Microsoft Sued Over Windows Live Tiles

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Microsoft is being sued over the "Live Tiles" it uses in its phones and Windows 8 RT.

SurfCast, in a complaint filed yesterday in a U.S. District Court in Maine, said Microsoft infringes one of its four patents -- No. 6,724,403 -- by "making, using, selling, and offering to sell devices and software products" covered by SurfCast's patent. That includes mobile devices using the Windows Phone 7 and Windows Phone 8 operating systems as well as PCs using Windows 8/RT. The company also said Microsoft is contributing to infringement by encouraging developers to make app tiles for the Windows Store.
 
Shit Apple gonna sue them tiles are like squares and rectangles, oh wait these don't have rounded corners m$ is safe.
 
They thought of the technology first?

Are you kidding me? This is almost as stupid as slide to unlock.
 
Another case of an obvious invention. If it's obvious the patent should be invalidated.

The patent office needs to stop employing cromagnon for "diversity."
 
They thought of the technology first?

Are you kidding me? This is almost as stupid as slide to unlock.

Another case of an obvious invention. If it's obvious the patent should be invalidated.

The patent office needs to stop employing cromagnon for "diversity."

The patent was applied for back in 2000. Back then, something like that probably was a pretty novel idea.
 
its been introduced for how many years now, and this is the first time they sued? lol

Im still not comfortable of the new UI on the desktop, but for the mobile smartphone and tablets, it really is something else, so Im not calling it stupid
 
...and where were they when WP7 was launched?

Typical troll. Sit on patents (that never should have been issued in the first place, as they don't meet the "novel, useful and non-obvious" requirement) and then spring them on a large company after they've committed to something big and cant turn back...

Scum of the earth.

I bet they aren't even using said patent to make anything of their own...

IMHO, the way to solve the portion of patent trolling committed by those who just sit on patents, is to enact a automatic invalidation of any patent that is not actively being used in a current product by the patent holder, after a certain period of time.

It still wouldn't solve the Apple/Google/Motorola/Samsung/Oracle mess, but it would deal with a lot of these stinkers who do nothing with their patents but troll, and try to profit off of others success.
 
Looks like someone has a patent on geometry. Pythagoras was unavailable for comment.
 
After reading the patents, these are two completely different ideas.
SurfCast was looking at cropping full images an displaying them as "tiles"
Microsoft is looking at using "tiles" as icons, or summarized info.

SurftCast does have a legit patent, but not in the context they using it to sue.
 
its been introduced for how many years now, and this is the first time they sued? lol

That's how the serious trolls operate.

They sit on their patents, and try to give them as vague descriptions as possible so they don't easily show up in patent searches.

Then they wait for a large company to commit to a developed product past the point of no return, and THEN they strike.

Scum of the earth.


And they usually win to, cause it winds up being cheaper to settle with them, than fight them in court.
 
That was my first thought...lol! If M$ won't do it then maybe the courts will. :D

Nah, nothing in Win8 is going to go anywhere. MS will give SurfCast a big fat check (well, big fat to SurfCast, petty cash to MS) to license the "technology" and everyone will be happy.
 
its been introduced for how many years now, and this is the first time they sued? lol

Im still not comfortable of the new UI on the desktop, but for the mobile smartphone and tablets, it really is something else, so Im not calling it stupid

It's more profitable to wait until a product goes on sale because you can sue for actual damages instead of just getting a court to tell someone they can't sell something. There's a better chance that money can change hands.

What'll probably happen, if Microsoft doesn't think they have a very strong case, is they'll just pay the patent holder to license the technology. Metro is too important for their corporate strategy for them to simply stop now and "reimagine" a new UI which they'd hafta do since they already bashed their old UI so bad that backpedaling would make them look really stupid to their customers/the planet.
 
Idk. Maybe it was in an episode of star trek, but unless someone produces something I have to believe they get the rights for being novel.

And if you can patent a 1-click purchase on a webpage, you can patent this. Not that I agree with the ability to patent the 1-click purchase.

As far as I can tell, they have a case. Whether they should have a case is another story.
 
It's more profitable to wait until a product goes on sale because you can sue for actual damages instead of just getting a court to tell someone they can't sell something. There's a better chance that money can change hands.

What'll probably happen, if Microsoft doesn't think they have a very strong case, is they'll just pay the patent holder to license the technology. Metro is too important for their corporate strategy for them to simply stop now and "reimagine" a new UI which they'd hafta do since they already bashed their old UI so bad that backpedaling would make them look really stupid to their customers/the planet.

Right now with the potential payoff, they have enough investors backing them up to be able to field a legal team to challenge Microsoft. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if some law office found them after checking on patents to offer to sue over wrt W8.
 
So they have a technology that allows for live updates in sections of your desktop....oh where have I seen this technology before http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Active_Desktop

Maybe they have a footing using Tiles but the push idea was used by MS way before they came up with the idea.

Could you launch resident applications with Acitve Desktop? They patent is they are both active and serve the roll of launch icon.
 
Right now with the potential payoff, they have enough investors backing them up to be able to field a legal team to challenge Microsoft. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if some law office found them after checking on patents to offer to sue over wrt W8.

Maybe so. Lawyers sometimes have to be responsible for generating their own business in order to maintain an adequate revenue stream. Kudos to them if they were smart enough to do that and make a profit at it. Practicing law is pretty competitive because lots of people enter the field thinking that it's like getting instant money and it just isn't like that once they get there so they have to do what they can to generate income.
 
The patent seems kind of vague, like when I have 6 separate programs up (sized so I can see them all at once) am I infringing on their patent?
While they are at it, they should sue google over android widgets, since they can display different kinds of information in separate "squares".
 
its been introduced for how many years now, and this is the first time they sued? lol

This is exactly what i was thinking......wait until the company makes a shit load of money off of it and then do something about it instead of blocking the design to start? Sounds like a bogus patent if they have had it since 2000 and did nothing with it.
 
Prior art

Windows_98.jpg


I'll say it again : Patents are bullshit that have no place in a free society. It is nothing more than economic rent seeking in which a crony capitalist engages in collaboration with the state to use violence and coercion to suppress competition. Patents do not encourage innovation; they do the exact opposite by allowing shysters to terrorize productive members of society.
 
The question I have did Microsoft seek patent protection for their version? Sounds like they did. So how much sympathy should we have?
 
I'm going to patent variables. Since it is not defined until used then it will apply to everything and I expect payment from all software companies everywhere by 12:00 PM tomorrow or you will all be hearing from my lawyer who I have yet to hire.
 
Prior art

Windows_98.jpg


I'll say it again : Patents are bullshit that have no place in a free society. It is nothing more than economic rent seeking in which a crony capitalist engages in collaboration with the state to use violence and coercion to suppress competition. Patents do not encourage innovation; they do the exact opposite by allowing shysters to terrorize productive members of society.

They do have a place - but should never be allowed to become never ending rights to something like the MPAA managed to do. They should also have a more rigorous litmus test for giving one out.

Robert_Kearns certainly had a real case for his patent.
 
They do have a place - but should never be allowed to become never ending rights to something like the MPAA managed to do. They should also have a more rigorous litmus test for giving one out.

Robert_Kearns certainly had a real case for his patent.
patents def have a place but esp dealing with software there needs to be something adjusted on what counts, and also time life. What default is 17 years? Which allows for patent an idea and then invest in time for development etc but 17 years is a bit much for software, i think exclusivity needs to be adjusted to like 3 4 years after release of initial product. If you're not bringing anything to market then you shouldn't be able to profit off the idea, because you failed to bring it to fruition.
 
It's more profitable to wait until a product goes on sale because you can sue for actual damages instead of just getting a court to tell someone they can't sell something. There's a better chance that money can change hands.
This rings of the piracy argument of "how is a loss of a sale that never would be an actual loss?" since the troll has had all that time to bring it to market to sell, probability is high that they never will, hence no actual monetary damages. Yeah I know they could, but we all know how often patent trolls actually do...never.
Maybe I'm mistaken, but I was under the impression that you used to have to build an actual working prototype in order to get a patent.
Patents should be "use 'em or lose 'em" in nature.
Apple's App icons must not have advanced enough features to qualify them for a suit.
 
Surfcast is way overreaching. As long as east texas doesn't get the case ms should be fine.

And lol, someone needs to show the troll windows 1.0. :p
 
This rings of the piracy argument of "how is a loss of a sale that never would be an actual loss?" since the troll has had all that time to bring it to market to sell, probability is high that they never will, hence no actual monetary damages. Yeah I know they could, but we all know how often patent trolls actually do...never.
Maybe I'm mistaken, but I was under the impression that you used to have to build an actual working prototype in order to get a patent.
Patents should be "use 'em or lose 'em" in nature.
Apple's App icons must not have advanced enough features to qualify them for a suit.

It would make sense if you had to have a working whatever-it-is and be sort of silly if you could patent something without at least having a product or prototype that can be reasonably developed into a product to prove the concept before getting approval. I really wouldn't know though since I only pretend to be a lawyer on Craigslist's divorce forums.

-SkribbelKat, Esq. (<--not really :D)
 
Nah, nothing in Win8 is going to go anywhere. MS will give SurfCast a big fat check (well, big fat to SurfCast, petty cash to MS) to license the "technology" and everyone will be happy.

if i was MS, i would buy surfcast, get the patents and shut the fuckers down.
 
The patent was applied for back in 2000. Back then, something like that probably was a pretty novel idea.

Displaying the current state of electronic information in little boxes is not a novel idea. Their implantation of it was ugly and probably close to unusable to boot.
 
If MS hired drifters to murder everyone at Surfcity I wouldn't blink twice. Just saying.
 
Let's see how long Surfcast lasts in court. Maybe they'll go bankrupt before they even finish.
 
The patent was applied for back in 2000. Back then, something like that probably was a pretty novel idea.

Not so sure about that. There's this link of AOL online kids that's basically scary-similar to Windows tiles posted by another user in this thread:

http://obamapacman.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/AOL-1996-vs.-Microsoft-Windows-8.jpg

I'd also wager Windows Tiles UI is very very similar to Windows Media Center's UI minus the ability to buy apps but one could argue it displayed purchased music, videos, pictures, etc therefore can be used to display purchased 'content'. Windows Media Centre as "freestyle" codename was available back in 2002.

I guess there's also: http://postimage.org/image/trkznbcez/ potentially as prior art if you look at the right-hand side. Ala 'Active Desktop' which didn't allow on the fly resizing but I think that was more of a gpu-hardware limitation/software GUI than the idea having not been through of. I think having two windows open side by side allowing each window to take about half-the-screen was done by some users back in Windows 3.11 when running 2 apps at once in windowed mode as possible.
 
Not so sure about that. There's this link of AOL online kids that's basically scary-similar to Windows tiles posted by another user in this thread:

http://obamapacman.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/05/AOL-1996-vs.-Microsoft-Windows-8.jpg

I'd also wager Windows Tiles UI is very very similar to Windows Media Center's UI minus the ability to buy apps but one could argue it displayed purchased music, videos, pictures, etc therefore can be used to display purchased 'content'. Windows Media Centre as "freestyle" codename was available back in 2002.

I guess there's also: http://postimage.org/image/trkznbcez/ potentially as prior art if you look at the right-hand side. Ala 'Active Desktop' which didn't allow on the fly resizing but I think that was more of a gpu-hardware limitation/software GUI than the idea having not been through of. I think having two windows open side by side allowing each window to take about half-the-screen was done by some users back in Windows 3.11 when running 2 apps at once in windowed mode as possible.
They were not patenting Buttons/Launch Icons that looked like TIles (AOL) or even Live Tiles (active desktop). They were patenting Live Tiles that also served as Launch Icons.
 
Back
Top