Which fan controller should I choose? Urgent!

Snel

Weaksauce
Joined
Jul 19, 2011
Messages
75
Hi. I am one click away from buying 8GB ram and two new Gentle Typhoon 1850rpm fans.
I have two of those i the front of my Fractal Design Refine R2. I also have a VERY loud 1900rpm 120mm Scythe fan in the top which I am going to replace with the 1850.
I think I will add the other 1850 to the bottom, or do you think it is neccesary?

In the back I have a corsair fan that came with my Corsair H50 liquid cooler. Is it enough with 1 fan in the top and one in the back?


I am also going to buy a fan controller. Since I want to be able to close the door on my Refine R2 I want a flat one.
First one is the Scythe Kaze Master Flat.
Also Scythe Kaze Master II
I think both of these can turn the fans completely off, I think I have heard that it might not be good to do that with some fans. I'm not sure if that is true though.
Do you think I can set a minimum level or something like that?

Then there is also the NZXT SENTRY MIX, which, if I'm not mistaken, slow the fans dow to 40%.
That sounds like it could be a good idle speed to set the fans to. So it would be simple to just slow all of them down to 40% and not have to accidentally turn them off like I assume you can do with the other two.


I would really appreciate if anyone would help me with this!
Thank you in advance!

Edit: I think I'm going to replace the fan that came with H50 as well.
Just to make sure that it isn't wrong, should the pump be plugged into pwr_fan1? And the fane to CPU_FAN?
 
Last edited:
You could just get a lower RPM version of that fan, or 7 volt them if they are too loud as well.

To 7V you just need a molex extension, you swap the red and black wires on one side and plug the fan into this adapter (well technically you don't even need an adapter but its kinda nice).

Sorry if you already knew this.
 
The ball bearing design of the Gentle Typhoons do not undervolt well, as they tend to whine. If you're looking for fans to undervolt, I would suggest looking at some different type of bearings, like fluid dynamic or one of those other fancy sounding ones.
 
Oh, I already bought 3 GT1850 and the Kaze Master II. So it was a bad choice then?
As I wrote earlier, I think, I already have 2 of these in the front. And I thought I would put one in the top, one in the bottom and one to replace the corsair fan on my H50.
It has already been shipped so I cannot cancel my order.
 
I have 5x GT1850's and they run around 85%-90% and I can barely hear them on my water cooling. I hear my pump more so then my fans.
 
I have 5x GT1850's and they run around 85%-90% and I can barely hear them on my water cooling. I hear my pump more so then my fans.

Okay, so you are using a fan controller?
Do they always run around 90%? Or do you set it lower when you're not doing anything or higher on full load for example?
 
Funny someone else recommended me AP-15's WITH a fan controller. I wasn't aware of the whine issue either as my panaflo L1BX are ball bearing fans and do not whine when turned down on a fan controller. I have 4 AP-15's on the way too. Honestly I'll probably just run them full speed anyways though, but it will be an interesting comparison to the L1BX which are not silent but damn close enough for me. I wouldn't worry too much about fan controllers being able to turn off fans. For me more control = better. If you get one that can only adjust 7-12v then if you have fans that like 5v you won't get the full benefit from those, and if you get one that can go down to 5v then your other fans won't spin up if they require 7v etc.
 
Yes, they are on a fan controller. When it is at idle they drop to about 40-45%. And they gradually go up based upon the temp of my CPU/GPU. At max load is when they are at the 85-90%
 
I installed the fans earlier and now have a total of 5 GT 1850's in my case and I am very pleased with how they sound. It's a lot better than before.
The Scythe Kaze Master II is okay as well. Though a little annoying when I accidentally lower the rpm to less than 300 or even turn it off when I want it down to about 50%. i think there should have been a fast way to tell when you're down to 50% instead of having to watch the display and wait a few seconds before the rpm is displayed.
 
Back
Top