USB 3.0 disk better then HDD?

MorgothPl

2[H]4U
Joined
Oct 13, 2008
Messages
3,020
I've an idea... with the native USB 3.0 support for Ivy Bridge, would it be better to forget about traditional HDD and use 500 GB USB 3.0 disks? They are almost as fast as SDD, much faster then HDD, and with a very good price.

With native 3.0, you won't need any drivers for ports to run at max speed. And with lets say 4 ports, you can add 3 disks, and get like 1,5tb fast disks cheaply.

Might even get some WD raid disk array, and it sill be better then HDD.

So, what you think of that idea?
 
USB are not safe, unsafe. You might loose data. USB disks can be dropped on floor, etc.

But performance wise they are almost similar.
 
I've an idea... with the native USB 3.0 support for Ivy Bridge, would it be better to forget about traditional HDD and use 500 GB USB 3.0 disks? They are almost as fast as SDD, much faster then HDD, and with a very good price.

With native 3.0, you won't need any drivers for ports to run at max speed. And with lets say 4 ports, you can add 3 disks, and get like 1,5tb fast disks cheaply.

Might even get some WD raid disk array, and it sill be better then HDD.

So, what you think of that idea?


do not look at the performance of the controller like Sata, SAS, IDE od USB
They are much faster than your disk, wether they are 2x or 20x faster than your
disk is irrelevent. In fact, a disk connected to Sata 3Gb should be faster than the same disk
connected to usb3 because of less overhead in hardware and drivers
 
Sorry, maybe I'm missing something, but the original poster's question doesn't make sense to me. How does one forget about traditional disks, and use 500GB USB 3.0 disks? Presuming these USB 3.0 disks are platter drives, how are they not traditional disks? And how are they faster than HDD's if they themselves are also HDD's?

Sorry, I'm really not trying to be rude at all here, but either the OP is confused, or I am :)
 
I've an idea... with the native USB 3.0 support for Ivy Bridge, would it be better to forget about traditional HDD and use 500 GB USB 3.0 disks? They are almost as fast as SDD, much faster then HDD, and with a very good price.

With native 3.0, you won't need any drivers for ports to run at max speed. And with lets say 4 ports, you can add 3 disks, and get like 1,5tb fast disks cheaply.

Might even get some WD raid disk array, and it sill be better then HDD.

So, what you think of that idea?

???? I have no idea what a "500 GB USB 3.0 disk" is... never seen one, never heard of one before... if anyone one can point one out to me, please do so.

They are almost as fast as SDD, much faster then HDD, and with a very good price.

I am very interested in a source for this information. If you have it, please enlighten me.

I'm a bit of a hard drive benchmarking geek, but have only been able to do limited testing with USB 3.0 so far. I plan on doing more, but so far my testing has been limited to a toshiba laptop that has an eSatap port (Sata II) and an external USB 3.0 port. I used an external usb 3.0 enclosure and an external eSata enclosure, a WD 750gb 7200 rpm black 2.5", and an Intel 320 series 120gb SSD. Both the traditional hard drive and the SSD performed better (~10%-15%) via the eSata enclosure/port combination than the USB 3.0.

At this time, I think the USB 3.0 spec of 5GB/s is highly exagerated. Maybe someday down the road with improvements in drivers it will get better. Maybe with native support it will be better. In any case though I seriously doubt any traditional hard drive will perform any better than current Sata II performance simply because there is not a single traditional hard drive that can saturate Sata II.
 
I think the OP doesn't understand the inner workings of external disks. USB 3.0 is simply an interface. The "inside" of a USB 3.0 HDD is a SATA drive, not a USB 3.0 drive. There is no such thing as a native USB 3.0 hard disk. The whole point of USB 3.0 is to get faster speeds for external drives, not to replace internal SATA drives, which I'm thinking the OP is calling SATA drives "traditional" drives. Even a SSD is a SATA drive. This is really very basic computer knowledge.

I think it would defy the laws of electrical engineering if a USB 3.0 HDD was faster than a SATA HDD when the same model SATA drive was inside the USB 3.0 HDD. It's like buying a fast motorcycle and carrying it around in a pickup truck. Though it's not fair to compare USB 3.0 to a pickup truck, unless it's a super-souped up tricked out pickup.
 
I think what the OP wants to know is this:

Why use a traditional SATA implementation over a USB 3.0 implementation for a given HDD?

The answer is that the native SATA HDD connection would provide the best overall speed and least amount of system overhead. While the USB 3.0 speeds seem like screamers, I think you will find that a SATA3 connected disk will outperform it any day of the week. I have no numbers or links to support these conclussions however.
 
It just makes sense. No matter how fast the theoretical burst speed of USB3 is, there will always be a translation layer between the SATA disk (or SSD) and the USB Host. eSATA has no such layer, and functions essentially the same as if the drive were connected to a SATA port (because it is). This means latency and overhead, not to mention the USB overhead itself. The actual performance will largely depend on the ability of the USB<->SATA bridge, and the USB host implementation. Most of them stink thus far, the ones that don't cost alot of money.
 
...there will always be a translation layer between the SATA disk (or SSD) and the USB Host. eSATA has no such layer, and functions essentially the same as if the drive were connected to a SATA port (because it is).

I've noticed and even had serious transfer speed problems with some eSATA external drives. Even if transfers hit full speed, bursts are lower. I can't say if it's the interface (on the external enclosure) or the eSATA controller on the motherboard or laptop card (usually JMicron or SiliconImage), but definitely not full speed. Makes me wonder if there's some overhead and/or latency with eSATA.
 
I moved my SATA III drive to USB 3.0 external and I love it. I only use it for backups but USB 3.0 easily maxes my disk write speed at about 60-70MB/s when I'm backing up.
 
I've noticed and even had serious transfer speed problems with some eSATA external drives. Even if transfers hit full speed, bursts are lower. I can't say if it's the interface (on the external enclosure) or the eSATA controller on the motherboard or laptop card (usually JMicron or SiliconImage), but definitely not full speed. Makes me wonder if there's some overhead and/or latency with eSATA.

There should be no difference. However, some companies choose to gimp their eSATA ports to ensure they meet spec electrical signaling specs. :(
 
I've had different results with different eSATA cables as well. I think cabling becomes more important at those lengths. Also, alot of JMicron controllers have similar issues even with internally connected devices.
 
I moved my SATA III drive to USB 3.0 external and I love it. I only use it for backups but USB 3.0 easily maxes my disk write speed at about 60-70MB/s when I'm backing up.

No modern hard drives max out at 60-70MB/s. If it has a SATA III interface, it's probably capable of doubling that.
 
Back
Top