NASA to Begin Outsourcing

CommanderFrank

Cat Can't Scratch It
Joined
May 9, 2000
Messages
75,399
With the Age of the Shuttle closing this week, a new age of space exploration is just beginning: exploring the pitfalls and cost of getting back into space without a ride. NASA is exploring the options and for the present is turning to private contract companies and the Russian Space Agency for a hitch into space.

“Just like a person hires FedEx to deliver a package across the country and you pay him 50 bucks, we’re delivering a 2,000-kilogram package to space, a few hundred miles above Earth, for a fixed price”
 
I'm not sure if this will help or be a hinderance. Companies are after profit, so will do things in the cheapest ways, which might not always be the best way. Though these companies are competing in a low competition segment, and maybe having 15 companies all striving for the same goal will push spaceflight into more peoples reach and move the tech forward. A lack of competition will have the opposite effect however, with people price gouging and cutting back to maximize profit. Which should never be a part of science.

As long as safety isn't compromised I think things will be ok. Nasa has a pretty good record on that front (considering what they do, they have only had a handful of disasters and near disasters).
 
I don't really mind if NASA outsources the piddly stuff, just so long as they take charge of the big picture, next step stuff like visiting asteroids and sending astronauts to Mars, themselves.
 
If you look into how many personnel are "required" to do a launch its no wonder why it costs so damn much to launch something into orbit considering at the end of the day once that firecracker is lit there's nothing that you can do to change what it does except press a self destruct button.
 
The only thing more sad than NASA not having a shuttle alternative ready is the 15+ companies that should also have a solution ready by now - but don't. I guess that doing nothing and sucking up venture capital makes more business sense than actually producing a workable product these days.
 
Take all the money dumped into going back and forth to the space station and invest it in new propulsion methods.

@GotNoRIce there was no market for it, and even still the space station exists just to exist right? What is its purpose? How does it benefit the space program or humanity?
 
The international space station has been used for many, many scientific research studies and experiments. I can't name anything specific off of the top of my head, but if you search google or some reputable scientific journal databases you will find plenty.

In either case, the ISS was primarily funded by NASA and other country's space programs, not by private corporations. As you mentioned, there is no market for it, no profit in it, and that is why no private company would have funded it.

The same can be said about new propulsion methods. Unless there is some kind of profit in it, no private corporation would bother to develop new space technology. the only reason these new companies exist is because they smell potential profit playing ISS taxi, not because they want to continue scientific research or human space exploration.
 
About time we privatise this thing, and let the research be done
without the taxpayers dime, doing it all.

In a few years we may see shuttle like ships, being flown by
private companies.

Campanies like this are small now, but will pave the way.
http://www.spacex.com/
http://space.xprize.org/

That is the next logical step.
 
The international space station has been used for many, many scientific research studies and experiments. I can't name anything specific off of the top of my head, but if you search google or some reputable scientific journal databases you will find plenty.

In either case, the ISS was primarily funded by NASA and other country's space programs, not by private corporations. As you mentioned, there is no market for it, no profit in it, and that is why no private company would have funded it.

The same can be said about new propulsion methods. Unless there is some kind of profit in it, no private corporation would bother to develop new space technology. the only reason these new companies exist is because they smell potential profit playing ISS taxi, not because they want to continue scientific research or human space exploration.

Nonsense, look at the big picture.

There is more resources,wealth and profit to be had in space
as the tech ramps up. One big thing is mining for rare minerals
on the moon for instance.

We need to change our thinking, and let goverment step aside
(except for military).

All great explorations/discoveries in the past were done through
personal inititive, not a wastefull goverment program.

NASA should be privatised itself, and become a resource of its own.
 
For that to come into play it will need to be cheaper and more profitable for companies to develop space-based resource acquisition than it is for them to get the resources from the earth. I don't see that happening any time soon.

And don't be silly, major explorations and discoveries were always funded by governments. While there was always personal initiative, the government still paid for most of it. King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella funded Christopher Columbus's exploration, Charles V funded Magellan, and in essence, Kennedy and the U.S. government funded and paid Wernher von Braun to explore the moon.

The only reason companies like SpaceX exist is because people need to pay someone to play space taxi, not because they are going to explore other worlds and do scientific research.
 
Continuing to embrace old school thinking will not advance us in
space technology.

Its why goverment cant deliver the mail better with less cost, then UPS or FedEx.
Its not just the quality, its the quantity....and that will lead to profits.

The US has been in space over 40 years, yet after the Shuttle program, why
are we left with nothing to take it place?

Only goverment planners, could have screwed this up.
 
My whole thing is this: There have only been THREE NATIONS (Russia, USA, China) that have sent men unto space. Now all of a sudden we expect the private sector to do it in no time flat. I for one see no US manned space flights for a long long time, not even from the private sector.

Bush killed the Shuttle
Obama killed the future of manned space flight in the US
 
Take all the money dumped into going back and forth to the space station and invest it in new propulsion methods.
The problem is that "new propulsion" isn't an issue. You're stuck in a gravity well, and it takes a big fucking expenditure of energy to get outside of it. Technology isn't going to change that, I mean sure you could build a huge ladder (space elevator) and just "jump" into space for relatively little energy... or you could invent "fiction" and have levitation but other than that you need a shit ton of propellant and essentially light a huge firecracker under your ass to get into space.

Now once you're in space... things change on how to move around, but the reality is that's relatively easy, and cheap. It's getting off this ball that's the hard and expensive thing.
 
My whole thing is this: There have only been THREE NATIONS (Russia, USA, China) that have sent men unto space. Now all of a sudden we expect the private sector to do it in no time flat. I for one see no US manned space flights for a long long time, not even from the private sector.

Bush killed the Shuttle
Obama killed the future of manned space flight in the US

Do some study, there already to go.

http://www.space.com/10548-private-spaceflight-ready-2011.html
 
All great explorations/discoveries in the past were done through
personal inititive, not a wastefull goverment program.

Well, not quite. Most of the time the personal initiative was funded by His or Her Majesty of someone, or in more recent times by people's taxes :D

You are right though, the privatization of space is a step in the right direction. NASA will still be doing a lot of the ground work that is needed for that next quantum leap.
 
Continuing to embrace old school thinking will not advance us in
space technology.

Its why goverment cant deliver the mail better with less cost, then UPS or FedEx.
Its not just the quality, its the quantity....and that will lead to profits.

The US has been in space over 40 years, yet after the Shuttle program, why
are we left with nothing to take it place?

Only goverment planners, could have screwed this up.

Irrelevant, there is direct profit in delivering mail. There is no direct profit in developing the James Web Space Telescope, Hubble, the Mars Science Rover, the Apollo project, or possible manned missions to Mars. That is why the government has to man up and run the scientific research show.

I do agree with you, the government screwed up pretty big by not having a project to take the space shuttles place. The space shuttle program has been obsolete, expensive, and needing to be completely retooled with newer, cheaper, and better technology for at least a dozen years now.

NASA needed a decent boost in funding years ago to start gathering the R&D necessary to develop a replacement for the shuttle or alternative manned space exploration project. Constellation was failed because it was underfunded to the degree that made any real progress impossible. Even though in the long run, a shuttle replacement would have made NASA spaceflight cheaper, it was easier to only look at the short term cost-savings of avoiding R&D and recycling the space shuttles.

Can't have a replacement without money, and NASA is simply not being given that money.

Like i mentioned before, I've got no problem with companies handling the small-ball tasks of playing low earth orbit taxi, but the only organization capable of spearheading real human space exploration or pure scientific research is NASA.
 
Irrelevant, there is direct profit in delivering mail. There is no direct profit in developing the James Web Space Telescope, Hubble, the Mars Science Rover, the Apollo project, or possible manned missions to Mars. That is why the government has to man up and run the scientific research show.

I do agree with you, the government screwed up pretty big by not having a project to take the space shuttles place. The space shuttle program has been obsolete, expensive, and needing to be completely retooled with newer, cheaper, and better technology for at least a dozen years now.

NASA needed a decent boost in funding years ago to start gathering the R&D necessary to develop a replacement for the shuttle or alternative manned space exploration project. Constellation was failed because it was underfunded to the degree that made any real progress impossible. Even though in the long run, a shuttle replacement would have made NASA spaceflight cheaper, it was easier to only look at the short term cost-savings of avoiding R&D and recycling the space shuttles.

Can't have a replacement without money, and NASA is simply not being given that money.

Like i mentioned before, I've got no problem with companies handling the small-ball tasks of playing low earth orbit taxi, but the only organization capable of spearheading real human space exploration or pure scientific research is NASA.

The public is not ready anytime soon to fund the next space projects.
Heck, we cant even fund the goverment properly!

So, who is going to do the next big thing?

If NASA wants to launch rovers and telescopes, fine, but will they
be funded to keep doing that from now on? I have nothing agsint this,
I just dontsee it as the segway for future acheviements in space.

The BIG thing has always been manned space flight.

Back in '68 when the first man landed on the moon, I think
most people would have thought "sure, we will be on Mars well
before 2011" and they would be wrong.

Should commecial spaceflight take off, the focus will be there
not NASA.
 
The only people who are not ready are the politicians in Washington, refusing to give NASA the funding it needs to thrive. If we can find the money to fight multiple unnecessary wars, we can find the money to fund the much cheaper NASA projects.

Private space flight is nowhere near ready for manned missions to LEO, let alone manned space exploration and pure scientific research. As mentioned before, there is no direct profit in that, thus there will be no private commercial corporations to perform such tasks.

All the private sector will do is as you've described, become mailmen.
 
The only people who are not ready are the politicians in Washington, refusing to give NASA the funding it needs to thrive. If we can find the money to fight multiple unnecessary wars, we can find the money to fund the much cheaper NASA projects.

Private space flight is nowhere near ready for manned missions to LEO, let alone manned space exploration and pure scientific research. As mentioned before, there is no direct profit in that, thus there will be no private commercial corporations to perform such tasks.

All the private sector will do is as you've described, become mailmen.

Your making my point, get goverment out of the way.

As I've already stated mining on the moon itself could be profitable.

Private companies don't have to reinvent the wheel. Its already been
done. There are plans in the works to create a smaller version of
the Shuttle, and that can make money.
 
What they lack is the safty record to put a human into space. Trial launches will be conducted for a long time to come.

But they will be in spcae no?

No one says it going to happen tomorrow.
From what I've read it will take about 3 years.
 
The problem is that "new propulsion" isn't an issue. You're stuck in a gravity well, and it takes a big fucking expenditure of energy to get outside of it. Technology isn't going to change that, I mean sure you could build a huge ladder (space elevator) and just "jump" into space for relatively little energy... or you could invent "fiction" and have levitation but other than that you need a shit ton of propellant and essentially light a huge firecracker under your ass to get into space.

Now once you're in space... things change on how to move around, but the reality is that's relatively easy, and cheap. It's getting off this ball that's the hard and expensive thing.
I understand escaping gravity requires enormous amounts of energy. My point is what is our goal once we do get into space? Go to Mars, or cruise about our solar system?

Smaller more nimble projects could benefit from new tech faster imo. Like unmanned probes, and telescopes like hubble.
 
My point is what is our goal once we do get into space? Go to Mars, or cruise about our solar system?
.

Going to Mars and starting a base/outpost increases the chance that humans will not go extinct. Sooner or later, something will happen on Earth that will wipe us out, as has happened to every other top level species. It might not be in our lifetime, or our children's, but it's inevitable.

Going to asteroids will give us access to materials to help continue out society's growth, as minerals/metals/gases on Earth/Mars are finite. When we get a workable fusion power generation system going, the Moon is a huge source of helium-3 which is rare on our planet.

Also, if we find a Earth like planet in another star's habitable zone(we have multiple candidates now), how can we as a species not try to go there and answer the big question of if we're alone in the universe.
 
I'm not sure if this will help or be a hinderance. Companies are after profit, so will do things in the cheapest ways, which might not always be the best way. Though these companies are competing in a low competition segment, and maybe having 15 companies all striving for the same goal will push spaceflight into more peoples reach and move the tech forward. A lack of competition will have the opposite effect however, with people price gouging and cutting back to maximize profit. Which should never be a part of science.

As long as safety isn't compromised I think things will be ok. Nasa has a pretty good record on that front (considering what they do, they have only had a handful of disasters and near disasters).

IN exploring space we should actually be seeing MORE losses. ITs ok to lose humans in the process of advancing space tech, it really is. We sent ships full of men off to their doom for CENTURIES. BY no means am I saying be reckless, but also dont get up in arms about acceptable losses in dangerous missions. Dont make safety so expensive that it hinders reasonable development.
 
Going to Mars and starting a base/outpost increases the chance that humans will not go extinct. Sooner or later, something will happen on Earth that will wipe us out, as has happened to every other top level species. It might not be in our lifetime, or our children's, but it's inevitable.

Going to asteroids will give us access to materials to help continue out society's growth, as minerals/metals/gases on Earth/Mars are finite. When we get a workable fusion power generation system going, the Moon is a huge source of helium-3 which is rare on our planet.

Also, if we find a Earth like planet in another star's habitable zone(we have multiple candidates now), how can we as a species not try to go there and answer the big question of if we're alone in the universe.

^^^ this plus the innovation that inevitably is developed for said space travel, that will trickle down for products for the masses.


IN exploring space we should actually be seeing MORE losses. ITs ok to lose humans in the process of advancing space tech, it really is. We sent ships full of men off to their doom for CENTURIES. BY no means am I saying be reckless, but also dont get up in arms about acceptable losses in dangerous missions. Dont make safety so expensive that it hinders reasonable development.

Absolutely. Exploration, like anything, has a cost, sometimes unfortunately it involves the loss of life.
 
I don't really mind if NASA outsources the piddly stuff, just so long as they take charge of the big picture, next step stuff like visiting asteroids and sending astronauts to Mars, themselves.

Exactly what they are doing. I think its a good thing overall that the shuttles are retired. $1.7 billion per flight is far to much , we need to trim that down into the 10's of millions and then over time make it even cheaper. All we need is the right push and that's whats going on , private business will pick up the slack.

And NASA can focus on landing Astronauts on an Asteroid and then on Mars finally. After that deep space vehicles can be developed to visit our neighbor Alpha Centuri.
 
Exactly what they are doing. I think its a good thing overall that the shuttles are retired. $1.7 billion per flight is far to much .

I totally agree they were way too expensive, especially when space X has a contract to do 12 resupply missions to the ISS for 1.6 billion total.
 
I fully support the privatization of cargo and crew transport to LEO.

To those against it, I recommend doing more research on the subject.
 
Exactly what they are doing. I think its a good thing overall that the shuttles are retired. $1.7 billion per flight is far to much , we need to trim that down into the 10's of millions and then over time make it even cheaper. All we need is the right push and that's whats going on , private business will pick up the slack.

And NASA can focus on landing Astronauts on an Asteroid and then on Mars finally. After that deep space vehicles can be developed to visit our neighbor Alpha Centuri.

Getting the cost down, going private, and mining on the moon
are all postive next moves in space.
 
I think it was time to make this change. The exploration of space should not be restricted as it has been. Space is the only area that isn't owned/governed anymore and we absolutely should be exploring/probing it.

With all the great work that NASA has done, I think we are behind where we should have been as a result of the way we regulated and funded it. In this economic climate, it simply doesn't make sense to continue in the fashion that we have been working in.

There is great potential to actually make greater advances now that capitalism can thrive in this market segment.
 
Most scientists I've heard comment on the issue don't believe the demise of the Shuttle program will have much effect on NASA's ability to do science. The consensus seems to be that the Shuttle, and associated ISS program, were mostly symbolic at this point.
 
IN exploring space we should actually be seeing MORE losses. ITs ok to lose humans in the process of advancing space tech, it really is. We sent ships full of men off to their doom for CENTURIES. BY no means am I saying be reckless, but also dont get up in arms about acceptable losses in dangerous missions. Dont make safety so expensive that it hinders reasonable development.

I agree, you cant usually progress anything without risk, and often the more risk you take the more progress is made.

I am kind of worried that the "safety" aspect will get much much stricter (like with most private companies operating in the US) and that safety stadards will get much much stricter, which will delay progress. It will probably happen soon after the first accident where there will be some kind of "public outcry" for safety standards to be raised or something, ignoring the big picture.
 
Gravity wells suck. Private space development on a large scale is going to have to be driven by mining interests. We're not going to screw around with the moon either (at least not as a quick source of minerals), it's another big gravity well you have to traverse to get things in and out. Better to capture an asteroid and place it in orbit...possibly around the moon so we don't clutter Earth orbit with mining operations and non-precious rock bits that will tear up future spacecraft.

To make two-way travel viable (as opposed to just dropping rocks in from space), we're going to need an elevator, which could theoretically be a profitable enterprise. Unfortunately, I don't want a super-strong cable as long as the Earth's circumference built by the lowest bidder. If it ever came down it would be a catastrophe the likes of which we've never seen. Using the moon as a space elevator testing ground (and potential mine site after it's up) is actually something I'd be a big fan of. 1/6 the gravity of Earth, and no one to kill if the elevator doesn't quite work out as intended.
 
Boeing, SpaceX, Orbital, Sierra Nevada, Virgin Galactic, Blue Origin, Bigelow

The future of space will may not be decided by these companies, but they will likely get it off to a very good start..
 
I've got mixed feelings. "Outsourcing" usually means "The Graft House is now open for business!", but it also means that NASA will get more money due to cronyism, and I'm willing to take the good with the bad.
 
I've got mixed feelings. "Outsourcing" usually means "The Graft House is now open for business!", but it also means that NASA will get more money due to cronyism, and I'm willing to take the good with the bad.

Well, that special NASA wrench costing the taxpayer $15, may only cost
a private company $5 to make...at there own expense.

We may not have asembly line Shuttles coming off the production line
tomorrow, but this is a good start. Mass production is the forte
of private business, not goverment.

I'm up for that cost cutting measure.
 
China will lead the way now. They don't have the administrative limitations that NASA or the private sector has to deal with. If they want to do it, they simply will. They don't have to worry about how many are killed or how much the public opposes the allocation of dollars. Huge advantage for something like space.
 
I don't really mind if NASA outsources the piddly stuff, just so long as they take charge of the big picture, next step stuff like visiting asteroids and sending astronauts to Mars, themselves.

If they can't even keep the shuttle program going, you can pretty much forget about mars entirely
 
China will lead the way now. They don't have the administrative limitations that NASA or the private sector has to deal with. If they want to do it, they simply will. They don't have to worry about how many are killed or how much the public opposes the allocation of dollars. Huge advantage for something like space.

I think that this could be the catalyst for us to do Mars, but
with our leaders not sure on how to even budget the money
in DC, it may not happen anytime soon.

Meanwhile what we can do, is to make sure private
companies have the access.
 
Back
Top