Developer Accuses Microsoft Of Making "Rape Jokes"

So this is out of line but in another thread is OK for Xbox pictures in red with the swastika and Hitler on it. People need to get over themselves.
 
Whether they should be considered as a subset of irony is a matter of linguistic debate and I doubt very much that the three of you are actually reading the journal articles regarding this debate instead of relying on what you're finding via wikipedia, etc.
What you mean like this one?

Hypocrisy as Irony: Toward a Cognitive Model of Hypocrisy
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1207/s15327868ms2103_3#.UbjXu3dMew0

You could be less of a condescending dick. The fact that it is disputed by linguists shows to me that using the term irony for hypocrisy is acceptable for the "common man". I could be wrong, of course, I never even passed high school level English (didn't fail, just didn't complete). You're the one waving the "professor" flag, you should be the one trying to educate rather than condescend :p

However, that you have to dispute it in a public forum, not of your peers (other academics and those educated in such matters), but rather of the common folk shows you either didn't realise that some people (educated people) consider hypocrisy a type of irony OR you are just here to do some condescending dick waving.

One of my professors (engineering and science) had a word for it, "intellectual masturbation".

The fact you didn't even bother to substantiate your claims with journal articles, but rather just state "there are journal articles that you aren't reading" just further shows intellectual dick waving more than anything. You could have said "hypocrisy is a more valid term" and when questioned you could have pointed to the journal articles supporting your claim, people would have still thought you were a bit pedantic and crazy, but it's better than being a condescending dick waving douche who is also pedantic and crazy.

I think Stephen Fry says it well (actually I think he says everything well :p)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J7E-aoXLZGY

Above linked article said:
"The studies reported earlier support the claim that hypocrisy is a kind of situational
irony."

"If the connection between hypocrisy and irony is so strong, then why
is it not more obvious? If hypocrisy is a type of situational irony, we would normally
expect the relation to be self-evident, as with the relation between the concepts
of mammal and dog, for example. The apparent absence of a self-evident relationship
between irony and hypocrisy is somewhat puzzling.
It may be that judgments of hypocrisy tend to mask out judgments of irony, in a
process similar to that of conceptual masking (Intraub, 1984; Loftus, Hanna, &
Lester, 1988). Perhaps, when presented with a hypocritical situation, people are
briefly aware that the situation is ironic before classifying it specifically as hypocritical.
As noted earlier, hypocrisy is a heavily freighted concept and so awareness
of this classification may tend to capture a person’s attention. As a result, the sense
of irony initially aroused by a hypocritical situation immediately fades from notice.
This hypothesis might be tested using a reaction-time paradigm. Perhaps participants
instructed to judge a given story as quickly as possible might be able to
make a judgment of irony in less time than a judgment of hypocrisy."

"The purpose of this article is to substantiate the claim that hypocrisy is nothing
other than a form of situational irony. That hypocrisy and situational irony are connected
is not news. Shelley (2001) noted that some situational ironies are also hypocrisies.
Consider the case of Emilio Valdez and Alfredo Hodoyan, twoMexican
citizens who were arrested in California on charges of drug trafficking (Shelley,
2001, p. 792). They were extradited to Mexico where they were accused of being
hitmen for a notorious drug cartel. Valdez and Hodoyan appealed the extradition
on the basis that the police had violated their human rights to obtain information
from them. The judges rejected the appeal, and one of them commented that it was
ironic that Valdez and Hodoyan invoked claims to human rights when they appear
to make their living by violating human rights, through drug trafficking and murder.
Note that not only is it ironic forValdez and Hodoyan to profess respect for human
rights when they flaunt those rights in practice, but it is also hypocritical of
them to do so, and for the same reason."
 
This kind of pussycat, trembling fear of offending others is a huge problem. It's the exact reason why western Europe has allowed its cultures to become infested by growing, lawless, unassimilating groups.
 
You know, let's be honest. This post has ALOT of truth in it. Quiet honestly I am surprised anytime I see two people gaming and there aren't rape or racist jokes.

Just because it happens doesn't mean it automatically becomes acceptable.
 
Just because it happens doesn't mean it automatically becomes acceptable.

Depends how often it happens and by how many people. I actually tend to think there are more people who don't give a shit than people who do.
 
Relax... nothing is wrong... everything is right... you'll enjoy it I promise :D
 
You could be less of a condescending dick. The fact that it is disputed by linguists shows to me that using the term irony for hypocrisy is acceptable for the "common man". I could be wrong, of course, I never even passed high school level English (didn't fail, just didn't complete). You're the one waving the "professor" flag, you should be the one trying to educate rather than condescend :p
Me pointing out that you are using a term incorrectly is not condescension. I also wasn't waving any professor flag. I only confirmed that I was a professor when he tried to use it against me--"aren't you a teacher you should know this"

I gave examples of what irony would be and why what he said wasn't an example of irony. It wasn't until multiple posts later from three of you trying to troll me that I said go look it up yourselves.

I'm not required to play along with your immature trolling and when I refuse to engage you feign like your feelings are hurt. Grow up. I was trying to educate until you guys just started arguing over bullshit instead of going oh man that's cool thanks for that information. If you haven't even graduated high school English why would you sit there and argue with a university professor about something other than to try and shit on what he's saying?

here's some clarity regarding that article you cited:
if someone says to his kid, "you can not go outside without sunscreen because you'll get burned by the sun" and then proceeds to go outside without sunscreen and gets burned--that's hypocritical *and* situational irony.

if someone says to his kid, "you can not go outside without sunscreen because you'll get burned by the sun" and then proceeds to go outside without sunscreen and does *not* get burned--that's merely hypocritical

that's analogous to the example he gave: someone says you shouldn't hate on women but meanwhile they hate men--that's merely hypocritical

there's no irony there. as I stated earlier, there is nothing in that scenario that is an unexpected result.

for it to be ironic, the person's anti-male behavior would have to actually incite further anti-female behavior. for example, a woman hates men who treat women like shit. so she goes around treating men like shit and asking how they feel about it. but instead of changing how they act they start treating women even worse *because* they were mistreated by a woman. that would be situational irony.
 
*head pats* You take forums waaay to seriously. Life's better when you can laugh at yourself, I promise-womise its twue. :p

Not really, but considering your invertible bloviating and this little display of passive aggressive textual behavior. I'd say that the stick up your ass is lodged tighter than you'd like it to be. Your venal attempt at baby talk only suggests that your a prick, but who am I to stand in the way smugness. This way madame.
 
What it means is they are in the heat of the moment and say the thing they are most often times held back from saying because someone told them that they should never say such a thing.

I disagree. Being an older gamer, I wasn't playing over the internet during my formative years. My friends and I never used such language when playing games in the same room as each other, even if there were no parents around. When a new kid starts playing online, he doesn't start already wanting to use such language, he learns that it's part of contemporary gaming culture.


What does a fucking child do when you tell them to not do something? They're going to eventually do it.

Unless your point was that gamers that use such language are basically behaving like spiteful children, which I will completely agree.


It's all about suppression. What to talk about all the things that offend people, lets talk about how far society has gone to suppress people from speaking freely without being judged or associated by groups.

You are just as free to say anything offensive as you have ever been. You just are more likely to face social consequences for it.
 
it is a rape joke. there can be funny jokes about rape. ive told funny jokes about rape to people who have been raped.

it will be quick and painless, and you wont feel a thing.
 
Honestly, reading what I've read in that article and lecture notes for English lectures, what we are talking about could easily be classified as both irony and hypocrisy. Someone who argues against sexism is actually sexist sounds exactly like the example in the article I quoted where the accused criminal claimed their human rights were violated when they appear to make their living from violating human rights.

That article I quoted specifically talks about hypocrisy being irony... not SOME hypocrisy being irony, but by it's very nature, hypocrisy is irony (that is my interpretation of the article I quoted even though apparently we can only rely on wikipedia :rolleyes:).

But either way, I once again bring up the point "intellectual masturbation". You seem to love it. But then I guess if you're a professor in english, that probably just comes with the territory.
 
it is a rape joke. there can be funny jokes about rape. ive told funny jokes about rape to people who have been raped.

it will be quick and painless, and you wont feel a thing.

I hope you made sure it was OK first.
 
I'm not saying that it has one possible meaning, but one of the meanings is DEFINITELY a rape joke. I see it this way, because here in Texas, we had a politician likening rape to bad weather, saying "if it's inevitable, just relax and enjoy it."

Context means so much when trying to comprehend and analyze the meaning of something said.
 
I'm not required to play along with your immature trolling and when I refuse to engage you feign like your feelings are hurt. Grow up. I was trying to educate until you guys just started arguing over bullshit instead of going oh man that's cool thanks for that information. If you haven't even graduated high school English why would you sit there and argue with a university professor about something other than to try and shit on what he's saying?

Also I feel I should address this point. I am not feigning like my feelings are hurt, I am stating you were needlessly dick waving, that is all. I am neither hurt nor insulted by your actions. If you inferred that I was trying to feign such emotions, that's your problem.

About the comment as to why I would argue with you... for shits and giggles. I read what you said initially and thought "hmm, that sure sounds like irony to me" *googles irony and hypocrisy definitions, finds university lectures stating hypocrisy is situational irony and posts findings*.

I don't know where you live, but where I come from, having the title professor doesn't imply you know it all and are infallible even in your specific area of study let alone other areas of study. I often have intellectual discussions with professors at my university, DISCUSSIONS, not the professor telling me "this is right and you must agree with me because I have a bigger title than you" (typically only on the science/engineering side of the university, but none the less).

I am not "shitting on what you are saying". My first post repeated what I read in a set of english lecture notes and the 2nd post I cited and quoted a journal article which supported what I said in my first post. That's more than you've done, and yet I'm the one who's immaturely trolling :rolleyes:
 
The only one getting raped is Microsoft.
I mean, when I told Microsoft to go fuck itself, I didn't mean literally! :eek:
 
for it to be ironic, the person's anti-male behavior would have to actually incite further anti-female behavior. for example, a woman hates men who treat women like shit. so she goes around treating men like shit and asking how they feel about it. but instead of changing how they act they start treating women even worse *because* they were mistreated by a woman. that would be situational irony.

Oh dare ask, what are you a professor of?

(If you say "women's studies", i'm gonna lose it.)
 
Not really, but considering your invertible bloviating and this little display of passive aggressive textual behavior. I'd say that the stick up your ass is lodged tighter than you'd like it to be. Your venal attempt at baby talk only suggests that your a prick, but who am I to stand in the way smugness. This way madame.

Obviously someone is having a case of the grumpies!
 
Country music, NASCAR, and American football pretty much show what I'm saying is true. I know it kinda stinks to see it happening and lots of people want to pretend it isn't the way things are, but I think the middle classes are sort of downtrodden and they just don't see a means of escape except downward toward the lower classes. :(

Excuse me but where do you get off saying country music, NASCAR, and Football are the prime factors in seeing the middle class become less and less civilized?
There are tons of reasons why this is happening and those 3 are at the very bottom of that list. I am a fan of all 3 and have read ALL the letters from the Earl of Chesterfield to his son.

www.gutenberg.org/files/3361/3361-h/3361-h.htm

I know what you are saying and agree we are seeing a sharp drop generation after generation but to attribute it to those three shows a complete lack of character on yourself sir and I'd advise you to think about your posts prior to saying asinine things such as this.
 
Excuse me but where do you get off saying country music, NASCAR, and Football are the prime factors in seeing the middle class become less and less civilized?
There are tons of reasons why this is happening and those 3 are at the very bottom of that list. I am a fan of all 3 and have read ALL the letters from the Earl of Chesterfield to his son.

www.gutenberg.org/files/3361/3361-h/3361-h.htm

I know what you are saying and agree we are seeing a sharp drop generation after generation but to attribute it to those three shows a complete lack of character on yourself sir and I'd advise you to think about your posts prior to saying asinine things such as this.

Well each of the three contributes in a different way to create a perfect storm of social and societal dysfunction. Country music tends to help grow and foster a culture that prides itself on drinking in bars after divorce or an unsuccessful fishing trip instead of developing coping skills. NASCAR encourages people to idolize an advertisement-funded person with a southern accent that drives unsafely and relies on heavy regulation instead of innovation and creative problem-solving skills. Football promotes violence, sexual deviance through unusual male to male contact, and loud objection to figures of authority who are attempting to make effective decisions. All that stuff combines to build in more gullible people to stay drunk, live for brand names, drive too fast, skimp on creativity, hurt one another, touch in unacceptable ways, and fight with police or government officials.

I think the world would be a much better place if people substituted country music for ambient nature albums, exchanged NASCAR for local walk-a-thons that fund scientific research, and exchanged football for ultimate frisbee or table tennis.
 
Well each of the three contributes in a different way to create a perfect storm of social and societal dysfunction. Country music tends to help grow and foster a culture that prides itself on drinking in bars after divorce or an unsuccessful fishing trip instead of developing coping skills. NASCAR encourages people to idolize an advertisement-funded person with a southern accent that drives unsafely and relies on heavy regulation instead of innovation and creative problem-solving skills. Football promotes violence, sexual deviance through unusual male to male contact, and loud objection to figures of authority who are attempting to make effective decisions. All that stuff combines to build in more gullible people to stay drunk, live for brand names, drive too fast, skimp on creativity, hurt one another, touch in unacceptable ways, and fight with police or government officials.

I think the world would be a much better place if people substituted country music for ambient nature albums, exchanged NASCAR for local walk-a-thons that fund scientific research, and exchanged football for ultimate frisbee or table tennis.

And your response is to justify your stance?

Need I mention rap, rock, metal, etc or ufc, boxing, hockey, etc or general thug culture in the inner cities? Most kids being raised in divorced homes or getting diplomas who are somehow still illiterate?

Cmon now.
 
And your response is to justify your stance?

Need I mention rap, rock, metal, etc or ufc, boxing, hockey, etc or general thug culture in the inner cities? Most kids being raised in divorced homes or getting diplomas who are somehow still illiterate?

Cmon now.

Now you're talking about a whole other chunk of the social strata that usually ends up incarcerated instead of being middle class that aspires to go lower. Except for hockey. What do you have against someone hitting a ball at a net with a stick? :confused: That's a really fun team sport that builds self-confidence and esprit de corps in middle and high school teenagers who need to learn to rely on one another during those annoyingly awkward years betwen being a kid and an adult.
 
Now you're talking about a whole other chunk of the social strata that usually ends up incarcerated instead of being middle class that aspires to go lower. Except for hockey. What do you have against someone hitting a ball at a net with a stick? :confused: That's a really fun team sport that builds self-confidence and esprit de corps in middle and high school teenagers who need to learn to rely on one another during those annoyingly awkward years betwen being a kid and an adult.

You voted for Hope and Change didn't you? I'd love to easily refute your post but that would take time on my cell phone and my time is valuable.
 
CreepyUncleGoogle really needs to put a troll disclaimer in his sig like a certain Kat that was Skribbely so people can more easily identify the obvious trolling :D
 
CreepyUncleGoogle really needs to put a troll disclaimer in his sig like a certain Kat that was Skribbely so people can more easily identify the obvious trolling :D

If you can't figure out that it's trolling, then you deserve to be trolled. ;)
 
Back
Top