Steve Jobs Dead

Status
Not open for further replies.
Oh, and for that guy slamming Kyle for making money off reviewing shit, you're a moron. The one product Kyle physically sells is made right here in the United States. That alone puts him ahead of Jobs in my book.

^ This would be you missing the point completely.

The point is that Apple has been castigated with repeated Foxconn accusations/threads here in the main page. Other companies use Foxconn--do they get any negative press here? No. Why? Dunno, except trolling Apple seems to be a regular thing here.
 
^ This would be you missing the point completely.

The point is that Apple has been castigated with repeated Foxconn accusations/threads here in the main page. Other companies use Foxconn--do they get any negative press here? No. Why? Dunno, except trolling Apple seems to be a regular thing here.

No it's not missing the point. What point is it missing? No one ever said it's only Apple. The reason why Apple is biggest target here is because people believe we would be living in caves if it were not for Jobs.
 
I applaud some of the posters who took the high road and refrained from disrespecting this man even though they did not agree with the man's practices.

RIP jobs
 
Why would you not be able to reach the scale in the US? I want you to list real tangible reasons now. What here completely prevents that? And as far as margins, you wouldn't have high enough margins to please the stock market. Who gives a fuck. There's no reason why you wouldn't be able to survive manufacturing anything here.

And you act like it's one or the other in China. In fact, maybe Foxconn going out of business would be better for them. Maybe then people over there would become pissed enough to overthrow their shitty government that allows for their shitty working conditions to exist.

Because labor costs here will not give you the margins you need to get the financing you need. Apple is able to get their high margins due to the high volume of orders, enabling them to keep down teh cost of manufacture, as well as their name. All the other tablets out there have razor slim profit margins, if any at all, and that is with using the same "slave labor" Apple is using. So bringing that manufacturing to the US would immediately have you taking a loss on every unit, or charging $1,000 plus each, which wouldn't sell.

That doesn't happen overnight. And you think just be overthrowing their government, all of a sudden 1.2 billion people will magically become middle-class and have all their wants and desires met? Please. Each country has to go through a development cycle. To grossly oversimplify, China is roughly around where we were during the industrial revolution, with the benefit of being able to import rich-world technology to greatly speed up the process. China's middle class is growing very rapidly, which is partly due to places like Foxconn. Foxxconn are surely shitty jobs, but they're also probably some of the top tier jobs you can get in terms of pay - I would guess somewhere around the 70th-80th percentile.
 
How much trouble will I get in here if I say what I really want to say about that jerk.

I'm glad he got to live a bit longer because he bought his way to the top of a donor list and others' suffered because of it.

And you have documented proof of that, right?
 
Only 80%? That's a pretty big number to be saying "only".

Oh 80% for survival rate for 5 years isn't bad, but using that number (I've actually seen 72% rate listed many places but I decided to use the most optimistic one) it means that almost 1,300 of the 6,493 people who recieved liver transplants in the USA in 2007 (the latest year I could find the numbers for) did not survive for 5 years after the transplant and about 973 didn't even survive for a year.

Also the OP that I was answered said something to the effect that Jobs deprived someone of possibly decades of life and I was pointing out that far more people then Steve Jobs died less then 5 years after this transplant.


While money wont buy you a liver in the US it can buy you a better chance at one. For example lists are very regional as those wanting on the list not only need to be able to have regular appointments at the transplant center but need to be able to get there in a set amount of time should the organ become available.

Now, most people can't fly around the country to make visits to various clinics, nor could most extremely sick people manage to go from California to Tennessee, especially at a moments notice? The ability to do that requires a ton of cash, especially as someone got sicker. Consider that often people are often removed from the list because they are "to sick to move" to the transplant center, but with money would could hire a private jet and staff it with a full medical team which would allow you safely be moved. Is it fair? Nope, but life isn't fair and if you expect it to be you'll be disappointed on a regular basis.
 
My bio lab TA today: "What did two unemployed cancer cells say to each other?"
.
.
.
.
.
.
"We need to get Jobs"
 
I may not have always agreed with the man, but I'm an ant compared to him. He made the tech world a better place! Rest in peace Steve Jobs.
 
Foxconn are surely shitty jobs, but they're also probably some of the top tier jobs you can get in terms of pay - I would guess somewhere around the 70th-80th percentile.

I think the bigger thing that's being forgotten is that so many people here mad about the Foxconn-Apple relationship are forgetting how many of the components (CPU sockets, backplane ports, etc.) on their mainboards are being made by Foxconn. How many OEM widgets that are part of the things everyone here in this forum is buying.

I have a hard time believing that most of us here, moderators included, are Foxconn-free when it comes to the technology we own. If Foxconn is that serious an issue here that someone wishes to call people out on it, then I think they need to take on that issue from where they stand themselves, by researching their products and choosing to avoid that which they don't like.
 
basically taking a shit on someone's grave because you didn't like the products they made shows the (lack of) character of the person doing so.

Even though I highly disapprove of their lock-in and restrictions on developers and users, human rights abuses, and their deceitful and underhanded marketing and blatant manipulation of the media, what really pisses me off is the mindless bleating of the brainwashed masses who can't think for themselves. The products would be far more palatable without these things. Apple's brainwashed masses have turned consumer computing into shiny status-symbol iBling that's only good for wasting time on activities devoid of any meaning and mindless passive consumption of mostly shit. The empty headed morons who seem to comprise a large majority of the population love Apple for giving them something to do with all the free time they have while pretending to be employed and getting overpaid for it. The poor bastards in China probably do more work in one day than your average over-paid, cottage-cheese assed Apple user does in a year.

I'd take a dump on the grave of L. Ron Hubbard. I'd treat the leader of the cult of Macintology no differently.
 
Because labor costs here will not give you the margins you need to get the financing you need. Apple is able to get their high margins due to the high volume of orders, enabling them to keep down teh cost of manufacture, as well as their name. All the other tablets out there have razor slim profit margins, if any at all, and that is with using the same "slave labor" Apple is using. So bringing that manufacturing to the US would immediately have you taking a loss on every unit, or charging $1,000 plus each, which wouldn't sell.

Back in the day, Henry Ford believed in paying his employees great money. One of the reasons he believed this was because he also believed he needed to create a great consumer base here that could afford to buy his products. And this ended up working out very well.


If all those corporations, with the help of governments around the world might I add, did not resort to such extreme cost cutting procedures in order to "maximize profits," maybe workers here would've seen dramatically increased wages that would've allowed them to buy the products at higher price points?

There's no real way to know what would've happened if a different path was taken by US corporations. I'm not an economist, so I don't know. And considering many economists had no idea the 2008 financial crises, I doubt many economists would know either .


That doesn't happen overnight. And you think just be overthrowing their government, all of a sudden 1.2 billion people will magically become middle-class and have all their wants and desires met? Please. Each country has to go through a development cycle. To grossly oversimplify, China is roughly around where we were during the industrial revolution, with the benefit of being able to import rich-world technology to greatly speed up the process. China's middle class is growing very rapidly, which is partly due to places like Foxconn. Foxxconn are surely shitty jobs, but they're also probably some of the top tier jobs you can get in terms of pay - I would guess somewhere around the 70th-80th percentile.

[/quote]

Where'd I say anything about it happening overnight? Did I say all of them would suddenly become middle class? I never said anything of the sort, so I have no idea why you brought anything else.

You think everything here was heaven after the American revolution? No, but it was the first step into elevating us into the greatest fucking country in the world. Everything happens in steps.

Obviously China is a developing country with great human capital, but just because they have it so badly, it does not justify the working conditions of Foxconn. I have no idea what their incomes are in comparison to others, probably a few dollars a day? But I'll tell you what, I'd rather kill myself then work around like a slave just to say i'm in the 80th percentile of my shitty country while corporations like Apple post billions of dollars in profit on my back.
 
I really wish we could edit our posts in this section. ^ above post full of errors.
 
I think we should respect Jobs as a businessman, and his accomplishments in business are outstanding. But to look at him as this true amazing visionary and speak of him in the same breath as Einstein and Gandhi is completely laughable. He was no humanitarian, and he was not a friend of the consumer.

Exactly. Great business guy. Humanitarian? Hmmm...

Last year the founder of the Stanford Social Innovation Review called Apple one of "America's Least Philanthropic Companies." Jobs had terminated all of Apple's long-standing corporate philanthropy programs within weeks after returning to Apple in 1997, citing the need to cut costs until profitability rebounded. But the programs have never been restored. .... Jobs' only serious foray into personal philanthropy was short-lived. In January 1987, after launching Next, he also, without fanfare or public notice, incorporated the Steven P. Jobs Foundation. "He was very interested in food and health issues and vegetarianism," recalls Mark Vermilion, the community affairs executive Jobs hired to run it. Vermilion persuaded Jobs to focus on "social entrepreneurship" instead. But the Jobs foundation never did much of anything, besides hiring famed graphic designer Paul Rand to design its logo. (Explains Vermilion: "He wanted a logo worthy of his expectations.") Jobs shut down the foundation after less than 15 months.

http://money.cnn.com/2008/03/02/news/companies/elkind_jobs.fortune/index4.htm
 
Back in the day, Henry Ford believed in paying his employees great money. One of the reasons he believed this was because he also believed he needed to create a great consumer base here that could afford to buy his products. And this ended up working out very well.


If all those corporations, with the help of governments around the world might I add, did not resort to such extreme cost cutting procedures in order to "maximize profits," maybe workers here would've seen dramatically increased wages that would've allowed them to buy the products at higher price points?

There's no real way to know what would've happened if a different path was taken by US corporations. I'm not an economist, so I don't know. And considering many economists had no idea the 2008 financial crises, I doubt many economists would know either .

A lot of it has to do with the rise of technology. In the day of Henry Ford, shipping a car from Japan/Korea to the US would mean that car would be hugely more expensive than a locally produced one. Massive cargo ships have changed that, as has the rapid rise of the rich-world's economies vs the rest, creating a huge disparity in labor costs. So what is happening now is that since transportation has become so cheap, the market for no- or low-skill labor is now global, and there are hundreds of millions or billions who would happily take that work. Although this has been a shitty decade thus far for the rich world, for the 3rd world, from 1990 - 2008 the number of people defined as "middle class" in developing Asia has gone from ~500 million to ~1.9 billion. So while it has been a rocky road with labor abuses, etc, it has broadly been positive change for the economic future of the people taking Foxxconn-esque jobs. http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/09/middle-class

Where'd I say anything about it happening overnight? Did I say all of them would suddenly become middle class? I never said anything of the sort, so I have no idea why you brought anything else.

You think everything here was heaven after the American revolution? No, but it was the first step into elevating us into the greatest fucking country in the world. Everything happens in steps.

Obviously China is a developing country with great human capital, but just because they have it so badly, it does not justify the working conditions of Foxconn. I have no idea what their incomes are in comparison to others, probably a few dollars a day? But I'll tell you what, I'd rather kill myself then work around like a slave just to say i'm in the 80th percentile of my shitty country while corporations like Apple post billions of dollars in profit on my back.

That may have been me misreading it; when you said by overthrowing their government they would be better off, I think it would be doubtful most people would be better off until quite some time afterwards, and even that is by no means a sure bet. If you were talking longer term, then yes that would be a positive development, depending on what they replaced their current gov't with.

And really in terms of percentiles, the average American worker is closer in terms of income to a Foxconn worker than the mega-rich CEOs and corporate profiteers you decry.
 
*hugs Kyle*

So, how many of your mainboards and laptops have Foxconn products?

I'm only asking because by that corrected rationale, any one of us who has something Foxconn-manufactured or provided in the past several years has probably assisted in killing at least one Foxconn employee.

Heck, I bet the entire HardForums could account for a few dozen by that rationale alone.
 
A lot of it has to do with the rise of technology. In the day of Henry Ford, shipping a car from Japan/Korea to the US would mean that car would be hugely more expensive than a locally produced one. Massive cargo ships have changed that, as has the rapid rise of the rich-world's economies vs the rest, creating a huge disparity in labor costs. So what is happening now is that since transportation has become so cheap, the market for no- or low-skill labor is now global, and there are hundreds of millions or billions who would happily take that work. Although this has been a shitty decade thus far for the rich world, for the 3rd world, from 1990 - 2008 the number of people defined as "middle class" in developing Asia has gone from ~500 million to ~1.9 billion. So while it has been a rocky road with labor abuses, etc, it has broadly been positive change for the economic future of the people taking Foxxconn-esque jobs. http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/09/middle-class

You forget that a lot of this happened because many of those asian countries began to adopt free-market principles and moved away from dictatorships/communism in favor of more democratic systems. In the case of South Korea, they were able to turn their country around because they adopted a democracy, moved toward a more free-market based economy, and they had tariffs in place in order to help their own internal industries develop.

There's no way you can convince me it's because of nasty corporations like Foxconn that this happened.

That may have been me misreading it; when you said by overthrowing their government they would be better off, I think it would be doubtful most people would be better off until quite some time afterwards, and even that is by no means a sure bet. If you were talking longer term, then yes that would be a positive development, depending on what they replaced their current gov't with.

And really in terms of percentiles, the average American worker is closer in terms of income to a Foxconn worker than the mega-rich CEOs and corporate profiteers you decry.

Of course they'd be better off. They have largely a one party system. Their government censors everything, and there's no free speech over there. And they can't even vote for their own president. And their government is also what allows corporations like Foxconn to behave as they do. They'd be MUCH better off.

I don't necessarily hate rich CEOs, but I'm not going to worship a guy like Steve Jobs the same 99% of the internet seems to do.
 
You forget that a lot of this happened because many of those asian countries began to adopt free-market principles and moved away from dictatorships/communism in favor of more democratic systems. In the case of South Korea, they were able to turn their country around because they adopted a democracy, moved toward a more free-market based economy, and they had tariffs in place in order to help their own internal industries develop.

There's no way you can convince me it's because of nasty corporations like Foxconn that this happened.

Of course they'd be better off. They have largely a one party system. Their government censors everything, and there's no free speech over there. And they can't even vote for their own president. And their government is also what allows corporations like Foxconn to behave as they do. They'd be MUCH better off.

I don't necessarily hate rich CEOs, but I'm not going to worship a guy like Steve Jobs the same 99% of the internet seems to do.

The entire population of South Korea is only 50M; even if their entire country went from dirt poor to middle class, it would barely be a blip in the move from 500M to 1.9B. And I see a lot of logical inconsistency in your post; you mention both free markets and tariffs positively in the same sentence. Nothing is more free market than Foxconn.

Overthrowing your government is absolutely not certain to make you better off; America's case was quite exceptional because of how well that process went. And despite many human rights abuses, China's government has done a very good job at economic management, and hundreds of millions of it's citizens have benefited. This does not excuse their abuses, but again I'm just trying to say it isn't black and white. I've both seen some of China's most prosperous middle class areas, busy industrial centers - Tianjin, Beijing, Shanghai. And I've also been to Tibet, where I see the Chinese gov't moving in tons of Han Chinese to basically "dilute" the native population, as well as platoons of soliders goosestepping through the markets and posted up at every block with 40mm grenade launchers, riot shotguns and AK47s. It is a hard country to pin down.
 
So, how many of your mainboards and laptops have Foxconn products?

I'm only asking because by that corrected rationale, any one of us who has something Foxconn-manufactured or provided in the past several years has probably assisted in killing at least one Foxconn employee.

Heck, I bet the entire HardForums could account for a few dozen by that rationale alone.

Exactly how many Foxconn workers have died?
 
Steve Jobs always most reminded me of Jim Jones. They both sure got a lot people to drink the Kool-Aid.
 
So, how many of your mainboards and laptops have Foxconn products?

I'm only asking because by that corrected rationale, any one of us who has something Foxconn-manufactured or provided in the past several years has probably assisted in killing at least one Foxconn employee.

Heck, I bet the entire HardForums could account for a few dozen by that rationale alone.

ujelly? ;)
*hugs LoneWolf*
 
The entire population of South Korea is only 50M; even if their entire country went from dirt poor to middle class, it would barely be a blip in the move from 500M to 1.9B. And I see a lot of logical inconsistency in your post; you mention both free markets and tariffs positively in the same sentence. Nothing is more free market than Foxconn.

I listed South Korea as an example. There are obviously many other countries in Asia that also adopted more free-market principles. If you want, I can go through a grocery list of those countries.

And there's no logical inconsistency in my post. I never said all out libertarian styled free markets. I said free market principles. Any many economists do agree that tariffs are necessary in order for countries to develop. The United States used tariffs to develop. Great Britain did. Japan did the same. In fact, it's the countries that are forced into trade-liberalization in Africa that have trouble developing. If you are interested in this, I suggest a book called Bad Samaritans by Ha-Joon Chang, a professor of economics at Cambridge.

Overthrowing your government is absolutely not certain to make you better off; America's case was quite exceptional because of how well that process went. And despite many human rights abuses, China's government has done a very good job at economic management, and hundreds of millions of it's citizens have benefited. This does not excuse their abuses, but again I'm just trying to say it isn't black and white. I've both seen some of China's most prosperous middle class areas, busy industrial centers - Tianjin, Beijing, Shanghai. And I've also been to Tibet, where I see the Chinese gov't moving in tons of Han Chinese to basically "dilute" the native population, as well as platoons of soliders goosestepping through the markets and posted up at every block with 40mm grenade launchers, riot shotguns and AK47s. It is a hard country to pin down.

I think history has shown that overthrowing totalitarian governments in favor of more democratic government leads to improved living standards and prosperity. I have no doubt in my mind China would be better off if they became more democratic.
 
What's funny is that people in the people in the US bitching about US imports from countries with low wages sounds a lot like the people in Europe were daying 100+ years ago about that sweatshops and cheap labor in the US.

In 100 years or so Chinese will probably be moaning about sweat shops in Africa taking work from Chinese workers.
 
What's funny is that people in the people in the US bitching about US imports from countries with low wages sounds a lot like the people in Europe were daying 100+ years ago about that sweatshops and cheap labor in the US.

In 100 years or so Chinese will probably be moaning about sweat shops in Africa taking work from Chinese workers.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/05/u...n-workers-in-place-of-migrant-labor.html?_r=1

I think America needs to get back to work. I've been fortunate enough that I can get even crap IT jobs that pay more than that but I'd like to think if I had to work a job like that to take care of my family; I would. (Fail grammar I know).

I'm quoting your post cause I can't think of Americans that would actually work the jobs you mentioned.
 
What's funny is that people in the people in the US bitching about US imports from countries with low wages sounds a lot like the people in Europe were daying 100+ years ago about that sweatshops and cheap labor in the US.

I don't think what you are saying is completely factually correct.
 
China has adopted many free market principles; that is why they are doing well too.

I think history has shown that overthrowing totalitarian governments in favor of more democratic government leads to improved living standards and prosperity. I have no doubt in my mind China would be better off if they became more democratic.

I agree. But history has also shown that overthrowing a totalitarian government is no guarantee of then putting into place a more democratic government.
 
Exactly how many Foxconn workers have died?

I don't have that knowledge. I don't know if the rest of us do either.

My point was that Kyle rearranged one of our forumites' quotes to blame Steve Jobs' for the death of hundreds of Foxconn workers. Someone thought that rearrangement was worthy of praise. I wanted to point out to that forumite what I feel is a flawed rationale by stretching it even further --that if hundreds really did die, then we could say the Hardforum was responsible for at least dozens of Foxconn employee deaths because I'm willing to bet a ton of us have mainboards with Foxconn sockets/ports, Foxconn mainboards in budget builds, laptops, built at a Foxconn factory, and so on.

By the existing rationale given me, I have two choices --I can believe that we as a forum, have had a hand in Foxconn employee deaths --or that the rationale is flawed at best, and needs to go back to the drawing board.
 
What logic? The one where you have to buy foreign goods to make a living promoting this site? That logic?

Lets take the blinds off here Kyle. You can pick one topic and ignore others just to push your agenda.

Are you for real? I lurk a ton here, and I've NEVER seen you use logic. I've NEVER seen you be right...about anything.

You're the king of ignoring facts and logic and claim others do it? Wow....:rolleyes:
 
Are you for real? I lurk a ton here, and I've NEVER seen you use logic. I've NEVER seen you be right...about anything.

You're the king of ignoring facts and logic and claim others do it? Wow....:rolleyes:

I see Azhar using nothing but basic logic, while you do nothing other than repeat pure fabrications and rumor as if it is fact, and quite frankly if you told me what time it was I would seek a 2nd opinion.
 
I see Azhar using nothing but basic logic, while you do nothing other than repeat pure fabrications and rumor as if it is fact, and quite frankly if you told me what time it was I would seek a 2nd opinion.

IMHO, this.

Lol @ boomstick.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top