No DVD Playback In Windows 8

Hmm lets see, Windows 7 = desktop + DVD + TV viewer...
Windows 8 = Metro - DVD - TV viewer

I think I don't have any incentives to upgrade. Smart move Microsoft :rolleyes:

Windows 8 = Everything Windows 7 does (ok the rarely used media feature might cost a few bucks) plus touch and a gazillion apps that you won't have with Windows 7 of which many will be free and a whole new generation of hardware that will be optimized for Windows 8.

Yes, a very smart move indeed if Microsoft wants to keep Windows relevant to average people.
 
I've fan into the same problem. I've used MediaPortal and it works mostly fine, but for best TV watching and recording it's WMC. XBMC is best for watching .avi or .mkv files, but that's it.

I've heard lots about MythTV for Linux, but I could never get it working with the cheap capture cards I have.

Since TV has lost interest for many people, so too has capturing video onto a PC. Probably the highlight for me to TV on a PC was when ATI has their All In Wonder graphic cards. That tech has unfortunately mysteriously vanished.

I was able to get Myth working ok -- but without CableCard support it is pretty useless to me (no ScyFy, no HBO, etc).

And, I just don't see this "people losing interest in TV" -- they are still watching just as much as they used to, they are just dropping cable service and streaming it.

That said, the free ride may be coming to an end very quickly -- as the revenue stream generated by streaming is not equal to the revenue stream generated from cable service sales. As an example of this, note Hulu's recent announcement that they are switching to an authorization based model where you MUST have an active subscription to a cable provider to be able to stream shows.

In other words, streaming is likely going to rapidly become a per pay only service that requires you to have cable service regardless -- so, if you have to pay for it anyway, then other than time-shifting, why wouldn't you rather have the higher quality video of a standard cable connection anyway?

Basically, things like XFinityTV via Comcast or ESPN3 are liable to continue to grow -- but, for the moment at least, the revenue stream generated by services like Hulu simply does not provide enough cash to fund the networks shows. Without cable subscription fees, HBO, Showtime, ScyFy, etc will all go away -- which would eliminate a LOT of content people are quite attached to (True Blood for instance).

Now is the time that Microsoft should REALLY be getting behind WMC and CableCard *AND* integrating internet based authentication and "better than Hulu" grade streaming and services like ESPN3 or Amazon Prime *DIRECTLY* into WMC (which already has a good "10 foot interface" using an IR remote control).

The content and the content providers are where the money is at -- providing the content to customers easily and reliably, while still preserving a viable profit model for the distributors is ONLY intelligent business model at this point in time. Hello? iTunes anyone? Amazon music store? Amazon Prime streaming?

By having the ONLY CableCard certified platform out there right now, Microsoft should be in the catbird seat. If they had half a clue, they would start actively pushing and marketing WMC to the CABLE COMPANIES as alternatives to the horrendous cable boxes they use now. Combine WMC with Metro and a Kinect type interface and you have a potential KILLER product -- and if it does streaming AND cable and integrates to the cable companies backend for authentication, etc. you have a guaranteed revenue stream for both the cable company, the content provider, AND Microsoft.

Basically, everything Microsoft has done recently pretty much confirms one thing: Steve Ballmer is a total idiot.
 
Windows 8 = Everything Windows 7 does (ok the rarely used media feature might cost a few bucks) plus touch and a gazillion apps that you won't have with Windows 7 of which many will be free and a whole new generation of hardware that will be optimized for Windows 8.

Yes, a very smart move indeed if Microsoft wants to keep Windows relevant to average people.

Um no Media Center is a deal breaker for me. My PC is my TV.
 
Basically, everything Microsoft has done recently pretty much confirms one thing: Steve Ballmer is a total idiot.

Okay, so Microsoft is paying tons in licensing fees that for technology that few people are using and is declining in usage and so Microsoft is still offering this unique technology just with an added cost that will probably be a very small fraction of a just a single cable bill and Ballmer is an idiot?

I can see you point about cable boxes, I think that Microsoft actually does those for a few cable providers but they are pretty cheap operators, they really aren't up to paying a lot for those boxes which is why they suck.

At any rate it's not like Microsoft can't add this stuff back in to the core of Windows if they need to and it's not like there's a lot of work going into cable service set top boxes anyway was people have gone iPad and steaming crazy.

As much as some may not like this decision I've not seen anyone say anything that makes financial sense to Microsoft. I do agree with you on the Microsoft set top box idea, it's something I've wondered about myself, and Microsoft is in that space but hasn't gained a lot of traction and in reality the XBox is the platform that Microsoft sees as the thing they sell that people will attach to a TV. Unfortunate I believe because the PC I think is the best thing a person can attach to a TV but the reality is that most people don't, again unfortunately.
 
Um no Media Center is a deal breaker for me. My PC is my TV.

And it is for me as well but that's like about 1% of Windows users. This is where the success of Windows becomes a drag. Assuming 1.5 billion Windows users in the world d even 1% we're taking about 15,000,000 users which is small number of Windows users but more people that in most US States.

This why it's SO hard to make changes to Windows and while people think Microsoft is slow about innovation which it is, there's no one that makes this critique that could do any better. Seriously, Microsoft should pay all kinds of licensing fees for every copy of Windows that the overwhelming majority of people don't even use? It just doesn't make any business sense.
 
Media Center is available for Windows 8. Problem solved?

The problem is that it will cost something for honest folks and yes that sucks. But there's no one here that has yet explained how it makes business sense for Microsoft to pay royalties on every copy of Windows sold for technologies that everyone one here knows full well are in serious decline and have never been used but by a small percentage of Windows users.

How many headlines has Steve [H] posted about the collapsed of cable TV and DVDs? More than one. And everyone said hurray! But then Microsoft starts to charge for that very same tech that Microsoft is paying for for in each and every copy of Windows sold that Steve has posted about a tons of times collapsing faster than matter around a black hole and all of a sudden Steve Ballmer is an idiot?

Maybe Steve is listening to much to Steve Ballmer is listening to much to the other Steve.
 
Steam and EA doesn't have to go through Microsoft's App store. Just go to steampowered.com and get the Steam UI and be done with it, the same way as it's been the past 10 years. I think you're running around shouting that the sky is falling. It's just an acorn.

If it's a Metro game it will need to be acquired through the MS App Store though, and you can bet MS will do everything possible to ensure everything that can be done in Metro will be.

Certainly all of Microsoft's own games will head onto Metro, and it wouldn't particularly surprise me if they made Metro a requirement for a game to be Games for Windows certified.

Their not going to sit back and watch all these games made for the desktop which could discourage adoption of Metro, and deprive them of 20-30% chunk of every game sold.
 
I don't hate microsoft for windows 8, it might be a smarter move for the "app" driven casual market. I just wish they would have a more technically intensive alternative available for the crowd that knows what they're doing. Until such a thing exists I see absolutely no reason to upgrade.
 
The problem is that it will cost something for honest folks and yes that sucks. But there's no one here that has yet explained how it makes business sense for Microsoft to pay royalties on every copy of Windows sold for technologies that everyone one here knows full well are in serious decline and have never been used but by a small percentage of Windows users.

How many headlines has Steve [H] posted about the collapsed of cable TV and DVDs? More than one. And everyone said hurray! But then Microsoft starts to charge for that very same tech that Microsoft is paying for for in each and every copy of Windows sold that Steve has posted about a tons of times collapsing faster than matter around a black hole and all of a sudden Steve Ballmer is an idiot?

Maybe Steve is listening to much to Steve Ballmer is listening to much to the other Steve.

If that is the case that Microsoft does not have to pay royalties than I expect each version of W8 to be discounted, relative to the equivalent version of W7, in the exact amount as it would cost to get 8MC.
 
DVD playback is irrelevant. The real story is the loss of Media Center itself.

If you run a HTPC with a Tuner card you would know what I mean. DVD playback is trivia, free programs do that fine, that is no loss to anyone.

Try finding good DVR/PVR software that has a free, reliable updated TV listing guide service, like you get in Media Center.

I don't get why people are only talking about the irrelevant part (DVD). I guess people only read the thread title before commenting these days.

Finally someone understands. If you haven't built an HTPC before than you guys probably won't get it , having to pay for WMC is like going back to when Windows Media Center was a different OS ENTIRELY.

This is a cheap tactic from MS to milk even more out. Thankfully Windows 7 WMC is fully robust and will be around for ages to come.
 
I get perfectly, I have two machines setup for recording with Windows Media Center. What you're not pointing out is that Microsoft has to pay royalties on EVERY copy of Windows use MC whether or not people is it or not, and not is the vast and growing population.

If the vast majority of Windows users aren't using this stuff, why should Microsoft pay for it in each and every copy of Windows?

Make a real business case for heaping this technology beyond emotion where Microsoft can make money and I bet you'd see a different outcome.

The more the Windows 8 debate goes on the more I think Microsoft is getting it right. DVD sales are plummeting and people are dropping cable TV left and right but Microsoft is supposed to keep paying tons of cash to keep doing things that most people don't even know exist?

It makes NO SENSE.
 
i have to get a separate application to play Blurays. may as well use that same app to play DVDs. i really don't see the problem in this.
 
I'm not paying extra to get WMC, I'll stick to Windows 7.
 
Agreed -- I've tried everything else from Sage to MythTV -- and none work anywhere near as well as 7MC does for day-to-day recording and TV DVR usage with a decent program guide. Additionally, NOTHING ELSE offers full conditional access support via CableCard -- PERIOD.

I've had no flakiness with 7MC at all in terms of reliability -- it always tapes everything, always updates the guide, and "just works". The only problems I have had have always related to add-ons and hacks to 7MC (Media Browser works pretty well, Arcsoft TotalMedia Theatre works "well enough" but has it's share of glitches, etc).

It's stable yes, but my concern is that with no one big trying to push it along television stations and cable companies will start to enable the never record flags on more of their shows and channels. The logic will be it's not necessary because they provide on-demand services or TV Anywhere, and they are trying to curb piracy. It's going to end up like Sage is, it still works but it's up in the air on what will happen as time marches on technology wise or if Google/MS decide to kill guide support after a couple of years.
 
That's it. I've heard enough shit about W8 that I've got to go download the W8 CP and try it out in a virtual machine. This is going to be my fun project of the hour.
 
the last time i tried to watch a dvd on my living room media pc i couldn't do it because it didn't work on a pc. freakin star wars. now i just watch them on the xbox.
 
For users like us this is clearly no big deal. For the average consumer though this is just yet another strike against Win 8 in the long list of strikes against it. I still fail to see how MS after doing so much right in Win 7 could manage to screw win 8 up this badly.
 
DVD playback is irrelevant. The real story is the loss of Media Center itself.

If you run a HTPC with a Tuner card you would know what I mean. DVD playback is trivia, free programs do that fine, that is no loss to anyone.

Try finding good DVR/PVR software that has a free, reliable updated TV listing guide service, like you get in Media Center.

I don't get why people are only talking about the irrelevant part (DVD). I guess people only read the thread title before commenting these days.

Windows Media Center works fine on my Windows 8 Consumer Release. Where are you getting information that they're cutting out Windows Media Center?
 
Windows Media Center works fine on my Windows 8 Consumer Release. Where are you getting information that they're cutting out Windows Media Center?

The first post, which links the MSDN blog that states they are removing WMC and you will have to install it as a paid upgraded to get it back in Win8.
 
That said, the free ride may be coming to an end very quickly -- as the revenue stream generated by streaming is not equal to the revenue stream generated from cable service sales. As an example of this, note Hulu's recent announcement that they are switching to an authorization based model where you MUST have an active subscription to a cable provider to be able to stream shows.

In other words, streaming is likely going to rapidly become a per pay only service that requires you to have cable service regardless -- so, if you have to pay for it anyway, then other than time-shifting, why wouldn't you rather have the higher quality video of a standard cable connection anyway?
Let me know when Netflix requires you to own a cable service. When that happens then you'll be correct, otherwise Hulu's move isn't a real concern.

Take a look at this link and tell me if streaming video is ever as bad as some of these images. People tend to forget that cable does compress their video streams, and the quality can get very bad.


By having the ONLY CableCard certified platform out there right now, Microsoft should be in the catbird seat. If they had half a clue, they would start actively pushing and marketing WMC to the CABLE COMPANIES as alternatives to the horrendous cable boxes they use now. Combine WMC with Metro and a Kinect type interface and you have a potential KILLER product -- and if it does streaming AND cable and integrates to the cable companies backend for authentication, etc. you have a guaranteed revenue stream for both the cable company, the content provider, AND Microsoft.

People aren't happy about the encryption that cable services use, which forces you to use a cablecard. Cable companies have to be careful as their business model is highly dependent on forcing consumers to go their way to get TV. They can get away with this because they supply the majority of the internet. All it takes is an internet connection that works through electrical wiring or Satellite internet that actually works, and they'll break down fast.

Forcing consumers to use their cables boxes, which requires you to pay a monthly fee. Constantly changing bandwidth and limits. Overpriced service for what many people only watch a handful of TV shows, at best. Nobody likes their cable service. Don't think I've ever met a single person who's ever been excited to have cable. Always something that pisses them off.

The reality is that cable makes having something like MCE to be very difficult. I know it's one of the reasons why I don't care about TV capture on my PC anymore. I don't feel like going out to buy a cablecard just to be able to watch crappy TV. I still have to pay cable like it's another cable box.
 
If that is the case that Microsoft does not have to pay royalties than I expect each version of W8 to be discounted, relative to the equivalent version of W7, in the exact amount as it would cost to get 8MC.

This is illogical in that you're discounting the value of all of the improvements in Windows 8 as having no value. Whatever one's opinion is of Windows 8 it does things that Windows 7 can't and these capabilities at least in Microsoft's opinion are more valuable than DVD and MC which seems to be the case from all of the information I've seen.
 
If it's a Metro game it will need to be acquired through the MS App Store though, and you can bet MS will do everything possible to ensure everything that can be done in Metro will be.

Certainly all of Microsoft's own games will head onto Metro, and it wouldn't particularly surprise me if they made Metro a requirement for a game to be Games for Windows certified.

Their not going to sit back and watch all these games made for the desktop which could discourage adoption of Metro, and deprive them of 20-30% chunk of every game sold.

I very much doubt Microsoft will push for Metro-only environment. They'll market it and give developers incentive to do so, but they're not going to shove it down their throats. It's the same with Games for Windows. Developers were free to use it, and likewise they were free not to.

Like it or not, touchscreens and tablets are taking over the market like a storm. Microsoft is forced to conform to it or slowly become irrelevant. They're going to do their best to make touch users life easier and remain ahead of the pack, but at the same time I don't see them alienating PC gamers and traditional Windows users by forcing an entirely Apps-based universe.

Touchscreen users will appreciate the availability of apps, while traditional users will enjoy their usual availability of "normal" programs as they had since 1995.

As for DVD, I'm sure they did their homework and it's probably best for them in the long run not to include it but I still certainly hope they only leave it out of Home Premium, not Professional and Ultimate. If home users need it, perhaps they should buy Windows 8 Media Center Edition, just like how it was with Windows XP. For people who bought a computer with vanilla Home Premium, perhaps OEM will bundle Microsoft Plus! or whatever they name the add-on pack, just as they have before. If not, I'm sure there'll be WinDVD, again just as before.
 
Its probably to try and keep from another lawsuit in Europe by giving a service away for free that you have to buy now like WinDVD or whatever.
Thanks socialist Europe. Oh well, I'm skipping Win8 anyway.
 
I very much doubt Microsoft will push for Metro-only environment. They'll market it and give developers incentive to do so, but they're not going to shove it down their throats.
They own the market, dude. They shoveled the Ribbon down everyone's throats. They will shove Metro, too, because it will save them development costs between their phone OS.
 
They own the market, dude. They shoveled the Ribbon down everyone's throats. They will shove Metro, too, because it will save them development costs between their phone OS.

OS X is approaching what, 10% market share? The sooner than get more market share the sooner MS gets some worthy competition. But then again OS X had some bone headed design decisions too...
 
It's stable yes, but my concern is that with no one big trying to push it along television stations and cable companies will start to enable the never record flags on more of their shows and channels. The logic will be it's not necessary because they provide on-demand services or TV Anywhere, and they are trying to curb piracy. It's going to end up like Sage is, it still works but it's up in the air on what will happen as time marches on technology wise or if Google/MS decide to kill guide support after a couple of years.

The issue with them enabling the "never record" flag on things is that it will also hurt monthly rental's of their own DVR's -- because it will prevent them from recording them as well.

As of a year or so ago, *ALL* new cable company cable boxes are mandated by the FCC to use the exact same M-Card CableCards for decoding that the cable company gives out to HTPC users, Tivo users, etc -- and they have to handle all decoding and copy flags EXACTLY the same as well. If they don't, then the FCC can fine them -- heavily. This was specifically done to prevent them from having their own boxes be allowed to record shows, yet have customer own equipment not be able to.

Additionally, based on comments from a friend who used to sit on a technical advisory committee in Washington, he feels that the some people in the FCC would take a VERY dim view of the cable companies starting to flag everything as "Record Never". So, here's hoping.
 
They own the market, dude. They shoveled the Ribbon down everyone's throats. They will shove Metro, too, because it will save them development costs between their phone OS.

Unfortunately, you are probably right.
The Ribbon interface to Office still is loathed by a lot of people -- myself among them.

The adoption of the Ribbon also generated a LOT of negative corporate feelings toward Microsoft due to the retraining it required compared to past updates to Office -- basically, retraining costs money, which does NOT make people happy in the business world.

Additionally, I remember seeing an early study after Office 2007 came out, which basically indicated that, while the Ribbon interface could be used for basic tasks more readily by a novice and that while initial training on the Ribbon was slightly quicker, once a user attained proficiency, a proficient Office 2007 user was still, on average, 10-15% *SLOWER* to perform the same task than a proficient Office 2003 user. Basically, the Ribbon interface, albeit perhaps a bit easier to learn, is actually slower to USE once you actually know what you are doing. This study was done without Microsoft's permission and disappeared VERY quickly (as it violated the EULA for Office regarding benchmarking the software without specific permission from Microsoft).

I have heard from numerous people I work for that their own secretarial staff has found this to be true in practice -- it takes them slightly LONGER to do the same tasks in Office 2007 and Office 2010 than it did in 2003. For some things, the newer features and functionality in Office 2007/2010 make up the difference, however, adding the new features and enhancements to the old interface might have yielded even higher efficiency.

While Microsoft has been pushing the Ribbon to business based on the shorter initial training requirements and costs, they have been quite adept at hiding the downside of lower long term productivity in some cases.

Basically, anymore, Microsoft is tending to focus on initial sales and supposedly consumer sales and seems to be totally IGNORING business users desires -- which is moronic, as they are their bread & butter of consistent sales of higher margin product (Windows 7 Pro and Office Pro are MUCH higher margin SKU's than the home versions are).

While Metro does have some potential benefit for phones, tablets, and even a 10' TV interface via Kinect or similar, I have yet to hear from ANYONE who things Windows 8 is going to have ANY benefits for business customers.

Maybe the Powers that Be at Microsoft (Ballmer, et al) are trying to woo stock holders with the potential of sales growth in the tablet/phone markets and drive stock prices up -- but, while this may make sense in the short term, I suspect the long term fallout and effect on their core strategy and business sales may end up hurting them badly.

In general, the corporate world has stuck largely with Microsoft (PC) products over Apple (Mac) products almost 10:1 -- but if Microsoft screws up the user interface to the point that it takes LESS effort to relearn the MacOS UI than it is to learn Metro, then they WILL have a major problem and defection rates are going to rise RAPIDLY. Additionally, multi-tasking, multiple monitor usage, and multi-application usage are VERY important in many business fields, and while you can still get to the deskop, the overall changes to the interface are NOT very conducive to running multiple windows on screen at the same time in ways that people are used to (and having to bring up the tiles interface to launch additional programs and find things is absolutely horrendous).

My own gut feeling is that Microsoft is royally shooting themselves in the foot with Windows 8. They have created a product that not only lacks some of the consumer friendly features in Windows 7, but also is likely to tick business users off royally.

Honestly, the lack of native DVD support in Windows 8 is likely to be a bigger issue for corporate users than for home users -- trust me, the number of presentations, training videos, safety videos, etc that are still available only on DVD is HUGE. These get carried around out in the field and to conference rooms daily and when a DVD is placed in a business laptop, it better JUST WORK. Thankfully, Dell and HP typically bundle PowerDVD or the equivalent with all of their systems -- but, a lot of larger companies use their own customized system images from volume media for roll-outs which may not include these applications. Personally, If Microsoft wants to leave DVD playback out of the consumer version, it may not be noticed all that much anymore, but for them to leave it out of the Pro version for corporate use is just ASKING for problems.
 
WMC (7MC) is VERY viable for recording -- and I know lots of people using it. With the advent of CableCard tuners from Ceton, HDHomeRun, and Hauppauge, it has become even more viable than it used to be -- especially since Windows 7 came out and you no longer needed to have a specific OEM setup to activate the DRM needed to support the CableCard licensing.

One of the other nice parts is no DVR or Cable Box equipment rental fee over the $1.50/mo tracking fee (vs $10/mo HD Cable Box or $15/mo HD-DVR fees). And, if it wasn't for the extenders, then I'd need cable boxes for EACH TV in the house.

I'm only running a dual tuner Hauppauge card on my HTPC, as we only have basic/extended cable. All the local channels are in open QAM or analog, and the rest are analog. I don't watch that much TV, so it's mostly the kids/wife, and they don't care that much about the quality.
My main concern has been if/when the cable company starts cutting off the analog service. I figured that I would just buy a Ceton card at that point & add a media extender for the 2nd TV.

Would really hate to see WMC go away.

FYI: You also forgot to include the electricity cost of the extra cable boxes, or HD-DVR. The cable companies don't seem to concerned about energy efficency, as thier boxes all seem to draw power even when off. I used to have a couple Replay DVR's until I replaced them with my i3 based HTPC. I have the HTPC set to go to sleep, and it automatically wakes up, records the show and then goes back to sleep. Noticed around a $7-$8 drop in my monthly electrical bill after switching.
 
I understand MS needs to pay royalties and such for including DVD playback and using certain codecs, but my question is this: why should I have to pay for that capability separately when I already paid for the right to use the codec with Windows 7? Obviously the right to use certain things is included in the price of Windows 7 - so is Windows 8 going to be cheaper than Windows 7 since it will have reduced functionality? I don't need to pay for the right to watch a DVD if I already paid for a DVD and a DVD player once.
 
If the vast majority of Windows users aren't using this stuff, why should Microsoft pay for it in each and every copy of Windows?

Ok, simple solution for Microsoft:

Leave these features out of the Basic OS (so no license fees paid), but have them available as no-cost apps through the Windows 8 App store for licensed copies of the OS. That way Microsoft saves a boat load of money up front, and it doesn't cost the users more money if they still need the apps.
So, when you put a DVD into your drive on a Windows 8 system, and there is no DVD player installed, it asks you if you'd like to install the DVD player.
 
I use VLC, so this is no big loss. I haven't used Windows player in years.

Has anybody? I also agree about the reasoning for charging it, it's probably to avoid a lawsuit for having it free bundled in with the OS, which is bullshit, IMO.

M$ should be free to put whatever they want on their operating system.
 
I use VLC, so this is no big loss. I haven't used Windows player in years.

Has anybody? I also agree about the reasoning for charging it, it's probably to avoid a lawsuit for having it free bundled in with the OS, which is bullshit, IMO.

M$ should be free to put whatever they want on their operating system.

As most people are saying, no, I don't use Windows Media "Player" for anything, had this computer for a while now and still haven't done the initial setup for WMP because I never use it.

However, I use Windows Media "Center" a lot, daily in fact, it's the best option for DVR/TV software I've used thus far, infinitely better than the shit that's normally bundled with TV cards.

My outrage will depend on the price and availability of WMC in Windows 8. Though honestly, either way I'm not seeing the point in upgrading to Windows 8 when I already have Windows 7. I couldn't give a flying fuck about Metro or Metro apps on my desktop machine and removing WMC from the core package is a step backward for me.
 
I'm guessing WMC will probably be included in Win 8 Ultimate or maybe even Pro.
 
I use WMC daily. Between Metro and this, I have even another reason to skip 8. Not that it matters, they are not likely to back pedal on either decision. There is always Myth TV, pita that it usually is, and nix if I want a traditional desktop. With the way the likes of EA are pissing me off lately, nix becomes more viable by the day.

I may may be the minority now, but keep on keeping on MS, and I may not be.
 
The adoption of the Ribbon also generated a LOT of negative corporate feelings toward Microsoft due to the retraining it required compared to past updates to Office -- basically, retraining costs money, which does NOT make people happy in the business world.

We deployed 200,000 installs of Office 2007 and training simply wasn't an issue. We had online training material but we didn't do any formal training overall and most people adapted just fine.

Additionally, I remember seeing an early study after Office 2007 came out, which basically indicated that, while the Ribbon interface could be used for basic tasks more readily by a novice and that while initial training on the Ribbon was slightly quicker, once a user attained proficiency, a proficient Office 2007 user was still, on average, 10-15% *SLOWER* to perform the same task than a proficient Office 2003 user. Basically, the Ribbon interface, albeit perhaps a bit easier to learn, is actually slower to USE once you actually know what you are doing. This study was done without Microsoft's permission and disappeared VERY quickly (as it violated the EULA for Office regarding benchmarking the software without specific permission from Microsoft).

If you say so. I've been using Office forever and I think that I'm much more proficient with the Ribbon, not that I've done any formal testing compared to the classic menus. I'll never go back to that expanding mess of menus ever again even if a few things here and there are faster. And the menus don't work on a touch device. Yes, I know, most people use Office with keyboards and mice but with the core Office products are coming for free on Windows RT devices and there's going to probably be millions that are going to start using Office on touch devices, not including the millions more that will use Office on x86 touch devices. And office automation is being a very big deal on tablets.

The ribbon was a necessary change to move Office forward and it seems to have done well considering the great sales of Office even with all of the free alternatives out there. The Ribbon certainly did force droves of people over to those alternatives it would appear.

I have heard from numerous people I work for that their own secretarial staff has found this to be true in practice -- it takes them slightly LONGER to do the same tasks in Office 2007 and Office 2010 than it did in 2003. For some things, the newer features and functionality in Office 2007/2010 make up the difference, however, adding the new features and enhancements to the old interface might have yielded even higher efficiency.

I'd love to now exactly though how over the course a work day just how much that slightly longer really is. And the really great thing about the ribbon is the instant previews of formatting changing. To me that's be a HUGE productivity booster and the classic menus simply wouldn't work as well as the ribbon for this.

In general, the corporate world has stuck largely with Microsoft (PC) products over Apple (Mac) products almost 10:1 -- but if Microsoft screws up the user interface to the point that it takes LESS effort to relearn the MacOS UI than it is to learn Metro, then they WILL have a major problem and defection rates are going to rise RAPIDLY. Additionally, multi-tasking, multiple monitor usage, and multi-application usage are VERY important in many business fields, and while you can still get to the deskop, the overall changes to the interface are NOT very conducive to running multiple windows on screen at the same time in ways that people are used to (and having to bring up the tiles interface to launch additional programs and find things is absolutely horrendous).

For separate screen multi-monitor setups (i.e. not Surround or Eyefinity) the Start Screen works fine and the only real issue with it are the hot corners on multi-monitor screens with a mouse. I'll be curious to see what changes there are in the Release Preview, my guess is that there will be something in it that addresses that issue.

Honestly, the lack of native DVD support in Windows 8 is likely to be a bigger issue for corporate users than for home users -- trust me, the number of presentations, training videos, safety videos, etc that are still available only on DVD is HUGE.

So how did this work with XP for businesses cause XP didn't have DVD support built-into it either.
 
Ok, simple solution for Microsoft:

Leave these features out of the Basic OS (so no license fees paid), but have them available as no-cost apps through the Windows 8 App store for licensed copies of the OS. That way Microsoft saves a boat load of money up front, and it doesn't cost the users more money if they still need the apps.
So, when you put a DVD into your drive on a Windows 8 system, and there is no DVD player installed, it asks you if you'd like to install the DVD player.

This too had crossed my mind but if it's something that anyone can download at no cost I'm not sure if licensing costs for Microsoft would be as simple as the number of downloads.
 
So how did this work with XP for businesses cause XP didn't have DVD support built-into it either.

Xp didn't really need it at launch. DVDs only came out in 95. It took a while for the AV cart to get a DVD player in many places. Businesses were still predominately using VHS, slide shows, and white boards back in 2k. And they still had the ability to just plop a DVD player on top of the VCR on the AV cart when they finally got that DVD player budgeted in and decided to catch up with the times.

These days, there tends to be a VGA port, audio jack, and a projector.


How things change ehh.
 
Xp didn't really need it at launch. DVDs only came out in 95. It took a while for the AV cart to get a DVD player in many places.

Agreed, my point is simply that if lots of businesses are still on XP which they are then hoe are they dealing with not having DVD support in the box if that's such an important feature to businesses?

We have a lot of video at work but it's all streamed and online these days. I really think that this a lot to do about nothing. And people wonder why Microsoft moves slowly. They kind of have to, it just doesn't matter what they do, millions of people won't like it. But that's still just a tiny fraction of Windows users, but upset people do tend to be the most vocal. The average user and even business
 
Agreed, my point is simply that if lots of businesses are still on XP which they are then hoe are they dealing with not having DVD support in the box if that's such an important feature to businesses?

We have a lot of video at work but it's all streamed and online these days. I really think that this a lot to do about nothing. And people wonder why Microsoft moves slowly. They kind of have to, it just doesn't matter what they do, millions of people won't like it. But that's still just a tiny fraction of Windows users, but upset people do tend to be the most vocal. The average user and even business

I agree on this point. It is not all that important for a business to have DVD support out of box. Especially since getting the plugin required is so easy via a number of different means. That said I have not come across a business Xp machine that did not have DVD support in recent memory. It is still needful in many situations.

But I sure as hell would want it in the consumer version, and I would certainly want MC as well.
 
Back
Top