Microsoft Speeding Up Windows Release Cycle

i hope Microsoft don't come back in their word and remove the desktop for good from windows 9-10... having a new windows version once a year is a good and bad thing imo. good, we'll have faster updates and new ideas implemented fast. bad, Microsoft might stop offering good ideas and turn into a dictator kind of company, people might just stop liking windows.
 
Their track record on this is very much like the Star Trek movie franchise, where every other movie tends to not be particularly great, with the notable exception of the JJ Abrams reboots - the debate is still open about them.

The verdict on Windows 8.x is still out as well. Obviously there's the old cliché of first impressions being lasting impressions and it's just hard to overcome a bad wrap. But Windows 8.x at the end is going to be a significantly different beast than 8.0 RTM. The history of Windows 8 will be divided but if the Start Menu returns and 8.x can function well as a familiar Windows desktop with keyboard and mouse and also has the ability to work well with touch on a tablet, then it will work out in the end. That's a hell of a lot of functionality in a single OS that can run on the same level of hardware as iOS and Android.
 
Are end users that much smarter in England? I do not see this working out particularly well in the US. Our user base here seems to primarily consist of the lower rung of the technically capable ladder. In my experience, anyway...

I think it is primarily a matter of budgeting and projections. I have recommended the subscription service to companies where they will have a number of temporary staff for a fixed time frame and for other companies that do not want to shell out $3 - 400 every couple years for professional versions of Office. If a company intends to utilize a software suite for a 5 year plus timeline, I think they are probably better off just buying the software outright as the annualized cost should be less than the comparable subscription.

Most of the places that I have worked with purchase their operating systems on the PC from an OEM, run the hardware for a 5 - 10 year period, then replace it when something as calamitous as the Windows XP demise happens. There is an argument to be made that they should invest a smaller amount annually on their IT needs rather than a larger lump-sum every half-decade or decade, but that kind of forward thinking seems to have been left out of the modern business school curriculum.

Well in the locations I've moved over to subscription it has worked smoothly. A lot of small firms are taking on staff now. Five years ago it was two guys in a spare room, now they have premises and need more resource.

For them its so much easier (once I've shown them how) to setup subscription plans and add users as they come along. Buy in a new PC, register a new user and download the software. I think most people can handle that.

The benefit is they are always on the same platform, don't have to worry about digging out that 2007 licence key when the old PC fails only to find its a Dell OEM copy that wont go on the new HP etc, etc. Again most of my customers just run standard software they range from financial consultants, plumbers, journalists, design firms, heating specialists etc. etc.

They can buy in new PCs as they want and the core application software all stays current. No one likes paying $500 for what was a £200 copy of Office 2010 6 months after 2013 came out

A customers IT infrastructure is only as complicated as the IT guy wants to make it. I like it simple and easy that way I'm not fighting fires all the time. The customer likes that too and is willing to pay for that. Give the customer what they NEED, show them how to best use it and the noise goes away. Also as I mentioned the customer has to be aware that whilst IT might be a new angle in their business, most are paralyzed without it so it has to have the same spending priority and decision as fleet, personnel, premises etc. It can't just be handled on a afterthought piecemeal basis.

I've seen companies give more thought to the brand of coffee in the vending machines than their CRM system or customer booking system.
 
Never been a fan of Linux on the desktop, but MS seems intent on self destructing. My next work laptop will probably be a Mac.
 
wtf people are complaining about software updates? Assuming these updates deliver features and keep the operating system more up to date in a more rapidly changing environment (keeping up with the androids and apples) I fail to see a problem. With a quicker release schedule these wont likely be complete system rebuilds, just part of your normal patching workflow... I like not working on an obsolete piece of software for years just because no one wants to bother installing an update...
 
Well in the locations I've moved over to subscription it has worked smoothly. A lot of small firms are taking on staff now. Five years ago it was two guys in a spare room, now they have premises and need more resource.

For them its so much easier (once I've shown them how) to setup subscription plans and add users as they come along. Buy in a new PC, register a new user and download the software. I think most people can handle that.

The benefit is they are always on the same platform, don't have to worry about digging out that 2007 licence key when the old PC fails only to find its a Dell OEM copy that wont go on the new HP etc, etc. Again most of my customers just run standard software they range from financial consultants, plumbers, journalists, design firms, heating specialists etc. etc.

They can buy in new PCs as they want and the core application software all stays current. No one likes paying $500 for what was a £200 copy of Office 2010 6 months after 2013 came out

A customers IT infrastructure is only as complicated as the IT guy wants to make it. I like it simple and easy that way I'm not fighting fires all the time. The customer likes that too and is willing to pay for that. Give the customer what they NEED, show them how to best use it and the noise goes away. Also as I mentioned the customer has to be aware that whilst IT might be a new angle in their business, most are paralyzed without it so it has to have the same spending priority and decision as fleet, personnel, premises etc. It can't just be handled on a afterthought piecemeal basis.

I've seen companies give more thought to the brand of coffee in the vending machines than their CRM system or customer booking system.

All good points. I suspect a lot of it is just the market conditions each of us work in that makes the experience so different. People here are happy to dump monthly subscription fees for cable for a TV in the lobby, but mention the idea of Exchange or Google Apps Mail out in the cloud for a subscription fee and all of a sudden you're denouncing the gospel or something. The fun, and simultaneously frustrating, part is getting them to that level of understanding where the light comes on and they go,"holy crap, that is actually a great idea and will save a bunch of money."

Office 365 is just the logical extension of Exchange in the cloud. Why waste resources hosting and managing things internally when they can be made accessible so easily via the cloud. Although you do run into the other problem in our market here: reliable high speed Internet service availability is laughable at best. And yes, I know that depending on the Office 365 subscription, you can have the offline apps as well, or at least you used to when I was working with it a lot...
 
How about they fix what's broken in the last release first, asshats...
 
Well in the locations I've moved over to subscription it has worked smoothly. A lot of small firms are taking on staff now. Five years ago it was two guys in a spare room, now they have premises and need more resource.

For them its so much easier (once I've shown them how) to setup subscription plans and add users as they come along. Buy in a new PC, register a new user and download the software. I think most people can handle that.

No reason you have to have subscription service over license. You could have all of the same features without renting software. The way it should be is buy a new PC, Click the apps you normally run(or have a default option preselected) and the PC should be ready to go.(after require download time) This is where Microsoft should be focusing on making a backend which can handle these small business situations. Instead they rather raise prices via subscription model as most people do not consider the true cost of monthly/annual payments.

Basically they should be running an amazing online store to get a cut of other developers work...while cutting out software stores. This and selling media to consumers.
 
But Windows 8.x at the end is going to be a significantly different beast than 8.0 RTM

how many revisions did it take to get to this point...even Vista improved dramatically in a shorter period of time...Windows 98 SE as well...Windows 8 will end up as a missed opportunity and the OS that MS had to make significant concessions to before gaining acceptance
 
how many revisions did it take to get to this point...even Vista improved dramatically in a shorter period of time...Windows 98 SE as well...Windows 8 will end up as a missed opportunity and the OS that MS had to make significant concessions to before gaining acceptance

A lot of the issues with Vista were related to 3rd party drivers and app compatibly, more so I believe than 8.x.8.x has been a very large effort, lots of optimizations, a whole new design language, API and Store and the last three items were not in Vista all. Of course things needed to go faster and I think that's the point here with a more rapid and iterative release schedule.
 
If you consider not having a Start Menu as something that's broken, then his is exactly what there are doing here.

Yes, I would consider that 'broken,' given that it was intended to be used on more than just touch hardware. It's shouldn't have taken so long to fix that.

A lot of the issues with Vista were related to 3rd party drivers and app compatibly, more so I believe than 8.x.8.x has been a very large effort, lots of optimizations, a whole new design language, API and Store and the last three items were not in Vista all. Of course things needed to go faster and I think that's the point here with a more rapid and iterative release schedule.

The majority of the complaints about 8 were UI related. It wasn't a complicated under-the-hood issue, it was the team at Microsoft refusing to listen to customer feedback. The issues with the API and store and such are meaningless if nobody wants to upgrade to 8 in the first place. Microsoft could release an incremental version of Windows every month and it would fail just as badly if they continue to ignore their users. Hopefully the new Windows team understands that.

It's really difficult to comprehend what was going on at Microsoft when 8 was released. This wasn't like New Coke where Coca-Cola had some evidence that people liked the new product that ultimately turned out to be wrong. Microsoft knew the new UI wasn't testing well. It's like they groupthinked themselves off a cliff, losing hundreds of millions of dollars in the process.
 
For standard stuff I can see the arguments for and against but for non-standard (which is everything I support) I don't see it being good. I made a Genmay post about retiring our last hardware VAX last month if that gives you an idea.

Two years ago we had 76,000 employees. All of the stuff we make is tested on custom software most of it running on MS operating systems.
 
Yes, I would consider that 'broken,' given that it was intended to be used on more than just touch hardware. It's shouldn't have taken so long to fix that.



The majority of the complaints about 8 were UI related. It wasn't a complicated under-the-hood issue, it was the team at Microsoft refusing to listen to customer feedback. The issues with the API and store and such are meaningless if nobody wants to upgrade to 8 in the first place. Microsoft could release an incremental version of Windows every month and it would fail just as badly if they continue to ignore their users. Hopefully the new Windows team understands that.

It's really difficult to comprehend what was going on at Microsoft when 8 was released. This wasn't like New Coke where Coca-Cola had some evidence that people liked the new product that ultimately turned out to be wrong. Microsoft knew the new UI wasn't testing well. It's like they groupthinked themselves off a cliff, losing hundreds of millions of dollars in the process.

It was a knee jerk reaction to everything mobile. No matter how much their focus groups, tier one vendors or regular customers told them they had their mind9s) made up. You could tell by the poorly implemented rush job of the original Windows 8 version. Boggles the mind.
 
It's really difficult to comprehend what was going on at Microsoft when 8 was released. This wasn't like New Coke where Coca-Cola had some evidence that people liked the new product that ultimately turned out to be wrong. Microsoft knew the new UI wasn't testing well. It's like they groupthinked themselves off a cliff, losing hundreds of millions of dollars in the process.

It's easy to comprehended what was going on with Windows 8. It was a huge release trying to do totally new stuff and Microsoft figured that the new stuff was more important than the desktop in that release. Sure it should it have been done better but they had to get something out the door for tablets, period. They dominate the desktop. Even the catastrophe that some think 8 is still beats handily all non-Windows desktop competitors. It was a necessary and calculated risk, it's not like Microsoft hasn't had to deal with rough Windows launches before and then fix the problems later. Not ideal, but not nearly the doomsday scenario that many like to proclaim.

Sometimes all's that ends well. x86 8.x with this future update should pretty much be right at home on a desktop or laptop with keyboards and mice as well as being able to run on cheap tablets for which Windows is now free. Yes it should have gone better and faster than it did but the outcome looks like it could be a pretty good one.
 
All good points. I suspect a lot of it is just the market conditions each of us work in that makes the experience so different. People here are happy to dump monthly subscription fees for cable for a TV in the lobby, but mention the idea of Exchange or Google Apps Mail out in the cloud for a subscription fee and all of a sudden you're denouncing the gospel or something. The fun, and simultaneously frustrating, part is getting them to that level of understanding where the light comes on and they go,"holy crap, that is actually a great idea and will save a bunch of money."

Office 365 is just the logical extension of Exchange in the cloud. Why waste resources hosting and managing things internally when they can be made accessible so easily via the cloud. Although you do run into the other problem in our market here: reliable high speed Internet service availability is laughable at best. And yes, I know that depending on the Office 365 subscription, you can have the offline apps as well, or at least you used to when I was working with it a lot...

Oh indeed it differs from business to business. But as the other guy was saying that it just doesnt work across the board is very wrong from my experience. Sure maybe watching every license and buy all the software day one might work out a fraction cheaper...but its a hassle for small firms. The software gets out of sync, license keys get lost (often) the wrong version is purchased etc. etc. It happens due to a lot of firms not having on site IT guys. Guys like me get called in to sort it all out once the situation gets too screwed up. I then sort it all out, make it simpler, more reliable.

Subscription may cost more (or less) over time but it also reduces hassle and thats something most of us will pay more for less of. It's been pretty easy to convince the monthly or annual cost. Plus at the end of the day if you cant afford say $400 a year to pay for software that helps you run your business and make money...then you shouldnt really be in business. A slight increase in cost should not stand in the way of improved efficency and effectiveness for general staff. You'll soon make the cost back if staff can get on with their work. Nothing hits revenue like crappy out of date or wrong IT.

I think a lot of the resistance if from traditional IT guys that see all the hassle and complexity as a way of maintaining their job. "Those guys would be lost without me!"

When in actual fact they are holding the company back by wasting time, adding stress and actually costing or losing money.

Again the company doesnt work for IT guy, the IT guy works for the company.
 
Sounds like Windows 8.1 update 2 will be the last free upgrade to Windows that adds new features.
 
Sounds like Windows 8.1 update 2 will be the last free upgrade to Windows that adds new features.

There may be one more. They may not windowed modern apps in this release and I think they'd like to get that in as it should help spur Windows Store development and make them more popular with keyboard and mouse users.
 
It's easy to comprehended what was going on with Windows 8. It was a huge release trying to do totally new stuff and Microsoft figured that the new stuff was more important than the desktop in that release. Sure it should it have been done better but they had to get something out the door for tablets, period. They dominate the desktop. Even the catastrophe that some think 8 is still beats handily all non-Windows desktop competitors. It was a necessary and calculated risk, it's not like Microsoft hasn't had to deal with rough Windows launches before and then fix the problems later. Not ideal, but not nearly the doomsday scenario that many like to proclaim.

Sometimes all's that ends well. x86 8.x with this future update should pretty much be right at home on a desktop or laptop with keyboards and mice as well as being able to run on cheap tablets for which Windows is now free. Yes it should have gone better and faster than it did but the outcome looks like it could be a pretty good one.

It wouldn't be a windows thread without Heartlesssun defending it. :p

The "get something out the door for tablets" argument doesn't work, especially with all the hybrid OS arguments given that they had to bring out RT at the same time because many of those tablets couldn't run the full Win8 (till bay trail a year later). They rushed out an OS that wasn't ready, to try and grab the tablet market on the back of their desktop customers and told their desktop folks to get with the program you old geezers.

Windows8 beats all the others because of inertia and they own the desktop OS market.
 
Oh indeed it differs from business to business. But as the other guy was saying that it just doesnt work across the board is very wrong from my experience...

I'll buy into subscription software when like Steam (via sales usually), it costs me pennies on the dollar that licensed software does.

If I am one hacked system (see adobe), forgotten payment, stolen credit card/login/database or "the internet is down" incident away from losing access to my work products or using that subscription software then I am at a huge risk versus calling in an IT guy to fix my screwups with licenses every few years. Just like the cloud storage stuff, if you don't control your data, you don't own it and its not secure at all. It may not be secure on your own systems but at least you control it.

I walked into my medical clinic last year for a blood draw, a week before my doc appointment to hear "the internet is down city wide!" from the nurse. They were helpless to confirm my doc's work order and would take my blood based on past tests I'd had but I may have to come back for more tests. That or I could come back later in the day (while fasting) in the hopes they had internet access again.

Next week I got to spend 5 minutes with my doc discussing the upsides and downsides of cloud computing when he started grumbling after I'd mentioned the testing incident. Apparently the system was down all that Friday and "whats the point of spending $40k for computers that don't work". From what I recall, their data host was offline all day.
 
The "get something out the door for tablets" argument doesn't work, especially with all the hybrid OS arguments given that they had to bring out RT at the same time because many of those tablets couldn't run the full Win8 (till bay trail a year later). They rushed out an OS that wasn't ready, to try and grab the tablet market on the back of their desktop customers and told their desktop folks to get with the program you old geezers.

For someone that supposedly is always defending Windows I actually said much of this in the post you quoted. But of course Microsoft was under a lot of pressure to get something out the door for tablets. Not really sure what you mean with many of those tablets couldn't run full Windows 8 until Bay Trail. Intel's Clover Trail, which is another product that was rushed, could although Bay Trail is FAR superior.

Windows8 beats all the others because of inertia and they own the desktop OS market.

Exactly. The days of significant growth in new desktops and laptops is done. Windows dominates a market that has NO NEW GROWTH. Of course inertia at that point becomes a huge factor. If OS X or Linux or other desktop OS were growing significantly, Windows 8 would have been a much different product at launch.
 
You don't own it now, You buy the license to use it...

Argue semantics all you want, the difference is pay once, versus pay forever (subscription).

Why do you think these companies are so eager to move everything to subscription based services in Da Cloud
 
For someone that supposedly is always defending Windows I actually said much of this in the post you quoted. But of course Microsoft was under a lot of pressure to get something out the door for tablets. Not really sure what you mean with many of those tablets couldn't run full Windows 8 until Bay Trail. Intel's Clover Trail, which is another product that was rushed, could although Bay Trail is FAR superior.



Exactly. The days of significant growth in new desktops and laptops is done. Windows dominates a market that has NO NEW GROWTH. Of course inertia at that point becomes a huge factor. If OS X or Linux or other desktop OS were growing significantly, Windows 8 would have been a much different product at launch.

Right, it is two companies, Intel and MS that missed out on the tablet market rushing to jump into the fray, trading on their name and making bad products. How dare people call them out.

Americans/Westerners are too focused on growth. So much so that windows could lose its position. Its this obsession with quarterly profits/stock market nonsense that oftens leads to rushed products that just make things worse. Its a fiat money/keynesian world I guess.
 
I'll buy into subscription software when like Steam (via sales usually), it costs me pennies on the dollar that licensed software does.

If I am one hacked system (see adobe), forgotten payment, stolen credit card/login/database or "the internet is down" incident away from losing access to my work products or using that subscription software then I am at a huge risk versus calling in an IT guy to fix my screwups with licenses every few years. Just like the cloud storage stuff, if you don't control your data, you don't own it and its not secure at all. It may not be secure on your own systems but at least you control it.

I walked into my medical clinic last year for a blood draw, a week before my doc appointment to hear "the internet is down city wide!" from the nurse. They were helpless to confirm my doc's work order and would take my blood based on past tests I'd had but I may have to come back for more tests. That or I could come back later in the day (while fasting) in the hopes they had internet access again.

Next week I got to spend 5 minutes with my doc discussing the upsides and downsides of cloud computing when he started grumbling after I'd mentioned the testing incident. Apparently the system was down all that Friday and "whats the point of spending $40k for computers that don't work". From what I recall, their data host was offline all day.


Well usually most of the subscription software I roll out is locally installed. Plus the activation servers are usually a once a month check. Things just don't grind to a halt if the router cable is pulled. If you live in a area where your internet can go down for a month...then you are pretty screwed whatever you do. I would recommend moving somewhere a little more civilised.

Currently I only recommend light cloud use or use it for off-site backups. I also don't believe in storing all your assets somewhere else. But again most cloud services also utilise local copies so again its not an issue if it goes down.

The average broadband speed in my area is maybe around 12Mbps down and 1Mbps up and by the end of the year it should be about 40Mbps down and 20Mbps up which makes it all the more attractive. It's largely urban with fiber rolling out so reliability is good.

I think I'm seeing a lot of people who haven't really explored the options as deeply as they should have. It's not as bad as it looks.
 
Just be ready for more bugs. Glad I'm not in IT, this will make more work for them.

Just to show how bad its got. The last update windows 8.1 update. I had to create "C:\ProgramData\Microsoft\Windows\Start Menu\Programs\System Tools". If the update didn't see System Tools it would throw error 80070002.

Yeah its got that bad. And they want to do a release each year. Good luck with that.

Link?
 
Well usually most of the subscription software I roll out is locally installed. Plus the activation servers are usually a once a month check. Things just don't grind to a halt if the router cable is pulled. If you live in a area where your internet can go down for a month...then you are pretty screwed whatever you do. I would recommend moving somewhere a little more civilised.

Currently I only recommend light cloud use or use it for off-site backups. I also don't believe in storing all your assets somewhere else. But again most cloud services also utilise local copies so again its not an issue if it goes down.

The average broadband speed in my area is maybe around 12Mbps down and 1Mbps up and by the end of the year it should be about 40Mbps down and 20Mbps up which makes it all the more attractive. It's largely urban with fiber rolling out so reliability is good.

I think I'm seeing a lot of people who haven't really explored the options as deeply as they should have. It's not as bad as it looks.

Dear lord a true subscription and cloud believer that thinks its that easy. We've explored those options as well and no it won't work for us and I won't go into the thousands of reasons why. Yes I'm sure it works well for some companies out there that only need the OS and Office. But let me guess I'm a dinosaur with his head stuck in the sand from the old school of thought...amiright?

PS: just for the record the "cloud" can mean anything you want it to be. A company domain network is a "local" cloud...big deal throwing new words around. Its easy to draw up a powerpoint presentation and make it look really easy. Try and actually do the work to implement that and you can see where it becomes a nightmare for both IT, accounting as well as employees when you find new and frustratingly interesting problems to deal with. Let me guess again, we're (IT) there to serve the company not the other way around. Problem is you need to find a balance of serving the company/employees while not turning it into a money pit of ever lasting testing, change and training on a semi annual basis. I'd hazard to guess if it was your company/money being drained by the IT dept you'd sing a different tune.
 
I'm adapting to the new world, you'll have to at some point. I guess you are the guy that looks after the old single piece of custom software that is no longer supported and is a millstone round the neck of the company but you've made a career out of keeping it going. Seen a lot of those in my time.


Holy fuck, that sounds just like a commercial for win 8.
 
Dear lord a true subscription and cloud believer that thinks its that easy. We've explored those options as well and no it won't work for us and I won't go into the thousands of reasons why. Yes I'm sure it works well for some companies out there that only need the OS and Office. But let me guess I'm a dinosaur with his head stuck in the sand from the old school of thought...amiright?

PS: just for the record the "cloud" can mean anything you want it to be. A company domain network is a "local" cloud...big deal throwing new words around. Its easy to draw up a powerpoint presentation and make it look really easy. Try and actually do the work to implement that and you can see where it becomes a nightmare for both IT, accounting as well as employees when you find new and frustratingly interesting problems to deal with. Let me guess again, we're (IT) there to serve the company not the other way around. Problem is you need to find a balance of serving the company/employees while not turning it into a money pit of ever lasting testing, change and training on a semi annual basis. I'd hazard to guess if it was your company/money being drained by the IT dept you'd sing a different tune.

Your main assumption is that ALL companies use high maintenance custom software that needs a IT team to patch it up and molly coddle it to work all the time.

I'm just saying that isn't true for all companies so more simpler and easier approaches can work just fine.

Not all companies work in chaos with their IT.
 
I'm adapting to the new world, you'll have to at some point. I guess you are the guy that looks after the old single piece of custom software that is no longer supported and is a millstone round the neck of the company but you've made a career out of keeping it going. Seen a lot of those in my time.


Holy fuck, that sounds just like a commercial for win 8.

The later part of that statement probably rings closer to the truth for some here though. Uncomfortable?;)
 
Your main assumption is that ALL companies use high maintenance custom software that needs a IT team to patch it up and molly coddle it to work all the time.

I'm just saying that isn't true for all companies so more simpler and easier approaches can work just fine.

Not all companies work in chaos with their IT.

No, you implied in your first posts All company's should be able to do it. And again implied by that last sentence if they don't agree with exactly what you think then their (mine) IT departments are in chaos with the rest of the company...such generic statements like that are a crock of shit. When you grow up you'll realize things aren't as black and white as a pretty power-point presentation.
 
No, you implied in your first posts All company's should be able to do it. And again implied by that last sentence if they don't agree with exactly what you think then their (mine) IT departments are in chaos with the rest of the company...such generic statements like that are a crock of shit. When you grow up you'll realize things aren't as black and white as a pretty power-point presentation.

My my, well we'll just have to agree to disagree.

I never use Powerpoint. Just face to face chats are more than enough to get the message across.
 
Americans/Westerners are too focused on growth. So much so that windows could lose its position.

It's no that simple. Windows, and for that matter all other desktop operating systems, are already losing their position, at least in the consumer space, as more can be done on tablets and smart phones that previously required a desktop or laptop. It does make sense to extended the capabilities of Windows to run on tablets and to be able to compete with those devices on price. Microsoft didn't get it right with 8.0 with far too many traditional desktop users.

But it looks like by the end of this summer, most of those issues will be resolved. Users familiar with the Windows desktop should be right at home with Windows 8.x overall but now Windows can run much more effectively on mobile devices than previously. If properly executed, this should be great thing for Windows and its customers as there will be more choice than ever in how one uses Windows and the devices on which that use it.
 
If properly executed, this should be great thing for Windows and its customers as there will be more choice than ever in how one uses Windows and the devices on which that use it.

More than ever? I dunno about that. They had tablet-friendly operating systems before now. I think if they do the whole listening to their customers thing again, they'll just get back to the place they were at before when XP Tablet Edition was around rather than further ahead.
 
More than ever? I dunno about that. They had tablet-friendly operating systems before now. I think if they do the whole listening to their customers thing again, they'll just get back to the place they were at before when XP Tablet Edition was around rather than further ahead.

If the start button/menu ends up being only shortcuts to Metro apps then they still aren't listening. We will see...
 
More than ever? I dunno about that. They had tablet-friendly operating systems before now. I think if they do the whole listening to their customers thing again, they'll just get back to the place they were at before when XP Tablet Edition was around rather than further ahead.

The overwhelming consensus that I've seen is that x86 Windows 8.x is a much better tablet-friendly OS than previous x86 versions of Windows for the simple fact that there are actually applications for 8.x beyond desktop applications which are almost all designed to work well with only keyboards and mice. And on top of that there are now affordable, lightweight and battery efficient devices that perform well with not only modern apps but many desktop apps as well. While those achievements are mostly from Intel, battery life, performance, weight and price were always big problems for Windows tablets.
 
If the start button/menu ends up being only shortcuts to Metro apps then they still aren't listening. We will see...

Huh? The Start Screen has always had the ability to show short cuts for desktop apps and elements. Currently the Start Button opens the Start or App Screen and what was shown at Build was clearly not the Start Screen but a Start Menu with both classic and modern elements. It's beyond clear that they are listening and responding to every major criticism of the 8.x UI and adding in a lot more options and smarter defaults based on input type. Of course we won't know with any specificity until we see the end product, but it looks this version of 8.x will be very familiar to desktop and mouse users while retaining all of the abilities to work well on tablets.
 
Huh? The Start Screen has always had the ability to show short cuts for desktop apps and elements. Currently the Start Button opens the Start or App Screen and what was shown at Build was clearly not the Start Screen but a Start Menu with both classic and modern elements. It's beyond clear that they are listening and responding to every major criticism of the 8.x UI and adding in a lot more options and smarter defaults based on input type. Of course we won't know with any specificity until we see the end product, but it looks this version of 8.x will be very familiar to desktop and mouse users while retaining all of the abilities to work well on tablets.

Huh...desktop apps and elements? wut? If they are going to show programs/folders (including 3rd party) on the start menu when I left click as in Win 7 then that is what I want. Right now I left click and it takes me to Metro apps, which is worthless to me. I don't want to right click at all to get a real start menu. If the menu allows both apps and regular program shortcuts that is fine by me. I didn't see any official version yet of the start menu, have you?
 
If the start button/menu ends up being only shortcuts to Metro apps then they still aren't listening. We will see...

Right now it just dumps you back out to the start screen. It's a really slow crawl for the OS to get a point where the UI will likely appeal to a broader audience and PC sales will pick back up. But yeah, like you said, we'll see.

The overwhelming consensus that I've seen is that x86 Windows 8.x is a much better tablet-friendly OS than previous x86 versions of Windows for the simple fact that there are actually applications for 8.x beyond desktop applications which are almost all designed to work well with only keyboards and mice. And on top of that there are now affordable, lightweight and battery efficient devices that perform well with not only modern apps but many desktop apps as well. While those achievements are mostly from Intel, battery life, performance, weight and price were always big problems for Windows tablets.

I'm not disagreeing about the table thing. It is an okay OS there, but the thing is that it's just a UI change. Computers aren't really doing amazingly new things because the UI is different. They still check e-mail and let people troll..errr...discuss stuff on forums. So sure it's more finger-friendly, but that didn't add capabilities that weren't already there before.
 
Huh...desktop apps and elements? wut? If they are going to show programs/folders (including 3rd party) on the start menu when I left click as in Win 7 then that is what I want. Right now I left click and it takes me to Metro apps, which is worthless to me.

I'm not trying to argue what you want but you're not describing the current function properly. Right clicking on the Start Button in 8.1 brings up the full screen Start Screen or App Screen depending on a configuration option that can be changed but that defaults to the Start Screen. The Start Screen can have whatever shortcuts a user wants, desktop apps, modern apps, folder locations, etc.

I don't want to right click at all to get a real start menu. If the menu allows both apps and regular program shortcuts that is fine by me. I didn't see any official version yet of the start menu, have you?

The Start Menu demoed at Build earlier this month showed a Start Menu with a search box at the bottom and shortcuts left and an All Apps link at the bottom, pretty much like the Windows 7 Start Menu. The right side showed a container for tiles. A question I had was if the right side could revert back to a static list of links as in 7.
 
Back
Top