Microsoft Reportedly Working on Stylus for Any LCD Screen

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
Microsoft is going to the ends of the Earth to prove that the touch interface feature in the upcoming Windows 8 operating system is a viable cross platform tool. If the reports hold true, Microsoft is already in the development stage of creating a working prototype to turn any LCD into a touch screen.

If the new Microsoft stylus concept were to become available, it would allow precise stylus use on any display, even on those that aren't already touch-sensitive.
 
If I want a touch interface, I'll buy a touchscreen monitor. No way I'm going to scratch up my monitor just to make it act like a touch screen.
 
A stylus-driven interface might be a better alternative to touch than leaving revolting finger goo smeared over a glossy screen surface. Scratches are possibly a problem like Socky says, but I'd bet they'll make the tip nice and soft so it doesn't mess up a screen and existing LCDs are pretty durable anyhow.

Still, I don't get what's so great about touching a screen to interact with something on a device that's larger than ~10 inches of tablet. All those finger gymnastics strike me as slower, even on a smaller screen than using a keyboard and mousey or laptop's touchpad to do stuff. Why should I have to make large, sweeping motions or move my hand across the entire width of a screen when I can move a single finger a very short distance on a touchpad?

Touch interfaces are fine for pocket carried devices like phones, but shoehorning it into a laptop or desktop seems as idiotic as the attempt to add 3D to home theaters.
 
buy screen protectors for 24" monitors 100$ :p
why not just use a kinect interface that would track a laser pointer on the screen ? lol
or force ppl to use kinect on pcs as the default interface xD
 
buy screen protectors for 24" monitors 100$ :p
why not just use a kinect interface that would track a laser pointer on the screen ? lol
or force ppl to use kinect on pcs as the default interface xD

Or you could buy a large number of smaller screen protectors and arrange them in a grid over your screen for the same coverage at a lower cost. :p

I had a roomie who would belly dance at the keyboard while waiting for fluid simulations to run on the computer when we were in college together, but who in their right mind wants to flail around like a live fish on a kitchen floor in front of their computer to interface with it?
 
Or you could buy a large number of smaller screen protectors and arrange them in a grid over your screen for the same coverage at a lower cost. :p

I had a roomie who would belly dance at the keyboard while waiting for fluid simulations to run on the computer when we were in college together, but who in their right mind wants to flail around like a live fish on a kitchen floor in front of their computer to interface with it?

I think it's a conspiracy by the health association of america to get ppl moving ? :D
 
I think it's a conspiracy by the health association of america to get ppl moving ? :D

Does that mean that Microsoft accepting bribes because of Kinect, but also resisting those awful health freaks by subversively making a stylus so we can continue sitting on our tail ends?
 
oh those are from bribes from the writers guild ..... ;)

<rant>When publishers leave writers with enough money to actually do nothing but write instead of having to hold down an altogether unrelated career to make a living, then they might have enough money around to form a guild and to start bribing others. At the moment, they just throw you a few thousand dollar bone, claim ownership over the book you just spent the better part of the past year creating as a labor of love to be sacrificed on the altar of corporate profits under some other moron's misrepresentation through stupid cover art and ask you for an estimated date of completion of the sequel or demand you turn a stand-alone novel into a serialized series....</rant>

What were we talking about? A stylus, right?
 
The mounts on LCD monitors are pretty flimsy and not really made to be constantly touching it. The monitor would be continuous wobbling all over the place. This is about the stupidist idea I can think of. The guys who always have to jump on the latest of anything can have Windows 8. I'll sit back and watch quite happily with my 7.
 
The mounts on LCD monitors are pretty flimsy and not really made to be constantly touching it. The monitor would be continuous wobbling all over the place. This is about the stupidist idea I can think of. The guys who always have to jump on the latest of anything can have Windows 8. I'll sit back and watch quite happily with my 7.

That's a really good point. LCD screens are generally sitting atop just enough plastic to keep them from tipping over. Development of a stylus like this is complementary to Windows 8's touch interface to make OS sales more widespread on existing non-touch hardware. (How long do people use the same monitor, after all and will they buy a new one with touch capability, seeing it as beneficial to support the touch OS or will they just forget the whole thing after including the cost of the screen into the TCO of Windows 8?)

Speculation like this is liable to trip Heatlesssun's Win8 sensors though so SHHH! :p
 
MS is really trying hard to make Metro seem like a good idea on non touch laptops, and desk tops. This will not do it imho. Admittedly, a good quality, precise, stylus for non touch screens will have use to certain professionals, especially graphical artist, but I can not remember a time when I wish I had a stylus for writing directly on my monitor.
 
A stylus to turn an LCD into a touch screen would also require some sort of kinect-style sensor, which would make this touchscreen a tad expensive for something that's stupid. The idea of using Metro on anything this side of a tablet is stupid, especially if a stylus is needed.
 
You know what sucks is all the shitheads that will buy this crap and go down the touch screen road anyway regardless of if you or I don't want to turn our pc's into a smart phone.
 
Isn't it WAAAAY better that Microsoft comes up with a hugely improved short range Kinect device for desktop PC's? No one reaches over their desk and keyboard and stuff to touch the screen on the desktop. No one lays down a screen on the desktop for any extensive time unless they want to get really bad backs and necks.
The only alternative for desktop is a really big desktop muti-touch pad that is expandable for people with m ore than one monitor so that a natural seating arrangement with a touch-surface can work on the desktop,
 
A stylus? We had those light pen things in the 90s, and they weren't good then and they'll suck now also.

Again, a desktop PC is not tablet. Metro doesn't work well on a desktop because it is NOT a tablet. I don't know how we can explain that to MS in a way that they can understand because obviously they just don't get it. A Keyboard+Mouse works well because it is relatively ergonomic to use with a dektop system. Your arms are rested on a surface (like the wrist pad and on your chair arms) and it will not tire you out because your arms are close to your body even if you use it for hours. A touch screen on a Desktop means you are holding your arm in the air in front of you, and your arm will get tired using this kind of interface from a normal seated position. Just try it, pretend you have a touch screen in front of you and are navigating the horrid metro interface with the flicking motion with your arm stretched out to the screen from your normal seated postion. Your shoulder will get tired and I am sure we'll get whole new set of repetitive motion injuries from using it. The other alternative, is to put your elbow on the desk and then bend your back and get closer to the screen to use the touch screen, which gives you bad posture. This is all because a desktop requires a different interface than a tablet.
 
I think this Stylus will really be useful for those who have been looking for one. The fact that you guys seem to think everyone sits at a desk all day and goes click, click, type, type and nothing else shows just how narrow your vision of the computer is.

Will I get a stylus? For my tablet, I think I might but that is because it supports handwriting recognition in Windows 8. For my desktop and laptop, I will not need it but then again, this stylus they are talking about is not marketed at me anyways.
 
I think some people are missing an important point here. This technology could have tremendous benefits in reducing the cost of ink capable tablets as the need for a pen digitizer in the screen could be eliminated and assuming the pens could be cheap accessories. Right now a traditional Wacom digitizer solution in an x86 devices adds around $100+ to the cost of the device. Plus when you think about Microsoft's acquisition of Perceptive Pixel and the desire to reduce the cost of those big screen, this would seem to play a huge part in that as well.

Microsoft has created some amazing ink capabilities in Windows, spent a LOT of money on the tech and has never been aggressive about refining the technology for last 10 years it seems since the launch of Windows XP Tablet PC Edition. In some ways I get that Vanity Fair article about Microsoft's lost decade because the ink in Windows even to this days is the best there is in any mainstream OS and ink has a special in tablets because ink really does add a lot of productive capabilities to tablets that can't be done with keyboards and mice, not easily. A pen is the most precise and free form input method there is.
 
Again, a desktop PC is not tablet. Metro doesn't work well on a desktop because it is NOT a tablet.

Metro works fine on a desktop when you actually sit down and use it. I've got a more complex desktop that 95% of Windows 7 users running Windows 8 with dual screens and as far as the desktop goes, it just isn't that much different than Windows 7. The issue with Windows 8 comes with dealing the separation of Metro and the desktop and navigating between them. But that's about a 10 minute tutorial and a few days of adjustment for most people, but I tend to think that people on average are smarter and more adaptable than most around here.
 
This might be ok...but not for it's intended purpose. I don't really see the benefit of sitting on a laptop or a desktop. But if it works well enough it could have some use for digital art. But then theres the same problems the pricey Cintiqs have. Lag. The bigger screen models are even worse. It could be refined and streamlined, but there might be trade-offs with accuracy. The "camera" methods are kind of fuzzy logic, so would probably be pretty useless for this kind of thing.

Tell ya what Microsoft, I'll buy windows 8 if you include a free Wacom Cintiq screen so that I can get the full experience.

Nooo. Those things are lagpiles! :eek: (it's a word)
 
I'm feeling pretty confident that Leap is going to provide a much better experience for the desktop than any stylus could. For everything but drawing precision, anyway.
 
This might be ok...but not for it's intended purpose. I don't really see the benefit of sitting on a laptop or a desktop. But if it works well enough it could have some use for digital art. But then theres the same problems the pricey Cintiqs have. Lag.

Depends on the application. Overall on modern hardware running Windows 7 ink responsiveness is pretty good these days. I'm not an artist but I use ink in the Tablet Input Panel and OneNote a LOT and for handwriting purposes the ink responsiveness is great, even a bit better in Windows 8.
 
I'm feeling pretty confident that Leap is going to provide a much better experience for the desktop than any stylus could. For everything but drawing precision, anyway.

Again, I don't think that this technology is about desktops but adding cheaper pen capabilities to tablets and reducing the cost of PPI screens.
 
Metro works fine on a desktop when you actually sit down and use it.

I can attest to that. After 10 minutes on Windows 8, I have no problem of using it at all on a desktop machine. I appreciate the simpler internet explorer, email apps etc. on the Metro desktop. If I want to do something more complicated, I go back to the traditional desktop interface. I don't understand what all these fuss about WIndows 8 if you have actually really sit down and use it, unless you are dead set against the Metro interface from the very beginning.
 
Metro works fine on a desktop when you actually sit down and use it. I've got a more complex desktop that 95% of Windows 7 users running Windows 8 with dual screens and as far as the desktop goes, it just isn't that much different than Windows 7.

Metro on a desktop is fine when you actually sit down and use it? Dude, there are things that people say that makes me think they're complete idiots.

I tend to think that people on average are smarter and more adaptable than most around here.

No need to be insulting. ;)
 
Regrettably, Metro does not work if you're standing, lying down, suspended from a ceiling or some other overhead object or floating in a zero-gravity environment.

Sitting? No prob, Bob. Metro away.
 
Regrettably, Metro does not work if you're standing, lying down, suspended from a ceiling or some other overhead object or floating in a zero-gravity environment.

Sitting? No prob, Bob. Metro away.

Huh? I don't get it. :confused:
 
Metro on a desktop is fine when you actually sit down and use it? Dude, there are things that people say that makes me think they're complete idiots.

For an idiot all I can say is that my personal opinion of Windows 8 has been formed over 10 months of using it across at this point 6 devices ranging from conventional and convertible laptops, pure slates and a dual screen desktop. All the comments I've made about Windows 8 are from experience using the product on multiple devices, input methods and scenarios. Which for an idiot is more than most people tossing out the term in regards to Windows 8 towards those that using the product regularly.

Regrettably, Metro does not work if you're standing, lying down, suspended from a ceiling or some other overhead object or floating in a zero-gravity environment.

I assume this is some kind of joke but it's hard to see the humor for person like me that has actually used many versions of Windows in these environments, except zero-g. And the ceiling thing is a long story.;)
 
I can attest to that. After 10 minutes on Windows 8, I have no problem of using it at all on a desktop machine. I appreciate the simpler internet explorer, email apps etc. on the Metro desktop. If I want to do something more complicated, I go back to the traditional desktop interface. I don't understand what all these fuss about WIndows 8 if you have actually really sit down and use it, unless you are dead set against the Metro interface from the very beginning.

Perfect description! The thing is that as much as people want to say there needs to be a switch to turn Metro off, here's the thing. We can talk about all of these UI switches for disabling Metro on the desktop. What about disabling the desktop in Metro?

That topic does come up from more insightful and thoughtful folks from time to time. But the bottom line is that Windows 8 x86, no matter the form factor, runs all the same binaries. Be it a tablet, laptop, or desktop all Windows 8 machines run ALL of the code.

Why would Microsoft put in a switch like "Well a few tech geeks think I'm too stupid to know anything for myself, they know what's best for me better than a multi-hundred billion dollar company that bought computers to the masses. Those tech geeks think I need to click "I'm too stupid to learn anything that I might enjoy button." so I better click that one.
 
Really, you can't tell us something like that and then not explain the details!

Just a joke.;) But seriously, Metro doesn't work standing or lying down? That's either a joke or a complete lack of understanding of it's capabilities.
 
Just a joke.;) But seriously, Metro doesn't work standing or lying down? That's either a joke or a complete lack of understanding of it's capabilities.

Aw, I was really hoping you were about to break out something like this:
lanparty.jpg
 
Aw, I was really hoping you were about to break out something like this:

Who knows, in my collage days I ended up in stranger positions.: confused: The looks of those monitors that picture does remind me of college seriously.
 
Who knows, in my collage days I ended up in stranger positions.: confused: The looks of those monitors that picture does remind me of college seriously.

I'm pretty sure that's at least a semi-old photo too. The only flat panel screen in it is being used by the person taped to the ceiling. But SHHH! Don't date yourself by admitting such things. ;)
 
I'm pretty sure that's at least a semi-old photo too. The only flat panel screen in it is being used by the person taped to the ceiling. But SHHH! Don't date yourself by admitting such things. ;)

Not sure... The game they are playing looks exactly like CoD MW3. Though it might be older...or an HD mod (of MW3)...
 
interesting.

This stylus would do wonders for CAD/3D Modeling and even Photoshop...

Imagine a 24" monitor in your lap that you could actually draw on.
 
Not sure... The game they are playing looks exactly like CoD MW3. Though it might be older...or an HD mod (of MW3)...

I would have guessed Counterstrike, but I've only played it a few times and I'm totally not into FPS these days because it induces nausea in those of us who have grown unaccustomed to that kinda motion. Anyhow, the first time I saw that image (which was also the reason why I knew it existed) was in like 2004 or maybe 2005 and it had apparently been around a little even then.
 
When publishers leave writers with enough money to actually do nothing but write instead of having to hold down an altogether unrelated career to make a living, then they might have enough money around to form a guild and to start bribing others.

If writers are stupid enough to 'still' use publishing companies...they deserve it. There are so many ways of selling books/articles/documentary online that a publishing company is a step backwards.
 
Back
Top