Need new hard drives. Need advice

ebs5049

Limp Gawd
Joined
Aug 9, 2009
Messages
429
So my 5 year old 160gb Seagate Barracudas are starting to show their age. I'm looking for advice from some guys here for what HDDs they have and if they or what they recommend.

I need two drives. I don't plan on running them in RAID. My computer is usually an evolving beast where I swap out parts annually, I tend to reformat a lot and I like not having to back up all my media and just leaving it on one drive. So I need one for storing media. Around 1TB should suffice

I need another for my OS. Don't have the money for SSD so that is out of the question. Also, I'm not that big of an enthusiast that I need that kind of performance. I just need something good and reliable. Anything will be an upgrade from the POS I have now. 500-750gb will be adequate.

I was wondering. Will those "green" drives be good for media or are they pretty slow? Will having a 64mb cache over 32mb make a significant difference?

Thanks
ebs5049
 
I am in a similar situation, but I am looking for more performance as it will serve for business use. I've been looking at some Seagate HDDs, but I haven't been able to narrow down my search for a reliable drive that can handle between 1 and 2 TBs. Any suggestions?
 
I am in a similar situation, but I am looking for more performance as it will serve for business use. I've been looking at some Seagate HDDs, but I haven't been able to narrow down my search for a reliable drive that can handle between 1 and 2 TBs. Any suggestions?

Go with the Samsung 1TB drive above. OR if you need 2TB:
$150 - Western Digital Caviar Black WD2002FAEX 2TB Hard drive
 
So no big difference between 32mb and 64mb cache or performance gain isn't worth the added cost? Are Samsung drives pretty reliable?
 
So no big difference between 32mb and 64mb cache or performance gain isn't worth the added cost? Are Samsung drives pretty reliable?

No big difference by itself. Samsung drives are pretty reliable.
 
my vote is this one for storage
SAMSUNG Spinpoint F4EG HD155UI 1.5TB 5400 RPM

less heat and noise form less rotation, (= less wear an tear and longer life) plus greater density from a newer generation offsets the loss of speed from less rotation, and 50% more space for 10% more cost.

ssd is the real improvement you would need, but i have a feeling the rest of your computer isnt up to that task.

do you have sata, and the appropriate sata power connectors?
 
my vote is this one for storage
SAMSUNG Spinpoint F4EG HD155UI 1.5TB 5400 RPM

less heat and noise form less rotation, (= less wear an tear and longer life) plus greater density from a newer generation offsets the loss of speed from less rotation, and 50% more space for 10% more cost.

ssd is the real improvement you would need, but i have a feeling the rest of your computer isnt up to that task.

do you have sata, and the appropriate sata power connectors?

Thanks for the advice! You don't think the 5400rpm will cause much slow down?


And my computer is newer, just my HDDs that are old. I have a Intel Q9550 and a Gigabyte UD3R and my PSU is a Antec Earthwatts 650W. I should be able to run SSD just fine but I just don't have that kind of cash. Maybe in a few years when I start making the big bucks. :) In the meantime, I just need a couple good, reliable, drives.
 
Thanks for the advice! You don't think the 5400rpm will cause much slow down?

Yikes, that's a terrible drive. 5400 RPM is still 5400 RPM. As far as "wear and tear" goes, you'll have replaced your computer 2 or 3 times before the 1TB F3 will probably even began failing (if it even does). Modern HDD's (like the F3) are very reliable now-a-days.

Add my vote in for the Samsung Spinpoint F3 1TB that Danny and Cmustang87 recommended as well. It is pretty much the fastest mechanical drive you can buy today, and it's very inexpensive, and very durable/reliable.
 
Well thanks for your input guys. I'm gonna buy the Samsung everyone has recommended. Thanks!
 
Back
Top