Windows 8.2 Will Make Start Menu An Option?

Adoption rates of 8.x in one tech savvy group, gamers, seems to be much higher than the general population if the Steam surveys are accurate.

No. And your repeated use of "technically savvy" is misleading at best. Outright bullshit at the worst.

Are some gamers technically savvy? Sure.
Are they, as a group, technically savvy? I don't know. I highly doubt it though.

So painting the entire group as technically savvy, then saying "higher adoption rates amongst the technically savvy" is just straight up lies.
 
Why they didn't make it an option to use their stupid ass metro bullshit or the traditional desktop is beyond me.

Microsoft keeps shooting themselves in the foot and I don't feel bad for them one bit.
 
No. And your repeated use of "technically savvy" is misleading at best. Outright bullshit at the worst.

I wasn't the one that bought up the term technically savvy. I don't have any proof that PC gamers would be considered "technically savvy", but as a group I it is reasonable to assume they are more technically savvy than the average PC user.

But anyone who is a "technically savvy" Windows user is certainly up to speed with the latest version, know how it works on desktops and laptops and with mice and keyboards and touch. Technically savvy people would be the ones using the most by definition, otherwise I'm not sure why they'd be considered technically savvy, at in terms knowing the latest Windows client.
 
The other problem with Win 8, is having a browser some businesses, or government organizations can't use for 90% of the applications that were coded with IE8 or 9 in mind, IE 10 and 11 break them.

I thought Server Core had a desktop background with a command line window. That doesn't count, does it?

Basically all it is.... the full OS install with a powershell as the login instead at first but all the other crap is still there essentially.
 
Try going to best buy, or most other sources to buy a new Laptop or Desktop without Windows 8. They aren't forcing anyone to upgrade existing installations, but they are certainly making it tough for people to buy new systems without it.
You have a point. But seeming as the need for new pc's are slowing down due to many reasons others have stated in this threads, I acknowledge it could be an issue for some but not that big of an issue. My mom's pc stil runs winxp. But I'm moving her over to Win8 whenever I buy her a new PC. Whenever that happens.

Yes they did go out of their way to remove it. There was a registry key during the early preview builds that allowed you to re-enable the Start Menu, and once a few sites popped up with "How to re-enable the Start Menu", Sinofsky ordered it removed.

And Windows 8 was hardly "built from the ground up" for Metro. It is essentially just a shell running on top of an evolved Windows 7 kernel. Proof? With literally just a shell swap using the Ex7ForW8 tool, which patches Windows 8 to use explorer.exe from a Windows 7 installation disc instead of Windows 8's explorer.exe, Metro never even hooks, and the OS continues to work perfectly with a genuine Start Menu.
I stand corrected. I did some quick research to confirm your allegations and you are right for the most part. I was going off of more of the whole "conceptual idea" of Windows 8 was built around the Metro way of doing things.

I don't necessarily see this as true. Modern apps have a place in business for things like point of sale, client facing apps, shipping and warehousing, automation and process control, etc.
I also agree with this. In offices and businesses, people working on their PC's don't need to be doing anything but what their job pays them for. So to be able to have nice big blocks for them to click on is a plus in my eyes. No you don't need to figure out where your itunes is. No you don't need to find your solitaire game. Do your freaking work, heh. If you really need to do that stuff, you prolly have a phone that can take care of all that for you.
 
Why they didn't make it an option to use their stupid ass metro bullshit or the traditional desktop is beyond me.

Microsoft keeps shooting themselves in the foot and I don't feel bad for them one bit.

You want the truth or you want lies? :) The truth is that Sinofsky convinced Ballmer that forcing Metro on every desktop and removing the choice for users to revert to the Start Menu would mean a shortcut to relevance in the mobile segments where Microsoft was a nonfactor. The second prong was to begin turning Windows into a closed, app delivery platform. The plan was sold as a 'two birds with one stone" strategy. And it has failed miserably as the uptake stats show now with Win8/8.1 having plateaued in the past 3 months. Microsoft had assumed they would have sold far more phones and tablets by now to make up for the "disruption" caused in the Windows PC space.

The lie for desktop users is that if you "just adapt" and "learn the new interface" designed for tablets first and foremost, that some magical door of increased usability and increased workflow would open up and it would be better than the tried and true Start Menu. And what happened was people that began using Metro on desktop PC's and laptops that weren't touch enabled was they had no such experience, that in fact Metro created obstacles needlessly.

Metro on desktop PC's is like someone insisting you just start writing everything with your left hand (or right hand if you're a lefty). "Just adapt, just start writing with your left hand. Its not that bad. Stop being afraid of change". Yes I can learn to sign my name with my left hand but its pointless and I haven't gained anything nor can I do it better than I already could. That's not a perfect analogy but "writing with your left hand" is how it feels trying to be productive on a Metro oriented PC that hasn't had third party hacks and tools installed to suppress it as much as possible.
 
The truth is simple. Yes Microsoft is leveraging the desktop to gain entry into mobile? Why? The new desktop market is shrinking and it's been affecting Mac sales overall the last year about as much as PC sales. And because it dominates the desktop and has for 20 years. And as much as some people think Windows 8.x is a POS, it now has more desktop market share than everything else combined not called.

We've simply reach the limit on new conventional PC sales. Start Menus won't change that.
 
Just think of the fun supporting a business where every department/user has a different customized GUI. {shuddder}

Hell. It's hard enough getting some idiots supported when every desktop is THE SAME!

Sit there, because a remote client has their permissions locked down so hard that they can't fart without setting off alarms. So you talk them through something, for 45 minutes, painstakingly describing it.

They uh huh and okay their way through.
Then tell you they got lost on the second step and were just following along...or taking notes...or nothing I described looks ANYTHING like their system...

:mad::mad:GAAAHHH!!!:mad::mad:
 
I found that on a mouse/keyboard touchless desktop, the reasons to move away from DOS to WIndows in the beginning are quite similar to the same reasons to stay with the old interface and avoid the Modern UI.
 
I wasn't the one that bought up the term technically savvy. I don't have any proof that PC gamers would be considered "technically savvy",

Yet you're trying to make exactly that point with your argument!

but as a group I it is reasonable to assume they are more technically savvy than the average PC user.

I wouldn't assume things like that.

First of all, because the mythical "average PC user" is just that.

But anyone who is a "technically savvy" Windows user is certainly up to speed with the latest version, know how it works on desktops and laptops and with mice and keyboards and touch. Technically savvy people would be the ones using the most by definition, otherwise I'm not sure why they'd be considered technically savvy, at in terms knowing the latest Windows client.

Simply being familiar with Windows 8 == adoption. You made a statement about "adoption of windows 8 being higher among the technically savvy", based on the fact that one gaming poll shows an outlier value compared to the entire install base of PCs. This is TAYA at its finest.
 
The truth is simple. Yes Microsoft is leveraging the desktop to gain entry into mobile? Why?

Because mobile devices are where the current sales bubble is. And the lifespan of such products is far shorter than in the desktop space.

The new desktop market is shrinking and it's been affecting Mac sales overall the last year about as much as PC sales.

Actually the desktop market isn't so much "shrinking" as it is falloff in new sales.

Current desktop PCs, even cheap ones, are GROTESQUELY overpowered for most of the functions that they're put to. Hell, most LAPTOPS are grotesquely overpowered as well. About the only thing that gives them pause are...games. With SSDs making inroads into the mainstream (and, eventually, budget) space(s), people and businesses are keeping them longer.

Now, as a form factor, for content consumption, the PC isn't really optimal. Even laptops aren't optimal.

Mobile devices are FAR more convenient. Additionally, the power requirements for them are relatively miniscule. Meaning they go well into smaller form factors, and provide better battery lifetimes WITHOUT having to deal with excessive thermal considerations (one does NOT put a "gaming laptop" on one's lap during gaming...unless you were looking for an excuse for gender reassignment...or think you're the McDonalds coffee lady). Also, nobody expects many of these "devices" to be user serviceable. As such, they can get away with cheaper manufacturing techniques. So, using cheaper components, and cheaper manufacturing allows them to build them inexpensively (relatively) and make up profits on volume.

PCs, OTOH, have longer sales cycles (we're at 5-10 years for most large businesses). On top of this, component performance is plateauing off somewhat with the push not really being greater speed, but better parallelism. The next wave of enterprise upgrades won't be using performance as their primary motivator for the upgrade. It'll be component lifetimes.

Is this mobile eating into the desktop market? Sure. A bit. As I said earlier, there are numerous (but not universal) use cases where a mobile device delivers a sufficient or superior experience to the desktop.

However, this is not to say that the mobile is going to replace the PC. No, the entire "computer ecosystem" is simply going to expand and encompass these mobile devices in addition to PCs.


And because it dominates the desktop and has for 20 years. And as much as some people think Windows 8.x is a POS, it now has more desktop market share than everything else combined not called.

Uh, No. It only recently surpassed Vista. It's still only ~5-7% of total PC installs. Win7 is sitting at around 40-44%. XP is still around 30-35%. Mac his holding right around 7% of the total market.

We've simply reach the limit on new conventional PC sales. Start Menus won't change that.

In short, it may not bring in new sales, but it's enough to actually forestall new sales as businesses try to eke out more life from existing, familiar systems to avoid the retraining costs and lost productivity.
 
Options and customizations aren't free. Every switch in Windows has a cost associated to it in terms of complexity, training and support. That's why I don't think the Start Menu per se is coming back but more options for the Start Screen, which while adding to the above, doesn't put two completely different things in the box that behave totally differently that do the same thing but not exactly.
When they did Windows 8, its obvious they started with Windows 7. Its why it took a few weeks to put 3rd party start menus in. So they actually did work to remove the start menu. At a minimum they have all the details behind why the WIndows 7 menu looks like it does and all the consequences of the associated switches. They would have to be stupid to throw that out. But then again...
 
Why? I freaking love the new Start menu, and most people would if they gave it a chance.
 
However, this is not to say that the mobile is going to replace the PC. No, the entire "computer ecosystem" is simply going to expand and encompass these mobile devices in addition to PCs.

But this is a point about Windows 8. It can run on these cheap, lightweight great battery life devices and also run desktop apps. Here's who I look at it. If I can buy an Android tablet for $200, why can't I get an Windows tablet for $200 that does the same things as Android on a tablet and everything that Windows does on a desktop? Some say that I don't want choice for consumers. I totally want more choice for consumers. The option to buy a single cheap device that does everything that desktops do (within performance constraints of such devices) and everything a tablet can do is a HUGE win for customers and gives lots of options at low prices.

Uh, No. It only recently surpassed Vista. It's still only ~5-7% of total PC installs. Win7 is sitting at around 40-44%. XP is still around 30-35%. Mac his holding right around 7% of the total market.

According to the latest NetMarketShare report: http://netmarketshare.com/

Windows 8.x --- 9.30%
Every non-Windows desktop OS combined --- 9.19%
 
Why? I freaking love the new Start menu, and most people would if they gave it a chance.

Most people would? Sorry, I can't make up their opinion for them. You, me, Heatless and a few others love the new start screen. However, this thread among thousands throughout the internet, prove that 'most people' that gave it a chance really DON'T like it. They are using it right, they don't fear change, blah blah blah - they just don't like it.
 
Most people would? Sorry, I can't make up their opinion for them. You, me, Heatless and a few others love the new start screen. However, this thread among thousands throughout the internet, prove that 'most people' that gave it a chance really DON'T like it. They are using it right, they don't fear change, blah blah blah - they just don't like it.

People that fear change never give stuff a chance.
 
Most people would? Sorry, I can't make up their opinion for them. You, me, Heatless and a few others love the new start screen. However, this thread among thousands throughout the internet, prove that 'most people' that gave it a chance really DON'T like it. They are using it right, they don't fear change, blah blah blah - they just don't like it.

I don't really think that most people think about it as so much as non-technical folks pick up they here from more interested folks in the subject like ourselves.

I like Windows 8 because it can run it on anything bigger than a smart phone. Where some think that a OS has be designed specifically for desktops or tablets, after about two years with Windows 8 I completely disagree. It might be a little more complicated especially if you're really tied to the classic desktop UI but I can do everything important on a Windows 8 desktop as a Windows 7 desktop with a keyboard and mouse and do pretty much the same things on my Windows 8 tablets as an Android or iOS device. And if I want to use desktop apps on that tablet or a tablet app on the desktop, I can do that and I do every day. To me THIS is what the choice is. The app launcher, not a big deal. Its the apps themselves and the hardware I wish to run it on.

In all of these discussions we spend tons of time about launching apps, sifting through menus or counting mouse clicks or full screen versus windowed but very little time about actually running programs or working with different kinds of hardware.
 
I still find it strange how people on the "bleeding edge" cling to age old comforts.

Bleeding "edge" in UI design isn't the hard numbers game that system performance is. It's, essentially, an expression ergonomic and skeuomorphic preference.
 
Most people would? Sorry, I can't make up their opinion for them. You, me, Heatless and a few others love the new start screen. However, this thread among thousands throughout the internet, prove that 'most people' that gave it a chance really DON'T like it. They are using it right, they don't fear change, blah blah blah - they just don't like it.

Devil's advocate: you won't hear from people who likes it. They're too busy using it. You'll only hear the outcries. Vocal minority perhaps.

I didn't care much for it at first but after a month of using it, I was hooked. My boss hated it and asked me to stockpile Windows 7 licenses. I told her to give it a month or two. Let's just say that we've replaced over 40 iPads with Lenovo ThinkPad Tablet 2.

Anecdotal evidence is just that - anecdotal.

Anyways, I'm seeing a lot of circular arguments here. Those who dislike it will probably continue to dislike it. I'm also detecting a lot of dislikes from those who never tried it or gave it time. And there are those who don't mind, but use GUI replacement software. And finally there's those who like it, or even love it.

Let's just wait and see what 8.2 brings us. Maybe we'll all agree that it's what Windows needed after all.
 
Devil's advocate: you won't hear from people who likes it. They're too busy using it. You'll only hear the outcries. Vocal minority perhaps.

Devil's advocate: If there really was some mythical silent majority that are too busy using Metro to talk about it, Windows 8 uptake wouldn't be flat lining while Windows 7 continues to grow. They'd be showing up on usage metrics.

Gpf2Pbg.jpg
 
Devil's advocate: If there really was some mythical silent majority that are too busy using Metro to talk about it, Windows 8 uptake wouldn't be flat lining while Windows 7 continues to grow. They'd be showing up on usage metrics.

According to data that this chart is based on, Windows 7 has gone from about 44 to 46 percent share since the release of Windows 8 last year. Meanwhile 8.x has gone from like .5 to about 10 percent. Let's see the growth numbers for December. Of course when those numbers show much stronger growth for 8.x (well really 8.1 as 8 is rapidly shrinking) of course Windows 8 opponents will mention this little thing called Christmas.
 
Of course when those numbers show much stronger growth for 8.x (well really 8.1 as 8 is rapidly shrinking) of course Windows 8 opponents will mention this little thing called Christmas.

Ah, and if it still is showing as plateaued, you'll simply fluff off any hint that you were wrong.

You're convinced that your opinion is "the right one" in this.

What you fail (and have failed, and will probably continue failing) to realize is that this isn't about right or wrong.

But please, don't let that keep you from attempting to somehow "win on the internet".
 
All I'm saying is that there should be some good growth in 8.1 this holiday. There's been a lot of new hardware coming out and a lot of aggressive sales on 8.1 devices. It's not a matter of winning an argument on the internet, just looking at what's on sale on the internet.
 
The tit-for-tat from both zealot camps is a little tiring, let's be honest. However the "just learn to adapt" and "you whiners are just afraid of change" types don't understand that that's not the way to build mindshare and positive buzz. Its turning people off.

There are those of us in the middle that actually use Windows 8 and appreciate the good parts of it - namely an evolved Windows 7 core under the hood - and simply want Microsoft to pull their heads out, fire the last of the Sinofsky lieutenants that still roam the halls at night, put choice back in Windows for desktop users and begin to rebuild the brand.

Give people back the Start Menu because it works, but at the same continue finding ways to make Metro more compelling rather than an Under Construction zone, and people will gravitate toward it on their own. It just needs to be properly incentivized and Microsoft has not made a business case with their first party Metro offerings short of maybe One Note. Because if you want people to do something or adopt something they have to think or believe it was their idea. Metro has to sink or swim on its own merits, and Microsoft must make the case for any benefits or better way of working and interacting than what already works for people in a way that is intuitive and clear. If it still requires hours of training, they've failed.
 
Which was the point, adoption rates of 8 actually being higher with more technically savvy folks than the mainstream. And is it really a surprise that Windows 8 adoption rates were low in November, just before all of the sales which started a late this year because of the lateness of Thanksgiving?

Do you have statistics from a reputable source to support the idea that "technically savvy" people are buying more Windows 8/8.1 licenses than anyone else? Making that claim is no different than saying that serious amature ninja zombie hunters open checking accounts with CitiBank more often than Bank of America. There's no demographics to support what you're saying and the holiday this past month has little to nothing to do with the past year plus of tepid sales and poor public perception of product value. It seems like you only quote Net Applications metrics when they support your claims and dismiss them when they don't rather than just accepting numbers as a neutral source.
 
I've been screaming for this from the second I played around with the pre-beta or whatever they called it.

1. Those that hate/despise the start button/menu, make it an option to turn the start button/menu off so they don't see it at all. Result: happy campers.

2. Those that want a start button/menu, make it an option to turn it on so they can use it. Result: happy campers.

It's just that simple. Don't just enable it with no option to disable it. I don't see why it's so difficult for Microsoft to understand. :confused:
 
I've been screaming for this from the second I played around with the pre-beta or whatever they called it.

1. Those that hate/despise the start button/menu, make it an option to turn the start button/menu off so they don't see it at all. Result: happy campers.

2. Those that want a start button/menu, make it an option to turn it on so they can use it. Result: happy campers.

It's just that simple. Don't just enable it with no option to disable it. I don't see why it's so difficult for Microsoft to understand. :confused:

It's not just MS. Its the for lack of a better phrase "fan boys" on here that refuse to allow for that choice. They scream to the high heaven that "change is good" or "your just afraid of change" and "its the future", so NO to choice. But they fail to realize that the majority don't want a mobile interface on anything but touch devices. The fact is numbers back that up, which makes it even more ridiculous. Heck even MS is willing to change more than some on this forum! Mind boggling...:rolleyes:
 
I still find it strange how people on the "bleeding edge" cling to age old comforts.

"Bleeding edge" of technology does not = accepting every change regardless of whether it's actually good or bad or indifferent just because someone told you it's best for you. If anything, that's what tech retard sheep do... it sounds almost like something a [H]'er would bitch about an Apple sheep for doing :p
 
It's not just MS. Its the for lack of a better phrase "fan boys" on here that refuse to allow for that choice. They scream to the high heaven that "change is good" or "your just afraid of change" and "its the future", so NO to choice. But they fail to realize that the majority don't want a mobile interface on anything but touch devices. The fact is numbers back that up, which makes it even more ridiculous. Heck even MS is willing to change more than some on this forum! Mind boggling...:rolleyes:

That means the people advocating change are the ones that are actually afraid of change since they're arguing for a lack of change in a currently shipping product and don't want to see it become anything different from the status quo. They fear that Microsoft will try something different with future revisions of their operating system and refuse to move forward with future products. They're stuck in a Windows 8 Modern UI rut. :D
 
Do you have statistics from a reputable source to support the idea that "technically savvy" people are buying more Windows 8/8.1 licenses than anyone else?

No more than anyone has data showing that the "technically savvy" aren't migrating more to 8.x than mainstream users. Odd that you would ask me to present data and not the person that initially made the point and "technically savvy" folks not using it. I simply showed that gamers seem to be using it more and present data indicating that. If you don't consider PC gamers as "technically savvy" then fine.
 
No more than anyone has data showing that the "technically savvy" aren't migrating more to 8.x than mainstream users. Odd that you would ask me to present data and not the person that initially made the point and "technically savvy" folks not using it. I simply showed that gamers seem to be using it more and present data indicating that. If you don't consider PC gamers as "technically savvy" then fine.

I was just curious if you had metrics that are not broadly available. If not, then that's just peach-fuzzy with me. I wouldn't consider people who use Steam any more versed in technology than anyone else. In fact, I don't think it's even fair to make that kinda distinction anymore since most people in first world nations are familiar with computer operations and there's not really a clear dividing line between those that know and those that don't. It's more like a smooth gradient and a branching one at that as there are a lot of people with specialized knowledge in one particular thing that might not qualify as a stereotypical nerd sort. It does the universe a great injustice to simplify them so merely for the sake of making an operating system a point of contention.
 
There are those of us in the middle that actually use Windows 8 and appreciate the good parts of it - namely an evolved Windows 7 core under the hood - and simply want Microsoft to pull their heads out, fire the last of the Sinofsky lieutenants that still roam the halls at night, put choice back in Windows for desktop users and begin to rebuild the brand.

Exactly. I have ZERO problems with the OS portion of Windows 8. It's some damn fine work on the core OS and has the capability to drastically expand the functionality of the OS in certain use cases.

My SOLE problem (or problem bundle) is with the UI.
And no amount of "Stop whining and adapt" is going to fix that.
 
It's not just MS. Its the for lack of a better phrase "fan boys" on here that refuse to allow for that choice. They scream to the high heaven that "change is good" or "your just afraid of change" and "its the future", so NO to choice. But they fail to realize that the majority don't want a mobile interface on anything but touch devices. The fact is numbers back that up, which makes it even more ridiculous. Heck even MS is willing to change more than some on this forum! Mind boggling...:rolleyes:

Where is that *clap* gif? This post deserves it.

With such a split with Modern UI, there should be the option to have the legacy start menu. Choice. Not because people fear change, not because that's the way the industry is moving to (sure industry is moving there, but what about those devices that haven't move or won't move forward).
 
No more than anyone has data showing that the "technically savvy" aren't migrating more to 8.x than mainstream users. Odd that you would ask me to present data and not the person that initially made the point and "technically savvy" folks not using it. I simply showed that gamers seem to be using it more and present data indicating that. If you don't consider PC gamers as "technically savvy" then fine.

*HEADDESK*

Nobody here BUT YOU made ANY claim about migration levels for Win8 for "technically savvy".

Us disagreeing with you and telling you your data point support your premise is NOT the same thing as saying the inverse of what you said.

Us disagreeing with "There's data showing technically savvy users are migrating to Win8 at a higher rate than otherwise" is not us saying "There's data showing technically savvy users are NOT migrating to Win8 at a high rate than otherwise" or "There's data showing technically savvy users are migrating to Win8 at a lower rate than otherwise."

We're saying your data point doesn't support your argument. PERIOD.

The fact that you are barking up the particular tree simply means you aren't actually paying any attention to this conversation and are simply posting in reaction to what you THINK you're reading.
 
*HEADDESK*

Nobody here BUT YOU made ANY claim about migration levels for Win8 for "technically savvy".

Incorrect...

so Microsoft has finally caved in?...I'm shocked...only took them 2 releases of windows 8 to finally listen...I'm willing to buy 8.2 is the Start Menu returns...W8 has a lot of under the hood improvements (like Vista did) but most tech saavy consumers wouldn't bite because of the Start menu issue

http://hardforum.com/showpost.php?p=1040455547&postcount=194
 
Back
Top