Windows 8 To Revamp Windows Update

I am truly amazed by some of the posts in this thread.

That makes two of us. There must be some version of Windows out there I've never used because some of the descriptions of Windows here make no sense to me. Machines that restart by looking at them too hard, Windows installs that are easier to deal will than running good AV software, required restarts that haven't improved in a decade.

Glad I'm on my version of Windows.
 
That makes two of us. There must be some version of Windows out there I've never used because some of the descriptions of Windows here make no sense to me. Machines that restart by looking at them too hard, Windows installs that are easier to deal will than running good AV software, required restarts that haven't improved in a decade.

Glad I'm on my version of Windows.

No joke, I have my machines do the auto updates and auto restart while I'm at work. I never notice them.

To the one who thinks there no difference between the patching reboots of win98 and now ... you don't remember having to reboot 7 times to complete a major patch day do you? heck even WinXP had some patches that required multiple reboots to patch. I don't think I've had to do multiple reboots wint Vista/7. If I kept it up to date.

My protection doesn't just protect me it also protects my time. I used to fall under the idea of "Im too smart to get a virus" but then I fell for a VERY well done hijacked link, downloaded the wrong freeware and my computer was more jacked then you ever knew. Problem was I couldn't slipstream because there was a ton of stuff I had to back up and the only way I was going to do that was to remove the crap that got on my machine first, back up then re slip stream my OS back on. It took a while.

I'll always keep ALL machines patched up and AV upto date. It bugs me to high hell my wife doesn't do the same.
 
I would like to be able to keep all the updates locally forever to save me time when doing reinstalls. Just point to the updates on my network. For everything, not just service packs.That is what i would like to see.

If you by chance have a technet account and some sort of VM server at home or the capability to make one, you can install a Windows Server Update Server and with a quick and easy group policy edit have all your machines updating from your very own update server. A fresh windows install may still take a few hours to fully update but downloading said updates at 1Gbps instead of 10-20MB/s or whatever your internet connection does definitely saves some time.

Are you high?

You get it EVERY TIME YOU OPEN A PROGRAM.

And even if it were every full moon.. what am I, a baby?

Look, you've already sunk down to personal insults. I really don't feel like I have anything else to say to you.

So yeah you pretty much blew any credibility you might have had with this one.
 
Good security requires a combination of protective measures and good judgment.

There are many cases were good judgment alone can not save you (like the example of malicious banner ads having nothing to do with the site they are on, previously mentioned in this thread).

UAC is one of the best new security features offered with Windows Vistand and 7. Turning it off is a very foolish thing to do. It gives you - the user a warning if any application is trying to make administrative changes, and as such brings Windows user management closer to the level of that of Linux/Unix systems which are pretty much the golden standard for how user security management should work. Running in an administrative account, or with UAC disabled is a very silly thing to do. Any user with half a brain will do all their work/gaming/browsing in a limited user account, and use an admin account only for administrative tasks. UAC was a bit annoying in initial Vista launches, but they have tweaked it since making it much less intrusive. Some programs will prompt you for access every time you run them, but this is because they are doing something that impacts the computer in a way a standard limited user account does not allow for, and that's the way it SHOULD be.

Disabling Windows Updates are also a very silly thing to do. I can't remember the link right now, but there was an article on the [H] a while back showing that the vast majority of compromised computers are so not because of 0-day exploits, but because of systems that are not patched with the latest security fixes. If your machine is not fully patched and up to date, it is possible for it to become compromised without you doing anything at all just by a compromised machine sitting on the same network and probing everything locally for security holes. The only downside is that Windows Update does not automatically update non MS software. This is - and will remain for some time, Windows biggest security disadvantage compared to most Linux distributions.

Anti-virus programs are the last line of defense. They are not always as effective as we would like them to be, but they are better than nothing. Back in the 286 days, or maybe even in the Pentium days there might have been a system performance argument here to not use a resident anti-virus program, but with today's multi-core systems with gobs of RAM that mostly sits unused/idle it is a no-brainer, especially considering the amount of good, free programs out there. It is also a good idea to supplement with a malware scanner.

To sum it up if you have Win Vista or 7, unless you:
  • Only run in a limited user account except when doing admin work
  • have UAC on
  • Keep Windows Updates on (does not need to be automatic, as long as its run daily, just don't forget. Automatic makes it easier and more secure as it stops you from forgetting)
  • Run resident Virus and malware programs with checks updated definitions (daily), and perform regular (monthly?) scans of your system just to make sure.
  • If you are still on XP or an older Windows version upgrade ASAP, as they are not secure and full of holes

you have either completely misunderstood data security and the threats that are out there or are a complete moron willing to get infected, and spread that shit on to others as part of being in a bot net.

It is IMPOSSIBLE to protect yourself through good judgment/habits alone, even if your good judgment/habits were perfect, which they never are. There are many exploits that are completely transparent to the user.

IMHO, Good judgment and habits when using the computer are important, and they include all the steps in the bullet points above.

This should - IMHO - be a minimum requirement to be allowed on the internet.

It's too bad ISP's don't/can't check and have an automatic shutoff if any of the above haven't been met.
 
Zarathustra[H];1038027289 said:
The only downside is that Windows Update does not automatically update non MS software. This is - and will remain for some time, Windows biggest security disadvantage compared to most Linux distributions.

I agree with your entire post except for this part.

Not every program is in the repository for Linux distros so its not like your are going to be set for everything. On top of that they don't keep them up to date on the latest and greatest.

They have to test the packages and ok them before they are tossed into a repository. For Red Hat that is 6 months to a year after something comes out that it is added. So you are never going to be up to date there, but in fact will normally be a ways behind. In some cases for some programs under some distros it might be longer if ever. Look at Firefox. My Linux based machines with all their patches are only at 3.x with red hat it is never going to get caught up.

One could claim to a point that it makes things a little easier to have 1 program to go to for updates. But at the same time I can see that being an issue for Microsoft. Kind of a damned if you do or damned if you don't Lets look at Red Hat for a moment. People that use them know that they are going to have to wait for new versions of program to be tossed into the list. They know that their programs are going to be lagging behind the current version but they are fine with that, partly because that means that they are being tested and partly because since it isn't Microsoft they can do whatever they want and people won't care. Just like UAC. Linux does that for everything and its fine, Microsoft does it and it is bullshit. Now if Microsoft was to start putting everyone's updates into Microsoft Updates and make you wait 6 - 12 months for them to test the program first people would bitch. Companies would also bitch that Microsoft is forcing them to use that instead of being able to use their own update program. So lawsuits in EU. And then if they tried to rush updates to the list and something happened people would bitch and blame Microsoft. Not the mention the storage size needed to store all those programs (which is a few billion times more that what you have for linux). So really the only smart thing to do is to just stay out of that area and stick to only their stuff being on there.
 
imo updating is by far the best security thing you can do besides not being a retard
 
I agree with your entire post except for this part.

Not every program is in the repository for Linux distros so its not like your are going to be set for everything. On top of that they don't keep them up to date on the latest and greatest.

They have to test the packages and ok them before they are tossed into a repository. For Red Hat that is 6 months to a year after something comes out that it is added. So you are never going to be up to date there, but in fact will normally be a ways behind. In some cases for some programs under some distros it might be longer if ever. Look at Firefox. My Linux based machines with all their patches are only at 3.x with red hat it is never going to get caught up.

One could claim to a point that it makes things a little easier to have 1 program to go to for updates. But at the same time I can see that being an issue for Microsoft. Kind of a damned if you do or damned if you don't Lets look at Red Hat for a moment. People that use them know that they are going to have to wait for new versions of program to be tossed into the list. They know that their programs are going to be lagging behind the current version but they are fine with that, partly because that means that they are being tested and partly because since it isn't Microsoft they can do whatever they want and people won't care. Just like UAC. Linux does that for everything and its fine, Microsoft does it and it is bullshit. Now if Microsoft was to start putting everyone's updates into Microsoft Updates and make you wait 6 - 12 months for them to test the program first people would bitch. Companies would also bitch that Microsoft is forcing them to use that instead of being able to use their own update program. So lawsuits in EU. And then if they tried to rush updates to the list and something happened people would bitch and blame Microsoft. Not the mention the storage size needed to store all those programs (which is a few billion times more that what you have for linux). So really the only smart thing to do is to just stay out of that area and stick to only their stuff being on there.

I see your points, although it would be convenient to have one console for updates rather than several. Maybe they could add in a section for 3rd party updates and have some functionality to let trusted programs tie in there. That way I don't have to separately update Windows and Flash, Java, etc.
 
I wish they would just integrate Java support directly into the OS. I hate the way Oracle Java handles updates. I suppose that would give the EU fits though. :rolleyes:
 
I hope this PC is not connected to the Internet. If it is, and you don't update, use an antivirus or UAC, that's simply retarded. No bones about it.

Unless RT 7 suggested removing Windows entirely and installing Snow Leopard, then he wouldn't need AV at all. :D
 
I can't say that I care for the direction MS has gone in lately. Delayed reboot is a terrible idea and it will bring back the "system goes nuts for no apparent reason, restart and everything is fine" havoc from the win98 days. This absolutely WILL leave your system in an invalid state, and during that time is a complete crapshoot whether anything invalid gets written to hdd.

MS can't copy ksplice because of patent issues so they are just going to "compete" by caving to stupid users who want their systems to slowly become corrupt over time
 
I can't say that I care for the direction MS has gone in lately. Delayed reboot is a terrible idea and it will bring back the "system goes nuts for no apparent reason, restart and everything is fine" havoc from the win98 days. This absolutely WILL leave your system in an invalid state, and during that time is a complete crapshoot whether anything invalid gets written to hdd.

MS can't copy ksplice because of patent issues so they are just going to "compete" by caving to stupid users who want their systems to slowly become corrupt over time

Did you stay in a holiday inn last night? I figured you might have, since you are speaking with a tone of authority without knowing what you're talking about.

Hotpatching for windows came out before ksplice even existed. Additionally, this isn't suggesting reboots delayed more than usual as a norm, but a mechanism to prevent user loss of data. So stop attacking that strawman, it's dead.
 
Hotpatching for windows came out before ksplice even existed.
Wrong. There is no program, whether from MS or 3rd party, that will rewrite in-memory library data structures aka ksplice "hinting." Windows hotpatching will only rewrite stack pointers, which is useless if the underlying data modified by the function has changed. It has many other limitations, such as the inability to add new functions. This is why the majority of Windows updates cannot be hotpatched.

Additionally, this isn't suggesting reboots delayed more than usual as a norm, but a mechanism to prevent user loss of data. So stop attacking that strawman, it's dead.
Uh-huh. Look at the opposition to patching displayed in this thread. How long will it be before your manager finds out about delayed reboot and demands it for himself and his circle, followed by the manager's friends and their circled, followed by the entire company?
 
Additionally, this isn't suggesting reboots delayed more than usual as a norm, but a mechanism to prevent user loss of data.
ps-you do realize that delayed reboots guarantee the system will slowly be filled with invalid user data until it collapses Win98-style, right? When that happens do you think MS will take the blame or the person who installed the system?

This is a move to appease consumers at the expense of sysadmins and all common sense / sanity.
 
I hope this PC is not connected to the Internet. If it is, and you don't update, use an antivirus or UAC, that's simply retarded. No bones about it.

I update, but I don't use anti-virus or UAC and haven't used anything for 15+ years. It's a waste of time, money, and resources in my opinion.

The only worm I ever got on a machine was back on like Windows 98... and it was the Blaster worm which traveled through our local network after someone else in the family got it... took 30 seconds to find the patch for that.

I pay close attention to process explorer so I know what applications / services are running. And nothing suspicious has ever popped up. I worked in a computer shop for a year and dealt with plenty of viruses and malware and used the same app to find the suspicious processes/services.

Unless given a solid reason otherwise... I'll continue to leave all of these "features" turned off.
 
Good for you man. One thing you learn fixing peoples computers for a living through is for every anecdote like yours, there are 100 telling a different story. Virus removal and data backup/restoration are lucrative side-hustles.
 
The only worm I ever got on a machine was back on like Windows 98... and it was the Blaster worm which traveled through our local network after someone else in the family got it... took 30 seconds to find the patch for that.
.
Blaster only infected XP and 2000.
 
ps-you do realize that delayed reboots guarantee the system will slowly be filled with invalid user data until it collapses Win98-style, right? When that happens do you think MS will take the blame or the person who installed the system?

This is a move to appease consumers at the expense of sysadmins and all common sense / sanity.

Clearly you are superior and know better than any of us working on the product. You should come over here and tell us what else we're doing wrong. We haven't considered any of the things you've said, that's how dumb we are.
 
Clearly you are superior and know better than any of us working on the product. You should come over here and tell us what else we're doing wrong. We haven't considered any of the things you've said, that's how dumb we are.
OK, then can we cut the patronizing stuff and concentrate on the main points:

1) Can Windows hotpatching modify in-use library data structures or can't it? If it can, why are the majority of windows updates not hotpatchable?

2)Can delayed reboot result in invalid system state or can't it?

3)If delayed reboot can result in invalid system state, what will prevent inconsistent in-use/on-disk libraries from causing the system to harm itself?

4) Will MS PPI/custom provide support for delayed reboot system currently in reboot pending state?

5) Will MSDN provide support for broken application due to reboot pending state?
 
I update, but I don't use anti-virus or UAC and haven't used anything for 15+ years. It's a waste of time, money, and resources in my opinion.

The only worm I ever got on a machine was back on like Windows 98... and it was the Blaster worm which traveled through our local network after someone else in the family got it... took 30 seconds to find the patch for that.

I pay close attention to process explorer so I know what applications / services are running. And nothing suspicious has ever popped up. I worked in a computer shop for a year and dealt with plenty of viruses and malware and used the same app to find the suspicious processes/services.

Unless given a solid reason otherwise... I'll continue to leave all of these "features" turned off.

I use to be like this. I'm amazed but how stubborn people are. You should go ahead and download a free antivirus and have it scan. If its been over a year since you've reformatted or run an antivirus then you've got a good chance of being a customer of yours. The reason why people get infected isn't because they're "stupid" although being unaware of a good site vs a bad site or running internet explorer and not firefox/chrome. But the fact of the matter is I've gotten notifications that java installed something to temporary files or whatever. Its constantly getting better, with adobe, java, MS all waking up to fixing HUGE amount of flaws in their products, but security is still a joke. It's not hard to install software in your pc, and the worst is when you get a rootkit and have fun figuring out how to get rid of that or IF you have that.
 
OK, then can we cut the patronizing stuff and concentrate on the main points:

1) Can Windows hotpatching modify in-use library data structures or can't it? If it can, why are the majority of windows updates not hotpatchable?
Yes. And from the comments there, you can find out more information on hotpatching. It is not generally used for updates for a number of reasons, but the fact is, the facility exists and can be done.

2)Can delayed reboot result in invalid system state or can't it?
Not on any system I've tried it with. I think you're presuming that this grants unlimited time to wait. If you had bothered to read the article, though, you would see that it's actually just a limited time feature. It gives a three day countdown to allow users the chance to save their files and reboot when they're ready, rather than the current practice of automatic updates on patch Tuesday triggering an involuntary reboot. The only exception is when there is unsaved/savable user data, which gives the user 15 minutes to save at next login.

The purpose of this change isn't to eliminate reboots, but minimize them. Additionally, it tries to make them less painful by not doing them when the user might be negatively impacted by the reboot. The reboot is still necessary, just delayed for user convenience.

3)If delayed reboot can result in invalid system state, what will prevent inconsistent in-use/on-disk libraries from causing the system to harm itself?
Since it shouldn't be able to result in such a state, this question doesn't need addressing.

4) Will MS PPI/custom provide support for delayed reboot system currently in reboot pending state?
I don't know what PPI/custom is, so I can't answer this question.

5) Will MSDN provide support for broken application due to reboot pending state?
Do you have an example of how this can happen? I think you're presuming applications will be broken without evidence.

Have you downloaded and tried the developer preview that we released at //BUILD/ ?
 
Rereading, I see you're asking now about changing the actual layout of data structures and not merely the use of those structures. While I presume that should be possible, I don't know for certain. However, that seems... well, silly. Why would the OS much around with data structures underneath the programs that are running? We spend a vast amount of time ensuring that the OS remains backwards compatible, changing the data seems like a huge break from that.
 
There are soo many things I dislike about windows update. Like it saying my pc is at risk because it is required to check with me before downloading and installing updates...

I have hated the new windows update ever since I had vista just reboot on me in the middle of a game to install updates it had downloaded and installed. No warning or anything. SOB.

I honestly hate microsucks stance that all users are retarded and should be treated as such.
 
There are soo many things I dislike about windows update. Like it saying my pc is at risk because it is required to check with me before downloading and installing updates...

I have hated the new windows update ever since I had vista just reboot on me in the middle of a game to install updates it had downloaded and installed. No warning or anything. SOB.

I honestly hate microsucks stance that all users are retarded and should be treated as such.

That's because 99% of users ARE retarded.
 
There are soo many things I dislike about windows update. Like it saying my pc is at risk because it is required to check with me before downloading and installing updates...
It is at a greater risk. That's a fact, not mere opinion. Would you prefer to be lied to?

I have hated the new windows update ever since I had vista just reboot on me in the middle of a game to install updates it had downloaded and installed. No warning or anything. SOB.
Heh, I've had that happen at 3am as well. It's one thing that should no longer happen with Win8.

I honestly hate microsucks stance that all users are retarded and should be treated as such.

Very mature comment. Don't you want to change the S to a $ as well, go whole hog?
 
Back
Top