Understanding Online Star Ratings

Being as there are now companies that will scour the web and give your products glowing reviews I think it's labelled as
4 or more stars = untrustworthy reviews
3 stars = crap
less than 3 stars = good product because the only ones rating are the few who couldn't get it to work as advertised and people who have something that works good more likely than not is not going to make a point to go online and say how good it works.

Seriously the vast majority of people will only speak up if they feel wronged and they're upset, if something works right that should be the norm, you shouldn't get a praise for doing what it's supposed to do.
 
Fairly true. In regards to Amazon, anyway. Though you still have to take the number of reviews into account regardless of rating.
 
Funny and pretty darn accurate. Though I usually find that 1 star = reviewed by 1 or two people whom both of which were complete idiots and not a reflection on the product.
 
True, but now I read the top reviews and the bottom reviews assuming they have text attached.
 
Being as there are now companies that will scour the web and give your products glowing reviews I think it's labelled as
4 or more stars = untrustworthy reviews
3 stars = crap
less than 3 stars = good product because the only ones rating are the few who couldn't get it to work as advertised and people who have something that works good more likely than not is not going to make a point to go online and say how good it works.

Seriously the vast majority of people will only speak up if they feel wronged and they're upset, if something works right that should be the norm, you shouldn't get a praise for doing what it's supposed to do.

I leave good reviews on NewEgg for good products all the time.
 
Funny and pretty darn accurate. Though I usually find that 1 star = reviewed by 1 or two people whom both of which were complete idiots and not a reflection on the product.

I love it when I'm researching a product, let's say a new guitar stand, and I see a 1 overall and there are two reviews.

Chances are the first review is for a different product alltogether and the second review is complaning about how slow the shipping was.
 
More often than not, the low ratings are from ignorant people looking to place blame elsewhere instead of admitting to their own shortcomings.
 
They say the devil's in the details. I find that to be true in many cases. Its not enough to look at star ratings. You have to read the reviews, pay attention to posting dates, and get a general idea of what is going on.

Consistent complaints of the same issue over a few months is key. Consistent glowing reviews, especially with minimal detail, should be taken with a grain of salt. I completely ignore ones like "It didn't blow up on me when I hit the power button! A+ would buy again! This thing is sooooo awesome!" because they don't tell me much beyond initial impressions.

I like reading reviews where people get into their user experience with the product, good or bad. If there are a number of people who have similar reviews, I feel a bit more confident in my decision to buy (or not buy) the item.

I also read the bad reviews as well, looking for key consistencies in complaints. I ignore ones that more or less demonstrate the individual had no idea what they bought or how to use it. It's pretty easy to spot those, so it makes sifting through them easier.
 
I don't even trust the star ratings any longer. The best one can do is read the actual reviews, and find any that have specific details of why the product is good or not good, and decide if those aspects are important to my need.
 
Funny and pretty darn accurate. Though I usually find that 1 star = reviewed by 1 or two people whom both of which were complete idiots and not a reflection on the product.

Seriously, more often then not I'll find a 5-star product sitting at the top of a sorted list only to read a review or two of "shipping was super quick" and "I'm so looking forward to when it gets here!". I will then read the 1-star product with 10 reviews that go a little something like this: "Shipping took a forever (a week)!", "I thought this was a different product", "I dropped it down a flight of stairs and now it won't work!", "I don't know how to use this thing!".

:rolleyes:
 
I don't even trust the star ratings any longer. The best one can do is read the actual reviews, and find any that have specific details of why the product is good or not good, and decide if those aspects are important to my need.

Yup.
 
Seriously, more often then not I'll find a 5-star product sitting at the top of a sorted list only to read a review or two of "shipping was super quick" and "I'm so looking forward to when it gets here!". I will then read the 1-star product with 10 reviews that go a little something like this: "Shipping took a forever (a week)!", "I thought this was a different product", "I dropped it down a flight of stairs and now it won't work!", "I don't know how to use this thing!".

:rolleyes:

Dragon Age 3 is the best game ever!! 10/10. I can't wait until it comes out! /wrists
 
I love reading reviews where people clearly don't pay attention to what they're buying. I looked at the GTX680 lightning in the egg recently and saw a review that was "- eggs for the horrible loud fans for like 30 seconds at startup" where it says CLEARLY on the box in huge letters and diagrams that the 30 seconds reverse fans at 100% is a feature to prevent dust buildup. If you don't like that, why buy it just to say you don't like it?
 
Funny but only vaguely true. You have to weigh reviews based on why they downrate. People will quickly give a product a downrate because they think it costs too much or shipping is expensive or some other bs reason. When buying electronics DOA products immediately get 1 or no stars which is unfair. No electronic product will ever be DOA free, so you have to weigh the amount of DOAs to the amount sold. Most people that are happy with a product never review it. Online reviews are only useful when properly sorted and useless reviews thrown out.
 
Funny but only vaguely true. You have to weigh reviews based on why they downrate. People will quickly give a product a downrate because they think it costs too much or shipping is expensive or some other bs reason. When buying electronics DOA products immediately get 1 or no stars which is unfair. No electronic product will ever be DOA free, so you have to weigh the amount of DOAs to the amount sold. Most people that are happy with a product never review it. Online reviews are only useful when properly sorted and useless reviews thrown out.
Exactly what I was going to say. People who 1 star a DOA before they bother to RMA before giving an honest review are complete morons. Gotta love how these same people often rate themselves high on the tech scale at places like Newegg. :rolleyes:
 
Exactly what I was going to say. People who 1 star a DOA before they bother to RMA before giving an honest review are complete morons. Gotta love how these same people often rate themselves high on the tech scale at places like Newegg. :rolleyes:
QFT. Newegg reviews are worthless because of this...
 
I'd say that online star rule applies in most places but on Netflix it doesn't. I've watched plenty of 3 star or slightly higher movies that I've enjoyed greatly.
 
I'd say that online star rule applies in most places but on Netflix it doesn't. I've watched plenty of 3 star or slightly higher movies that I've enjoyed greatly.

Netflix ratings don't really work the same way. It is based on what genres you enjoy, how other people that like movies you like rated the movie you are watching, what ratings you have given similar movies and so on. Quite often a movie rated 3 or more stars can be something you enjoy. I don't see why not. 3/5 stars is definitely a passing grade when factual reviews are listed.
 
Netflix ratings don't really work the same way. It is based on what genres you enjoy, how other people that like movies you like rated the movie you are watching, what ratings you have given similar movies and so on. Quite often a movie rated 3 or more stars can be something you enjoy. I don't see why not. 3/5 stars is definitely a passing grade when factual reviews are listed.

I know but its interesting how the system Netflix uses actually lines up with the actual average. So often a 3/5 is brushed aside as "acceptable" and not enjoyable.

For instance on Amazon a 3/5 stars is something you avoid. The system is different but the actual rating is the same. Its just funny how it works out like that.
 
QFT. Newegg reviews are worthless because of this...

QFT. 90% of them seem to be some mouth breather bitching about how NewEgg took 2 days to ship instead of one, or some other random non item related complaint.
 
I leave good reviews on NewEgg for good products all the time.

You do, but you're probably the exception to the rule. Most people on the internet treat online shopping like regular shopping, I buy something at the store I'm not going back to tell them how great it is.
 
I know but its interesting how the system Netflix uses actually lines up with the actual average. So often a 3/5 is brushed aside as "acceptable" and not enjoyable.

For instance on Amazon a 3/5 stars is something you avoid. The system is different but the actual rating is the same. Its just funny how it works out like that.

It took some getting used to myself. Now I am more willing to give new stuff a try. Found some stuff I really liked lately!
 
Newegg tech level is a joke.

Amazon reviewer intelligence is usually a joke. I was just in the market for new headphones and so many one star reviews were cause open cans were leaking sound. These people seriously spent $200+ and didn't know the difference between open and closed. How do they function in society?
 
Almost forgot about a particular gem I found on newegg once.

Tech level high

1 star threatened zero stars if it was an option.

Complaint - Product was crap and too difficult to install. Never could get it installed so returned it.

This was for a stick of ram.....

Newegg seriously should hire someone to filter through reviews like this and just ban that account from ever being able to post a review again just based on gross stupidity.
 
Back
Top