LeninGHOLA
Vladimir Hayt
- Joined
- Aug 26, 2009
- Messages
- 18,416
Why would average people make above average money?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Why would average people make above average money?
That was just an example, the actual pay could be variable based on what was needed, there could be a 250k janitor even, but no one making MILLIONS, or if they are, that money goes back into society elsewhere with roads, schools, etc.That system isn't fair either though ... who says all janitors are equal ... a
Well most of society, because that's a selfish attitude that leads to extreme inequality unchecked. You're not doing the work of millions, or billions. You started a company, work hard and successful. You should be paid well if your company is successful and operates ethically. I don't understand why you think you're entitled to millions of dollars unless you really think your value as an individual is worth that of thousands of other people.and who is to say that if I create my own company I am not entitled to millions (or billions) because of that (if my company is successful)
I am in agreement with that, but I also think we need a way to make sure people don't just starve and are homeless (so long as a nation can afford that and isn't impoverished itself).We should do what we can so that everyone who wants a job can have one but job performance needs to affect compensation at some level
In my scenario, I don't see any reason you couldn't work at a different location, nor reasons you couldn't have private enterprise. Say a business brings in 100 million. Fine, that money can be re-invested as a BUSINESS into expansion and resources, but an individual can't be taking home 10 million of that.Know what's wrong with this idea? In order to institute this, the only employer would have to be the government, and then we'd all be slaves. Don't like your boss? They treat you poorly? Tough, if you quit, you have nowhere else to go to make a living. In addition, you have to take what they give you, no matter what job it is.
Man don't look at the AVERAGE income, that will be skewed all to shit. Look at the median household income, which was about 29k in 2010.The AVERAGE household income (this doesn't mean "everyone gets this"...just that this should be the AVERAGE if the income of the country was distributed along a curve) is right about $150k a year.
Man don't look at the AVERAGE income, that will be skewed all to shit. Look at the median household income, which was about 29k in 2010.
People keep abusing this quote with misinterpretations. The man is obviously speaking about society in the abstract and his point is arguably correct. Humanity is capable of providing for everyone, hence "...a time of abundance..." However, human nature is petty, cruel, and generally incapable of the kind of self-sacrifice that would be necessary to forge this theoretical utopia. The Star Trek economy is not an impossibility, but it will not be reality until there is something bigger than our little blue orb for people to concern themselves with.
Either I'm misunderstanding things, or that's not socialism, that's communism. I feel like you're only looking at opposite extremes. I think a middle ground like social democracy would provide the optimal results. So let's take your example of 15k a year for everybody. That would be the communist route. My example would be more like this:
Don't do any work = you don't get ANY money, but government can provide you with basic housing and food. So you don't HAVE to work, but it will be a meager lifestyle if you don't.
You're a janitor = 30k a year
You're a plumber = 50k a year
You're a doctor / structural engineer = 150k a year
You're some other position deemed highly essentially to society = up to 250k a year
Who gets millions or billions of dollars for their work in this system? Fucking no one. There would be a "cap" to maximum income, but there would still be plenty of incentive to work. Now of course this will never happen because the people who DO have millions will never give it up, but if you had sort of a fresh slate, this sort of society isn't
A system like this would allow profit incentive without taking it to the truly unbridled extremes we currently do.
Profit = inefficiency in the system.
A guy who bought a Hawaiian island and sued a city for regulating against his private jet from landing at night talks about plenty for all. Ok...
That's $16,800 per year.
So, by your math, being a janitor instead of a lazabout is only worth $13,200 per year.
Being a plumber, having to deal with all sorts of crap, both literal and figurative, and working 50 hours per week, which is average for a plumber, is worth $33,200 per year.
Do you see where I'm going?
Basically, the lower on the pay scale you get, the more offensive it is to just provide for someone who refuses to work.
There was a point and time everyone lived the same. There was a point and time everyone was farmers/hunters too.
As times changed, and skills became diversified, those who were more clever, efficient, and hard working found means to return more of their work towards themselves.
I believe you mean Larry Elison...
not Larry Page.
I was pulling the numbers out of a hat, they're just as an example. But to answer your point, let's assume that EVERYONE would have access the the public-provided facilities if they WANTED. The idea is that they would be meager enough that most people would want to work to afford something nicer, but they're there to keep people from going homeless who have things harder. I left that detail out, but in the system I'm describing, there would be NO downside to working, you would ALWAYS have more than the person who does not if you chose to work. So that's 30k + free housing option + free food option + free basic services option.OBasically, the lower on the pay scale you get, the more offensive it is to just provide for someone who refuses to work.
level the playing field. In my world, the foreign companies would pay the same level of tax to do business here. And if they have an unfair edge, (ie: cheap labor) then they get additional tax % thrown on to make up for the wage difference. Thus encouraging companies to hire workers back home. That said, everyone would realize that their iPhone would likely be $2000. That is one of the things you would have to accept. Less stuff, but less stratification.
Actually I believe Americans work more than most western developed nations (A lot of Asia still has us beat though). Not trying to undercut your point however, our social mobility is SHIT compared to those same countries. So lazy, not really. Stupid, kind of, yeah.Americans are actually pretty lazy and stupid, just about the same as most other cultures.
FYI: before the conversation goes COMPLETELY off the rails, I'd STRONGLY recommend the GMI concept.
I think you'd be surprised how many of your preconceptions are fully addressed.
Like...well, yeah, all of the above.
Seriously, read up on it. I think you'll see this is a good proposal to VASTLY reduce the cost of our government, while simultaneously improving the quality of life for all Americans.
Actually I believe Americans work more than most western developed nations (A lot of Asia still has us beat though). Not trying to undercut your point however, our social mobility is SHIT compared to those same countries. So lazy, not really. Stupid, kind of, yeah.
FYI: before the conversation goes COMPLETELY off the rails, I'd STRONGLY recommend the GMI concept.
I think you'd be surprised how many of your preconceptions are fully addressed.
Like...well, yeah, all of the above.
Seriously, read up on it. I think you'll see this is a good proposal to VASTLY reduce the cost of our government, while simultaneously improving the quality of life for all Americans.
I'd rather see all those who work have their quality of life improve, while those who don't get shoved to the bottom. That's where they belong. We all suffer from God's curse (Genesis 3:17) for the first sin. They shouldn't get any sort of out for it just because they don't want to work.
I have no problems helping people who have gotten into trouble though no fault of their own, or even those who are having a hard time because of a bad decision. I do help those people. I have no help supporting those who can't support themselves, those who are too old or have disabilities that prevent them from being able to hold a good job. I donate to help those people all the time.
Who I don't like to support are those people who work entry level jobs at age 40 because they haven't bothered to work on their own skills to get better jobs, and strongly proclaim that they want $15/hour for service fast food or working entry level retail. They don't deserve it. Those jobs are supposed to be for teenagers, so they can learn to work while making what their work is worth, and slowly work on their skills to become more and make more. They are like the servant in on of Jesus' parables (Matthew 25:14-30) qho is given one talent to invest and protect, so he buries it rather than investing it despite knowing his master intended him to invest and grow that money. (A talent is a unit of money roughly equal to a year's pay for the average person back then, iirc.) We are all supposed to work and become more than what we're given. Those who sit at one job, complaining about their pay, and never work to get any better are a millstone around society's neck, dragging us all down. They are the reason we have these issues on "income inequality."
Maybe the US should stop having the highest corporate tax rate in the world?
But I do agree with you. US companies should pay taxes based on their percentage of revenue that originates FROM the USA.
As times changed, and skills became diversified, those who were more clever, efficient, and hard working found means to return more of their work towards themselves. After a while wealth becomes self perpetuating as Maslov's heirachy of needs are met and excess wealth is reinvested. This is how the rich get richer.
Meanwhile an entire class of citizens who lack proper training and education are stuck in remedial jobs where they don't even have a chance of prospering. Certain political parties depend upon these poor and point to the big guy and go, "He's the source of your problems" And those same people gain political power that way. Blaming the other guy for your woes has always been a source of great way to obtain power.
I really hate being forced to help those that simply won't.
So a socialist in your world is a dick and the capitalist has his head up his own ass?A socialist says, "No one should live in excess wealth"
A capitalist says, "Everyone should live in excess wealth"
I was pulling the numbers out of a hat, they're just as an example. But to answer your point, let's assume that EVERYONE would have access the the public-provided facilities if they WANTED. The idea is that they would be meager enough that most people would want to work to afford something nicer, but they're there to keep people from going homeless who have things harder. I left that detail out, but in the system I'm describing, there would be NO downside to working, you would ALWAYS have more than the person who does not if you chose to work. So that's 30k + free housing option + free food option + free basic services option.
Have you ever seen what happens to public housing? Most these people who are too lazy to work, are also too lazy to watch their kids, clean their house, or even take out the garbage. Public/free housing ends up trashed after a few years.
Many landlords learn this lesson the hard way after taking section 8 housing. It's only worth it if you place is already a dump.
I disagree this is "the real problem", but simply "a problem". The thing to understand is we're fighting over table scraps. Again, since 2009, 95% of gains have gone to the upper 1%. So if this was 100 pizzas for 100 people, one person would walk off with 95 pizzas, leaving 99 to argue about who is being greediest or not deserving with the the remaining 5.Which is the real problem.
Most people don't have a problem helping people who really need it, but are fed up supporting people who simply won't work or take responsibility for themselves.
I disagree this is "the real problem", but simply "a problem". The thing to understand is we're fighting over table scraps. Again, since 2009, 95% of gains have gone to the upper 1%. So if this was 100 pizzas for 100 people, one person would walk off with 95 pizzas, leaving 99 to argue about who is being greediest or not deserving with the the remaining 5.
So how do you know these things? I'm black, from a middle class black family that grew up in a smallish Southern town. I don't dispute some of what you're saying. Sure there are lazy people in projects that don't work. Laziness is always mentioned around here but I rarely do I see people mention things like employment issues because of criminal records. Gee, who's more qualified, the person with or without a record?
What I always find ironic about all of this is how 150 years ago in this nation, a great war was fought to defend the practice of slavery because blacks were the only ones that had the fortitude to in the hot sun of agrarian South. Not my words, but those of the State of Mississippi when it seceded from the Union: http://sunsite.utk.edu/civil-war/reasons.html#Mississippi.
I don't blame anyone or anything for who and what I am today. Most people regardless of race, gender or religion are their own worst enemy. From wrath to avarice to sloth to pride to lust to envy to gluttony and beyond, the flaws in humans are many. Long ago I learned that often the perp and victim see each other in a mirror. One deals the reality their history and humanity and then decides for themselves. For some the choices are easy and for some they are hard. Unfortunately we've become so polarized that we forget and ignore the simplest thing about being human.
It's not about a person having "too much" so much as a person taking so much to the point where massive amounts of people don't have enough. When many mega-wealthy people are essentially buying government influence and undermining democracy, that's basically oppression, not something I celebrate. So in other words, I don't really care if someone is as rich as an emperor, so long as everyone else doesn't have to worry about being homeless, starving, not being able to get basic medical care, etc. It's extreme wealth at the cost of others to the point of harming them that's the problem. This isn't really an issue of individuals, more the system in place that enables this kind of outcome.That's life ... get over it ... I dislike this whole concept of saying a person has too much ... that is for them to judge ... we should have laws that try to prevent people from accumulating or retaining wealth through criminal means but the whole concept of regulating the maximum wealth a person can accumulate reeks of Communism
Well I agree with you on the equality thing. Some people clearly contribute more to society than others and should be rewarded. My issue is I don't think any one person contributes as much as MILLIONS of people. Even most great inventions would have happened anyway on a different timescale (or happened simultaneously among different people).I also question the concept of all of the wealthy being thieves (which others have proposed) ... you need to have a certain cut throat nature to succeed in business at those levels but that doesn't make you a thief ... and guess what. Michael Dell, Bill Gates, Mark Cuban, Mark Zuckerberg, and other highly successful businessmen are better than most workers (they had a dream, determination, and in some cases luck that allowed them to succeed where most others would have failed) ... I don't believe we should penalize someone for succeeding ... the whole concept of equality also seems like it could lead to the world of "Harrison Bergeron" ... for all its failings, capitalism is still the best system out there (and the fewer constraints we put on it the better)
One of the worse quotes I ever heard was from a certain minority leader during the Rodney King riots out here in LA. When ask why most of the stores in the neighborhood where owned by Asians, he replied that it was unfair to his people that these store owners worked 12 hours a day, 7 days a week. Instead of encouraging his people to work harder, he blamed the people who did work hard.
Updated for accuracy.An honest socialist says, "The select few ruling elite should live in excess wealth while dictating sacrifice for the common good to the masses."
An honest capitalist says, "Everyone can live in excess wealth if they earn it, create it, or inherit it."
Updated for accuracy.
I kind of agree with him. On the one hand, people are free to devote their lives to working. On the other hand, working often does not bring happiness and some people realize that there is more to life than working. Why should one have to dedicate their lives to work to compete in the job force? One should be able to put in a mediocre effort and get back mediocre results, not go out of business because some people out there are working machines. People who put in more should get more but not to the degree that it harms others. People should not be expected to be work machines and they should not have to be to survive.
It's the same thing I was talking about before. What is with these ridiculous expectations many people place on working?
I'm not advocating Communism or Socialism or anything like that but I do think there are some major problems with the way the working world works.
I suggest you study some basic macro economics