X58 MOBO

all depends on how much you want to spend. they all pretty much perform the same the only differences are the extra features added onto the board, or if you want crossfire/sli or tri-fire/tri-sli..
 
yes i am planning to do tri fire/sli.I have about $300-500 for the board.Also plan to do some overclocking.Alot of gaming and maybe some Folding.
 
well if you want to go all out then this would be the board to get..

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131642

if you want to save a little and get almost the same features minus stuff you won't ever use then this is a good option..

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131666

but honestly unless you are going with the i7 970 or 980x i'd recommend taking a look at lga-1155, far cheaper and better performance, only the 970/980x are faster than an i7 2600k.
 
Okay thanks although I just got a 920 cheap from a friend I will look into the 1155 cpu's.
 
well if you want to go all out then this would be the board to get..

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131642

if you want to save a little and get almost the same features minus stuff you won't ever use then this is a good option..

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813131666

but honestly unless you are going with the i7 970 or 980x i'd recommend taking a look at lga-1155, far cheaper and better performance, only the 970/980x are faster than an i7 2600k.

Not by much my friend.. not by much.
 
Well of you already have a 920 I don't really see a reason not to go through and get a mono for it. Especially if it was a good deal. You may give up a frame or 2 in games if that. X58 boards are getting a lot cheaper also. Sandy bridge rocks and all but for me I just don't see the need to upgrade from my 950.
 
Okay thanks although I just got a 920 cheap from a friend I will look into the 1155 cpu's.


if you got it cheap stick with it. no reason to spend a few hundred bucks more when you already have a processor thats more then enough for what you want to do.
 
if you got it cheap stick with it. no reason to spend a few hundred bucks more when you already have a processor thats more then enough for what you want to do.

Yeah I was planning on getting a 2500k or 2600k but couldn't past up on this chip.Just need a good MOBO for it now and Ill wait for Ivy or Bulldozer to come out and see what happens or where to go to upgrade
 
i'm enjoying my rampage 3 formula. Very convenient to use. Didn't need the extreme because i'm not pushing my CPU hard enough to require using 2x8 pin CPU power connectors... and all the other features it has hahaha. I'm just aiming for 570 tri sli, no quads in my eyes. Formula was the choice :)

Also, you cant do tri-sli very well on the 1155 boards. 16 lanes, aka 8x8 on 1155 means dualies at BEST. Except with the virtu chips, but they don't exactly perform up to anybody's snuff. - just read the review on MSI's 1155 big bang marshall (b3). In summary: it doesn't work.

vs x58's 36 lanes 16x8x8 + 4 or 16x16x1 + 3, or 8x8x8x8 + 4 means you can do tri sli/fire + sound card, or even quadfire/quadsli


theres a reason intel still considers the x58 to be the enthusiast chipset, and h/p67 and z68 to be performance chipsets.
 
Last edited:
x58/920 is an awsome setup...blinding fast...im amazed every time i fire this thing up..with my ssd for the operating system its something else to use...honestly it amazes me when burning a dvd or file conversion...and for everyday use its so overkill its not funny...they are also alot of fun to o/clock too.
 
Not by much my friend.. not by much.

No they aren't and they are really only faster in specific applications. Encoding being the main one. If you are a virtual machine fanatic, then the Core i7 970, 980X and 990X start to make more sense if you can afford it.

I second the recommendations for the Rampage III Formula, Rampage III Extreme, and Rampage III Black Edition. Assuming you can foot the bill for the last two.
 
No they aren't and they are really only faster in specific applications. Encoding being the main one. If you are a virtual machine fanatic, then the Core i7 970, 980X and 990X start to make more sense if you can afford it.

I second the recommendations for the Rampage III Formula, Rampage III Extreme, and Rampage III Black Edition. Assuming you can foot the bill for the last two.

Anyone who buys a 970, 980X or 990X is a complete moron. The Xeon W3670 is MUCH cheaper AND enables ECC memory. Stick some heatspreaders on Crucial RAM and go overclocking.
 
Anyone who buys a 970, 980X or 990X is a complete moron. The Xeon W3670 is MUCH cheaper AND enables ECC memory. Stick some heatspreaders on Crucial RAM and go overclocking.

You might want to check again there bud. W3670 is $600 and 970s go for $550.
 
I'd definitely go for the 1155/2600k setup over an X58, but that's just me.
 
Anyone who buys a 970, 980X or 990X is a complete moron. The Xeon W3670 is MUCH cheaper AND enables ECC memory. Stick some heatspreaders on Crucial RAM and go overclocking.

The Xeon W3670 isn't multiplier unlocked and I couldn't give two squirts of piss about ECC memory in a gaming computer. I'd rather use higher frequency RAM modules with tighter timings thank you. I purchased my 980X right after the 990X's came out at Microcenter for $699.99. Not too bad given the time I've saved encoding with it and I don't have to depend on bus clocking to overclock it. By overclocking the multiplier I get more choice about what RAM speeds I use. It's quite nice I assure you.

You might want to check again there bud. W3670 is $600 and 970s go for $550.

Yep.

I'd definitely go for the 1155/2600k setup over an X58, but that's just me.

For most people I'd agree. If you can really leverage a six core CPU though, the 970, 980X, 990X and any hex core Xeons are good choices. While dated, the X58 platform has a lot going for it. The most important of which is more PCI-Express lanes. This gives me far more choices for motherboards, allowing for more flexibility. Some P67 boards use the nForce 200 MCP to help alleviate the bottlenecks of the P67 Express chipset and the Sandy Bridge I/O controller, but such boards are few and far between compared to X58.
 
The Xeon W3670 isn't multiplier unlocked...

And neither is the 970. Besides, unlocked multiplier isn't all that useful, unless you are overclocking so much that using bclock alone is an issue.

... and I couldn't give two squirts of piss about ECC memory in a gaming computer.

That's very polite...

I'd rather use higher frequency RAM modules with tighter timings thank you.

As if it's going to make any noticeable difference in performance. What was the last game that was memory bandwidth limited? Oh, right... none. In fact, most are GPU limited, and to a lesser extend CPU limited.

I purchased my 980X right after the 990X's came out at Microcenter for $699.99.

I was referring to the people who spend a thousand bucks for it, not for those who got it as a clearance deal.

You might want to check again there bud. W3670 is $600 and 970s go for $550.

Yeah, depends on the store. I can see W3670 for $500, i7 970 for $500 too. The difference ain't THAT between them, but you get more with the Xeon.

Some P67 boards use the nForce 200 MCP to help alleviate the bottlenecks of the P67 Express chipset and the Sandy Bridge I/O controller, but such boards are few and far between compared to X58.

A PCIe switch is not a replacement for PCIe lanes though. It just happens that with GPUs you usually don't see a difference, as they usually don't fully saturate eight lanes. Other add-on cards are a different story though.
 
If the need for PCI-Express lanes truly weighs above all else in this case, then yes X58 would be the way to go.

For gaming purposes, I'd still stick to P67, at least at this point.
 
If the need for PCI-Express lanes truly weighs above all else in this case, then yes X58 would be the way to go.

For gaming purposes, I'd still stick to P67, at least at this point.

Z68 please. P67 is kinda pointless now; actually it has always been.
 
And neither is the 970. Besides, unlocked multiplier isn't all that useful, unless you are overclocking so much that using bclock alone is an issue.

I have more control over the overclocking with unlocked multipliers. I get to set my memory speeds without concern for where my BCLK may put the actual memory clocks. It is also easier to overclock the CPU because I can literally raise the multiplier and the CPU voltage without touching any other settings. Some of us like that.

That's very polite...

I was making a point. ECC doesn't really benefit the home user or the gamer a whole hell of a lot.

As if it's going to make any noticeable difference in performance. What was the last game that was memory bandwidth limited? Oh, right... none. In fact, most are GPU limited, and to a lesser extend CPU limited.

Some of us do more than game with our computers. Also, X58 seems to benefit from more memory bandwidth due to architectural differences between say Nehalem / Gulftown vs. Sandy Bridge. Second generation Core ix processors simply don't benefit much if at all going from DDR3 1333MHz vs. DDR3 1600MHz or more. The reverse is not necessarily true when referring to X58 based systems. Granted games aren't where the need for memory bandwidth comes from.

I was referring to the people who spend a thousand bucks for it, not for those who got it as a clearance deal.

Well generally speaking, I think the Core i5 2500K and the Core i7 2600K are the best buys for a high end machine today. The 970, 980X, 990X and their Xeon brothers on the other hand are only useful for very specific scenarios. Even at $1,000 one may find value in such a processor if they can truly leverage those extra cores. Again your average home user and gamer won't. But for professional workstations, especially those doing 3D rendering / modeling and video editing, and or encoding, they really can represent a value. Time is money for some folks.

Yeah, depends on the store. I can see W3670 for $500, i7 970 for $500 too. The difference ain't THAT between them, but you get more with the Xeon.

How do you get more with the Xeon? All it supports that the Core i7 970 doesn't is ECC memory and AES NEW instructions. How will the home user or gamer benefit from either one of those things? I know some people believe ECC will make their system crash proof, despite the fact that ECC equipped servers crash when they've got problems just like anything else. I see it all the time in data centers. You get a whopping two features which most people don't give a shit about and don't need.

The CPUs are virtually identical. I'd say get which ever is cheaper.

A PCIe switch is not a replacement for PCIe lanes though. It just happens that with GPUs you usually don't see a difference, as they usually don't fully saturate eight lanes. Other add-on cards are a different story though.

I never suggested that it was. I'm the guy who argues against that logic in all the motherboard and GPU threads revolving around that topic. What I did mean was that X58 is a more flexible solution which does offer more PCI lanes than P67. X58 boards are a better choice for people wanting to add additional devices like sound cards and drive controllers. X58 is more flexible when it comes to PCIe lane allocation. Simple as that.

Z68 please. P67 is kinda pointless now; actually it has always been.

How is P67 pointless? How has it always been? Z68 has the SSD caching feature which only benefits people who do not use an SSD for their OS. The onboard video is really only good for quick sync and people who do not use a discrete adapter. Currently, there are no power savings to be had using it and unless you want to run multiple monitors in a non-Eyefinity / NV Surround setup, it has no value for most gamers. P67 boards can be had for less money than Z68 and if Z68's added features aren't helpful to you then why spend the money?
 
Some of us do more than game with our computers.

Memory bandwidth is unlikely an issue there.

Also, X58 seems to benefit from more memory bandwidth due to architectural differences between say Nehalem / Gulftown vs. Sandy Bridge. Second generation Core ix processors simply don't benefit much if at all going from DDR3 1333MHz vs. DDR3 1600MHz or more. The reverse is not necessarily true when referring to X58 based systems.

X58 has triple channel memory. That's a LOT of bandwidth at 1333MHz, 32GB/s. What workload needs that much of memory bandwidth, let alone more? Wait, what workload needs more than 22GB/s that dual-channel offers? Well I can only think of business stuff like ERM, sales databases & calculations, etc. Those are run on dual or quad socket systems, not an overclocked X58 chip.

The 970, 980X, 990X and their Xeon brothers on the other hand are only useful for very specific scenarios. Even at $1,000 one may find value in such a processor if they can truly leverage those extra cores. Again your average home user and gamer won't. But for professional workstations, especially those doing 3D rendering / modeling and video editing, and or encoding, they really can represent a value. Time is money for some folks.

Those folks get a LOT more value from a dual socket system. If that's too costly, they will CERTAINLY get a Xeon, maybe not for ECC memory, but for support and maintenance. Dell/HP/Lenovo offer business support on their workstations, not on gaming computers. Very few businesses would take the risk to overclock, so that's out the window.

How do you get more with the Xeon? All it supports that the Core i7 970 doesn't is ECC memory and AES NEW instructions. How will the home user or gamer benefit from either one of those things?

AES instructions ain't too useful really, only if you encrypt your boot SSD.

I know some people believe ECC will make their system crash proof, despite the fact that ECC equipped servers crash when they've got problems just like anything else. I see it all the time in data centers. You get a whopping two features which most people don't give a shit about and don't need.

ECC isn't going to help with a bad driver causing the operating system to crash. It will help with memory errors causing the crashes though; lots of people keep their computers on for a LONG time (average Joe simply turns off the monitor), memory errors can develop easily; all it takes is a single flipped bit and the kernel can panic, or data can be corrupted. Most people won't care much though, although geeks should.

The CPUs are virtually identical. I'd say get which ever is cheaper.

I'd recommend the Xeon any day, especially with ECC memory, except if you need the unlocked multiplier, in which case, ask for a discount on 980X now that 990X is out.

I never suggested that it was.

My mistake then, sorry, understood it wrong because the usage of the word "alleviate".

I'm the guy who argues against that logic in all the motherboard and GPU threads revolving around that topic. What I did mean was that X58 is a more flexible solution which does offer more PCI lanes than P67. X58 boards are a better choice for people wanting to add additional devices like sound cards and drive controllers. X58 is more flexible when it comes to PCIe lane allocation. Simple as that.

Sound cards aren't really a use case for X58 heh, but drive controllers or network cards, sure. That's precisely what will make you curse a PCIe switch, especially the NF200, which seems to have higher latency than alternatives from PLX, probably due to extra logic for SLI.

How is P67 pointless? How has it always been? Z68 has the SSD caching feature which only benefits people who do not use an SSD for their OS.

That's not a great feature anyway.

The onboard video is really only good for quick sync and people who do not use a discrete adapter.

THAT! Also extra monitors, if you're into lots of monitors. But Quick Sync is the whole deal; all Core i-2000 CPUs have the sillicon for that, why not be able to use it? Typical Intel retardness; it's not like the P67 boards are a lot cheaper, if at all.

Currently, there are no power savings to be had using it and unless you want to run multiple monitors in a non-Eyefinity / NV Surround setup, it has no value for most gamers.

Everyone encodes a video sooner or later, and since it costs the same or close to, why not? It's faster than doing it on the CPU with nearly identical quality.

P67 boards can be had for less money than Z68 and if Z68's added features aren't helpful to you then why spend the money?

Not much cheaper, on the order of $10-15. QS is pretty helpful actually, can save a lot of time.
 
Memory bandwidth is unlikely an issue there.

X58 has triple channel memory. That's a LOT of bandwidth at 1333MHz, 32GB/s. What workload needs that much of memory bandwidth, let alone more? Wait, what workload needs more than 22GB/s that dual-channel offers? Well I can only think of business stuff like ERM, sales databases & calculations, etc. Those are run on dual or quad socket systems, not an overclocked X58 chip.

Outside of benchmarks, it's hard to make a case for the extra memory bandwidth, though I have seen it make a slight difference in a few applications. I'm not necessarily talking about business applications beyond 3D modeling, rendering, and video editing / encoding. Enough to justify the cost? No, not hardly. So fair enough.

Those folks get a LOT more value from a dual socket system. If that's too costly, they will CERTAINLY get a Xeon, maybe not for ECC memory, but for support and maintenance. Dell/HP/Lenovo offer business support on their workstations, not on gaming computers. Very few businesses would take the risk to overclock, so that's out the window.

If it's a business machine I'd agree. Workstations maybe. Gaming computers, no way. Again I'm not necessarily talking about business computers.

AES instructions ain't too useful really, only if you encrypt your boot SSD.

That was my point. That's something the Xeon supports and the Core i7 970 doesn't.

ECC isn't going to help with a bad driver causing the operating system to crash. It will help with memory errors causing the crashes though; lots of people keep their computers on for a LONG time (average Joe simply turns off the monitor), memory errors can develop easily; all it takes is a single flipped bit and the kernel can panic, or data can be corrupted. Most people won't care much though, although geeks should.

Except this doesn't happen often enough to justify the use of slower and more expensive ECC memory. Most of the time when someone has a crash they simply reboot. Most of the time there is no loss of data or data corruption. For servers and ultra high end workstations, ECC is desirable. For home users and even most business and workstation machines, it's not. Also, your local Microcenter doesn't typically stock a good selection of ECC RAM. It sometimes boils down to availability. I don't think this is a value add for the Xeon. At least, not if they are priced differently. At the same price between the Xeon W3670 and the Core i7 970 I'd grab the Xeon so long as the Xeon was about the same price. Though if I were building a server, then the Xeon would make a better choice. In my gaming computer, the extra features would go unused. I suspect most gamers and home users, even the enthusiasts will not take advantage of the extra features offered by the Xeon. I'd still probably grab the Xeon assuming the price was again about the same. I might re-purpose the processor down the line when I upgraded my gaming machine again and use the old hardware for server duty.

I'd recommend the Xeon any day, especially with ECC memory, except if you need the unlocked multiplier, in which case, ask for a discount on 980X now that 990X is out.

I recommend Xeons too. To businesses and professionals who need them. Not to gamers and people who like to encode video on six core machines at home.

Sound cards aren't really a use case for X58 heh, but drive controllers or network cards, sure. That's precisely what will make you curse a PCIe switch, especially the NF200, which seems to have higher latency than alternatives from PLX, probably due to extra logic for SLI.

The sound card was one example. Network, sound and drive controllers all come to mind. Without the nForce 200 MCP, the P67 and Z68 are severely limited in how they use their PCIe lanes. With the nForce 200 MCP, latency and other issues crop up. And the extra logic in the nForce 200 MCP isn't for SLI. SLI has nothing to do with it. You can have SLI without nForce 200 MCPs. Also, if you plan on adding drive controllers, or using more than one RAID controller at a time, the Z68 platform runs out of option ROM space and other resources for integrated hardware faster than X58 and even P67. The reason? That extra video hardware (even though most is on the CPU die, other hardware exists for connectivity) takes up some when in use. I went over that with an engineer from Gigabyte because a couple of their boards lack the ability to run more than one of their integrated SATA controllers in RAID mode at the same time.

That's not a great feature anyway.

While cool on paper, it's actual usefulness is debatable. I can agree with that.

THAT! Also extra monitors, if you're into lots of monitors. But Quick Sync is the whole deal; all Core i-2000 CPUs have the sillicon for that, why not be able to use it? Typical Intel retardness; it's not like the P67 boards are a lot cheaper, if at all.

Why not be able to use it? Because some of us don't care to use it. I'm running two GTX 580's in SLI. The last thing I need is another DVI port. Using the Virtu feature doesn't help as that robs you of performance in I-Mode. In D-Mode the onboard video doesn't do anything beyond Quick Sync. Many people won't give a damn about it.

Everyone encodes a video sooner or later, and since it costs the same or close to, why not? It's faster than doing it on the CPU with nearly identical quality.

No, I'm fairly certain I know many people who will NEVER encode video on their machines. In fact I know plenty of people who are unlikely to ever do so. Some of which are gamers and all around computer enthusiasts. They just have no desire to do that. Now if you had said just about everyone who has an HTPC will encode video, then I'd agree with you.

Not much cheaper, on the order of $10-15. QS is pretty helpful actually, can save a lot of time.

I've noticed that some people will actually balk at spending $10 or $15 more when we are talking about features they do not need.

And again, I advocate P67 or Z68 more often than not. The people who will benefit from X58 are few and far between and unless you are going with some kind of six core processor and can leverage it, chances are you won't be among those who can really take advantage of what little X58 has to offer over other more modern chipsets.
 
Thanks guys for all the suggestions still up in the air on MOBO.But my top two are G1 assassin or Rampage edition MOBOs.Evga is third.
 
Rocking the Rampage Formula here...very happy with it, despite the wonky SATA3 chip but that is OT.

If the OP is planning on folding or mining then PCIE lanes become a consideration and to date X58 is pumping the most PCIE bandwidth...if OP has a 920 in hand I say go for it.
 
Ill sell you my p6t deluxe for 120$? /shameless plug.

Rocking the Rampage Formula here...very happy with it, despite the wonky SATA3 chip but that is OT.

If the OP is planning on folding or mining then PCIE lanes become a consideration and to date X58 is pumping the most PCIE bandwidth...if OP has a 920 in hand I say go for it.

Thanks.Looking at either the formula or extreme or G1 assassin(goes with color themed build).The Rampage black edition to is in my color scheme but is expensive.
 
For servers and ultra high end workstations, ECC is desirable. For home users and even most business and workstation machines, it's not.

Anyone who does software development, should demand ECC. Can't imagine debating where the bug is due to a coding error or due to memory flakiness. Usual business machines, not so much; workstations, the little extra cost of ECC is worth, just one instance where the machine would crash of a memory error in it's 3-5 years of lifetime and it's payed for itself several times.

I might re-purpose the processor down the line when I upgraded my gaming machine again and use the old hardware for server duty.

That's a good idea. I haven't thought of that before. It pretty much makes the $10-15 difference of getting the Xeon worth it; the CPUs are so good these days they'll be fine in 5 years or more as a home server CPU.

I went over that with an engineer from Gigabyte because a couple of their boards lack the ability to run more than one of their integrated SATA controllers in RAID mode at the same time.

Not too useful to run the integrated controllers in RAID anyway; outside of RAID 0/1/10, the performance is horrible.

Why not be able to use it? Because some of us don't care to use it. I'm running two GTX 580's in SLI. The last thing I need is another DVI port.

You can get Z68 mobos without video output ports. Quick Sync still works fine in that case. You can encode on software and on QS at the same time at full speed.


I've noticed that some people will actually balk at spending $10 or $15 more when we are talking about features they do not need.

Let me guess, the same people spending a thousand bucks on a CPU, or five hundred on a motherboard? Even if not, I know some people won't do it; you can't please everybody after all.

And again, I advocate P67 or Z68 more often than not. The people who will benefit from X58 are few and far between and unless you are going with some kind of six core processor and can leverage it, chances are you won't be among those who can really take advantage of what little X58 has to offer over other more modern chipsets.

I get horrified when I see people buy 990X just to run GTX 460 SLI on it, or even 580 SLI, using that computer only for gaming; that'll be slower than a 580. Or requiring 16 lanes to the GPU, to shave 100ms off level loading, or add half an FPS to their already 150+.
 
Anyone who does software development, should demand ECC. Can't imagine debating where the bug is due to a coding error or due to memory flakiness. Usual business machines, not so much; workstations, the little extra cost of ECC is worth, just one instance where the machine would crash of a memory error in it's 3-5 years of lifetime and it's payed for itself several times.

I don't know if I believe that. I've seen plenty of machines with ECC RAM go tits up and crash for no apparent reason. It's difficult to quantify how many crashes ECC prevented vs. how many crashes would have happened no matter what kind of memory you had. Also I believe testing of software should happen on common system configurations out there found in homes across the world. Which would preclude the possibility of using ECC RAM in the test environment.

That's a good idea. I haven't thought of that before. It pretty much makes the $10-15 difference of getting the Xeon worth it; the CPUs are so good these days they'll be fine in 5 years or more as a home server CPU.

In such cases it absolutely would make the Xeon a better buy. I've been running my dual Intel Core 2 Extreme Edition QX9775's with FB-DIMMs now for about 2 years. Previously it was my gaming setup.

Not too useful to run the integrated controllers in RAID anyway; outside of RAID 0/1/10, the performance is horrible.

No disagreement there. I just wanted to point out that integrated RAID on many of the newer, X58, P67, Z68 and even 990FX boards are a total mess these days. Adding a controller of your own may or may not work in all instances and cause you even more pain.

You can get Z68 mobos without video output ports. Quick Sync still works fine in that case. You can encode on software and on QS at the same time at full speed.

True.

Let me guess, the same people spending a thousand bucks on a CPU, or five hundred on a motherboard? Even if not, I know some people won't do it; you can't please everybody after all.

No. The people who I've seen bitch about $10 or $15 price difference are on a budget they absolutely have to stick to. People who I've seen budget for super high end hardware generally don't care if they run hundreds of dollars over their initial cost projection.

I get horrified when I see people buy 990X just to run GTX 460 SLI on it, or even 580 SLI, using that computer only for gaming; that'll be slower than a 580. Or requiring 16 lanes to the GPU, to shave 100ms off level loading, or add half an FPS to their already 150+.

WTF? I get feeling horrified by people buying a Core i7 990X just to run GTX 460 SLI or something low end like that, but why not GTX 580s in SLI? I use GTX 580 SLI on mine. Though I do more than just game with it. But how is that slower than a 580? WTF are you talking about? As for requiring x16 PCIe lanes for a GPU, I'd agree. People blow that way out of proportion. 8x8 is more than good enough for SLI. If it weren't, we see dramatic performance differences between LGA1155 systems and LGA1366 systems with the performance advantage going toward LGA1366 systems. That is clearly not happening.
 
Z68 or P67 for gaming, if you don't care about quick sync, which I don't think a lot of gamers do (I could be wrong), why even argue the point.

My original claim was for the 1155 socket alone as opposed to going with a 1366 board, the P67 comment was more of a push in that general direction.
 
Also I believe testing of software should happen on common system configurations out there found in homes across the world. Which would preclude the possibility of using ECC RAM in the test environment.

ECC RAM doesn't impact the testing negatively, it helps rule out bugs, and helps rule out debugging weirdness. It's not really important on testing machines though, I meant for developer workstations, when debugging the applications. You seriously don't want a memory error when you're deep inside application code.

In such cases it absolutely would make the Xeon a better buy. I've been running my dual Intel Core 2 Extreme Edition QX9775's with FB-DIMMs now for about 2 years. Previously it was my gaming setup.

Ouch, FB-DIMMs :<

No disagreement there. I just wanted to point out that integrated RAID on many of the newer, X58, P67, Z68 and even 990FX boards are a total mess these days. Adding a controller of your own may or may not work in all instances and cause you even more pain.

Well unless you get a board like X8ST3-F which has an LSI chip, yeah, integrated RAID is a mess.

No. The people who I've seen bitch about $10 or $15 price difference are on a budget they absolutely have to stick to. People who I've seen budget for super high end hardware generally don't care if they run hundreds of dollars over their initial cost projection.

If they are on a strict budget why are they looking at 2500K/2600K and P67? Well maybe if they want to keep that system for 5-7 years. I agree there. Intel could have ditched P67 from the start and made Z68 cheaper. Or hell, ditch Z68 and give P67 access to video.


But how is that slower than a 580? WTF are you talking about?

Ahh sorry, I was writing something and scrapped it, but didn't remove all of it. Now it makes no sense xD Forget about the 580 SLI and slower than 580.
 
In my opinion any of the ASUS Rampage 3's, I have a Rampage 3 Extreme in my desktop never had a problem. Also I have a Rampage 3 GENE in my HTPC I love it cause it has the X-FI onboard sound chip
 
In my opinion any of the ASUS Rampage 3's, I have a Rampage 3 Extreme in my desktop never had a problem. Also I have a Rampage 3 GENE in my HTPC I love it cause it has the X-FI onboard sound chip

No it doesn't. It has a software license for EAX. The hardware is a Realtek ALC889 or ALC892. Most likely an ALC889 as that's what all ASUS Boards with "Creative X-Fi's" use.
 
Last edited:
ECC RAM doesn't impact the testing negatively, it helps rule out bugs, and helps rule out debugging weirdness. It's not really important on testing machines though, I meant for developer workstations, when debugging the applications. You seriously don't want a memory error when you're deep inside application code.

I'm not a software developer, so that's not really my field of expertise. It simply made sense to me to have software tested on common configurations. I do know something about game development and that's pretty much what you have to do. Though they do write to specific APIs like Direct 3D and OpenAL, there are still issues which can occur due to differences in hardware configurations.

Ouch, FB-DIMMs :<

The one serious weakness of the D5400XS motherboard I'm afraid.

Well unless you get a board like X8ST3-F which has an LSI chip, yeah, integrated RAID is a mess.

Well server and high end workstation motherboards can be an exception to the rule as are many consumer / retail boards. However a lot of retail, consumer and enthusiast motherboards have sloppy RAID implementation and it's not worth a crap for anything but RAID 0, 1, 0+1.

If they are on a strict budget why are they looking at 2500K/2600K and P67? Well maybe if they want to keep that system for 5-7 years. I agree there. Intel could have ditched P67 from the start and made Z68 cheaper. Or hell, ditch Z68 and give P67 access to video.

I've built systems for very weird people over the years. While I've seen some who absolutely refuse to deviate from a budget even $10 or $15, the bulk fo them would be fine with it. Most people I know either build for a 3-5 year cycle, or a 2-3 year cycle.

Ahh sorry, I was writing something and scrapped it, but didn't remove all of it. Now it makes no sense xD Forget about the 580 SLI and slower than 580.

Ahh OK.
 
I have more control over the overclocking with unlocked multipliers. I get to set my memory speeds without concern for where my BCLK may put the actual memory clocks. It is also easier to overclock the CPU because I can literally raise the multiplier and the CPU voltage without touching any other settings. Some of us like that.

It appears that Xeon W3680 and W3690 do have unlocked multipliers. They're roughly $50-60 more than the i7`s at newegg (MSRP) and usually are better binned. But check this out:

http://www.builderdepot.com/browse.ihtml?pid=1294590&step=5&prodstoreid=12154

Seriously, 700 bucks for W3680.

http://forums.guru3d.com/showpost.php?p=3459819&postcount=128
http://forums.guru3d.com/showpost.php?p=3544102&postcount=227

To prove my binning point, look at the Vcore:
http://forums.guru3d.com/showpost.php?p=3451190&postcount=28
 
I think P67 is best bang for the buck now, considering how easy to push @4.5ghz stable on 2600K.
That would give you enough juice for any game .
X58 just not so hot anymore even if you go with 970/980x chip.
 
I think P67 is best bang for the buck now, considering how easy to push @4.5ghz stable on 2600K.
That would give you enough juice for any game .
X58 just not so hot anymore even if you go with 970/980x chip.

It's pretty easy to get 4.7GHz+ out of a 2600K.
 
Back
Top