The Whole Planet Almost DIED!

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Did you feel that "swoosh" earlier? That was that asteroid, discovered just last week, whizzing by the Earth. Scientist say that it was only 100ft wide but they probably just didn't want to scare us, you know it was a planet killer. ;)

The space rock now labeled 2011 MD came with no such warning, and narrowly squeaked by Earth today at approximately 1:01PM Eastern time. Astronomers just discovered the asteroid late last week, and while there was virtually no chance of it impacting our planet, the rock passed by close enough to be seen by some in Africa and possibly Australia.
 
See, and people call me an alchoholic when really I'm just prepared for the end at any given time!
 
Lulz a planet killer has to be alteast 1mile wide not a 100 feet...

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the things velocity has something to do with it as well. A very fast moving 100ft wide object could do some damage given the speed of impact.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the things velocity has something to do with it as well. A very fast moving 100ft wide object could do some damage given the speed of impact.

Not likely. Most asteroids I've heard about whiz around at a brisk 50k mph. The friction this thing (I believe it was a stoney type asteroid) would have seen in our atmosphere would have disintegrated most, if not all of the asteroid. In this case, it's mostly an issue of mass.
 
Depends upon the orbital path of any said asteroid. If it's a very tight orbit chances are it'll be traveling quite fast, If its an orbit that's similar to Earths going in the same direction and tiny perturbations brought it into contact with Earth then very slow speed.

Also depends upon the composition of such asteroid, they range from being dense metals, to relatively less dense (and less held together) carbonates.

That said the meteor that made the "Meteor Crater" in Arizona, which is a crater almost 1 mile wide, was about 150ft wide, but dense iron-nickle as well as moving quite fast.
 
Well at 50,000 mph it would spend about a millisecond in our atmosphere straight down ...
Also, Earth is traveling 66,780 mph around the sun, so if it came from the other direction ...
 
yawn. at 100' what are the chances of it being deflected by the atmosphere? this narrowly missed stuff is annoying. Seems like you get a report every few years and yet historically no big events have happened in the history of man. Before man, yes. We have a lot more to fear from volcanoes and earthquakes.....
 
Pretty incredible how something only 100ft-1mi wide can be so dangerous.
 
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the things velocity has something to do with it as well. A very fast moving 100ft wide object could do some damage given the speed of impact.

Velocity and mass, a 100' object if it were made out of something like say iron could easily solve all the worlds problems.
 
Even if it had come close enough to make entry an asteroid this size would most likely have burned up in the atmosphere. A few years back I was lucky enough to be working the night shift when an asteroid around this size flew overhead in a spectacular fireball (the fire was bright enough that you could see the smoke coming off of it in the middle of the night). It was an awesome sight. It burned up completely before it ever got to the ground though. If you work the night shift at a job that keeps you outdoors a lot you'll see a ton of meteors but that was easily the brightest one I have ever seen.

Anyway, I'm sure that debris this size actually hits the earth all the time.
 
yawn. at 100' what are the chances of it being deflected by the atmosphere? this narrowly missed stuff is annoying. Seems like you get a report every few years and yet historically no big events have happened in the history of man. Before man, yes. We have a lot more to fear from volcanoes and earthquakes.....

I'm pro anything that points that average Joe in the direction of astrophysics. :D

Hopefully it'll spark the curiosity of the young, inspiring them to become a contributor in the field.
 
Good one, heh.

Sounds like a headline from Digg before it went through it's completely media-controlled transformation. There would be a monthly headline such as "EARTH TO BE DESTROYED BY ASTEROID"

Actual contents of article:
Scientists have discovered an asteroid that they say could come within 1.2 million miles of earth within the next 3.6 billion years.
 
Leave it up to the forum dwellers to turn a joke into a scientific debate.
 
All it takes is a billion people pointing their butts in the air and farting enough wind to push any asterioid clear of our atmosphere(but then that billion might die from the smell....)
 
Another near catastrophe averted by Jeff Goldblum and his PowerMac!
 
Yeah I think a lot of people aren't taking into consideration mass, composition, etc...

Imagine some robot hurling a piece of sand from the beach at your face. Now imagine that piece of sand is a super dense metal and weighs in on a scale of tons and is traveling at 12 miles per second. It's just a piece of sand, sure, but it would damn well explode your face guaranteed or your money back.
 
dunno, seems like it might be a little like the frozen chicken debate,
ie: in airplanes they shoot chickens with a cannon at the windshields to test bird impacts at speed
the joke was that frozen chickens would do more damage
mythbusters tested both frozen and unfrozen chickens, the damage was the same.
 
dunno, seems like it might be a little like the frozen chicken debate,
ie: in airplanes they shoot chickens with a cannon at the windshields to test bird impacts at speed
the joke was that frozen chickens would do more damage
mythbusters tested both frozen and unfrozen chickens, the damage was the same.

The freaken mass of a chicken does not change when its frozen, the damage will be similar at a high enough speed. Jumping into a pool from high enough will kill you, even if the pool is deep enough, the what will not move out of the way fast enough to allow you to slow your decent.

Sorry, now lets add velocity: dropping a cannon ball on your foot hurts (or breaks it), shooting a cannon ball at your foot sucks!
 
velocity through atmosphere may actually have a reverse effect.
First off, it will make it more likely to deflect the mass.

Second type of example, being in just a few feet of water you are safe from rifles or similar weapons. The water will cause bullets to shatter.

Now things like shotguns and handguns are more dangerous through water because they have much lower velocity and can penetrate without shattering.

Anyway there are tons of variables that would be applied and probably a lot of conditions that all have to come together perfectly to create a catastrophic event.
 
You can still get pancaked if you hit water fast enough. I imagine even air would feel like a brick wall if you were going insanely fast.

Of course, it could also be similar to you falling at terminal velocity and landing in a kiddie pool 2 inches deep.
 
Back
Top