Cable TV Boxes Are 2nd Biggest Energy Users

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
We've talked about your cable TV box being a power hog in the past but I don't think most people realize it was this bad.

The seemingly innocuous appliances — all 224 million of them across the nation — together consume as much electricity as produced by four giant nuclear reactors, running around the clock. They have become the biggest single energy user in many homes, apart from air conditioning.
 
It the energy conscious folks want to really make an impact getting things like cable boxes and game consoles to actually power down would do more than changing every light bulb to led. I remember an article that either the XB360 or PS3 used as much energy in standby as a refrigerator.
 
I do not leave my computer on so it has zero standby power. My Xbox one stays on in low power mode and despite claims to the contrary, uses very little power. That is pretty much it. (Whenever I put my air conditioner in the window, that will use a lot more power than anything else I have.)
 
Every cable box I have ever seen is horrible. Most of the reasons for high power usage is because there using incredibly old technology even in there HD boxes. My parents cable box heats up the hole entertainment center even when it's supposedly off.
 
That article is a bit misleading and very unscientific. I wont deny that most people leave their cable boxes on, and Im sure they use a ton of power. But, "... as much electricity as produced by four giant nuclear reactors" is no where near an even remotely useful measurement. And I seriously doubt it is using 500W, on or otherwise, if that were the case my power bill would be a lot higher than it is. Nevertheless, out of curiosity I will test this when I get home today to be sure.

Fortunately, the cable comes free with the apartment otherwise I wouldn't be paying for the damn thing to begin with.
 
The problem with cable boxes is turning them "off" really does nothing, it basically turns off the LED's and any displays on the front and video out in the back, but all of that uses a fraction of the power that the rest of the device uses. Last cable box I had used ~30W when on and in use and ~30W when off. Reasoning for this is it has to stay on to maintain connection to the cable service. You know when you power cycle your cable box and it takes 5 to 10 minutes to connect before it can actually display something, imagine that every time you turned on your TV. Throw DVRs on top of that which have to be on when they record and on when they play back.

Since this massive electric bill isn't one the cable industry has to shoulder themselves and fixing it would require replacement of all cable boxes and massive overhaul to backend equipment, there's not a lot of market incentive to fix it.
 
I remember an article that either the XB360 or PS3 used as much energy in standby as a refrigerator.

I remember reading an article that said the same thing about PS3. So, I tested it out and it used about 0.3 watts in standby... My conclusion is that the article was probably written by some liberal wacko :D
 
most devices these days do not power off but merely stay in stand by mode, add up all those little devices and your draining a lot of un-needed power.
 
Ever tried to power down a cable box? Those things go apeshit and won't come back online sometimes at all without a call to Comcast, or otherwise can take 10 mins before you see TV again.
 
Don't believe everything you read.

I'm throwing a Kill A Watt meter on my box.
The simplest test is the hand test. If its cold to the touch everywhere and doesn't have a fan, its probably nothing to worry about.

That said, I've had some cable boxes that were little toaster ovens.
 
That article is a bit misleading and very unscientific. I wont deny that most people leave their cable boxes on, and Im sure they use a ton of power. But, "... as much electricity as produced by four giant nuclear reactors" is no where near an even remotely useful measurement. And I seriously doubt it is using 500W, on or otherwise, if that were the case my power bill would be a lot higher than it is. Nevertheless, out of curiosity I will test this when I get home today to be sure.

Fortunately, the cable comes free with the apartment otherwise I wouldn't be paying for the damn thing to begin with.

You need to argue both sides of the coin if you want to win. Some people relate to pure numbers and some need to relate to something they can visualize/hold. If you don't understand that...don't go into anything in which you will be required to convince people of something since you already lost 50% of them.

What is a kW*hr. It was a made unit that really means "joules". What is a joule...how do you relate that to somebody who doesn't work with electronics? But a nuke plant is maybe 1GW per core...4GW. So, the analogy makes since 4000MW/224million boxes = 17.8W. Most people have seen a nuke plant and can understand its size/complexity.

Secondarily, the 500W number was "sourced". Bad on the manufacturer for allowing to get out. If you don't want to get shot, don't give your enemies ammunition.
 
I'm calling BS on this one...surprising, since the article comes from the LA Times...
This is a direct quote from the article:
when she saw a rating on the back for as much as 500 watts — about the same as a washing machine.

A set-top cable box with a digital recorder can consume as much as 35 watts of power

So which is it, 500 watts or 35 watts?

I also didn't see a singe source cited for the power consumption numbers...
 
The main issue is that they "need" to be on constantly. First reason being that they need to be connected to the cable provider and the DVR's always record 1 hour of whichever channel they are on. I could personally do without that feature though. The best we are probably going to get right now is similar to watch DirecTV or Dish(I think?) do, with 1 main DVR and the rest being little devices that just need to connect to it wirelessly.
 
Theres such a long list of reasons to hate comcast, the great thing? You don't have to choose!
 
The problem with cable boxes is turning them "off" really does nothing, it basically turns off the LED's and any displays on the front and video out in the back, but all of that uses a fraction of the power that the rest of the device uses. Last cable box I had used ~30W when on and in use and ~30W when off. Reasoning for this is it has to stay on to maintain connection to the cable service. You know when you power cycle your cable box and it takes 5 to 10 minutes to connect before it can actually display something, imagine that every time you turned on your TV. Throw DVRs on top of that which have to be on when they record and on when they play back.

This.

I don't have a cable box, but I have a HTPC with a cablecard. I really hate the switched video that's now in use, as it requires 2 way communication with the cable companies systems. This usually takes at least 3 minutes and sometimes longer than 6 minutes for the handshake and to switch the channel. Bit of a pain if you turn on the HTPC as you have to wait.

My HTPC only draws around 32 watts when on (even when recording 4 channels), and 1-2 watts when sleeping. I have it set to goto sleep when it's not in use (about 60% of the time), so my average power usage is much less than a cable box. For recording, it wakes up automatically 5 minutes before the show starts which helps with the switched video delay.

Had a couple Replay TV boxes before, but they each used around 40 watts, wiether they where on or off.
Went from around 55KW/month to 7KW/month, plus gained HD recording and double the tuners. That saved me around $60/year just in electrical costs due to the high rates out here in Southern California.
 
Every cable box I have ever seen is horrible. Most of the reasons for high power usage is because there using incredibly old technology even in there HD boxes. My parents cable box heats up the hole entertainment center even when it's supposedly off.

It doesn't help when there's absolutely no need for them. Back of my TV there's a card slot for inserting a cable card into them. But regardless they still charge you a monthly fee for using this feature, if they support it.

They wonder why people are cutting TV services left and right. A HTPC will actually go in low power mode when I want it too, and it doesn't cost me an extra $5 a month for the privileged to use it. Can't say the same for Xbox One or PS4 owners.
 
This article is pretty useless. The typical home's HVAC system consumes an order of magnitude more power than all of the consumer electronic components combined.
 
That article is a bit misleading and very unscientific. I wont deny that most people leave their cable boxes on, and Im sure they use a ton of power. But, "... as much electricity as produced by four giant nuclear reactors" is no where near an even remotely useful measurement. And I seriously doubt it is using 500W, on or otherwise, if that were the case my power bill would be a lot higher than it is. Nevertheless, out of curiosity I will test this when I get home today to be sure.

Fortunately, the cable comes free with the apartment otherwise I wouldn't be paying for the damn thing to begin with.
Yeah, the article is a bit misleading. The chart is better, which shows the average power consumption of a cable box to be about 36 W. There's no way a cable box has a 500 W PSU in it. :eek:
 
This article is pretty useless. The typical home's HVAC system consumes an order of magnitude more power than all of the consumer electronic components combined.
Sure, but the HVAC doesn't run all the time. The cable box does.
 
Don't know why cable boxes are such energy hogs, and if you do unplug it/power it down it takes like 10 minutes to get ready before you can watch TV.

I've heard the stand by "oh it needs to stay on because it's a computer and needs to be able to record shows, and.... " well I can say my first cable box, you could unplug it, and plug it back in and TV was ready to go, then a little while later didn't even fucking need cable boxes because the TV had 99 channels it could cycle through and you just plugged cable into that, then we got "digital cable" which helped prevent leaching off your neighbor, but those cable boxes went on and off without hitch, directv though? even before I got a DVR took fucking forever to boot up.
 
I have a ps3 Fat and it gets pretty hot when on, I guess i need to hook up a killawatt to see but I am pretty sure it uses a good chunk of electricity. As far as the cable boxes having 224 million devices period is going to use a good amount of power. But I think their math is off, so the average nuclear reactor in the us is about 4MW or 4,000,000 Watts so 4 of them is 16,000,000 W, if you divide the 224mill devices by the 16mill watts you get a constant load of 14w for each device. All assuming I am doing the math right.
 
I'm curious how entertainment centers in the 70's for example fair against the components of today. I don't know the numbers but I suspect we were using vastly more power running CRT TV's and receivers with tube power. Now it's LED TV's with solid state components but the trade off is we have a lot more stuff plugged in.

I am always amazed at how much heat comes off my tubed McIntosh audio equipment after 5 seconds of being turned on.
 
I just tested my TV/PVR box and it runs at 23w running/playing and 0.7w in standby.

TV uses 88w and 0.1w in standby or switched off.

Not too bad I guess.
 
But I think their math is off, so the average nuclear reactor in the us is about 4MW or 4,000,000 Watts so 4 of them is 16,000,000 W, if you divide the 224mill devices by the 16mill watts you get a constant load of 14w for each device. All assuming I am doing the math right.

1: You're not doing the math right, You want to divide 16 million by 224 million not the other way around.

2: The article said "giant nuclear reactors", those can be upwards of 2 gigawatts or more, which is in line with the numbers 224M x 35W = 7840 MW which is about 4 giant reactors worth.
 
If it meant a cable box that ran worth a shit, I would gladly use a cable box that gobbled down 500W when on. The things are designed by sadist fucks of the highest order.

NO I DONT WANT MORE DVR SPACE, I WANT IT TO RESPOND IN UNDER 30 SECONDS TO COMMANDS I GIVE IT! FAWK!
 
Oh and all of these "standby devices are killing mother gaia earth!!!" are written by the same people that couldn't ever grasp pre algebra even in college and did a liberal arts major instead cause it didn't require and math or science.
 
Don't believe everything you read.

I'm throwing a Kill A Watt meter on my box.
This. I generally don't give much thought to this since the damn thing doesn't serve it's purpose if it's not on. But, I'm really curious now after reading the post.

However, I feel that no matter what is done to conserve energy, the power companies will balance things out with higher prices.
 
Though I know people love to hate on 3D television, I actually found it to be the only method that forced Comcast to upgrade my cable box to a newer model.

Before: Comcast wanted to give me their standard HD DVR box which was, if I remember right, the Motorola DCX3400. That model is huge and uses about 35 Watts when in operation and not much less when in standby. It produced a fair amount of heat and the DVR only had a 160GB hard drive, which isn't very big if you record much HD content. What it couldn't do, however, was play all of the 3D content Comcast provides. It could do some of it, including all that was available from On Demand, but showed a black screen on some 3D content from one of their regular 3D channels (something like channel 890 in my area)..

I'm sure you won't be surprised, but the online technicians did not know that the DCX 3400 couldn't stream all of their content. If I remember right, this was because the box could only decode MPEG-2 and not MPEG-4 content. Some of the 3D content was in MPEG-4. It took a technician coming to my house, scratching head, calling it in, and then finally realizing that it was a hardware issue on their end. So he went out to his truck and got one of their best boxes but which were apparently in short supply (this was ~2 years ago).

Now: Motorola/Cisco RNG200N can display MPEG-4 3D content and uses only about 17W when at full power. It still doesn't have a true low power mode as it only drops to about 15W when "off", but it made a noticeable difference on my power bill. In addition, it came with a 500GB hard drive which allows me to store a lot more content on the DVR. Not surprisingly, the box also runs much cooler.

The bottom line is that Comcast has a large investment in their older, less power efficient cable boxes and they aren't terribly interested in upgrading customers unless it is to fix a technical problem. By me being something of a pest and forcing them to upgrade my box to show all of their 3D content, it allowed me to get a better box that uses less power. I'm sure there are even more efficient cable boxes out there, but I needed to work with what I could get at the time. Funny thing is I only watch a little bit of 3D content out of curiosity once every 3-6 months (some decent concerts here and there), but it was the pathway to a cable box that uses less power.
 
Correction to my post, my old power hungry box was probably a DCT3400 instead of a DCX3400.
 
So by Comcast's logic, power companies should charge them separately for the power they're consuming in our homes...right? Damn you Comcast, piggybacking on PG&Es infrastructure and expecting them to just upgrade their infrastructure for free to power your energy-hogging devices!
 
I'm calling BS on this one...surprising, since the article comes from the LA Times...
This is a direct quote from the article:


So which is it, 500 watts or 35 watts?

I also didn't see a singe source cited for the power consumption numbers...

They draw around 35 watts. I think the 500W number might come from the fact that some of them had another outlet built into the back of the box. So you would be able to daisy chain power plugs from one box into another if you needed a rack of them somewhere. With a quick google image search I can confirm the 500W rating and the additional outlet seen on a standard box.
 
Wouldn't surprise me if the 500W number was simply the max power rating of the cords or plug if there's a modular power cord.
 
Regardless of what the actual power draw of these devices is, it could probably easily be lower. Non-dvr boxes don't really do much of anything. Worse yet, Charter is STILL using the same GUI that's been around for 10+ years, a bunch of low-res menus that don't scroll quickly. It's 2014, menus and changing channels should be instantaneous.
 
Regardless of what the actual power draw of these devices is, it could probably easily be lower. Non-dvr boxes don't really do much of anything. Worse yet, Charter is STILL using the same GUI that's been around for 10+ years, a bunch of low-res menus that don't scroll quickly. It's 2014, menus and changing channels should be instantaneous.

Not to mention, why in god's name does it take 20 minutes to download the programming list if you have to power down your cable box? It has to be a central table somewhere that can't be more than a few MB, if even that!

In fact, as Comcast is terrible and I keep getting sound/video sync issues, I've found that even an hour or multiple hours after powering down and back up, I cannot use DVR functionality. There was more processing power in my TI-86. :mad:
 
I have the Comcast X1 DVR. It does not use the old menu but has a far superior UI. (Not as good as a Tivo, but definitely getting close.)

The real issue is that these things run on RG-6 coax and then are expected to be split downstream in your hose for MOCA connections to smaller devices.

Tivo handles all of this with Cat-5 connections to the MOCA adapter and draw far less power because of it.

Its time for cable to dump coax after the demarcation point. Coax is fine to get the signal to your house but once inside the house you need to be using green Ethernet.

2.png
 
Really cant they redesign the boxes with a quad core arm cpu, 2 gigs of ram and flash memory with a modern and fast interface?
They could run cooler faster and more efficient.
I'm honestly sick of both of my Time Warner boxes taking over 5 minutes each to boot.
 
Back
Top