. Let's see how this works out for them, I know what I would do with a notice from the FCC.
 
Why should I have to cater to someone who chooses to be too lazy to learn to hear?
 
So the FCC is claiming the ability to police an entire multi-national network. Let's see how this works out for them, I know what I would do with a notice from the FCC.

It appears to only apply to news/TV clips posted online that already have captioning.

"Once in place, the rules will require broadcasters, cable, and satellite distributors to caption clips that are played on TV and then posted on a website or mobile app."

Its quite a sensible rule really and shouldn't impact your uploading lolcat videos. :)
 
The three letters are really overstepping their bounds lately. I'm sure the American sheeple will just plod along and continue to allow it.
 
The three letters are really overstepping their bounds lately. I'm sure the American sheeple will just plod along and continue to allow it.

Or have more important things to do in their lives, like feed their families, pay the bills and tuition fees.
 
It appears to only apply to news/TV clips posted online that already have captioning.

"Once in place, the rules will require broadcasters, cable, and satellite distributors to caption clips that are played on TV and then posted on a website or mobile app."

Its quite a sensible rule really and shouldn't impact your uploading lolcat videos. :)

Bingo.

RTFA FTW.
 
Likely a veiled attempt of copyright & entrenched media enforcement by doing something only the big boys could do before it became too onerous.
 
It's a good thing most people here don't struggle to care for a family member with a disability. You know, the last thing [H] needs is comments posted from some actual perspective to the topic at hand.
 
Why should I have to cater to someone who chooses to be too lazy to learn to hear?
What about the deaf AND blind? Are you claiming these people don't exist? Are you such a a-hole that you can't appreciate that we should require a law that puts scrolling braille devices on each and every computer screen? And what about non-English speakers, there are certainly far more of them than deaf people. If you don't agree, the only logical conclusion is that you're racist.
 
Thanks for proving my point.

Yes, that people have real lives and don't have time to crusade on some misguided idealist ethical hipster quest; those aimless, more often than not, silver spoon fed morons masking their true intentions of self-affirmation by attempting to appear to stand on some moral high ground when in fact they change nothing.

Fuck off.

Real people have real responsibilities regarding themselves, their families and loved ones, no one else.

You can shove your nebulous point up your ass.
 
Yes, that people have real lives and don't have time to crusade on some misguided idealist ethical hipster quest; those aimless, more often than not, silver spoon fed morons masking their true intentions of self-affirmation by attempting to appear to stand on some moral high ground when in fact they change nothing.

Fuck off.

Real people have real responsibilities regarding themselves, their families and loved ones, no one else.

You can shove your nebulous point up your ass.

Bravo sir.
 
Good grief. All this does is require close captioning of web and app content that's already required to be closed captioned on TV.
 
Good grief. All this does is require close captioning of web and app content that's already required to be closed captioned on TV.
Yes, but its setting precedent that the FCC can regulate the internet. I don't want my internet regulated.

Besides, doesn't it make you angry that all cars aren't made handicap accessible? I mean, would it really be so difficult for GM to install ramps on Camaros? Why does this have to be left up to individuals and aftermarket solutions regardless of how small a minority they make up of the population, when we could simply force the entire population to comply?
 
Yes, but its setting precedent that the FCC can regulate the internet. I don't want my internet regulated.

So you're against net neutrality? No anti-trust interference when companies like Comcast and Time Warner want to merge? At the end of the day, even the most conservative folks want some regulation, even when it comes to the Internet.
 
So you're against net neutrality? No anti-trust interference when companies like Comcast and Time Warner want to merge? At the end of the day, even the most conservative folks want some regulation, even when it comes to the Internet.
That's not the same thing, although yes that is technically regulation so I should perhaps use better wording. I should say that I want the internet to be as free and open as humanly possible as an anonymous network of people and information. Anti-trust laws and net neutrality accomplish that. Internet censorship, family controls, right-to-forget, thought policing, handicap regulations and so forth that button down the internet, I don't want.
 
That's not the same thing, although yes that is technically regulation so I should perhaps use better wording. I should say that I want the internet to be as free and open as humanly possible as an anonymous network of people and information. Anti-trust laws and net neutrality accomplish that. Internet censorship, family controls, right-to-forget, thought policing, handicap regulations and so forth that button down the internet, I don't want.

Requiring web content to have the same close captioning that's already required for TV in no way impacts wanting "the internet to be as free and open as humanly possible as an anonymous network of people and information." Indeed, having content on the web that's available for the hearing impaired only make the Internet MORE accessible.
 
As long as it stays at that, my concern is that they pass this they now say they have carte blanche to set in place all kinds of other requirements on the internet. X site isn't children friendly, Y site isn't handicap accessible, Z site has "hate speech".
 
As long as it stays at that, my concern is that they pass this they now say they have carte blanche to set in place all kinds of other requirements on the internet. X site isn't children friendly, Y site isn't handicap accessible, Z site has "hate speech".

There's enough porn, uncaptioned video and flat out hate sites, there's tons of those if you look, where there's little to worry about for a long while.
 
That's not the same thing, although yes that is technically regulation so I should perhaps use better wording. I should say that I want the internet to be as free and open as humanly possible as an anonymous network of people and information. Anti-trust laws and net neutrality accomplish that. Internet censorship, family controls, right-to-forget, thought policing, handicap regulations and so forth that button down the internet, I don't want.

Stop, take a step back and think about this one. While I agree with most of your points, this CC deal is basically the same thing that we have with television. Does it place a burden on the media providers to supply closed captioning? Yes. Does that burden negatively affect more people than the closed captioning positively affects? Not even close. And considering the group of people they are trying to help, those that were born with a disability...

Not everything has to be black in white when it comes to these things and your conservative views.
 
Yes, that people have real lives and don't have time to crusade on some misguided idealist ethical hipster quest; those aimless, more often than not, silver spoon fed morons masking their true intentions of self-affirmation by attempting to appear to stand on some moral high ground when in fact they change nothing.

Fuck off.

Real people have real responsibilities regarding themselves, their families and loved ones, no one else.

You can shove your nebulous point up your ass.

Well said.
 
There's enough porn, uncaptioned video and flat out hate sites, there's tons of those if you look, where there's little to worry about for a long while.

Ah, the classic "it won't kick in for a while...you won't even know it's there" line to justify government action.

Sort of like the minor increases in premiums following ObamaCare. Nobody would even notice.
 
Ah, the classic "it won't kick in for a while...you won't even know it's there" line to justify government action.

Sort of like the minor increases in premiums following ObamaCare. Nobody would even notice.

And the classic any regulation of the Internet will lead to widespread censorship. Even a regulation that indeed makes it EASIER for everyone to access the Internet.
 
And the classic any regulation of the Internet will lead to widespread censorship. Even a regulation that indeed makes it EASIER for everyone to access the Internet.

Captioning was already being added to everything WITHOUT the FCC's interference. Amazing how you credit the FCC for something that everyone else is accomplishing without them.
 
Stop, take a step back and think about this one. While I agree with most of your points, this CC deal is basically the same thing that we have with television.
Which is my concern, that they'll feel they have the right to put as much regulation on the internet as they do on broadcast television and landline telephones. IMO, you don't touch the internet.

They can just do a few baby steps as precedent that they have authority to regulate the internet, and then decide that the Communications Act applies to the internet just the same as television/phone/radio. Remember, it was that act that was said to have created "natural monopolies", and hasn't the FCC already decided to tack on a crapton of fees to IP phones (aka internet communication) as well? Thought I read about Vonage users suddenly being charged all those extras that landlines had. And a while back I recall they tried to push through a Decency Act on the internet, which was passed but shot down by the Supreme Court as unconstitutional luckily. Just want them to stay outa my sheet.
 
Why should I have to cater to someone who chooses to be too lazy to learn to hear?

I say they should be executed.... :eek:

From what it sounds like, it's just news broadcasts and such that should already be CC previously on broadcast TV, they just want it displayed on web videos, too. Works for me. A little strong arming it, though. Rather than a recommendation, it's a requirement. Not too fond of those.
 
That's not the same thing, although yes that is technically regulation so I should perhaps use better wording. I should say that I want the internet to be as free and open as humanly possible as an anonymous network of people and information. Anti-trust laws and net neutrality accomplish that. Internet censorship, family controls, right-to-forget, thought policing, handicap regulations and so forth that button down the internet, I don't want.

Go start your own internet of you don't want equality for all. Don't let the door hit your butt on the way out :D
 
If you want the internet to remain as open as it has been, the FCC and any other government should remain hands-off. If you look at the proposed net-neutrality rules, they say that no "legal content" should be blocked, slowed, etc.

Who defines legal content and under which jurisdiction for a world-wide network? Something perfectly legal to say in one country could mean the death penalty in another.

How will they determine if the content you're accessing is legal unless they are doing deep-packet inspection, thereby knowing exactly what data is flowing to whom?

By explicitly protecting "legal content," they are implicitly allowing blocking of illegal content. Again, who determines that? The RIAA or MPAA?

The No Agenda Show analysis is that the big networks are actually pushing for this regulation because they can't compete with cable or the internet due to the FCC regulations against nudity and language.
 
Captioning was already being added to everything WITHOUT the FCC's interference. Amazing how you credit the FCC for something that everyone else is accomplishing without them.

The captioning in question is based on FCC regulations for TV content and this just extended that to the same content via the Internet. Since the content was already captioned for TV, sure, that content is usually closed captioned on the Internet as well. It makes no sense to be against this regulation if you support the close captioning regulations already in place for TV.
 
By explicitly protecting "legal content," they are implicitly allowing blocking of illegal content. Again, who determines that? The RIAA or MPAA?

So there is no illegal content? Everything is now legal and no one can touch anything? Not even child pornography, drug trade or human trafficking?
 
The captioning in question is based on FCC regulations for TV content and this just extended that to the same content via the Internet. Since the content was already captioned for TV, sure, that content is usually closed captioned on the Internet as well. It makes no sense to be against this regulation if you support the close captioning regulations already in place for TV.

News flash: just because something is a good idea doesn't mean it's a good idea for the government to force people to do it.
 
Go start your own internet of you don't want equality for all. Don't let the door hit your butt on the way out :D

Because there are only pro-equality and anti-equality people, just like every other issue, and you happen to be on the side that isn't evil, right? :rolleyes:
 
What's legal and what isn't changes all the time.

Sure details of law change but clearly there are things that are clearly illegal and have been for a long, long time. We talk about Internet regulation usually in first world, white collar terms like content distribution around here. The Internet is used by plenty for much more evil and damaging purposes.
 
Back
Top