Windows 8.1 Allow Users to Boot to Desktop?

Win8 Start screen sucks. Put the start menu itself has sucked since vista when it went "search first".

Everyone says "just search for what you want" yeah the start bar search is often slower for me than hitting START-P-First letter of application Enter.

In corp IT, where it is hard enough to get users to use freaking anything, the start screen is not helping.

So many companies still use XP, and win8 is a HUGE departure from that (as far as a worker drone is concerned)...not just in regards to application incompatibility...but workflow compatibility is a massive issue.The last thing a company wants to do is spend tons of money to update software that slows down their employees.
 
Windows 8.1 is already confirmed to remove existing methods to bypass the quote/unquote Modern Style UI which is expected to terminate the functionality of existing products such as Start8. There are no known memo's or any other information leaks that have even remotely suggested that the Windows 8 design team is backing down. There is evidence to suggest that Microsoft intends to double down on Modern Style UI.

This is why I'd NEVER install a 3rd party app to return basic functionality to Windows 8 in an office environment, and why I'll (and I'm sure a lot of other businesses) stick to Windows 7 as long as I can.
 
I think Microsoft has a great UI with the Start Screen & Tiles, but only on a touchscreen.

IIRC from computer history, the reason the mouse was utilized was because people were able to hit the on-screen targets faster than with other available methods.

I'm unless you park the keyboard and mouse behind the monitor, basing a desktop OS around touch is absolutely asinine.

Microsoft's mistake is not the Start Screen or Tiles, it's the blanket roll out across all platforms. Metro is kinda annoying on the Xbox compared with the PS3's XMB. It's not as fluid. However, if the goal was to have a unified platform, they did the trick. Unfortunately, a screwdriver doesn't work so well to drive nails, which is what they've been trying to do with Windows 8/Metro UI.
 
Fix or dump Windows 8.- Stating the obvious.

Complete agree

Up the resolution, screen quality. - 1366x768 SHOULD NOT be a laptop standard.

Also completely agree. 1366x768 is ok for a 10" screen, but a complete waste for anything over 12 inches.
I spec out the 1920x1080 screen on the 15" laptops I buy for the office.

Improve battery life for laptops.- Makes sense since many smartphones and tablets last LONGER than most battery efficient laptops to date.
Lower the prices.- If a $300 to $400 smartphone can do pretty much 70% to 80% of the functionality of a $500 or $1200 laptop, that price makes absolutely no sense if the laptop is just used for day-to-day functions that you could technically do on a tablet.

This is where I disagree. Battery life has improved a lot over the last 5-6 years. The New 2.8Ghz i5 laptops I'm buying last 2x as long as the old 2Ghz dual core laptops, while the batteries are 1/2 the size.

Also, a tablet/phone is no comparison to most laptops when is comes to performance. Even the lowest i3 is several times faster than the typical tablet/phone CPU. Plus, how many phones/tablets have over 500GB's of disk space, or 8GB of ram?
If all you do is email/facebook it doesn't matter what you use, but comparing a stripped down app that runs on a phone/tablet to a full app that runs on a PC is just dumb.
 
Actually Apple has already started this move. Xcode was put into app store, not to be downloaded regularly anymore. Final Cut X same thing (which pissed a lot of us off in education). We have faculty who want the old version but were limited on licenses. I actually think all their products are available in the app store and almost all going away from buying in the regular store or website.

That's... a lot of wishful thinking.


Apple doesn't even do this, as there is still a differentiation of programs on OS X and apps on iOS.
If Microsoft truly does go this path, they are going to be in for an even bigger world of hurt.

This is why proprietary OSes can become dangerous.
Not to mention, do you really think that Microsoft store apps are going to be backwards compatible with the newer OSes years from now?

Before you say "that won't happen", I'm going to remind you about the gadgets in Vista/7.
Those are so handy *cough* oh wait, Microsoft discontinued them, making them all totally worthless.

Not to be cagey, but what makes you think, that when the Microsoft store is totally unsuccessful, that they won't just pull the plug on all of the apps within it?
That means, that potentially these apps may only run on Windows 8, which is great right now, but when a user has blown hundreds (if not thousands) of dollars on these apps, I don't think it is going to give the user a warm and fuzzy feeling about their apps being worthless/gone and their money lost forever.
 
Apparently Microsoft can be taught. Now give me the ability to get back the start button. I don't like the Charms Bar. Leave that shit exclusively for Metro.
 
^ Wow, that's unfortunate.
Oh well, I doubt that Apple would drop support for their apps anytime soon.

Can't say the same for Microsoft.
 
If/When my company upgrades to Windows 8, we won't be allowed to install 3rd party software.

And that is assuming the code for a start button will continue to work as windows 8 is updated.

This is pretty much PRECISELY the sticking point for I.T.-centric folks. We arent allowed to use funky 3rd party weirdness to correct MS shortcomings.
 
If Microsoft truly wants to make the tile format the next evolution of Windows, then they can't let people boot straight into the desktop. The only way to get people to use the tile/metro system to is to force it. It's going to be uncomfortable.

It's going to make Microsoft go out of business, if they keep trying to force it. Metro only sucks a little for the average computer user who doesn't do anything more intensive than Facebook. It is, however, pretty terrible for getting any kind of actual work done. It's just not an environment that allows effective multitasking, or the handling of multiple documents at once. Business clients hate it.

It's not easy for companies to jump ship, but it can happen. Macs are getting more popular with small businesses especially (if you can't afford a dedicated IT person, the much lower malware/virus susceptibility is huge) and Linux has great remote-administration tools and can be dressed up to look a lot more like what current employees are used to than Metro does. They're both viable options that will only get more viable as more companies move to them.

Hell, if I personally had to choose between working in Metro in the future or using Linux or a Mac, I'd take Linux first and the Mac second. And I liked Windows 7 a lot.
 
...Windows 8.1 is already confirmed to remove existing methods to bypass the quote/unquote Modern Style UI which is expected to terminate the functionality of existing products such as Start8.

If true I will be more than happy to take the money I am giving Microsoft and donate it to Linux.
 
If true I will be more than happy to take the money I am giving Microsoft and donate it to Linux.
Not to difficult to research updates before installing them to see what they do, as you should be anyways. Once you see that an update removes said code then you click 'hide update" and not worry about it.
 
...I'm afraid that I have to say this rumor is false.

Windows 8.1 is already confirmed to remove existing methods to bypass the quote/unquote Modern Style UI which is expected to terminate the functionality of existing products such as Start8. There are no known memo's or any other information leaks that have even remotely suggested that the Windows 8 design team is backing down. There is evidence to suggest that Microsoft intends to double down on Modern Style UI.

Actually, it's startisback's problem for using undocumented code in windows for their product. Start8, Pokki and several other start menu replacements worked just fine or needed a minor update to work in 8.1 and they are working just fine currently. '

Stop falling for linkbait and actually do some research. The fud is starting to become comically bad.
 
This NBC article makes some very good points regarding the PC vs. tablet/smartphone issue

even more stupid comments of the nbc article:

However, few apps take advantage of all that extra performance. Where Windows Vista pushed the hardware envelope with an Aero interface that required faster components than many users had, Windows 8 and all of its apps shoot for the lowest common denominator.

The NBC article is just some of the things you would write when you are on drugs and don't care about the world anymore.

And then this:

PC manufacturers need to work with Microsoft and other software publishers to build more must-have apps that require or at least take advantage of newer processors. As it stands, most users don’t see a reason to upgrade from a first-gen Core i3 to a third-gen Core i7.

The problem is that the person from the NBC staff has no clue doesn't know what he is talking about and never will get a clue for as long as he lives, unless we get taken over by the Borg and finally he maybe can adept.


Some other things, the idea is not about the desktop dear god that is so sad again , Windows was made to run METRO UI, when that fails you paid for it and as a consolation prize you get Windows 7 UI. Now you get Windows 7 UI just from booting windows 8 which was already possible if you knew what you were doing.

Fix the stupid touch screen interface MS , JUST DO IT , stop wasting all of our time, stealing UI been done before YOU CAN DO IT AGAIN!!!.
 
I think you just aren't seeing what the article was trying to say.

in 2006, $400 machines had been around for a while and for the average consumer those systems were plenty for what they were doing. Vista however, ran poorly on most of those systems either because those systems didn't have the graphical horsepower or just simply didn't come with enough memory. A prettier looking system wasn't enough to get people to spend more money on a system that could run Vista properly so it's performance left a sour taste in people's mouth.

The same thing is happening now with 8. There's little to no $400 computers that have touch capabilities and people don't see the need to pay more for systems that do. Even if there were touch systems that cheap most consumers PC that they purchased 4 years ago is running just fine because with the exception of games surfing the web and doing office work does not require faster computers.

Modern may run power users off, but the vast majority is doing fine with their current system, and a $200 tablet. Bringing the desktop back isn't going to change that.
 
No new lines of code needed, more like lines of code removed or replaced.

MS put a lot of work to make boot to desktop impossible with out 3rd party tools.
 
This all goes back to what I thought would be the best method for transitioning. Making new features.... Optional. Giving us the option to boot to desktop should have been their since the beginning. As well as the 'option' to have a start button. This way people can find what they like best of both interfaces and use the one that works for them... You know I'm a PC, it is what I wanted. Somehow what I and many others wanted isn't the concern of M$ this time around. Perhaps by Win9 people will tolerate and at least know what metro is and have had some experience using it.

At least this is a step in the right direction if this is so.
 
Comments inline...

This NBC article makes some very good points regarding the PC vs. tablet/smartphone issue:

http://www.nbcnews.com/technology/gadgetbox/7-ways-bring-back-pc-1C9319686

  1. Fix or dump Windows 8. - Stating the obvious.

    Yes. Fix the issues.
  2. Improve battery life for laptops. - Makes sense since many smartphones and tablets last LONGER than most battery efficient laptops to date.

    Lets be real here. A laptop is a larger device supporting more power-hungry components than any tablet or smartphone. There is more screen area to be backlit, HDDs or SSDs to power, accessory ports, along with fans and other mechanical parts. Given the power consumption differences, laptops and ultrabooks have made good progress in battery life improvement. This trend will undoubtedly continue, but is not lacking some major step.
  3. Up the resolution, screen quality. - 1366x768 SHOULD NOT be a laptop standard. Makes absolutely no sense when a $300 to $400 smartphone has a higher resolution than your $300 to $400 laptop.

    I want to agree that 1366x768 should not be the standard. However, the comparison to tablets/smartphones is incorrect because of the larger surface area that a laptop presents and needs to power. Increasing resolution to 1920x1080 creates additional cost from needing more GPU power. That $300 or $400 laptop suddenly becomes $50-$100 more expensive. There is no need to demonstrate this, just look at how much laptops with higher resolution cost, they already exist. So if the standard is higher resolution, this will directly be related in the price. I am OK with that - but I suspect the average consumer would not be. Hence if you want cheap, then you have lower resolution.
  4. Lower the prices. - If a $300 to $400 smartphone can do pretty much 70% to 80% of the functionality of a $500 or $1200 laptop, that price makes absolutely no sense if the laptop is just used for day-to-day functions that you could technically do on a tablet.

    First, there is a large difference between a $500 and $1200 laptop in terms of functionality, quality, and performance (processing speed, storage space, memory, screen quality, resolution, built in peripherals, etc).
    A tablet or smartphone most certainly cannot perform %70-80 functionality of a higher end laptop.
    Second, if you are doing only day-to-day functions such as using the web then I agree with your point. Surely a laptop can be optimized to maintain the same performance & functionality as last year's model with newer more efficient and cheaper parts, thereby lowering the price or keeping it the same as last year (no increase). Doing day-to-day functions, yes a tablet or smartphone can probably do about 70% of what that laptop does.
  5. Preload powerful software. - Heck, many smartphones and tablets are preloaded with better preloaded software than the bloatware and trial software on laptops.

    The bloatware and trial software are from old business models, prior to smarthphone/tablet popularity. I agree -- these need to go. However, the base functionality of the laptop OS as preloaded software is very reasonable. Remember, that with smartphones and tablets, some of the more useful preloaded 'Apps' are simply interfaces to web services such as email, online calendars, or online storage and require a data connection which you pay for. These same services can be consumed through a browser and unless you want a specific application installed to do the same on a laptop, using the browser (1 app) is far cleaner. This of course IS possible with Win 8, it does have those preloaded apps just like Apple/Google smartphones or tablets. So not sure if that's a point for or against. :confused:
  6. Focus on build quality. - Stating another obvious.

    Build quality = higher price in the immediate. Price becomes more reasonable over time. All devices suffer equally from this concept.
  7. Utilize all that processing power. - Again, stating the obvious.

    This is more up to individual applications than just the OS. I can always go for more efficiency though and the OS is the most basic place to make advances.

    Makes sense. Why upgrade to Haswell, for example, if you're Sandy Bridge or Intel Core 2 Duo can run practically all the software released up to now and play your current games released up to now? It's a lot of wasted processing power that doesn't get fully used. And, many computer systems will last 3 to 5 years because of the software, hence no need to upgrade to newer processors and systems.

    Agreed, system longevity has increased with more powerful and efficient components along with software improvements in efficiency and performance to where 'upgrading' every 2-3 years is no longer necessary to keep up with software/application demand. Upgrades now are moreso for innovative changes or functionality, which is why smartphones and tablets are so popular. They let you do things due to form factor, portability, long battery life, etc. that you wished you could do with a laptop years and years ago but was never practical (can't whip a laptop out of your pocket to take a picture! CAN sit on train with laptop but its uncomfortable, tablet is MUCH better, etc.).

Sorry for long post folks :p
 
Boot to desktop does not mean the traditional desktop interface with start menu will be there.
 
http://www.classicshell.net/

Problem is solved. Add the edit button in here...............

This really doesn't even solve half the problems with Windows 8.
Things it doesn't solve:

Default app launch behavior, were if you click on RDP it maximizes the current RDP ression as opposed to giving you the dialog for a new RDP session, which is desired behavior. If you wanted the current RDP session you'd just click on that as opposed to the icon to launch a new one. RDP is just an example, this happens to all apps.

Default bullshit Windows 8 apps. When I want to look at an image I don't want it to be full screen, I want it to be in a window (as it has always been for decades) so that I can easily tab between stuff I am working on and whatever screenshot I need to look at.

Windows Update behavior, location. Try to easily access Windows update to run updates on your own schedule, or using the "notify and download, but don't install unless I tell you". Though this is less of an issue for corporate users.

The list goes on and on and on, and yes, you can change most of that over to how 7 used to be, but why bother when you can just run 7 and not worry about any of it. There is zero value proposition in paying for 8 and then spending lots of time to make it work like 7.
 
This really doesn't even solve half the problems with Windows 8.
Things it doesn't solve:

Default app launch behavior, were if you click on RDP it maximizes the current RDP ression as opposed to giving you the dialog for a new RDP session, which is desired behavior. If you wanted the current RDP session you'd just click on that as opposed to the icon to launch a new one. RDP is just an example, this happens to all apps.

Default bullshit Windows 8 apps. When I want to look at an image I don't want it to be full screen, I want it to be in a window (as it has always been for decades) so that I can easily tab between stuff I am working on and whatever screenshot I need to look at.

Windows Update behavior, location. Try to easily access Windows update to run updates on your own schedule, or using the "notify and download, but don't install unless I tell you". Though this is less of an issue for corporate users.

The list goes on and on and on, and yes, you can change most of that over to how 7 used to be, but why bother when you can just run 7 and not worry about any of it. There is zero value proposition in paying for 8 and then spending lots of time to make it work like 7.

1. Hold shift when you click. This isn't just a thing in Windows 8. 7 acts the same way by default.

2. Assign another app to pictures. You can do this in the control panel, or by right-clicking on the file, choose open with and check always open with this app.

3. Yes Windows Update can be improved and a lot of this will change in 8.1 so there won't be two different versions anymore.
 
When your in TIFKAM you should be able to tap escape too to get to the desktop, that always annoys me. Escape has ALWAYS closed the "start menu"
 
I cannot stand the people who want a Start Menu. WTF it was a bad way to find a program ESPECIALLY in corporate/education market. Lets say you made a folder called Google and put picasa in it, some people would not know its google and complain. Search is the way to go which windows 8 still has let alone, when you open All programs IT IS A START MENU but without having to expand each option so you can actually read for a name like picasa even if its in the Google group. Now a Start Page Button would be helpful for remote sessions or vms, gets hard to get that mouse in that particular location. As for giving people the ability to boot up to desktop, microsoft should for atleast this OS. I still see the desktop being needed for 3-4 years until every app is made into the microsoft store. Ability to run metro apps in windows is already available from stardock program so microsoft should do this as well. I want to have the time on my 2nd screen while gaming on my 1st screen. Even if move my metro to the 2nd screen it goes away and the TIME with it. Would be helpful having it as a widget like window OR add the time to the 2nd taskbar too!

Oh, so you like having like 30+ tiles for every program you install???? Stuff like MS Office and Visual Studio and any other programs that also install aditional links for utilities, help, etc all add an extra tile for each regular shortcut that would normally be under the program's folder in the start menu.

Yeah, like that is making it easy to find stuff. The tile setup is a huge mess and not usefull at all unless you don't actually use your computer for anything other than surfing the web.
 
This really doesn't even solve half the problems with Windows 8.
Things it doesn't solve:

Default app launch behavior, were if you click on RDP it maximizes the current RDP ression as opposed to giving you the dialog for a new RDP session, which is desired behavior. If you wanted the current RDP session you'd just click on that as opposed to the icon to launch a new one. RDP is just an example, this happens to all apps.

1. Hold shift when you click. This isn't just a thing in Windows 8. 7 acts the same way by default.

yeah win7 does the same thing. just to add, middle clicking (or mouse wheel clicking) also does the same thing. it's what i do to launch multiple windows explorer windows.


amen
 
Oh, so you like having like 30+ tiles for every program you install???? Stuff like MS Office and Visual Studio and any other programs that also install aditional links for utilities, help, etc all add an extra tile for each regular shortcut that would normally be under the program's folder in the start menu.

Yeah, like that is making it easy to find stuff. The tile setup is a huge mess and not usefull at all unless you don't actually use your computer for anything other than surfing the web.

That is my biggest problem with the start screen. As a programmer I have over 100 applications installed on every development box and most of these have 5 or more attentional links in the Start Menu. I would certainly not want all this crap on a start screen nor would I want to spend hours to organize this.
 
yeah win7 does the same thing. just to add, middle clicking (or mouse wheel clicking) also does the same thing. it's what i do to launch multiple windows explorer windows.

I don't know which Windows 7 you guys are using, but when I launch RDP it doesn't bring up my existing RDP session, it starts a new one. Which is the same behavior any other apps have. I am reasonably sure that I didn't edit anything to make that happen.
 
useless ModernUI... the only time i'm in there (in there cuz it feels like a separate part of the OS) is when i'm launching a program that doesn't have a shortcut on my desktop

otherwise, all it does is use up resources by leaving ModernUI apps running in the background (unless you practice Alt-F4 closing on ModernUI apps)

in desktop mode... i can easily monitor running programs by glancing at the always-present taskbar
 
I think you just aren't seeing what the article was trying to say.

in 2006, $400 machines had been around for a while and for the average consumer those systems were plenty for what they were doing. Vista however, ran poorly on most of those systems either because those systems didn't have the graphical horsepower or just simply didn't come with enough memory. A prettier looking system wasn't enough to get people to spend more money on a system that could run Vista properly so it's performance left a sour taste in people's mouth.

The same thing is happening now with 8. There's little to no $400 computers that have touch capabilities and people don't see the need to pay more for systems that do. Even if there were touch systems that cheap most consumers PC that they purchased 4 years ago is running just fine because with the exception of games surfing the web and doing office work does not require faster computers.

Modern may run power users off, but the vast majority is doing fine with their current system, and a $200 tablet. Bringing the desktop back isn't going to change that.

This pretty much sums it up.

If you look for a $300 to $500 computer that has Windows 8 pre-installed that can do day-to-day tasks and some light gaming, they don't have touchscreens.

But, if you look for a tablet at $300 to $500 tablets, they're all touchscreens with screen resolutions between 1024x600 to 1920x1080. No $300 to $500 laptop has both.

And, those with an older generation Core 2 Duo or Phenom II-- mobile or desktop-- are still able to run a good majority of the regular productivity software and browsers released between the time the processor was released and to now, and most likely for the next few years. So, what is the point of upgrading to a newer processor?

Does it make sense to upgrade to Haswell or Athlon FX if the software you use now still runs fine? Or the games still run at a good framerate?

It only makes sense if you want to move to Haswell for the power improvements, but that seems like the only wanted feature. Most consumers, actually the majority of them, will not notice or care about the 5% to 10% improvement over Ivy Bridge or Sandy Bridge.

Therefore, the PC market stagnates or slows to a crawl while tablets that are practically upgraded in hardware each year with better features that can do a lot of those day-to-day tasks sans productivity software are increasing in market share.

Thus, Microsoft and Windows 8 finds itself stuck between a rock and a hard place. Touchscreen tablets and ultrabooks with Windows 8 are priced higher than the entry-level and midrange laptops that people buy the most and can afford. And, those entry-level and midrange laptops in the $300 to $500 range have lower resolution than more expensive WIndows 8 tablets and ultrabooks, and many tablets in the same price range. At the same time, for having Windows 8 pre-installed, they don't have touchscreens that allow the touch features of the OS to be utilized.

Then, we get to the desktop PCs. Only touchscreens available to desktops are in the higher-priced-- usually $800 to $1000-plus-- all-in-one computers. Why buy an all-in-one computer that's in that price range when a non-touchscreen desktop PC at $400 to $600 can do similar functions? It makes no logical sense honestly spending that much more for touchscreen capability to use Windows 8. That and the majority of OEM LCD monitors are not touchscreen enabled either.

So, several things have to happen if Microsoft expects Windows 8 and future versions to succeed:
  1. OEMs need to price-match touchscreen LCD monitors to that of tablet LCD screens.
  2. OEMs need to price-match or lower the price of higher resolution LCD screens-- 1600x900 to 1920x1080-- to that of tablet LCD screens so they can be used on lower-end and mid-range laptops and desktops; as well as provide touchscreen capability. All the while still maintaining the $300 to $500 price range of these entry-level and midrange desktop and laptop PCs.
  3. OEMs need to get their foot out of their fucking ass and stop pricing desktop and notebook processors higher than tablet SoCs, so that laptops and desktops don't have to be priced higher than tablets that can do similar day-to-day functionality of most PCs.
  4. OEMs need to get desktop and notebook PCs be priced competitively against tablets, which offer more capability and functionality than tablets themselves.
Price matters first and foremost to the majority of the consumers out there. Features come second. If an Android/iOS tablet can do most of what a $300 to $500 laptop can do with Windows 8 at the same price, and offer touchscreen capability, the consumer will go for the tablet.

Therefore, it's either that above or Microsoft needs to scrap the touchscreen features for non-touchscreen enabled desktops and notebooks, or set them as an optional, non-default feature of Windows 8.

Either way, Microsoft or the OEMs have to cave in to market demands if they want to compete and/or succeed against mobile devices.
 
Touch screens only work on small screens.

Why? I can move my mouse 1" and cover 10" of screen. If I have to use my hand, it takes much longer.

And it moves a hand away from the keyboard.

We tried some touch screens for icon-based tech software. Nobody used the touch function after 2 months.

And we have three large Touchscreen computers at home. Nobody uses the touch feature. It's not wanted, even by casual users.

Food Chain = Keyboard>Mouse>Touch

It might surprise people, but you could fill out a spreadsheet or document before the mouse was around. The biggest difference is it's faster not to have a mouse in a work environment. For CAD software and the like, you needed the mouse or digitizer tablet. When mice were $400, few desktops had them.
 
Well at some point you're still gonna have to use the start screen:rolleyes:

and yep here we go with the weekly windows 8 sucks thread:p is that popcorn done? :D
 
Pfft. According to many "in the know" Windows 8 works exactly the same as Windows 7. Microsoft doesn't know it's own product. That's Microsoft's biggest problem. It doesn't know that when something looks different and works different it's really the same. :rolleyes:
 
I think you just aren't seeing what the article was trying to say.

in 2006, $400 machines had been around for a while and for the average consumer those systems were plenty for what they were doing. Vista however, ran poorly on most of those systems either because those systems didn't have the graphical horsepower or just simply didn't come with enough memory. A prettier looking system wasn't enough to get people to spend more money on a system that could run Vista properly so it's performance left a sour taste in people's mouth.
.

Which comes down to MS does not have a clue on what they are doing because they are not the people who produce an Operating System based on consumer needs they produce due to monopoly of the market hence no innovation piss poor features and laughable (yes laughable) memory usage .

Look at Android supposedly started in 2005 released in 2008 and guess what it delivers.

My guess is that you are not some n00b , you can clearly see over the years that MS can not do these things right because of the difference how the market is addressed , consumer based vs monopoly driven.

I would almost say it is impossible for MS to do it right. If Linux was anything else then open source then MS would have bought it and ran away with it already.
 
Well at some point you're still gonna have to use the start screen:rolleyes:

and yep here we go with the weekly windows 8 sucks thread:p is that popcorn done? :D

The day I'm forced to have to use the start screen, metro ui, in built apps is the day I format and go back to 7. I don't mind 8 as it is (even though the desktop is relatively ugly compared to 7 or Vista, or even XP to be honest), but I have no use for these "great new features" they put in place. I don't want them, don't need them, and don't have any intentions of altering my computer habits to add these things into my life.

Beyond that, I still like 8. Not as huge of a jump as was XP to 7 when I got that, but it's ok. Could have been worse, I suppose...
 
Which comes down to MS does not have a clue on what they are doing because they are not the people who produce an Operating System based on consumer needs they produce due to monopoly of the market hence no innovation piss poor features and laughable (yes laughable) memory usage .

Look at Android supposedly started in 2005 released in 2008 and guess what it delivers.

My guess is that you are not some n00b , you can clearly see over the years that MS can not do these things right because of the difference how the market is addressed , consumer based vs monopoly driven.

I would almost say it is impossible for MS to do it right. If Linux was anything else then open source then MS would have bought it and ran away with it already.


Yes, they got that they reached too far with Vista, which is why they spent a lot of time optimizing for lower memory systems in 7 and went further in 8.

But I still think you would say that Microsoft's head is still in the sand if they didn't make a big move to touch in 8 since Android and iOS shows it's the future. Problem is, the OEMs weren't ready, and not forcing people to be in people's faces will make it just like the touch extensions in XP, Vista and 7 largely ignored and rarely developed for.
 
Seems to me that Win8 would be a lot more accepted if there were 2 modes:

- Tablet mode (Metro)
- Win7/Classic/Desktop mode

IMO Win8's metro on a tablet device isn't half bad. For a desktop, it has more problems. MS shouldn't force people on a desktop to use a tablet interface and visa versa. Granted adoption rates for Win8 apps will proablby be slower, but the Win8 OS might gain more traction and in the long run help out the Win8 apps.
 
I think I am going far against the status quo here, but I really like Windows 8. I think it is a move forward in just about every way possible. I have it on three machines at home. I have to use several different versions of Windows at work for managing Windows Server 2003/2008 R2/2012 and I always cringe at the limitations of XP particularly.

One click to the desktop doesn't seem to be that big of a deal to me. I also find the shortcut to the management tasks (right click in the lower-left hand corner if you haven't found this...took me a while) far more useful than having to navigate multiple menus to get to most of the stuff I use often.

I do understand the pains of legacy apps and have to move platforms, but I don't want to muck around with a computer when I do it all day at work, and Windows 8 generally gets out of my way and just lets me do what I need do.

And, no, I do not work for Microsoft :p
 
I think I am going far against the status quo here, but I really like Windows 8.

It's as much as individuals as it is about anything really. Microsoft may have to address the declining desktop market by offering the old UI and a Metro off switch. I think that would be a pretty serious blow to Microsoft because I doubt that such options would do much to change the course of traditional desktop and laptop sales even if the PR came across well. And those options would slow the development of the new UI.

After 18 months of Windows 8 daily across different form factors and input methods, 8 is capable of a lot, perhaps too much. The UI is on the complex side and it does make more sense if one uses it on a touch screen or with some type of touch input what supports gestures. This complexity added with a lot of unfinished parts do make it rough product. I do think that a good number of keyboard and mouse users can be made somewhat happier with refinements in the new UI without the need to bring back the old UI in the box. How successful Microsoft will be in that venture in 8.1, I have no idea.
 
Back
Top