Illegal File Sharing Isn't Stealing

We already have a term for copyright infringement: copyright infringement. It is not stealing, theft or piracy.

Personally, I avoid it, though I have been known to download software cracks and rip my own movies for convenience. I'm pretty sure I'm violating the DMCA, but I don't care. The "pirates" put out a better product.
 
The "pirates" put out a better product.

IMO that's the main reason by far that people pirate. Having to deal with the headache of DRM and all kinds of other bullshit is not a good customer experience.
 
With all this suing and litigation and bullshit going on from the MPAA/RIAA I won't be spending any of my cash on their artists and producers. Too much "Legal organized crime" style stuff going on. They bought some judges, some senators and are going to town. My small deduction won't mean shit to them, but it means a lot to me to not support these fuckers. Indie music labels do a much better job, give more to the artist (some artists do all their own distribution and advertising). Movies, not too sure on alternatives other than streaming and TV.

They are killing their own market by treating their consumers like shit. They forget that the consumer is what keeps them in business. I can't stand companies that forget where the money comes from.

BTW: What do the RIAA/MPAA do for any of the movie or music studios? Just like a union for the studios? They take care of regulation, laws, etc., but everyone else does the real work?
 
Just guessing but I would say that 20% would probably be the amount of people who would have paid if they could not of downloaded it for free. The other 80% would probably of not paid even if they could not get it for free (don't have enough money, etc.) I'm not saying it's right but it's probably more true than saying everything pirated = one lost sale.
 
I forgot to add. Music sales are an example of something that has really suffered. How many people who listen to free online radio, whether a local station or Pandora or something, would of normally bought an album if the streaming wasn't available. It's not fair to say piracy is the cause of all sales issues. Then of course there is the new French "three strikes" which has halfed piracy, yet sales are lower than the year before with double the piracy.

Video game and movie industry is absolutely booming even with all the piracy.
 
I agree but I don't think that's relevant.

This problem isn't a matter of degrees; how much is lost or gained by the process of copying a work of art. That's really what we're talking about here, no matter what the art is: musical composition, game development, drawing, whatever.

Those who create content of any type have the right to control if and how they distribute their works.
But only the ones they themselves directly control. Further, they have no right to control my property, e.g. if I want to use my ink and paper to copy a book--they have no right to tell me I cannot.

There is a big difference between copyright infringement, trademark infringement, and patent infringement. We're discussing here primarily copyright infringement, which doesn't prevent anyone from reproducing the work themselves and distributing it themselves (they would have created a replica of a pre-existing work using their own labor, which they then have control over) but it protects an artists right to their original work (can't copy a work and then distribute it as your own).
That falls under plagiarism/fraud. If, however, you want to copy something and sell it with all attributions--you should be able to.

t's about who owns the labor of an artist. Unless they've signed a contract giving that ownership to someone else (and many do), the artist owns what they create and have the right to control how their works are handled.
Only what they directly sell.

Your labor is your property, which is why we despise forcing people to work for others without compensation in slavery.
Copyright infringement then, is a form of appropriating a person's labor for your own purposes without paying appropriate compensation to the artist for their work.
Non sequitur.

From a principled perspective, it's wonderful to see how many amazingly generous people labor and then share their creations with the world (some even doing it for free). Those who cheapen their efforts by creating copies and then distributing them without permission undermine this incredible gift and discourage people from doing the same.
That's counterhistorical.
 
My favorite thing to point out whenever this is brought up is that copyright infringement does NOT NECESSARILY equal a lost sale.

No real figures to back it up, but do you really think that every time a person downloads a song or movie that they would have paid to listen or watch that content otherwise? If its worth the money people will pay for it. If its not, they wont and wouldnt have regardless. They just would have never consumed the content.

http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1683320

This seems to be related. If what you say is true... there sales should be up, no?
 
They need to put their money where their mouths are

  1. Anyone they take to court must be charged with "theft". See how that flies with the judge.
  2. They should claim all losses from piracy on their tax returns, just like any other loss. See how that flies with government revenue collectors.
  3. Take out an insurance policy against "content theft". See how that flies with their insurance companies.


Until they do these things, they have no right to claim it's theft.
 
IMO by far the main reason people pirate is because it's free ;)

To some extent I disagree. People are generally looking for the path of least resistance. If there is an easier way that people aren't paying exorbitant prices for they will generally go that route. It's all about the value being right, and the values generally aren't. If someone could buy a movie and download it for $2 more people would be like to buy it then try to torrent it, simply because they are assured of the quality of the product and the cost is in line. They wouldn't want to go through the trouble of trying to find a quality torrent with a decent download.
 
Back in the day, I would use a dual cassette deck to record the radio, records, cassette's and even CD's. I eventually graduated to a Sony CDA-920s and copied CD's borrowed from the library. Now days, it's MP3 downloads.

My point is they have not lost any money from me. They don't make a product that is worth anything to me as there are free sources even without the internet.
 
File sharing is isn't stealing.
Jaywalking is isn't murder.
Peanut butter isn't a tractor.
Dancing isn't a pack of AA batteries.

We have different words for different things; I abhor this corruption of the English language.
 
To some extent I disagree. People are generally looking for the path of least resistance. If there is an easier way that people aren't paying exorbitant prices for they will generally go that route. It's all about the value being right, and the values generally aren't. If someone could buy a movie and download it for $2 more people would be like to buy it then try to torrent it, simply because they are assured of the quality of the product and the cost is in line. They wouldn't want to go through the trouble of trying to find a quality torrent with a decent download.

But then you have games which have no DRM, are easy to obtain through Steam or various other forms of digital and physical distribution and often are cheap and they still get pirated to buggery. I'm not saying that piracy equates to lost sales, but lets call a spade a spade here and admit a large portion of people are doing it because it's free first and foremost.

The price thing is an interesting issue. Games are typically $50 or $60 at launch. What price do you think they'd have to lower them to in order to win over these people who would supposedly buy it instead of torrenting it that you mention? $20? $10? $5? I don't doubt publishers have considered this option, but clearly they don't feel they'll gain the 3, 6 or 10 times as many sales required in order to make the same amount of money as releasing at $60. They are, after all, in the business of making money, so they're gonna sell games for the price they think is going to make them the most money, not the most money per sale, but the most money overall. They've surely thought about it "hmm, if we halve the price of this, will we get double the sales to make up for it?".
 
One of the MAME developers made a really good point at the shmups forum a few weeks ago. When it comes to copyrighted works such as music, movies, games, and software, the market can be represented as a pyramid. At the top, you have people who will buy it new. Second level, people who will buy it second hand. Third level, people who will acquire it via unauthorized downloading (or buying it from one of the street vendors who deal in this kind of trade). Fourth level, people who don't consider it worth buying or getting from P2P. Bottom level, people who have never heard of it.

The industry sees everyone below the top level as lost sales no matter how ridiculous it is in reality. The people on the bottom four levels of the pyramid never were customers, and the only ones who can be converted are the ones on the very bottom via advertising and word of mouth, and even then, it's not a guarantee.

The big corporations in the industry know full and well that copyright infringement doesn't cost them anywhere near as much money as they're claiming, but that's not what they're after. They want to keep everything locked down and controlled. They don't want to embrace the new market because it operates via a medium that they don't control. They control what's on the radio and tv. With those mediums, you have to go through them, so either you give them a cut or your work gets no exposure. With the internet, everyone has equal representation. Anyone can put their creative work on the internet and distribute it without the need to go through one of the big players. That's what these companies don't like, and that's what SOPA and PIPA were about. Instead of embracing the new market and putting out quality, they would rather maintain an archaic business model. They want to use legislation and scare tactics to further that end.
 
File sharing is isn't stealing.
Jaywalking is isn't murder.
Peanut butter isn't a tractor.
Dancing isn't a pack of AA batteries.

We have different words for different things; I abhor this corruption of the English language.

.... uh... can you explain the last 3?
 
File sharing is isn't stealing.
Jaywalking is isn't murder.
Peanut butter isn't a tractor.
Dancing isn't a pack of AA batteries.

We have different words for different things; I abhor this corruption of the English language.

Corruption of the English language is how English got to where it is now. If it weren't for corruption of the English langauge we'd probably all still be able to understand Beowulf. :p

Its part of how English has developed as a language, words changing with context and usage. People tie a certain word with an act or object because of vague ties or perhaps simply because they find it abhorrent and liken it to some evil act.

Look at piracy. Piracy has come to mean copyright infringement due to labelling a perceived abhorrent act and subsequent usage of the word in that context, even though it has little to do with criminal acts on the high seas. Of course piracy as a criminal act on the high seas is in itself a modification of a word to a specific context. It has an interesting etymology.

http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=pirate

I had no idea that the word "pirate" had a connotation of taking another's work going all the way back to 1701, always figured it was a much more modern term. Nor did I know the word shares the same root as "peril".

If people find copyright infringement enough of a terrible act to liken it to thievery and continue to use the word in such a context, the English language will adapt and copyright infringement will become "thievery", if not by the current definition of the word, then by some other definition.

Its this sort of corruption of the English language that has produced such a broad and interesting language which allows us to do things like crossword puzzles due to the multiple meanings of words and the way multiple words can have the same meaning.
 
But then you have games which have no DRM, are easy to obtain through Steam or various other forms of digital and physical distribution and often are cheap and they still get pirated to buggery. I'm not saying that piracy equates to lost sales, but lets call a spade a spade here and admit a large portion of people are doing it because it's free first and foremost.

The price thing is an interesting issue. Games are typically $50 or $60 at launch. What price do you think they'd have to lower them to in order to win over these people who would supposedly buy it instead of torrenting it that you mention? $20? $10? $5? I don't doubt publishers have considered this option, but clearly they don't feel they'll gain the 3, 6 or 10 times as many sales required in order to make the same amount of money as releasing at $60. They are, after all, in the business of making money, so they're gonna sell games for the price they think is going to make them the most money, not the most money per sale, but the most money overall. They've surely thought about it "hmm, if we halve the price of this, will we get double the sales to make up for it?".

Those people aren't customers.
 
The copyright movement is nothing more than the rich and the powerful trying to control the free flow of information under the guise of "protecting the artists" They've propagandized people to the point that some folks actually think it is necessary for society, and that our civilization will collapse without it.

Copyright was really useful when the community of people that could communicate with each other was in the hundreds or thousands; ideas were rare commodities to be protected. Now we have seven billion people spewing out and endless supply of art. Ideas are no longer scarce; they don't need the protection they once did. Nobody needs to encourage works to be created because they're gushing from literally billions of sources.

All that copyright does now is create a system of artificial scarcity, using public resources (court systems, legislature, prisons) to steal ideas away from the public from the public domain.
 
But then you have games which have no DRM, are easy to obtain through Steam or various other forms of digital and physical distribution and often are cheap and they still get pirated to buggery. I'm not saying that piracy equates to lost sales, but lets call a spade a spade here and admit a large portion of people are doing it because it's free first and foremost.

I don't completely diagree here, but I would add there are virtually no protections for the consumer. There's absolutely no chance of returning products of these types if the purchaser either doesn't like it or if it doesn't run correctly on whatever hardware and OS they have. I think people would feel a whole lot better buying something knowing they could return it. I know that opens another can of worms with return abuses when someone returns a game they finished. But, there should be some return policy.
 
But then you have games which have no DRM, are easy to obtain through Steam or various other forms of digital and physical distribution and often are cheap and they still get pirated to buggery. I'm not saying that piracy equates to lost sales, but lets call a spade a spade here and admit a large portion of people are doing it because it's free first and foremost.

I only buy games in cash. There's only one store chain that sells those games over here. Imagine a shop like Gamestop with a monopoly of a whole country's retail PC game store industry. That's our situation. If the launch price is $60, that price would stick for at least 4+ years. For example, CoD: 4 is still the same price as CoD: MW2 and CoD: MW3. The only games that get small discounts are Madden '05, NBA Live '06, The Sims, Football Manager 2004, Sim Theme Park...
 
I only buy games in cash. There's only one store chain that sells those games over here. Imagine a shop like Gamestop with a monopoly of a whole country's retail PC game store industry. That's our situation. If the launch price is $60, that price would stick for at least 4+ years. For example, CoD: 4 is still the same price as CoD: MW2 and CoD: MW3. The only games that get small discounts are Madden '05, NBA Live '06, The Sims, Football Manager 2004, Sim Theme Park...
I think this is where sweeping generalizations really fall apart--reality :D

These companies know they can reduce piracy dramatically by selling all their games for $10, but they'll never do it. Why give the customer what they want at a reasonable price when you can CONTROL THE LAWS AND THE PEOPLE OF THE ENTIRE EARTH instead?
 
Back
Top