building pc for (low res) gaming

YesPlz

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 26, 2007
Messages
245
) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc
Web browsing, media, BF3 @ 1280*1024, and a few other [older] games.

2) What's your budget?
$600 but if we can save without sacrificing performance

4) Already have monitor, mouse, keyboard

What I've looked at so far:

ASUS M5A97 motherboard - $99.99
AMD Athlon II X3 455 Rana 3.3GHz - $79.99
XFX ATI Radeon HD6770 HD677XZNLC - $109.99
G.SKILL Ripjaws Series 4GB DDR3 DDR3 1600 F3-12800CL9S-4GBRLL - $22.99
CORSAIR Professional Series HX650 - $114.99
Seagate Barracuda ST250DM000 250GB - $89.99
ASUS 24X DVD Burner - $19.99
LIAN LI Lancool PC-K58W Black - $79.99

Don't need more than 250gb, but i feel like that hard drive is expensive, but the only cheaper ones i found were refurbs.

Also didn't need a window on my case. Want the case without tons of lights, but i guess i can deal with a window if the case is a good one.

5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing? Monitor, mouse, keyboard.

6) Will you be overclocking?
No.

7) What is the max resolution of your monitor? 1280*1024

8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC? Within a week or two

9) What features do you need in a motherboard? None necessarily.

10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license? yes, windows 7 32bit license.

Thank you for suggestion ahead of time :)
 
Last edited:
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
My suggestions:

1. Take a quad over the X2, especially for BF3. Had a sandy bridge dual core G620 @ 2.6GHz. Just couldn't cut it for BF3, even at 1440x900. Was barely driving a 6870 to 60% utilization. Not recommended, unless you're okay with 35 FPS average.

2. Take a 4GB 1 stick so that you'd have the option to quickly double the RAM with another. In my experience, BF3 runs so much faster if you had more than 4GB - even just 5GB (like in my Q6600 rig). Not sure how the latter would apply to you though since you're going to be running on 32bit.
 
You're buying a much larger psu than you need, and there are cheaper cases than the lian li that are nicer. I'll try to post a parts list when I'm no longer on my phone. Are you near a microcenter?
 
no i am not near a MC :( online preferred.

I changed the processor to an X3 and memory [to a single stick].

is there maybe a cheaper motherboard ?

Ok i will wait for you to post some good cases. very simple outside is fine by me.
 
Last edited:
I'm in the US and no big electronic retailers here :) online preferred

Well next time please answer that question as not everyone who asks for help here on the forums is from the U.S. And some of the non-U.S posters use Newegg links for references.


Anyway, I recommend this build isntead:
$173 - Intel Pentium G620 CPU + Biostar TZ68A+ Intel Z68 ATX Motherboard
$20 - G.Skill F3-10666CL9S-2GBNT 4GB DDR3 1333 RAM
$110 - XFX HD-677X-ZNLC Radeon HD 6770 1GB PCI-E Video Card
$156 - Hitachi Desktar 7K1000.D HDS721010DLE630 1TB SATA 6.0Gb/s Hard Drive
$19 - LG iHAS224-06 DVD Burner
$79 - Antec High Current Gamer Series HCG-620 620W PSU
$50 - NZXT Source 210 Elite White with Black Front Trim ATX Case
----
Total: $607 shipped

The above setup gets you a faster CPU and a signigicantly faster hard drive. The hard drive is usually going to be the slowest part of the PC and will affect how the PC actually feels and responds to your input. Not to mention the faster load times as well with a game like BF3. As such, I went with one of the faster consumer grade drives out there in the above setup. Especially since that 250GB drive you chose is really bloody slow.

As for the CPU, despite what mda said, in that price range, the Intel G620 outperforms virtually every AMD CPU under $100 in many games out there. Your budget simply doesn't allow for a higher-end quad-core CPU.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Ok, now that I have something with an actual keyboard in front of me...

Danny's list is good, but I still think you'd be spending money where you don't need to. There is ZERO need for a 600w+ power supply on a system like this; with no overclocking you're going to struggle to hit more than 250-300w with a 6770 and a 100w TDP cpu, and that'd be slamming the system with furmark and prime95 or something similar. A good 400w would be sufficient; anything more is just a waste of money.

I agree with him on the CPU, though; unless you're beholden to an AMD platform for some reason, go with sandy bridge. The x3 455 is $80 at Newegg and on most gaming benchmarks even the Pentium G620 ($73 before a $10 instant rebate) is faster ( http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/202?vs=406 ).

I would stick with 2 sticks of RAM, though. Going to one knocks you down to single channel and the cost is basically the same so... why would you give up free performance?

All that having been said, here's what I'd do with $600:
Case: Antec 300 w/430w PSU
The 300 is a decent case; I'd prefer the top fan to be a 120mm, but 140s are common enough that when it fails you can find something to replace it. The BP430 power supply is OEM'd by Delta, and while it's not a high end power supply it's certainly capable of hitting its rated power output, and it has some japanese caps on the secondary so it's not exactly scraping the bottom of the barrel. For this system it's more than good enough.​
PSU: Comes w/case
Motherboard: Intel BOXDH67CLB3
This is cheaper than the Biostar board Danny linked (even with the combo deal), and it's hard to beat Intel boards for reliability. You can't/won't overclock so that's not a concern, and while it gives up a second x16 slot to the Biostar board and runs a H67 chipset instead of Z68, for your intended use it doesn't matter.​
RAM: Mushkin 4GB (2x2GB) DDR3-1333
Newegg has a bunch of different 2x2GB DDR3-1333 kits around $20-25; my preference is for Mushkin, but most of them would serve you fine. Like I said eariler, I'd stick with a 2x2GB kit.​
CPU: Intel Core i3 2120 combo w/Xigmatek 92mm HDT heatsink
The 2120 is a hell of a lot faster than the G620 or the AMD CPUs you were looking at, and the Xigmatek heatsink is pretty decent. Technically speaking the retail Intel heatsink will be sufficient, but I'd be more comfortable with something a little better on it. I've used the SD963 on several systems before, and for lower-power chips at stock speeds I like it a lot.​
Video Card: XFX AMD Radeon HD6850
Much faster than the 6770, not that much more expensive after rebates and still not too power hungry.​
Optical Drive: LiteOn DVD-RW/+RW dual layer with Lightscribe support
LiteOn makes fantastic optical drives, there's no reason to spend any more on anything else.​
Hard Drive: Western Digital 5000AAKX Caviar blue- 500GB, SATA III, 7200RPM
A SSD is kind of a non-starter for a gaming system at this price point, unfortunately. The 5000AAKX may or may not be as fast as the 1TB Seagate drive Danny recommended; I buy SSDs almost exclusively so I honestly haven't paid attention. As far as I know though, the 5000AAKX is a single platter drive so it should be very quick, and I've used a few of them in systems at work and they've done fine.​

And that's about it. The Antec 300 comes with a couple exhaust fans and you won't need intake fans for this build in that case.

Total: $649.88
-$20 rebate on CPU/Heatsink combo
-$30 rebate on graphics card
-----
$599.88 + tax if applicable and shipping


You're not going to get a faster stock-clocked system for $600 than that. If you can't wait on the rebates and it needs to be under $600 (before tax and shipping) at Newegg, throw the XFX 6770 in instead of the 6850. You'll be at the same $599.88 but before rebates; after rebates it'll be $559.88.

One more thing to consider; if you want a higher quality PSU than the CP430, and you're OK with a case that you have to punch out the I/O shield covers on, take a look at this HEC 6C60BS. Going this route over the Antec 300 will save you enough to buy an XFX Pro Series 450w PSU, which is OEM'd by Seasonic and has 100% Japanese capacitors. There's nothing wrong with the BP430 in the Antec case, but this is a higher quality unit that'll probably last a few years longer than the BP430. You'll need to pick up a couple 120mm fans for it, though; given your budget I'd go with the Antec Tricools; they're not quality fans by any stretch of the imagination but they're good enough and they're not offensively loud. Going that route would be about $10 more (after rebates) than going with the Antec case would.
 
Danny's list is good, but I still think you'd be spending money where you don't need to. There is ZERO need for a 600w+ power supply on a system like this; with no overclocking you're going to struggle to hit more than 250-300w with a 6770 and a 100w TDP cpu, and that'd be slamming the system with furmark and prime95 or something similar. A good 400w would be sufficient; anything more is just a waste of money.

I agree with him on the CPU, though; unless you're beholden to an AMD platform for some reason, go with sandy bridge. The x3 455 is $80 at Newegg and on most gaming benchmarks even the Pentium G620 ($73 before a $10 instant rebate) is faster ( http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/202?vs=406 ).

I would stick with 2 sticks of RAM, though. Going to one knocks you down to single channel and the cost is basically the same so... why would you give up free performance?

There is a method to Danny's madness, and I see a couple of issues with your build:

- The Antec Three Hundred is a cramped case. If the OP decides to use a high-end video card in the future, then he will have problems fitting it into the case.

- The performance loss from going from dual-channel RAM to single-channel RAM is at most single digits. It's virtually unnoticeable in everyday tasks. With only one stick of RAM, however, you open up the possibility of upgrading (in the future) to 16GB (or more, if the prices of 8GB sticks drop down soon enough).

Danny designed his build (compared to yours) on the assumption of future plans to upgrade the processor and video card and add more RAM. All that, of course is prefaced on when the OP decides to upgrade his monitor, which would necessitate those upgrades.
 
Danny designed his build (compared to yours) on the assumption of future plans to upgrade the processor and video card and add more RAM. All that, of course is prefaced on when the OP decides to upgrade his monitor, which would necessitate those upgrades.

That's a valid point, and it's good justification for buying a larger power supply and a board with multi-GPU support, but I have to respectfully disagree with you on the case and the RAM.

I can't speak directly to the space in the 300; I haven't used Antec cases in years and if I were to start it wouldn't be with the 300. BUT it comes with a decent power supply, and the cost savings from that makes room for spending money elsewhere. From what I've seen on GIS, it fits a 560Ti with plenty of room to spare, so... I dunno. Anything up to about 10.5" seems to be fine; this is apparently a GTX260. I don't see it being cramped unless you're trying to fit a 580 or something in it. *shrug*

Personally, in this price bracket, I'd buy a HAF912 and take out the upper hard drive cage if I needed to to make room for a longer card, but that'd run more like $100-120 (edit: with a decent power supply), plus the cost of at least two additional fans.

As far as the RAM goes, I'm aware of the reasoning behind going with 1 4GB stick and I was refraining from explicitly stating my opinion on it. Since it's been brought up though, I think it's silly.

I mean no offense at all, but it strikes me as absolutely nonsensical. I mean... You can do it, but it's not how I would go about it (obviously), and here's why: You're spending about $20-25 either way, right? Right. So you get a bit more performance at the same price for now. When the OP is ready to upgrade, both the Biostar board and the Intel board have 4 RAM slots, so they could upgrade to 12GB without a problem. Sure, if they want to go to 16GB (with 4GB sticks), they'll end up tossing two usable 2GB sticks and they'll have to buy 4 4GB sticks instead of 3 but I mean... so what?

At current prices that'll cost about $50-the $25 "lost" from throwing the original 2x2gb kit away, and the $25 more you'll spend on a 4th 4GB stick. O...k...? I can't even fill up my car for $50 and it has a gas tank the size of a thimble. You can barely buy lunch for two people-around here, at least-at a restaurant that doesn't serve food on cafeteria trays for $50. It's a trivial amount of money, especially if he's going to run the system the way it is for more than a month or two.

As you alluded to, it really comes down to the OP's priorities. Giving up the i3 and the 5850 could definitely buy them a lot of headroom for upgrades down the road. But Haswell will be out in what, about 18 months, give-or-take? Unless he's planning on doing a wholesale upgrade to a high end Ivy Bridge CPU and a $250+ video card within about 9 months, I think it'd be a waste of money to upgrade this box at all.
 
Last edited:
I can't speak directly to the space in the 300; I haven't used Antec cases in years and if I were to start it wouldn't be with the 300. BUT it comes with a decent power supply, and the cost savings from that makes room for spending money elsewhere. From what I've seen on GIS, it fits a 560Ti with plenty of room to spare, so... I dunno. Anything up to about 10.5" seems to be fine; this is apparently a GTX260. I don't see it being cramped unless you're trying to fit a 580 or something in it. *shrug*
Compared to other cases in that price range, it's a fairly cramped case. Can it fit relatively long video cards? Somewhat. However it leaves little to no space. Not to mention that there are plenty of other cases in that price range that has more space and significantly greater cable management. The pictures you have provided clearly show to me how cramped that case is. Not to mention my personal experience with that case. As such, unless that Antec 300 case was like $30 or less, it's not a good deal considering that there are $50 to $60 cases that offers a greater amount of space as well as cable management.

As far as the RAM goes, I'm aware of the reasoning behind going with 1 4GB stick and I was refraining from explicitly stating my opinion on it. Since it's been brought up though, I think it's silly.

I mean no offense at all, but it strikes me as absolutely nonsensical. I mean... You can do it, but it's not how I would go about it (obviously), and here's why: You're spending about $20-25 either way, right? Right. So you get a bit more performance at the same price for now. When the OP is ready to upgrade, both the Biostar board and the Intel board have 4 RAM slots, so they could upgrade to 12GB without a problem. Sure, if they want to go to 16GB (with 4GB sticks), they'll end up tossing two usable 2GB sticks and they'll have to buy 4 4GB sticks instead of 3 but I mean... so what?

At current prices that'll cost about $50-the $25 "lost" from throwing the original 2x2gb kit away, and the $25 more you'll spend on a 4th 4GB stick. O...k...? I can't even fill up my car for $50 and it has a gas tank the size of a thimble. You can barely buy lunch for two people-around here, at least-at a restaurant that doesn't serve food on cafeteria trays for $50. It's a trivial amount of money, especially if he's going to run the system the way it is for more than a month or two.
It is still wasting money and parts. Personally to me that's a silly idea as well: Why waste money and parts for just a miniscule performance increase? To you, $25 is trivial. To other, $25 is a decent chunk of change that they don't want to waste.

In any case, it's up to the OP and whatever his priorities are. If this was my setup, I wouldn't do as you would and waste $25 and two usable sticks of RAM.

Ok, now that I have something with an actual keyboard in front of me...

Danny's list is good, but I still think you'd be spending money where you don't need to. There is ZERO need for a 600w+ power supply on a system like this; with no overclocking you're going to struggle to hit more than 250-300w with a 6770 and a 100w TDP cpu, and that'd be slamming the system with furmark and prime95 or something similar. A good 400w would be sufficient; anything more is just a waste of money.
Thats a fair point and Tiraides already made my case for the larger PSU. I know full well that setup will be fine on a 400W PSU. So, if the OP isn't planning on upgrading to a GPU higher than HD 6850/HD 6870 in terms of power use for the next 3-5 years, then by all means he should downgrade the PSU I recommended earlier to a solid 400W PSU.


However, the parts you recommended aren't exactly the best of buys. I should preface that I do not factor in MIR until the rebate check/card is in my hands. IMO, it's a bit foolhardy to factor in the cost of a MIR when there's always a chance for the rebate companies to deny your rebate. Not to mention that not everyone is that attentive when filling out the rebates.
All that having been said, here's what I'd do with $600:
Case: Antec 300 w/430w PSU
The 300 is a decent case; I'd prefer the top fan to be a 120mm, but 140s are common enough that when it fails you can find something to replace it. The BP430 power supply is OEM'd by Delta, and while it's not a high end power supply it's certainly capable of hitting its rated power output, and it has some japanese caps on the secondary so it's not exactly scraping the bottom of the barrel. For this system it's more than good enough.​
PSU: Comes w/case
Once you factor in shipping, that case comes out to $95. Not a good deal at all considering the cramped size as well as shitty cable management mentioned earlier about the Antec 300. Not to mention that the quality of the PSU, despite being a Delta, is only so-so. For $95 shipped, you can get a better setup:
$50 - NZXT Source 210 Elite White with Black Front Trim ATX Case
$45 - Antec NEO ECO 400C 400W PSU
--
Total: $95 shipped

Same price as the case + PSU combo you listed but better:
- Roomier case with significantly better cable management.
- Significantly better quality PSU
Video Card: XFX AMD Radeon HD6850
Much faster than the 6770, not that much more expensive after rebates and still not too power hungry.​
At $168 shipped, that video card is not a good buy at all considering that the faster costs $2 more:
$170 - XFX HD-687A-ZHFC Radeon HD 6870 1GB PCI-E Video Card

Hard Drive: Western Digital 5000AAKX Caviar blue- 500GB, SATA III, 7200RPM
A SSD is kind of a non-starter for a gaming system at this price point, unfortunately. The 5000AAKX may or may not be as fast as the 1TB Seagate drive Danny recommended; I buy SSDs almost exclusively so I honestly haven't paid attention. As far as I know though, the 5000AAKX is a single platter drive so it should be very quick, and I've used a few of them in systems at work and they've done fine.​
Do note that I recommended a Hitachi drive, not a Seagate. Anyway, yes the 5000AAKX is a single platter drive but the design itself is fairly old at this point in time. The Hitachi drive I recommended is based on a newer single 1TB platter design. As a result, it's roughly 30% to 35% faster than that WD drive. That WD 500GB Drive comes out to $128 shipped. The extra $28 for the Hitachi drive I recommended is well worth it IMO as it gets you 30% to 30% performance increase as well as double the space.
 
However, the parts you recommended aren't exactly the best of buys. I should preface that I do not factor in MIR until the rebate check/card is in my hands. IMO, it's a bit foolhardy to factor in the cost of a MIR when there's always a chance for the rebate companies to deny your rebate. Not to mention that not everyone is that attentive when filling out the rebates.

Valid point. I never bother with MIRs. Too much hassle for too small an amount of money. But if you're trying to squeeze the absolute fastest components you can into a given budget they can be a valid option. Just depends on how much work you want to do.

Once you factor in shipping, that case comes out to $95. Not a good deal at all considering the cramped size as well as shitty cable management mentioned earlier about the Antec 300. Not to mention that the quality of the PSU, despite being a Delta, is only so-so. For $95 shipped, you can get a better setup:
$50 - NZXT Source 210 Elite White with Black Front Trim ATX Case
$45 - Antec NEO ECO 400C 400W PSU
--
Total: $95 shipped

Same price as the case + PSU combo you listed but better:
- Roomier case with significantly better cable management.
- Significantly better quality PSU

Your definition of cramped is a bit different from mine, it doesn't look too bad to me. But then I stuck a 125w Phenom and 4 3870s in a case that's only very slightly larger, and I didn't really think that build was too cramped either, so... :D

But yeah, the NZXT Source looks like a nice case. The reason that I didn't recommend it is that I haven't even seen a NZXT case in person; only Microcenter carries them around here and I haven't looked at their case selection in a while. The Antec isn't an amazing case, but it's adequate and (for me) it's a known quantity; I've dragged one off the shelf at Fry's and looked at it (and then said "Oh, eww. 140mm fan." and put it back :p), so at least I know basically what's going on with it. The last time I recommended a case that I hadn't yet seen in person (I ordered a couple at the same time), it ended up being a flaming hunk of shit in spite of positive reviews, so I tend to avoid doing that. If the NZXT is of decent quality it's definitely a better buy than the Antec is at the same price.

I haven't seen a review or a teardown of the 400C and a quick google search didn't turn up much of interest. If you've got a link to one handy I'd be curious to read it.

At $168 shipped, that video card is not a good buy at all considering that the faster costs $2 more:
$170 - XFX HD-687A-ZHFC Radeon HD 6870 1GB PCI-E Video Card

Sure. After rebates it'd still put it a bit over budget, but it'd be a worthwhile upgrade. This might be better, it's about $10 cheaper both before and after rebates: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814131378

I don't know what Powercolor's support is like, though; I've had a bunch of their cards and they've never given me an issue so... XFX's is supposed to be decent as far as I know.

Do note that I recommended a Hitachi drive, not a Seagate. Anyway, yes the 5000AAKX is a single platter drive but the design itself is fairly old at this point in time. The Hitachi drive I recommended is based on a newer single 1TB platter design. As a result, it's roughly 30% to 35% faster than that WD drive. That WD 500GB Drive comes out to $128 shipped. The extra $28 for the Hitachi drive I recommended is well worth it IMO as it gets you 30% to 30% performance increase as well as double the space.

My mistake on the brand, had a brain fart. Between the two, if it were my build, I'd go with the Hitachi as well-but not at the expense of the i3 and the video card. The WD was a necessary concession to get into the $600 ballpark with the CPU and the video card, and this is probably the one area that I'd spend the least money possible... Given that all hard drives are slower than hell relative to a SSD, the way I see it, if you don't need the storage you might as well buy the cheapest drive you can for now and wait until you can drop about $200-300 on a decent ~120GB SSD.

But like everything else it depends on priorities; the Hitachi will improve boot and load times and it should improve how the system "feels" overall. However, it's (obviously) not going to do anything for framerates in games, and I'm not honestly sure that it's going to do much for the user experience in general. I've had OS installs on basically every 7200rpm+ drive WD has offered since 2008, including both 2.5" generations of Velociraptor as both single drives and in RAID arrays, and the occasional Hitachi and Seagate drive. They all run like crap, imo. Even a pair of the 600GB Velociraptors in RAID 0 is sluggish and annoying to use.

I'm not sure that the performance delta between the Hitachi and the WD is significant enough for most people to notice it in general use without having otherwise identical systems right next to each other. My perception is undeniably skewed; maybe it is, but I couldn't say either way.

Of course, you could say the same thing about single vs. dual channel RAM, the difference there is that (in terms of up-front cost) the RAM is a wash, the HDD upgrade would come at the expense of something to keep it within budget.
 
I haven't seen a review or a teardown of the 400C and a quick google search didn't turn up much of interest. If you've got a link to one handy I'd be curious to read it.
Here's a link fo the 520W version of the Neo Eco line:
http://forums.guru3d.com/showthread.php?t=317192

AFAIK, the entire Neo Eco line is based on the same Seasonic platform.

Sure. After rebates it'd still put it a bit over budget, but it'd be a worthwhile upgrade. This might be better, it's about $10 cheaper both before and after rebates: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814131378

I don't know what Powercolor's support is like, though; I've had a bunch of their cards and they've never given me an issue so... XFX's is supposed to be decent as far as I know.
If he needs to save every bit of cash, then yes that PowerColor would be a choice. However IMO, the extra $10 for the lifetime warranty seems worth it.

My perception is undeniably skewed; maybe it is, but I couldn't say either way.
Fair enough: it is indeed a matter of perception.
 
Back
Top