Multi-system upgrade, need help with vid card(s), CPU(s), etc

titan97

Gawd
2FA
Joined
Sep 27, 2004
Messages
568
My motherboard (ASUS P5Q-Pro) on my server is causing me problems, so I'm going to replace it. While this sounds easy enough, here is where it gets confusing. I have 2 other PCs (mine and the kids'). My PC is a hand-me-down Dell XPS400 (link to specs) with an upgraded video card (GeForce 7600-ish?), a P4 3.0GHz, and 2GB of RAM. The kids' PC is a gifted refurbished Acer Aspire T180 (link to specs) with 1GB of RAM and an Athlon 64 3800+ CPU. The server has a C2D low-end E-series CPU and 2GB of RAM.

Here are my initial thoughts. Please let me know what you think.

Server:
Newegg has a Gigabyte board that will take the same CPU, but needs DDR3. I buy the board and 4GB of DDR3. I take the P4 from the Dell and use it here.

Dell PC:
Move the C2D from the server to here. Move the RAM from the server to here (now up to 4GB). Potentially buy a video card??

Acer PC:
Buy more RAM (now up to 3GB or 4GB). Move the GeForce from the Dell to here. Find an Athlon 64 x2 (if possible).

My budget is around $500 to $600. I could do more, but there would have to be a benefit, of course. The server needs to be able to stream video, occasionally rip DVDs, and otherwise run Windows Home Server. My Dell is used for some gaming (couple of hours per week, max) and general computing stuff. When I do get a chance to game, I would like it to be smooth and enjoyable. The Acer is used for gaming, but my oldest kids are 8yo-twins, and they aren't into (nor are they allowed to) playing Teen and Mature games, which usually require some heavy-lifting hardware. They still get a kick out of playing my old Win95 and DOS games (X-Wing, anyone?).

Thoughts?



 
Have you confirmed whether or not your Dell system can accept a newer processor like the C2D? Some proprietary Dell motherboards are finicky as to what they'll accept.

What resolution are you playing games (for yourself, not the twins) at? Which games are you playing?

If you have to build a new PC, would you prefer it to be a server or your personal machine?
 
Is that Asus mobo still under warranty?

Looking at the specs for that Dell, it doesn't appear that Dell will be able to accept C2D CPUs. Tiraides is right that Dell mobos are finicky as to what CPUs they'll accepte. So like Tiraides said, confirm with 100% certainty that C2D CPU will work in that Dell. Though right now, it doesn't look like it'll work.
 
Thanks guys. I just happened to check on the warranty of the mobo and I'm still covered for another 2 months. Sweeeet.

And yes, you are correct that the 945P chipset of the Dell won't take this C2D. It has support for the E6xxx series, but not the E7xxx series. oh well.

What resolution are you playing games (for yourself, not the twins) at? Which games are you playing?

I play my games at whatever I can stand for frame rates, which is typically poor (1024x768 or lower). I haven't kept up with current gaming trends, but I play a smattering of everything, from RPGs to FPSs, driving sims, etc.



 
Please answer Tiraides' last question.

Also what C2D CPU do you have?
 
If you have to build a new PC, would you prefer it to be a server or your personal machine?

I've thought about converting the Dell to be the server, but it is a BTX mobo and my server case is ATX. I have 6 hard drives, so the mid-tower Dell won't hold everything. I'd have to get an external case OR find a cheap BTX server case. But why would I waste my time with a new BTX case?

And, if I go this route, I'd need:

ATX case
mobo
CPU
RAM
vid card
etc

Basically a whole new system. The only thing I could really carry over would be the C2D. Although, I'm already looking to buy a mobo, RAM, and vid card. So a CPU and case wouldn't be that much more. Well, a current-gen mobo and CPU would cost a bit more than the P45 replacement would.


 
Update: I have a case number with ASUS. They are checking stock for a refurb'ed mobo to send my way and I will send mine back to them. So, if this happens, I'd still like to get some more RAM for all the PCs, plus a vid card. Any thoughts? I suppose for $300, I sould get a fairly nice card ;-)


 
Go used on the RAM, but try to reach at least 4GB on all of your systems. That amount is ideal for everyday use.

A brief Google search informed me that the Asus board (should you be able to replace it) can support any Core 2 Quad processor. However, I've seen nothing on the XPS 400 that suggests you could replace the processor. (What about the Acer?)

What's the native or maximum resolution of the monitor that you're using? Would you like to play newer games (2007 or later) on your system? For the time being, the Radeon HD 5770 would make a huge improvement for you in gaming. Again, go used.

However, just to be on the safe side, I recommend replacing the power supplies in all three systems with new ones. Here are a couple of cheap yet quality PSU options:

$45 - Antec NEO ECO 400C 400W PSU
$45 - Corsair CX430 V2 430W PSU
 
Go used on the RAM, but try to reach at least 4GB on all of your systems. That amount is ideal for everyday use.

A brief Google search informed me that the Asus board (should you be able to replace it) can support any Core 2 Quad processor. However, I've seen nothing on the XPS 400 that suggests you could replace the processor. (What about the Acer?)

I will shoot for 4GB. Of course, I will have to reinstall the OS's @ 64-bit to realize all of that. WHSv1 is 32-bit only, so I'm maxed at 3.whatever. I may buy WHS 2011 if required.

What's the native or maximum resolution of the monitor that you're using? Would you like to play newer games (2007 or later) on your system? For the time being, the Radeon HD 5770 would make a huge improvement for you in gaming. Again, go used.

I'm using a Dell 1800FP with a native resolution of 1280 x 1024. I'd love to play modern games, if possible. On the Acer, would I lose anything going from the integrated nVidia 6100 to the 7800GT board?

However, just to be on the safe side, I recommend replacing the power supplies in all three systems with new ones. Here are a couple of cheap yet quality PSU options:

$45 - Antec NEO ECO 400C 400W PSU
$45 - Corsair CX430 V2 430W PSU

The server has a PC Power & Cooling 510W, so I should be good for now. I know the Acer has a mighty, mighty 250W unit. I will check out the Dell. I'm a big fan of quality power supplies. I know their value in a stable system. Thanks for the tip!


 
I'm using a Dell 1800FP with a native resolution of 1280 x 1024. I'd love to play modern games, if possible. On the Acer, would I lose anything going from the integrated nVidia 6100 to the 7800GT board?
Nothing really as long as the PSU can handle it. That 250W PSU is a bit anemic for that 7800GT IMO. Best get a new PSU for that.

Ok, here's how I see it: You're basically are looking at a totally new PC for your workstation. Don't bother reusing anything from the Dell or even the server. The Dell's parts are more than likely proprietary and/or just too old to be used anywhere else. Though you should be able to reuse the RAM in the server.

As for reusing the server parts as the new workstation, I wouldn't reuse it for the workstation on account of current DDR2 RAM prices and the performance of the C2D CPUs. Not to mention that you would still need to get a new mobo, RAM, and CPU anyway to replace the C2D setup for your server. So keep the server as is.

Unfortunately, this also means that you will have to buy a new OS license as you can't transfer the OS license from that Dell or the Acer to any other PC. So that will cost you another $100. So that would leave about $500 in your budget for a new PC.

So here's what I propose:
$125 - Intel Core i3-2100
$75 - Biostar TH67 Intel H67 mATX Motherboard
$44 - G.Skill Value Series F3-10600CL9D-8GBNT 2 x 4GB DDR3 1333 RAM
$123 - XFX HD-677X-ZNLC Radeon HD 6770 1GB PCI-E Video Card
$45 - Western Digital WD5000AAKX 500GB 7200RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive
$45 - Antec NEO ECO 400C 400W PSU
$30 - Sunbeam EVO IC-EVO-BK ATX Case
$100 - Windows 7 Home Premium SP1 64bit OEM
---
Total: $587 shipped.

The above setup should last you for quite some time and will be enough for gaming at such a low resolution. If you don't have a SATA DVD burner, then you will need to get one as many modern mobos these days do not have IDE/PATA support:
$20 - LG GH22NS70 DVD Burner
 
So, just a recap:

-Server: getting replacement mobo from Asus. upgrade to 2GB more RAM. (get RAM from the FS/T forum to save money)
-Dell: replacing with a new workstation build. donate it.
-Acer: upgrade to 2GB of RAM (get RAM from the FS/T forum to save money)

So you had a $600 budget, minus the RAM upgrades leaves you with around $560 for the new workstation? which would include an OS, so leaving $460 for the new hardware?

Do you live near a Microcenter?
 
Regarding an OS, I have several Win7 Ultimate licenses. I have connections within MS.

There are no Microcenter's nearby.
 
Regarding an OS, I have several Win7 Ultimate licenses. I have connections within MS.

There are no Microcenter's nearby.

Oh that saves you money then. Just drop the Windows 7 license I had in the above list and you'll be set. That $100 can go towards the used RAM you'll need to get.
 
Back
Top