Will Wright: Games "Falling Way Short"

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
This is definitely one of those articles / interviews that just confirms all the good things you hear about Will Wright. :cool:

"I think we have an extremely powerful medium here at our disposal, and I think we've only realized a small fraction of its potential," Wright said. "It wouldn't take too many things to really impact a lot of people. Relative to what we have as a medium, with what we could be doing with it, we're falling way short."
 
Will Wright claiming that the game industry is falling short? Ok, can't say I disagree with that. Now what has Will Wright done recently to set a good example that everyone should follow because he surely follows his own ideals?

Spore.

Oh.
 
Spore... and man was that different from what they previewed us.

No kidding. I found the preview that Robin Williams played for an audience sitting on my backup drive after I played Spore. My memory did not deceive me. Half the game was missing.
 
Will Wright claiming that the game industry is falling short? Ok, can't say I disagree with that. Now what has Will Wright done recently to set a good example that everyone should follow because he surely follows his own ideals?

Spore.

Oh.

Indeed. What good is "wisdom" on the growing problems in the gaming industry when a developer so well known for games in the past and failures in more recent times doesn't set the example him/herself.

Let's hear from a developer that has made the kind of game that pushes the industry forward instead of more inflated wording from people like Will or Cliffyb..
 
To this effect we are pleased to announce the newest upcoming addition to SimCity, today we officially anounce the "Big Cities" Expansion and it's highlighted feature, slightly bigger cities!

From same article
 
Indeed. What good is "wisdom" on the growing problems in the gaming industry when a developer so well known for games in the past and failures in more recent times doesn't set the example him/herself.

Let's hear from a developer that has made the kind of game that pushes the industry forward instead of more inflated wording from people like Will or Cliffyb..

It's not even just that he doesn't set the example himself, I don't think he has to go that far. However with spore... he didn't even try. Let's face it, if Will Wright was the epitome of the greatest game developer ever, the article wouldn't need to exist because everyone would be thinking "why can't these guys be like Will Wright?". It is complete BS though to see the guy spewing such nonsense as if he's somehow better or should be treated as an example, when he's one of the worst offenders. I mean come on, spore ffs.
 
That's because every game has just become a 3D first or 3rd person button mash action game. In the past 15 years they've stripped the diversity out of the types of games. After a while they just all feel the same, even ones with goods stories.

I remember back in the day if I wanted to just blast through things I had DOOM, if I wanted a nice, turn based game that was more about getting into the story, and exploring a world, I'd play Might and Magic. If I wanted a little of both, I'd play Daggerfall.

Now the difference isn't so much. There are still shooters and 99% of the RPGs are that with stats, or massive online games.. Only real half decent games are the Elder Scrolls ones..

Who knows, maybe Might and Magic X will change things. Too much pretty over fun these days.
 
To be fair, Spore is enormously-complicated on a technical level. Wright doesn't design cookie-cutter games — the systems his games use have such a deep degree of interaction with one another and with players, and these types of systems are finicky as hell to stabilize.

He may not see what he's doing as "falling short" for that reason.
 
To be fair, Spore is enormously-complicated on a technical level. Wright doesn't design cookie-cutter games — the systems his games use have such a deep degree of interaction with one another and with players, and these types of systems are finicky as hell to stabilize.

He may not see what he's doing as "falling short" for that reason.

I'm going to agree with this. Spore was in the end a nice toy at best, and at worst a pretty crap game.

However, I don't think it's Will Wright that is to blame. It's EA! Remember our common enemy here! EA sucks so much they're horrible pieces of garbage . . . which is why I haven't purchased a game published by EA since they bought and closed Westwood Studios.

I was planning on coming in here to talk about what a hypocrite he was being, especially since the new Sim City has been a total debacle, but then I read the article and he's pretty critical of all of that.

So it's back to hating EA. Come on! Spread the EA hate!
 
Spending even a million dollars let alone 10 or 20 or 50 million dollars to bring a game to market is very risky. This is common sense.

Does Will understand that they are going to invest those dollars in something proven? Like another Call of Duty or something along those lines.

It's clearly obvious that more can be done. Thank you Capt Obvious ( Will Wright )
 
Will Wright claiming that the game industry is falling short? Ok, can't say I disagree with that. Now what has Will Wright done recently to set a good example that everyone should follow because he surely follows his own ideals?

Spore.

Oh.

Indeed, there was much potential there. SimEarth came out back in 1990 and it's still fun to play.
 
Does it even need to be said anymore. Games were great until they started making them down for consoles. Maybe its not consoles but the people who buy them or the nature of the cookie cutter process. Who knows. But the last game I was heavily into literally was one of that last PC centric games. I'm not the only one who feels that way.
 
So where is that game he was supposed to be doing with Mr. T where he fights Hi-Tech Nazis in South America?
 
Does it even need to be said anymore. Games were great until they started making them down for consoles. Maybe its not consoles but the people who buy them or the nature of the cookie cutter process. Who knows. But the last game I was heavily into literally was one of that last PC centric games. I'm not the only one who feels that way.

It's more about once the industry targets the mass audience, quality and diversity suffer. It's not that the original audience disappeared even, it's just become irrelevant. EG: I enjoyed adventure games. I remember on the boxes they'd have things like "A Blockbuster with 100,000 copies sold!"

The problem is, the larger the audience becomes, the more a developer has to dumb the game down.
 
It's more about once the industry targets the mass audience, quality and diversity suffer. It's not that the original audience disappeared even, it's just become irrelevant. EG: I enjoyed adventure games. I remember on the boxes they'd have things like "A Blockbuster with 100,000 copies sold!"

The problem is, the larger the audience becomes, the more a developer has to dumb the game down.

Yes, I think this is the bigger issue ... mass market disease ... although some game genres have suffered from the console alignment (shooters using less system killing graphics, control schemes aligned to controllers, etc) the bigger enemy has been the publisher system that isn't interested in game titles with audiences smaller than multiple millions of customers

With more publishing venues now (App stores for mobile, Steam/GOG for PC, and others) I think there might be a better market now for more niche type titles (like real time and turn based strategy, RPGs, etc)

I think if we give the developers more chances to get good games directly to their customers without the publisher filters we will ultimately see better and more challenging games :cool:
 
It's more about once the industry targets the mass audience, quality and diversity suffer. It's not that the original audience disappeared even, it's just become irrelevant. EG: I enjoyed adventure games. I remember on the boxes they'd have things like "A Blockbuster with 100,000 copies sold!"

The problem is, the larger the audience becomes, the more a developer has to dumb the game down.

I think it would be better to say "The larger the audience you are trying to attract, the fewer risks you're likely to take."

The problem isn't that games are being made to be on multiple platforms, the problem is that all people are looking to do is make a profit from their games. Spore only came out for PC, and that was still dissapointing. I feel that the problem is that the only reason some publishers are in the business is to make as much money from the games as possible. Spore itself feels like a game that EA felt was taking too long to develop, so they scaled it way back, cut out a large portion of the unfinished content/ideas, and sold it as it was.
 
With more publishing venues now (App stores for mobile, Steam/GOG for PC, and others) I think there might be a better market now for more niche type titles (like real time and turn based strategy, RPGs, etc)

Mmmm... I think it's more that there's less of a financial risk, as developers no longer have to have the capital on hand to pay to have physical materials made anymore. It means that more money can be spent on the game development itself, and they can still get a lot of publicity. In a way, it's also hurting the bigger developers, because their huge bankroll isn't QUITE as big of an advantage anymore.
 
I think it would be better to say "The larger the audience you are trying to attract, the fewer risks you're likely to take."

The problem isn't that games are being made to be on multiple platforms, the problem is that all people are looking to do is make a profit from their games. Spore only came out for PC, and that was still dissapointing. I feel that the problem is that the only reason some publishers are in the business is to make as much money from the games as possible. Spore itself feels like a game that EA felt was taking too long to develop, so they scaled it way back, cut out a large portion of the unfinished content/ideas, and sold it as it was.

Companies in general only exist to make money for the owners (CEO, board, shareholders). Customers and employees can go and screw themselves.

That is the attitude.
 
Mmmm... I think it's more that there's less of a financial risk, as developers no longer have to have the capital on hand to pay to have physical materials made anymore. It means that more money can be spent on the game development itself, and they can still get a lot of publicity. In a way, it's also hurting the bigger developers, because their huge bankroll isn't QUITE as big of an advantage anymore.

I am not sure how it would hurt the companies with too much money ... unless having to compete with younger or hungrier companies is "hurting" ... if they have good folks (or hire them) then the money is still an advantage as they can still afford to build a better game (if they want too) ;)
 
There's so much angst and whining in the gaming industry that it's hard to take any of it very seriously. It's like watching people make a big deal out of sports. It's unimportant and doesn't matter at all.
 
There's so much angst and whining in the gaming industry that it's hard to take any of it very seriously. It's like watching people make a big deal out of sports. It's unimportant and doesn't matter at all.

Get thee behind me, SATAN :p
 
There's so much angst and whining in the gaming industry that it's hard to take any of it very seriously. It's like watching people make a big deal out of sports. It's unimportant and doesn't matter at all.

There's a difference though. We become older; we evolve; games evolve. At some point, we aren't the audience anymore, the next generation of gamers is.

Sure, the people whining are a vocal minority. But in the context of a gaming audience, they often do have a valid position for their grievances.
 
There's a difference though. We become older; we evolve; games evolve. At some point, we aren't the audience anymore, the next generation of gamers is.

Sure, the people whining are a vocal minority. But in the context of a gaming audience, they often do have a valid position for their grievances.

They seem as though they're mostly the same kill, collect, build, etc. things they have been for a long time. They might look different, but they haven't changed and most certainly aren't worthy of being upset about.
 
They seem as though they're mostly the same kill, collect, build, etc. things they have been for a long time. They might look different, but they haven't changed and most certainly aren't worthy of being upset about.

Of course the broader you make something, the more similar games will be. But I wouldn't call an FPS a RTS nor would I call it an adventure game, a platformer, a turn based strategy, etc. All of the above could have kill, collect, build, etc. in them, but they're different games, and one person might not like another genre.

It's like saying all movies are stupid because they have a beginning and an end and there is conflict within the movie. Does that mean a person who enjoys Rambo is guaranteed to enjoy Pretty Woman?
 
I am not sure how it would hurt the companies with too much money ... unless having to compete with younger or hungrier companies is "hurting" ... if they have good folks (or hire them) then the money is still an advantage as they can still afford to build a better game (if they want too) ;)

It's because the companies with a lot of money aren't the ones controlling the market anymore. In the 90's, if you wanted to get your game out on the general market, you really only had the option to go through the process of getting it printed to disc and packaged in a box, and to make any significant quantity of a packaged game required a lot of money. That forced almost any developer to go through a publisher.

Now, you can submit a game to the Google Play Store, iTunes or Steam without needing to spend money on boxing and printing discs, so many developers are bypassing publishers entirely. Now, anyone who has an idea can get it on the market without the support of EA, Ubisoft or anyone else. And they get to keep their profit. EA, whom had a lot of control on the market, is not only losing that control, but now they have to compete with people that are propelled by a desire to just make games. EA still has an advantage, but it's not what it used to be.
 
To be fair, Spore is enormously-complicated on a technical level. Wright doesn't design cookie-cutter games — the systems his games use have such a deep degree of interaction with one another and with players, and these types of systems are finicky as hell to stabilize.

He may not see what he's doing as "falling short" for that reason.

You shouldn't try to 100% stabilize them. Games,... simulations are most interesting when things can go horribly wrong or when emergent behavior happens.
 
Will Wright claiming that the game industry is falling short? Ok, can't say I disagree with that. Now what has Will Wright done recently to set a good example that everyone should follow because he surely follows his own ideals?

Spore.

Oh.

This probably goes back to EA again, I remember you had to login, in order to access the game, the beginning of EA trying to control what gamers could and couldn't play. Before Origin, before the empire *strokes beard in deep thought*.

And I just found out Disney just gave green light to EA studios to work on the next bunch of Star Wars games, so those will suck, I'd like to see the finished product of this thanks http://vimeo.com/65491177
 
Of course the broader you make something, the more similar games will be. But I wouldn't call an FPS a RTS nor would I call it an adventure game, a platformer, a turn based strategy, etc. All of the above could have kill, collect, build, etc. in them, but they're different games, and one person might not like another genre.

It's like saying all movies are stupid because they have a beginning and an end and there is conflict within the movie. Does that mean a person who enjoys Rambo is guaranteed to enjoy Pretty Woman?

I'm not sure what Rambo or Pretty Woman are or why movies justify being upset about things you do for fun or to pass the time though. Regardless of how it's spun, they're supposed to be for fun. People get so emotional and throw so much money into entertainment that they lose sight of the whole reason why entertainment exists.
 
Back
Top