MSI 7870 Hawk Running Hot & Loud

Alusan

n00b
Joined
Oct 15, 2011
Messages
16
I set up this card yesterday. Performance is nice, almost more than I expected, and there seems to be a lot of headroom with the small amount of testing I did so far. Drivers are perfect after simply uninstalling the previous Cats and installing the June 6 betas. But the card is running really hot, even at default settings of 1100MHz core, 1200MHz memory and 1.168V for the core. I came from an XFX dual-fan 6870 which usually sat around the 70s in games while being pretty much inaudible. Ambient temp here is about 24C.

With the 7870's default fan profile, however, it was getting far too noisy in any game I was playing. Looking at Half-Life 2, the game settled around the low 80s, but the fanspeed was staying around 93% and even 99% after it reached 84C. I set up my own profile to deal with this, but with that the card was reaching 90+ C in games.

Using my custom profile, I've tested Metro 2033, where I don't go above 35fps. With the default fan profile the GPU doesn't go above 77C with a fanspeed of 76%. The card settles around the upper 80s with fan speed at a loud 59%, and cracks 90 and fan speed 100% once I get into some action.

Running around dust2 in Counter Strike Source, it takes about a minute for the card to reach 90 C with the same 59% fanspeed. I'm averaging about 130fps (using SSAA) without vsync.

Skyrim and Morrowind settle around the mid 80s with fanspeed between 57-59%, but once I get into combat they both crack 90 as well.

I'm not sure if the case simply isn't providing enough airflow for the card. I've got an 800D which isn't the best at air circulation, but the CPU temps are still reasonable with the 7870 installed. I can't imagine the power use of the 7870 is so much higher than the 6870 that my case would have this much trouble with it.

My results seem a lot more in line with what Techpowerup got than with Guru3d's results, but even Techpowerup got somewhat reasonable temps I'd heard that the Twin Frozr was up there with the other good vendor air coolers; are my results normal?
 
Last edited:
That does seem hot for that card. I had a MSI Twin Frozr 7850 that was overclocked to 1140/6000MHz and it never excceded 64c in any game and most of the time it stayed in the high 50's and this was with the stock auto fan profile and the fans were practically inaudible.
 
It sounds like the cooler isn't making good contact if the temps are that high at nearly full fan speed, especially if you're able to break 90c at 100% fan. Or the airflow around the card isn't ideal for its heatsink type.

The good thing is the card shouldn't let it hurt itself thermally, however I would definitely remove the heatsink and clean everything up and apply new thermal paste and then make sure it's installed correctly.

Also, do you have a lot of front to back airflow in that case? Like some decent fans bringing air in the front of the case and right into the back of the card? I found with my GTX 590, which exhausts air out both sides too, that having fans in front of it would just blow the hot air coming out the back of it into the fan again and it would hit 90c+ very quickly even with its fan at 100%. If you're going to provide fresh air to these types of cards it should really only be from overhead, from fans in the side door of your case.
 
Looking at the 7850 Twin Frozr heatsink, this one for the 7870 looks a lot more substantial so I'd expect it to have similar or better cooling characteristics accounting for the higher TDP. Right now my card is idling at 49-52C...not sure if it could be the heatsink's not properly mounted. Is this enough to RMA the card? I haven't ever RMA'd before so I don't know if the issue has to be an actual failure to work properly.

It sounds like the cooler isn't making good contact if the temps are that high at nearly full fan speed, especially if you're able to break 90c at 100% fan. Or the airflow around the card isn't ideal for its heatsink type.

The good thing is the card shouldn't let it hurt itself thermally, however I would definitely remove the heatsink and clean everything up and apply new thermal paste and then make sure it's installed correctly.
I know people do that pretty often, but does that void the warranty?

I left my fan arrangement close to the 800D's stock config. So there's 1 stock fan bringing air in from below that's offset a bit from the graphics card, 1 stock fan to exhaust out the back of the case next to the CPU heatsink, and 2 cheap Coolermaster fans at the top set to exhaust as well, but that's it. No back to front airflow, but I don't think it's possible beyond modding to mount a fan to bring air from the front of the case directly to the card. At the very least, when I load up the game I can feel a lot of hot air exhausting from the back and top so it seems to be working to some extent.
 
Last edited:
yes the temps are a bit too hot. I think you should check with MSI customer support and get them to help you find the cause of the problem. if they aren't able to resolve the problem you should RMA.
 
I know people do that pretty often, but does that void the warranty?

I'm not sure what MSI's policy is, but if you don't want to risk voiding the warranty I would just RMA it. 90c at 100% fan when it's under load is not normal so something is definitely wrong.

Before doing that though, I would remove your side panel and verify that there is no air coming towards the back of the card. Try disconnecting your front case fan and running the card with the side off and see if there is any improvement. It should be able to run with no external airflow and not hit 90c at 100% fan like you're seeing. If that's still the case, RMA the card if you don't want to risk removing the heatsink and fan.
 
Scratch my earlier estimate of the idle, cause after letting it sit for a while it seems like the idle temp is 35C which is a lot better. Removing the side panel lowered load temps by about 3-4C in Portal 2 from 79-80C to 76-77C and the fan from 86% to 76%. I think I'll definitely contact MSI about it then at the very least. Thanks guys.
 
Pretty sure with MSI if you remove the heatsink you void the warranty so contact them before you do anything like that.
 
Spoke to MSI tech support guy and he actually said I could try reseating the heatsink before an RMA. Let's see if that's the problem.
 
Well that's good, clean it up good and use some good paste like Arctic Cooling. I hope that does it for you.
 
So after applying some Shin-Etsu G751, idles dropped to 29C, and running around in CS Source, temps settle at 69-70C with fan at 55%. Portal 1 reaches 71C and ramps up to 62% fanspeed. Just tested Morrowind too, and it got up to 66C at 52% fanspeed. I didn't do a great job at removing the old paste either because I only had 70% alcohol lying around. Dunno, it's livable now but it doesn't seem all that great.

Portal 2 was crashing everytime it tried to load a level, not sure what that's about, but I couldn't do the run I was doing in there before.
 
I can't speak from experience, but just looking up the 7870 Hawk, it looks like the Twin Frozr 4 design... but I swear the fans on this card look smaller than, say, the ones on the 7970 lightning (which does use the TF4 design right?...).

The fans on that 7870 look more akin to the fans in the TF3 design on my 6950... (I'm starting to miss the TF2 design over TF3 honestly...)
 
Yeah, the fans on the lightning are 100mm, afaik the hawk ones are 80mm. The lightning PCB/Shroud is actually wider than a regular one, so it's a bit hard to tell by eyeballing it.

I gotta say though, I like the aesthetics of these newer Twin Frozrs over the older ones.
 
Bit of an update here, I ended up RMAing the Hawk. It took the full two weeks to get back to me, but I was out of town so it wasn't a problem. I got sent a different card; not sure if it's a refurb or a new card, but they included a new retail box and the certificate, cables etc. The ASIC quality is a bit lower too, 76% vs. 85.6%. I don't put much faith in the ASIC quality, although the old 7870 seemed to overclock stably pretty high. Haven't tried yet with this new one.

Temps and fanspeed are a little better than after I reseated the cooler, but the card is inaudible now. I guess there must have been a problem with the old fans, because at 50% I can't hear a thing from this new card where the old one was getting pretty loud. I am gonna look into outfitting my case with a few more fans in the future too. Just letting you guys know it's not a problem with all 7870 Hawks.
 
Back
Top