There is so much wrong info posted in this thread:
- Trinity uses Piledriver cores, a slight revision of Bulldozer. It's a big and hot and isn't a good fit for consoles (it would also be expensive given the low TDP required meaning crap yields)
- Jaguar is a brand new core microarchitecture from AMD. It's a redesign of the older Bobcat cores and promises up to 50% better performance.
- 8 Jaguar cores are being used for the PS4 as well as the new Xbox.
- The Kabini/Kaveri APU (it's the same die) uses the same Jaguar cores and 2 GCN CUs. It was designed to provide very good performance for a small TDP and great perf-per-watt (5-25W TDP for dual and quadcore versions)
- The PS4's die is actually an APU with a slightly-more-powerful 7850 GPU coupled with 8 Jaguar cores and who knows what else. The GPU and the CPU feed off of the same memory and sit right next to each other, chatting it up while mixing up the workload.
- The 8GB of GDDR5 means that both the CPU and GPU will be fed from the same, incredibly fast memory. This gives the CPU and GPU a lot more wiggle room and prevents and potential bottlenecks (which you see in even high end desktop CPUs). Because of the 8GB GDDR5, it wouldn't surprise me to see some console games having better physics performance on the console than on a PC with much better hardware.
- The ISAs aren't brand-spanking new, but it does feature goodies such as AVX2 and F16C. It lacks FMA3/4, but I'm guessing it wasn't worth the die space.
Now the nVidia portion:
Sony and Microsoft both wanted/needed x86. Obviously, nVidia can't provide that, but they could have provided them with a decent ARM SoC and a fast GPU. nVidia is right in that it would have been far too expensive for them to provide the consoles with the proper CPU they need, but that's mainly to due with nVidia still failing to provide a core microarchitecture of their own. Their current ARM SoCs use bog standard ARM core which just wouldn't be enough to power a next-gen console (you could argue that the A15s have that power, but there's still a tremendous benefit with opting to go with x86). In short, nVidia just doesn't have the engineers nor the x86 license to provide a CPU for the next-gen consoles. AMD has the CPU - though AMD stick at the high end, their low end processors are great - and they can couple that with their GCN architecture.
nVidia never had a shot at winning the next gen consoles given AMD marketing their APUs. Where nVidia could have provided a GPU, AMD is able to provide both sides of the die and do it cheaper than nVidia+CPU can do it. I don't think AMD will make a killing from these consoles off the hardware sales, but the potential advantage that AMD gains across their entire lineup of products (all of the discrete GPUs will use the same architecture as the consoles) means nVidia will have to work much much harder to equal AMD's natural performance advantage due to developers targeting their cards specifically. IMO, that's the biggest issue facing nVidia going forward. Are they going to dedicate millions and millions of dollars with a newer version of TWIMTBP just to get on an even keel with AMD? I'm not sure about that.
nVidia is going to have to win the architectural race for years to come just to break even with respect to performance with AMD, and I just don't see that happening considering how the last few years have played out. They've been pretty much neck and neck, but now the developers are heavily in AMD's favor.
- Trinity uses Piledriver cores, a slight revision of Bulldozer. It's a big and hot and isn't a good fit for consoles (it would also be expensive given the low TDP required meaning crap yields)
- Jaguar is a brand new core microarchitecture from AMD. It's a redesign of the older Bobcat cores and promises up to 50% better performance.
- 8 Jaguar cores are being used for the PS4 as well as the new Xbox.
- The Kabini/Kaveri APU (it's the same die) uses the same Jaguar cores and 2 GCN CUs. It was designed to provide very good performance for a small TDP and great perf-per-watt (5-25W TDP for dual and quadcore versions)
- The PS4's die is actually an APU with a slightly-more-powerful 7850 GPU coupled with 8 Jaguar cores and who knows what else. The GPU and the CPU feed off of the same memory and sit right next to each other, chatting it up while mixing up the workload.
- The 8GB of GDDR5 means that both the CPU and GPU will be fed from the same, incredibly fast memory. This gives the CPU and GPU a lot more wiggle room and prevents and potential bottlenecks (which you see in even high end desktop CPUs). Because of the 8GB GDDR5, it wouldn't surprise me to see some console games having better physics performance on the console than on a PC with much better hardware.
- The ISAs aren't brand-spanking new, but it does feature goodies such as AVX2 and F16C. It lacks FMA3/4, but I'm guessing it wasn't worth the die space.
Now the nVidia portion:
Sony and Microsoft both wanted/needed x86. Obviously, nVidia can't provide that, but they could have provided them with a decent ARM SoC and a fast GPU. nVidia is right in that it would have been far too expensive for them to provide the consoles with the proper CPU they need, but that's mainly to due with nVidia still failing to provide a core microarchitecture of their own. Their current ARM SoCs use bog standard ARM core which just wouldn't be enough to power a next-gen console (you could argue that the A15s have that power, but there's still a tremendous benefit with opting to go with x86). In short, nVidia just doesn't have the engineers nor the x86 license to provide a CPU for the next-gen consoles. AMD has the CPU - though AMD stick at the high end, their low end processors are great - and they can couple that with their GCN architecture.
nVidia never had a shot at winning the next gen consoles given AMD marketing their APUs. Where nVidia could have provided a GPU, AMD is able to provide both sides of the die and do it cheaper than nVidia+CPU can do it. I don't think AMD will make a killing from these consoles off the hardware sales, but the potential advantage that AMD gains across their entire lineup of products (all of the discrete GPUs will use the same architecture as the consoles) means nVidia will have to work much much harder to equal AMD's natural performance advantage due to developers targeting their cards specifically. IMO, that's the biggest issue facing nVidia going forward. Are they going to dedicate millions and millions of dollars with a newer version of TWIMTBP just to get on an even keel with AMD? I'm not sure about that.
nVidia is going to have to win the architectural race for years to come just to break even with respect to performance with AMD, and I just don't see that happening considering how the last few years have played out. They've been pretty much neck and neck, but now the developers are heavily in AMD's favor.