Noob Question: Maximum Memory Capacity

Machupo

Gravity Tester
2FA
Joined
Nov 14, 2004
Messages
6,263
So, I'm curious what controls the maximum memory capacity that a motherboard can support. I thought that with the memory controller on the die of the cpu, there would be no difference between various motherboards as long as they had the same socket.

Guess not. For example, I have a Gigabyte H67N-USB3-B3 which is running with 16GB of memory (2x8GB dimms). I want to upgrade to a Z68 motherboard (specifically, the Giada MI-Z68) but it only claims support for 8GB memory.

Is this just outdated documents, or is it something controlled by the BIOS/UEFI? Can I hex edit a value to recognize more memory?


Never really thought about these things, and doesn't seem to be too much specific info around (or my google-fu is lacking), what do you think [H]?
 
Sandy bridges don't have north bridges, the IMC is on the CPU. Maybe it is just a translation issue, and they mean that it has two slots that support 8GB per slot instead of total? That would make more sense, since SB CPUs can support 8GB DIMMs.
 
Last edited:
The IMC is not the only thing that decides how much RAM can be used, the IMC only determines how much badwidth of RAM can be "handled". The amount of bandwidth for the RAM is determined by the bus given to it on the MB. The bigger the bus, the more money it costs the manufacturer. This is why some MBs only allow Dual Channel on 2 lanes, and others will allow it on all lanes. These days it is becoming more rare to not see Dual Channel available on all lanes. As for the total capacity, many manufacturers just spit out the recommended rather than the max allowed. So if you have a board that says 8GB and has 4 slots, most likely it can handle 16GB. But those 16GB probably can't operate at OC speeds, meaning that you would most likely have to run it at 1333 or 1066 and not 1600 or above.
 
No issues -- board is running fine w/ 16384MB accessible :)
 
So, I'm curious what controls the maximum memory capacity that a motherboard can support. I thought that with the memory controller on the die of the cpu, there would be no difference between various motherboards as long as they had the same socket.

Guess not. For example, I have a Gigabyte H67N-USB3-B3 which is running with 16GB of memory (2x8GB dimms). I want to upgrade to a Z68 motherboard (specifically, the Giada MI-Z68) but it only claims support for 8GB memory.

Is this just outdated documents, or is it something controlled by the BIOS/UEFI? Can I hex edit a value to recognize more memory?


Never really thought about these things, and doesn't seem to be too much specific info around (or my google-fu is lacking), what do you think [H]?

Maximum supported memory comes down to a wide range of variables. The most important are what the memory controller and chipset were designed to handle. Memory controllers have to be validated to handle the requirements of higher density modules. It doesn't matter if you have 4 memory slots if the controller only supports 16GB of RAM. It won't take 4x 8GB modules no matter how much you want it to. Part of their specifications includes density of modules per supported DIMM slot. On the motherboard side, validation for a given module type may come down to simple compatibility testing. One thing I've noticed is that some cheaper boards may only be validated for a certain amount of memory despite what the chipset actually supports. This may simply come down to the time and resources needed to procure all the necessary modules and actually perform validation on them. All these things take time. In some cases a given module simply didn't exist or wasn't available when a board was designed, validated, and launched. Therefore it won't appear on the motherboard (QVL) for RAM modules.

In some cases a motherboard manufacturer may not have validated a given motherboard with the necessary modules to verify the board works with the maximum amount of RAM supported by the chipset and memory controller. Though I don't see this as often as I used to and typically only see it with budget boards anyway. In these cases installing the maximum amount of RAM supported by the chipset may indeed work but it remains an untested configuration so the manufacturer simply lists the configuration as unsupported or airs on the side of caution while publishing motherboard specifications which indicate support for less than what the chipset does.

If you've ever read any QVL documentation from manufacturers, which is typically posted on their web sites, you'll find that they only test boards with a handful of modules and in a variety of configurations which may or may not cover the modules you intend to purchase or you've already got. For example: I've seen motherboards which validated Corsair part number TR3X6G1866C7GT ver 2.1 DDR3 1866MHz modules, but didn't validate TR3X6G2000C8GT modules. Does that mean the latter will not work? No it doesn't. But what it means is that if you contact the manufacturer for support, and you aren't using modules on the QVL, then they may lay the blame on those modules, or at least suggest you test with supported modules before they'll issue an RMA. Rarely are they such hard asses about it, but such things are known to happen from time to time.

On a more technical side, or rather in some cases in which the amount of supported memory falls short of what the chipset is designed for, it may not be a matter of firmware / BIOS coding either. It may also come down to electrical considerations. I'm not an electrical engineer, so if one is around here, please feel free to chime in. But as I understand it, part of what it boils down to is electrical design. Higher density modules may have more strict need to adhere to certain specific voltages and signal quality, in which case variances which may be present in a board designed for 16GB of RAM won't have high enough quality components to handle increased frequencies of some modules, or the load of additional modules. If you look at a motherboard PCB, you'll notice that there are power phases like the ones flanking the CPU socket. All things being equal, more is typically better. Too few, or in the case of low quality component selection, these phases just end up being inadequate. They are necessary for memory stability. Again I don't know if there is an actual increase (beyond a negligible amount anyway) in electrical load when it comes to higher density modules, but I do know that more modules, and larger modules at higher frequencies, will require stronger electrical support. In other words, clock frequency and number of modules definitely increase the need for stronger components.

So a manufacturer can cheap out and simply say, OK no one will use 8GB modules at DDR3 2133MHz on this board, so we'll design it with 4GB in mind and we'll support speeds up to 2133MHz or whatever. Conversely you will have some companies support 4 modules instead of 8, but use a very strong power solution for those 4 modules in order to attain greater flexibility and clock speed ranges while overclocking RAM. So there are always potential trade offs when designing these things.

In short if it's a matter of simple validation, you may be able to use more RAM than is officially supported so long as the memory controller can handle that amount of RAM. If it's a matter of shoddy design and or cheap component selection on the motherboard manufacturers part, you won't like the result of trying to use higher density modules than are officially supported. If you are trying to exceed what the chipset will support simply because you can physically shove more modules in there, don't bother. It's not going to work.

Examples of this: If you've got a P67 motherboard, it suppots up to 32GB of RAM max. Period end of story. If another P67 board says it supports only 16GB of RAM, it's either only got two DIMM slots, or it's either a piece of shit by design or it wasn't validated due to coming from a third rate company and because the QVL testing was lacking severely. Both conditions are suspect and are a cause for concern. If you've got an older P55 chipset based board, it has the same number of slots as P67 typically does, but again don't bother shoving 32GB of RAM in it because the memory controller can't handle more than 16GB of RAM. If you've got an X79 chipset based board, it can support 64GB of RAM in 8 DIMMs. You can not however throw in 64GB of RAM in 4 DIMMs, or throw in 128GB of RAM in 8 DIMMs. This will not work because the design of everything will not support higher density modules even if the amount of installed RAM is within the range of what is supported.

The difference is caused by the north bridge chip set used.

In part.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top