Bird Wings Hoax Guy Interviewed

Uh huh. Though with the poor quality of that hoax video they did, it would be surprising if they actually though it would fool anyone.

Though, shockingly, there were quite a few people on [H] that seemed to believe it.
 
the most amazing part is the direct link to the story and not to the hardocp.com link first
 
Uh huh. Though with the poor quality of that hoax video they did, it would be surprising if they actually though it would fool anyone.

Though, shockingly, there were quite a few people on [H] that seemed to believe it.

The best part of that vid was seeing how many people are easily mislead.

Remember they can all vote.
 
Not really surprising. While something like that technically could be done with lightweight batteries, motors, structure, good engineering, etc. It was pretty obvious it was a fake.
 
Uh huh. Though with the poor quality of that hoax video they did, it would be surprising if they actually though it would fool anyone.

Though, shockingly, there were quite a few people on [H] that seemed to believe it.

I will say in my defence and the defence of [H], a lot of the "seemed to believe it" comments were from me in that thread, and I didn't actually believe it (though I will admit I wanted to, and know nothing about CGI and faking videos so didn't pick up on any of that stuff, I thought it was fake based on structural and power delivery reasons, like the cloth being unloaded, the spars being insufficient and not flexing like a loaded beam, the engine which probably is sufficiently powerful but being positioned where it needlessly had to fight against a lot of torque which would waste most its power, and the structural design being such that it looked to be hugely unstable) but rather I was enjoying having a physics discussions on misconceptions people had on flight physics and calling it a hoax because of supposed aerodynamic laws that don't actually exist. :p

A large part of my day to day job is studying flapping flight in insects and small birds (which is fundamentally different to flapping on larger birds and ornithopters, though still largely related). It was funny to read comments like "because of x aerodynamic reason its a fake" when x aerodynamic reason doesn't exist or is already implemented on other flyers both natural and man made that work just fine.

I will admit I wanted to believe it though. :p
 
It's kind of a pity that it didn't work. The number of Darwin awards resulting from people trying it and failing with it would be rather entertaining.
 
Douche-bags like this desensitize the public to truly amazing feats.

Next time someone actually accomplishes something great, half the people out there will be shouting "faaake, fake, fake"!
 
Back
Top